Richard the Lionheart Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Richard the Lionheart
Richard the Lionheart, a 2017 game published by CMON and designed by Andrea Chiarvesio, has drawn praise for its table talk and manipulation. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast was first drawn in by the Robin Hood, Sheriff of Nottingham, and Ivanhoe mythology and by the box, which the reviewer described as full of gorgeous miniatures, a beautiful board, and fantastic artwork. Once the rules were played, the real appeal turned out to be a game where teammates are each other's chief rivals. That reviewer argues the game is meant to be played "hardball," with every discussion aimed at personal benefit, and hopes an expansion will add more options on each turn.
Rolling Dice & Taking Names covered the game in both an early look at a prototype shown at a trade show and a later Gen Con recap, after the publisher had reworked the board. Both segments returned to the same core point: the game rewards players who scheme against their own team, and the mounting tension of the Crusade keeps the table engaged. The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast also found that player count changes the experience sharply. With six players the board becomes crowded and turns get clogged, while four players open up freedom of action.
Core Mechanics That Define Richard the Lionheart
Card Drafting
Each round, players feed cards into a shared Crusade deck, with every player required to contribute at least two cards. The pool is shuffled, a number of cards are revealed based on the player count, and each team tries to win the majority of banners among the revealed cards so that its tracks advance. Movement adds a drafting layer of its own. When a player moves into a city, they can exchange cards from their hand for cards in the reserve, which lets them pick up exactly the cards they need for a banner track instead of relying on blind draws. Rolling Dice & Taking Names singled out the moment the revealed cards are counted as the peak of the game's suspense.
Resource Management
Coins, gold, cards, and movement are spent on nearly every action. Each turn, a player moves up to three spaces, and actions often require spending cards or money to gain specific or random cards, coins, or prestige points. Market purchases add to the squeeze. Players can buy an influence card or prestige, a horse that raises movement from three to four spaces, or a ship that crosses water spaces. Secret Cabal noted that these purchases depend heavily on the table. With four players they are useful extras, but with six players the crowded board makes horses and ships feel like gold, because players need them just to reach the spaces where they want to act. Spending two coins also lets a player add a third card to the Crusade pool, so every coin has a competing use.
The Richard the Lionheart Experience
Negotiation and Betrayal
The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast describes the table talk as the heart of the game. Edict cards give each player individual objectives that often conflict with teammates, so every conversation about which cards to play has to serve personal benefit. Players can even make this openly cooperative in a twisted way. A teammate can move through another player's space and steal a card, and the player whose card is taken may have asked for it, since they hold many cards and their partner holds few. The reviewer says the simple cooperative approach leaves little to do, so the real game is the manipulation of teammates and the constant maneuvering to undercut them.
Push and Pull Suspense
Rolling Dice & Taking Names described the suspense of the Crusade pool as the most memorable part of play. When the banners are compared, the difference between the teams moves a track closer to the end. Richard's journey home and the royal coffers each respond to which side has more banners, so the team that advances a track can change the table's sense of when the game might end. The hosts said the rest of the board movement felt secondary to this push and pull, and that the game gains energy once the players realize the game could end on any turn.
What Makes Richard the Lionheart Stand Out
Beautiful Production and Clear Iconography
Secret Cabal praised the production in strong terms, calling the miniatures absolutely gorgeous and the board beautiful, with fantastic artwork and tons of cards in the box. Rolling Dice & Taking Names credited CMON for acting on feedback from the prototype stage, when the graphic design was hard to read and the tokens criss-crossed as they moved. After the revision, the hosts said the board was easy to understand, the iconography was straightforward, and tokens now move cleanly from left or right. That clarity matters because the game's tug-of-war depends on players reading the track positions at a glance.
A Team Game With an Individual Winner
The defining structure splits players into two teams, one backing Richard and one backing John, but only the prestige leader on the winning team is the ultimate winner. Rolling Dice & Taking Names described the team structure as a cooperative game in name only, where the other team barely matters to players who care about beating their own teammates. A teammate who piles up prestige while the team loses gets nothing, a lesson the hosts drew from their own table. Secret Cabal described the first, softball way of playing as a comfortable win that still feels like victory even when the player is not the ultimate winner, and contrasted it with the hardball style that the game is designed to reward.
Potential Drawbacks
A Premium Price Point
Secret Cabal lists the MSRP at seventy dollars, which the reviewer said might be cost prohibitive for many players. The reviewer also described the production as almost overproduced, with a lot of cool components that some buyers may not value. For anyone unsure about the investment, the reviewer recommended trying the game before buying, since the beautiful components and the deeper manipulation play are what justify the price.
A Thin Theme on the Cards
Secret Cabal's central criticism is that the event cards show a title but no text describing what actually happened. The reviewer argued that the intrigue of the Crusade, such as a tournament, a theft, or a murder, is missing from the mechanics and has to be supplied by players at the table. Events still change the rules or offer additional prestige scoring, so the mechanics are felt without the narrative behind them. The reviewer wished the theme were stronger, but stressed that this is not a deal breaker for the game.
If You Enjoy Richard the Lionheart
Players drawn to the push and pull of Richard the Lionheart may appreciate Star Cartel, an Osprey Games market game that Rolling Dice & Taking Names called a good tug of war, where players drive resource prices up or down and keep only the values in the middle. Players who enjoy hidden loyalties and table talk can look at Ultimate Werewolf, the social deduction series that Rolling Dice & Taking Names described as one of the most popular party game series, and at Crossfire, a fast social deduction game in which a VIP must be protected while players bluff and lie at the table. Each of these titles rewards reading other players and making deals, the same skills that drive the teammate rivalry at the center of Richard the Lionheart.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"This game is all about the manipulation. If you really get in deep, that's how this game is played best, because there isn't as much replayability if you play the softball version of just a nice co-op."
— The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast
"Tension is everything in this game, because to be honest with you, moving around that board, there wasn't much to it. It was very interesting on how that tension kept ramping up, and you're sitting there trying to count: okay, how many cards are in there? I really love that about this game."
— Rolling Dice & Taking Names
"The miniatures are absolutely gorgeous, the board is beautiful, the artwork is fantastic, tons of cards in the box, but then when I read the rules, it disappointed me because it wasn't what I expected it to be."
— The Secret Cabal Gaming Podcast