Poppycock! Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Poppycock!
Poppycock!, a 2018 trivia bluffing party game published by Clarendon Games, received a uniformly negative reception from The Dice Tower. Tom Vasel scored it 1 out of 10 in Vasel's dedicated segments and 2 out of 10 in a later rapid-fire roundup. Vasel's criticism centers on rules that are hard to follow, questions that do not work for a party game, and a bluffing system that Vasel felt did not hold together. Vasel summed up the view bluntly: "I hate this game. It is a waste of space. I despise it."
The one positive note across the reviews concerns the core idea. Vasel said that bluffing about whether you know an answer "is not particularly a bad one," but Vasel immediately argued that the rest of the design undermines it. Overall, the reviews treat Poppycock! as a game with a reasonable premise buried under confusing execution.
Core Mechanics That Define Poppycock!
Claim-and-Challenge Bluffing
Each round, the active player rolls a die to pick a trivia category, then reads a multiple-choice question with three answers. The player announces whether they know the answer and bids one, two, or three teeth, which functions as the distance they move on the tooth track. Each other player then secretly chooses either a "persuaded" card or a "poppycock" card. If everyone is persuaded, the outcome depends on whether the claimed answer is correct. If one or more players call poppycock and the answer is correct, the claimer advances and the callers move with them. If the answer is wrong, the callers advance by the bid instead.
Vasel found the structure confusing to parse. Vasel pointed out that the rules do not require the claimant to choose the answer they believe is right, which makes it unclear whether a claim is truly a bluff. Vasel described the teeth movement as a set of overlapping conditions that players must track at once.
Trivia Category Rolls and Three-Answer Questions
The game ships with 750 questions, and the die roll determines the subject area. Vasel's examples included which language "Merry Christmas" comes from, which company used the slogan "finger-licking good," which animal Indiana Jones fears, and which country the Vasa dynasty ruled for almost three centuries. Because the answers are presented as three options, the question itself carries most of the decision-making weight. The reviews argue that the quality of those questions determines whether the bluffing has anything to work with.
The Poppycock! Experience
Confusion Over Rules and Betting
The prevailing feeling in the reviews is bewilderment. Vasel said that reading the rules alone left Vasel with a sense of frustration, and described the game as one that takes far longer to understand than a party game should. Vasel noted that the game lists about 30 minutes of play but roughly two minutes to learn, a balance Vasel considered far off for a party game. "It should be like 10 seconds to learn a party game," Vasel said. The betting layer added to that confusion: Vasel asked why players bet teeth at all, and why a one-tooth bid is read as a sign of doubt when the knowledge behind it could go either way.
Guesswork Over Trivia Knowledge
In practice, the reviewers describe the play as guesswork rather than a contest of knowledge or deception. Vasel noted that a one-tooth bid gives other players only a one-third chance to be right about the answer, and that players can read too much into a low bid. Vasel argued that when a question is either too easy to bluff about or too obscure to know, the decision to call poppycock comes down to reading the table rather than thinking through the trivia.
What Makes Poppycock! Stand Out
- The bluffing premise: Reviewers agree that a game built around claiming to know an answer you may not know is a reasonable foundation for a party game, even though the execution fell short.
- The artwork on the cards: In one review, Vasel raised the art only as a rhetorical aside before listing other problems, but it is the one design element that a reviewer described positively. The box cover, by contrast, was called "really ugly" in another review.
Potential Drawbacks
Questions That Miss the Mark
The most consistent complaint concerns the trivia. Vasel said that a party game needs good questions, and argued that Poppycock! misses this in both directions. Some questions are so easy that they break the bluff, since nearly everyone knows that KFC is "finger-licking good" or that Indiana Jones is afraid of snakes. Others are so obscure that most players cannot evaluate them at all. The reviewers summarized the problem as questions that are "either too obscure or too common," which removes the knowledge gap that makes a bluff meaningful.
A Bluffing System That Does Not Hold Together
Vasel's central technical objection is that the rules do not reliably distinguish bluffing from honesty. A player can claim to know an answer, pick a wrong one, and still satisfy the rules, while a player who guesses correctly without knowing the answer has not technically bluffed. Vasel also questioned the purpose of the betting system, asking why players wager teeth at all when a bid of one only signals doubt that the table cannot verify. Although the underlying idea is "not particularly a bad one," Vasel's view is that the surrounding conditions turn it into more bookkeeping than a party game should require.
If You Enjoy Poppycock!
The Dice Tower reviews do not compare Poppycock! to any other titles, so there are no specific recommendations to draw from the discussion. Readers who seek out bluffing party games may still find the claim-and-challenge idea appealing, particularly those willing to set aside rules that the reviewers found hard to parse. Anyone who wants a smoother take on the same concept should weigh the reviewers' consistent complaints about the questions and betting before committing to it.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The rules never say I have to put down the answer I think is right. I just have to put down an answer. I could say I know the answer, you all believe me, and I pick the wrong answer."
— The Dice Tower
"The idea here of bluffing if you know an answer or not is not particularly a bad one, but so many bad things. First of all, the questions in this game are so important when you make a party game that you have good questions."
— The Dice Tower
"Poppycock is a terrible party game from Clarendon Games, in which I'm telling you the answer and then you guess if I know it or not or something like that. It's awful. I mean it just I hate everything about it."
— The Dice Tower