Medina (Second Edition) Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Medina (Second Edition)
Reviewers agree on the central appeal of Medina (Second Edition), the revised edition of Stefan Dorra's city-building game. The game is about construction, but the tone reviewers use is competitive. In a full two-player playthrough on the Getting Games channel, the host describes it as "essentially a game about being really mean to each other while we are building a city kind of organically." That framing recurs across the discussions. Players build a shared town, but every placement can help or hurt the other player's scoring.
Enthusiasm is strong. The Watch It Played reviewer calls Medina one of their all-time favorite games, and the Getting Games monthly update describes the reviewer falling in love with the game on Board Game Arena, which led to a physical copy. Reviewers also share a caveat. The game rewards players who enjoy confrontation and long calculation, and the Getting Games playthrough explicitly warns that viewers who dislike mean games should skip it. The discussions treat the game less as a casual pick-up title and more as a deliberate choice for players who want tension across the whole table.
Core Mechanics That Define Medina (Second Edition)
End Game Bonuses
Most of the points in Medina are resolved at the end of the game, and reviewers spend a lot of time explaining why that matters. Each player claims one building of each color, and the score pad then tallies the wooden pieces attached to those buildings. Beyond the base count, the largest building of a color earns a majority bonus, and the Getting Games playthrough notes that brown is worth three points to whoever holds its majority. Walls are another source of end-game points: every wall adjacent to a player's building scores one point, and the player who first connects an owned palace to a corner takes a tile and the merchants attached to it, after which each later connection to that corner pays out. Merchants add a point to any adjacent palace, and palaces positioned exactly two spaces orthogonally from the well are worth plus four points.
Because so many bonuses are unresolved until the final tally, standings stay uncertain. In the Getting Games playthrough, the host felt behind for much of the match, yet the final score landed at 52 to 46 and the host called the six-point margin closer than expected. The host summarizes the effect as a constant tug of war: a corner that looks like a four-point gift can be contested by the other player's later walls, so planning ahead for the final tally matters more than any single turn.
Claiming Buildings With Rooftops and Neutral Pieces
Each turn, a player places two wooden pieces, although a tea tile can be spent to place only one. A new building cannot touch the well or another building, which leaves alleys between structures, and growth normally extends an existing building of that color until it is finished. Claiming is handled with rooftops. Each player may claim only one building per color, and once a player does so, that player is finished with the color. When both players have claimed a color, the leftover pieces of that color are removed from the board. The first claim on purple grants three tea tiles and the second grants two, which gives the Getting Games host a constant decision about when to commit. Neutral pieces add a further layer: they can block a building from being grown, and they can claim a building for an uninvolved party, so the timing of a claim is never purely your own choice.
Stefan Dorra's design makes the tension feel physical. Reviewers describe the moment of claiming as a commitment that is hard to undo. In the Getting Games playthrough, the host explains that "once you place your rooftops that's it on that color," so the other player must then decide whether to build next to it or leave it open for a rival. Stables can enlarge any building and steal majorities late in the game, and the playthrough shows how quickly a player can run out of them.
The Medina (Second Edition) Experience
Deceptive Meanness and Constant Tension
The defining feeling in Medina is that every quiet move is also an attack. Reviewers repeatedly describe moves that look cooperative until their consequences appear. In the Getting Games playthrough, the host admits, "I think that's it's a deceptively mean game," and adds that players forget how mean some options are because they expect pieces to stay in their own territory. Reviewers say the game makes players second-guess themselves: one playthrough admits that "it is hard to commit to an action in this game." The tension builds because many decisions can be turned against the player who makes them.
The Satisfaction of Building a Town
The other prominent feeling is the reward of physical construction. The Watch It Played reviewer celebrates how the game transforms from an empty board into something visible, and the Getting Games playthrough says that setting out the chunky wooden pieces is "really satisfying" and that the experience of building a little town feels different from playing on a screen. The board fills in a way that changes each game, and both reviewers find the result rewarding: a completed Medina looks like a city that the players built together, even when their goals were opposed.
What Makes Medina (Second Edition) Stand Out
A Second Edition Built for Two Players
Reviewers repeatedly identify the new edition as the best way to play two-player. The Getting Games playthrough explains that the first edition was built primarily for three and four players, and that the second edition's changes make the two-player game work: a smaller double-sided board, neutral buildings for blocking, tea tiles that let a player stall, merchants that extend from the corners, and the well are all new. The same playthrough notes that the two-player version of the first edition was abysmally ranked on BoardGameGeek, while the second edition's two-player game is highly rated. The Getting Games update vlog reinforces the point, noting that the second edition is recommended for two, three, and four players.
Chunky Components and the Finished City
Both reviewers consistently praise the production. The Getting Games playthrough praises the game's "fun chunky little wooden pieces," and the Watch It Played reviewer argues that the game is at its best once the board is full, calling the finished city the visible record of the match, memorable even after a loss.
Potential Drawbacks
Perfect Information and Limited Randomness
The most pointed criticism comes from the Getting Games host, who compares Medina directly to Helis, another design by Stefan Dorra. The host says Helis is one of their favorite games and that Medina lacks the small injection of randomness that Helis has. In a two-player match with full information, the back-and-forth can leave one player feeling pushed into a corner. In the playthrough, the host believed the other player was going to take most of the majorities and was relieved to recover to a six-point finish. The Getting Games host accepts this as part of the design, but some players may find that the outcome feels predetermined once the board becomes crowded.
Heavy Decisions and Pacing Pitfalls
Medina asks a lot of its players. The Getting Games host notes that the early turns are difficult, that it is hard to commit to a placement, and that the forced two-piece turn can leave a player with awkward options. Tea tiles provide flexibility but can become a problem late in the game if a player has not planned for them. The Getting Games host says the hardest part so far is remembering to use neutral pieces defensively and keeping track of how many pieces remain, especially for a player who has only played a few times. The Getting Games host still finds the game rewarding, but its learning curve and demanding calculations may discourage players who prefer lighter decisions.
If You Enjoy Medina (Second Edition)
The clearest recommendation comes from the Getting Games host, who points to Helis, another Stefan Dorra design. The host calls Helis "a very different game" but still the one that Medina most reminds them of, and directs viewers to the Helis playthrough on the same channel. Players who enjoy Medina's push and pull, where every placement creates a new bait for the opponent, will likely find similar satisfaction in Helis. Helis adds a small measure of randomness that Medina does not have, so players who prefer perfect information may want to compare the two carefully before choosing. Players who value the tactile satisfaction of a growing town, along with the end-game scoring tension, are the audience the Getting Games host and the Watch It Played reviewer most often describe as enjoying Medina.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It starts off just an empty board, but once you've built all these big chunky wooden pieces, it's showstopping. It's one of the most beautiful games ever."
— Watch It Played
"I think that's it's a deceptively mean game. It's easy to forget how mean some of the mean options. You're just like, wait, I could do that, cuz we're so used to playing games where you know these are my pieces, these are John's pieces."
— Getting Games
"I played this one a couple of times on board game arena absolutely fallen in love with it so I'm happy to have a physical copy."
— Getting Games