Murray the A**hole Frog Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Murray the A**hole Frog
Murray the A**hole Frog is a 2024 set collection game from Devious Weasel Games, designed by Jenna Fi, with a play style that reviewers compare to rummy. Players assemble swarms of insects, score them at the end of the game, and contend with a frog who periodically arrives to devour a swarm. The Hungry Gamer channel offers the most detailed coverage of the title, and its reviewer calls the game "delightful" and says that Devious Weasel "knocked it out of the park" with it.
The consensus is that a small, inexpensive box delivers an outsized table experience. The reviewer praises the compact footprint, the convenience of carrying it to conventions, and the way the game gets a group talking. In the year-end Hungry Gamer video, Murray the Frog is named an honorable mention rather than a game of the year, with the reviewer explaining that it "doesn't quite have the depth" of a top pick, even while calling it a blast to play every time.
Core Mechanics That Define Murray the A**hole Frog
Swarm Building and Face-Value Scoring
The central set collection system asks players to form a swarm from at least three cards of the same insect type, and then to extend existing swarms with additional cards on later turns. Hungry Gamer explains that every card in front of a player scores its face value, so a larger tableau is worth more. Two bonuses reward disciplined building: a swarm of at least four cards earns five extra points, and a "perfect swarm" in which every card shares the same shape earns another five. Cards left in hand when the game ends are subtracted from the total, which the reviewer describes as a source of "a lot of kind of back and forth" and of large score swings. In one session the reviewer recalls a winning total of 56 points, and in another a winner finished with about 19, which illustrates how much the result depends on how a player manages Murray and the cards in hand.
Players also have a rich set of options around the swarms. Royal flies each carry an ability, such as the Firefly, which can pick up a swarm, and the Robber Fly, which can discard flies from swarms, and a player may discard a fly to use its power. Trading a card from hand with the Pond, the shared market of face-up cards, gives players a way to refresh their options.
Murray Attacks and Tadpole Compensation
The second core system is the frog itself. When Murray appears, he eats the entire Pond, which goes to the discard pile, and the active player then sends him to devour any swarm on the table. The owner of the eaten swarm receives a tadpole in return. Each tadpole scores one point more than the number of tadpoles its owner holds, so the value escalates as attacks accumulate. The reviewer describes this as a "weird thing that can happen" in which a player who has been attacked several times becomes harder to hurt, since each new tadpole is worth more. A wasp can redirect Murray to a different swarm, but a wasp held in hand is worth 10 points at the end of the game, so players must decide whether to spend it on protection or keep it for scoring. The Hawk is shuffled into the deck after the first full pass and serves as the endgame trigger. A player who holds it can play it as a first action for 20 points and end the game, or pass it along.
The Murray the A**hole Frog Experience
Mean, Gleeful Table Aggression
Reviewers are candid that the game is aggressive. Hungry Gamer says the game is "mean and it's really mean in the sense that Murray's coming up and you are just detonating people's tableau," and treats that cruelty as part of the fun. The tension comes from the frog's unpredictability: almost any turn can end with a carefully built swarm disappearing. The reviewer frames the result as comic rather than cruel, describing the frog's behavior as the reason every bad moment happens, which keeps the table laughing rather than sulking.
A Quick, Table-Talking Party Filler
Hungry Gamer describes the game as quick, smooth, and easy to tuck into a bag. Players move through the deck at a steady pace, and the reviewer notes that a player is rarely left without a move because the Pond trade and the discard-to-draw action give every hand something to do. The reviewer compares the title directly to Mouse Cheese Cat Cucumber, saying it is a game that will always be pulled out when there is a spare moment. Its effect on a group is the feature the reviewer returns to most often: it "really gets a table talking and thinking," and it does so in a short, light session.
What Makes Murray the A**hole Frog Stand Out
A Theme That Explains Every Moment
The strongest praise concerns how well the theme and mechanics fit together. Hungry Gamer admits that the theme seemed "just kind of there" while learning the game, but says it "really makes sense" once play is underway. Murray eats the Pond because he is a jerk, eats a swarm for the same reason, and leaves a tadpole behind for someone else to take care of. Even the Hawk, who eventually eats Murray, is described as satisfying. The reviewer says the design is "amazingly thematic" for a game they did not expect to be thematic at all.
Clever Trade-Offs in Every Turn
Reviewers highlight how the rules reward careful decisions. Each Royal fly offers a different power, and the wasp is worth 10 points if kept, so holding one is a real choice rather than a formality. The reviewer also praises the scoring as "very simple yet there's a lot that goes into the thought behind it," because the bonuses for four-card swarms, perfect swarms, and leftover hand cards all pull in different directions. The result, in the reviewer's account, is a game with real planning inside a light footprint.
Potential Drawbacks
Aggression May Not Suit Every Table
Hungry Gamer is clear that the attacks are the point and also the main hurdle. Players who take being targeted personally may find the constant swarm-eating frustrating. The reviewer warns that "if you are the type of person that has bad feelings from that then this is not going to be the type of game that you want to play." Rather than treating this as a flaw to be fixed, the reviewer presents it as a question of table temperament, with the game's appeal depending on whether a group enjoys playful spite.
Player Count and Setup Friction
Murray the A**hole Frog requires at least three players, and Hungry Gamer says the game "shines" at four, five, or six, which can make it harder to schedule with a small group. The reviewer also points to a production issue: with fewer than five or six players, certain cards must be removed from the deck, and the reviewer wished the bottom corner of the cards had said "five plus" so that players would not have to sort the deck by hand. The art also did not fully land for the reviewer, who said bugs are not a favorite subject, although the Murray and Hawk artwork is singled out for praise.
If You Enjoy Murray the A**hole Frog
Hungry Gamer names Mouse Cheese Cat Cucumber as the closest comparison. Both are light games that earn a permanent place in a convention bag and reliably start conversation at the table, so readers who like the quick, sociable pace of Mouse Cheese Cat Cucumber are likely to find the same appeal here. The Gen Con recap also shows the reviewer playing Killer alongside Murray the Frog during the convention, which suggests the two titles suit a similar kind of group. Readers who want a short, interactive game with a sharp edge should consider both, while keeping in mind that the aggressive tone of Murray will matter more to some tables than others.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"There's this weird thing that can happen in games where you have been attacked a couple times, you have a few tadpoles, well now suddenly you're kind of safe because you're going to be getting exponential points with every new tadpole."
— Hungry Gamer
"It's a game to me that one I did not think would be thematic, it is amazingly thematic. It is just a blast every single time I play it. It has not failed to hit once, fantastic game."
— Hungry Gamer
"This is another game like Mouse Cheese Cat Cucumber that's just always going to be in my convention bag, just pull out when there is a little bit of time, because it really is fun. It really works well, it really gets a table talking and thinking and it's just a blast."
— Hungry Gamer