Reforest: Old Growth Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Reforest: Old Growth
The reviewers at The Dice Tower agree that Reforest: Old Growth is a worthwhile expansion, but they agree just as firmly on who it is for. Z Garcia describes the expansion as "basically the same concept with a couple of new additions," and argues that it keeps every idea from the original game while adding old growth trees, parasitic plants, and a terrain module. Zee Garcia, reviewing the expansion in a weekly roundup on The Dice Tower, reaches a narrower conclusion: the expansion is "definitely for people that have played Reforest a lot."
Both reviewers position the original Reforest as the better entry point. The base game is praised for its compact size and its directness, and the expansion is described as more complicated, larger, and slightly clunkier. Z Garcia still gives Reforest: Old Growth a 7.5 out of 10 and calls it a recommendation with caveats, while Zee Garcia frames the game as "not bad by any means" but reserved for a veteran audience. The shared view is that the expansion rewards players who already know the card pool well and is not a good place to start.
Core Mechanics That Define Reforest: Old Growth
Old Growth Trees and Placement Limits
Old growth trees are identified by a symbol before the name and a dark green bar along the bottom of the card. Reviewers explain that they represent trees that have been established for a long time, and that each one is limited in how many a player can have in front of them. In the base game, a player may hold only one old growth tree per pile. In the expansion, the canopy has six piles arranged by elevation (three at the lowest level, two at the middle level, and one at the very top), and a player may place only one old growth tree on each of those six piles. This restriction forces players to plan their canopy layout around which piles they reserve for these trees.
Parasitic Plants and Tucked Abilities
Parasitic plants carry a brown bar across the bottom and are often played for zero cost, but with a requirement about what they must grow under. Z Garcia explains that these cards are tucked beneath the canopy rather than placed on it, and that the tucked position is what unlocks their effect. Some parasitic plants have a "when played" ability that is revealed only once the card is tucked under another card. Placement is governed by the card's height and by symbols such as the sunlight requirement, which sends a card into the undergrowth. The most notable new twist is that some abilities allow a player to take a tucked card and flip it back over, turning its ability back on. Z Garcia notes that this allows players to recreate combos they had previously buried, but that doing so requires knowing the game well enough to remember what was hidden.
The Reforest: Old Growth Experience
Captivating but Thinkier
Reviewers describe the base game as a small box that delivers outsized engagement. Z Garcia says that the original game is "deceptive" in that it "will give you more interesting and engaging gameplay than you would suspect," and that its strength lies in being straightforward while still captivating. The expansion keeps that engagement but changes the feel. Z Garcia says the new version is "trickier to play now," with newer concepts that demand more attention, and Zee Garcia says it is "slightly clunkier" and loses some of the streamlined punch of the original. The result is a game that still holds attention but asks more of the table.
Acting on Incomplete Information
The expansion also changes how players think about the deck. Z Garcia points out that when the expansion is mixed with the base game, a four player game uses only 90 cards, which means more than 100 cards are not in play at all. Because of this, a player cannot account for something being in the deck, since a card they are hoping to see may simply not be included. Z Garcia says the expansion "very much feels like it is for people that have played this little guy backwards and forwards," and describes a player who knows the cards well and the combos they create, looking to go beyond that familiarity. For these players, the uncertainty adds a layer of tension that the base game does not provide.
What Makes Reforest: Old Growth Stand Out
The Terrain Module
The most praised addition is the terrain module. Each player draws three terrain cards and can keep one or more, placing each at an elevation of their choosing on the canopy. Terrain cards carry abilities that can be scoring, passive, or triggered during setup, and a player who dislikes a terrain card can discard it and draw a replacement card, beginning with one more card in hand. Z Garcia calls the module "excellent" and says they like it better than the events module from the original small box. Because terrain applies to elevations in front of everyone, the module also adds shared considerations to the table.
An Expansion That Removes Nothing
Reviewers consistently highlight that the expansion is additive. Z Garcia notes that the designers "removed no ideas" from the base game, so every mechanic from the original is still present alongside the new old growth trees and parasitic plants. The expansion also adds more visitors and events, which can be shuffled in as optional modules. Both reviewers appreciate the artwork and the presentation, with Zee Garcia calling the game "pretty" and describing it as "still very much an interesting game." The storage box is also a practical feature, because it holds both the original game and the expansion together.
Potential Drawbacks
Reduced Accessibility Compared to the Original
The most consistent concern is that the expansion is harder to learn and less clean to play than the base game. Zee Garcia says the expansion is "more complicated than the original release" and loses much of the streamlined quality that made the original stand out. Z Garcia says the original is the better standalone game because it "cuts to the quick a little more directly." Both reviewers suggest that the new mechanics are not a good starting point for new players, and that anyone who wants to experience Reforest should begin with the base game and play it extensively before approaching the expansion.
Packaging and Standalone Use
Reviewers also question how well the expansion works as a standalone product. Z Garcia says the box is "a little big, unnecessarily" when the expansion is used alone, and it becomes more sensible only when everything is stored together. Zee Garcia argues that the standalone question matters less than the audience question, since the expansion is still best suited to someone who has already mastered the base game. For buyers who do not own the original Reforest, the larger box offers less value than it would for a fan who plans to combine the two.
If You Enjoy Reforest: Old Growth
Reviewers are clear that the base Reforest is the best first step. Players who enjoy the compact, deceptive engagement of the original will find that the expansion builds on it without replacing it. Those who enjoy the tucking and flipping of parasitic plants will find similar satisfaction in rediscovering combos they once buried, though the expansion requires more knowledge of the card pool to use effectively. Players who value the terrain module will find that it offers shared, elevation-based considerations that change how the whole table approaches the canopy. The reviewers' advice is consistent: play the original Reforest extensively, then move to Old Growth when the base game begins to feel familiar.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I really like this little card game. And I think one of the strengths of it was the fact that it was deceptive. This little box, it is a small thing. It's something that certainly can fit in a purse or in a pocket even and will give you more gameplay, will give you more interesting and engaging gameplay that than you would suspect. It belies its little box size."
— Z Garcia, The Dice Tower
"This expansion very much feels like it is for people that have played this little guy backwards and forwards that know the cards really, really well. They know the combos really well and they're looking to step beyond that."
— Z Garcia, The Dice Tower
"It's not bad by any means. I just would never recommend it except for an audience that has already played the original one a lot."
— Zee Garcia, The Dice Tower