Pie Face Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Pie Face
Nights Around a Table and The Dice Tower both treat Pie Face as a light, nostalgic novelty rather than a serious game. The reviewers are describing the spinner-and-crank edition that uses whipped cream or a wet sponge, not a game of drawing pie pieces from slots. Ryan of Nights Around a Table covers it in a list of "Russian roulette games for kids," noting that the box says "Whipped cream not included." Tom Vassel of The Dice Tower revisits the game 10 years after first reviewing it and gives it a 7 out of 10, saying Tom's enjoyment has faded somewhat.
Core Mechanics That Define Pie Face
Spinner-Set Cranking
Ryan explains the core loop in one sentence: "You spin the spinner, and that's how many times you got to turn the crank." The spin decides how many turns a player must make, and each turn moves the player closer to the splat. Ryan presents the spin as the only real input a player controls, which is central to Ryan's argument about the game's design.
Uncontrolled Splat Timing
Ryan's main critique rests on how little choice players have, describing the genre as a design where "you have absolutely no say when the thing is gonna pop. It's a completely randomized deal." Ryan defines a game as something that involves "some degree of skill or choice or agency," and places Pie Face on the toy side of that line. Players choose when to keep cranking, but the outcome of each crank is left to chance.
The Pie Face Experience
Slapstick Laughter
Tom Vassel finds the basic premise funny: "there's still something funny about seeing someone get hit in the face with a pie." The humor is physical and immediate, and it depends on watching another player take the hit. Tom's rating reflects that this humor has worn thinner across the decade, though Tom still acknowledges its appeal.
Messy Household Chaos
Ryan treats the mess as a defining part of the experience. Imagining a parent with a can of whipped cream in the living room, Ryan concludes that "whipped cream will be everywhere." Ryan also points out that the included wet sponge is an alternative to cream, though it never gets wet during the video. The reviewers picture the game being played at home, where cleanup is part of the fun.
What Makes Pie Face Stand Out
An Option Beyond Whipped Cream
Ryan notes that "they have included a sponge that you can wet," which gives families a way to play without the cream, suggesting the sponge might be the way to hit the player in the face.
A Long-Running Party Staple
Ryan expresses surprise at learning that Pie Face "is actually a game from the 60s, as BoardGameGeek informs me," and later cites a 1964 origin when discussing how long the genre has existed. Tom notes that the publisher had recently run a large marketing push, leading Tom to assume it was a modern release. Both observations point to a classic that has returned to shelves with new attention.
Potential Drawbacks
An Unclear Win Condition
Ryan admits uncertainty about how the game is won, asking, "what is the win condition? Do you WANT to get hit in the face with whipped cream?" Ryan is also unsure whether the splat counts as a reward or a penalty, finding that the design does not make the goal of play obvious.
Limited Decisions and Fading Novelty
Tom's concern is longevity. Looking back, Tom says that "maybe my amusement for this has dipped a bit," noting that beyond the pie gag there is little else to hold attention. Ryan's objection is structural: with so few decisions, the game sits closer to a toy than to a game, by Ryan's own definition of the terms.
If You Enjoy Pie Face
Based on the reviews, Pie Face suits families and groups who want a loud, silly party game where the laughs come from the splat rather than from strategy. It works best for players who are happy to hand the outcome to the spinner. Players who want meaningful decisions and agency will find less here, according to Ryan's framing. Reviewers also suggest planning for the mess before play, since Ryan expects whipped cream to end up on the furniture.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"As a parent, I can assure you that will not happen. Whipped cream will be everywhere!"
— Nights Around a Table
"I'm sure the rules say it, but what is the win condition? Do you WANT to get hit in the face with whipped cream? Do you NOT want to get hit in the face with whipped cream?"
— Nights Around a Table
"Maybe my amusement for this has dipped a bit, but there's still something funny about seeing someone get hit in the face with a pie, but that's about it."
— The Dice Tower