Set & Match Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Set & Match
Reviewers who cover Set & Match agree on its basic appeal: it is a flicking game that takes tennis seriously. The most detailed discussion comes from BoardGameBollocks, whose reviewers call it the closest thing they have played to real tennis and rate it five out of five. That enthusiasm sits alongside a long list of practical complaints about the rulebook, the court, and the look of the base edition, so the praise reads as considered rather than casual.
A shorter but equally positive view comes from Adam Porter, Adam in Wales - Board Game Design. Porter places Set & Match among the sport-based flicking games, a group whose objectives come from the sports they imitate, and they describe the game as an excellent recent sports simulation. They also stress that its tension does not depend on being a tennis fan. Where BoardGameBollocks dwells on rules and presentation, Porter is more interested in where the game sits within the wider flicking tradition, which they trace back through marbles, carom, and early table football. The two perspectives meet on one point: this is a serious attempt to recreate a sport, not a light theme laid over a flicking mechanism.
Core Mechanics That Define Set & Match
Flicking
Flicking is the core action. Each player works with a single ball pawn, placed on the left side of the baseline for a serve, and flicks it across the net toward target boxes on the far side. BoardGameBollocks stresses that the result of each shot rests on the player's hand, since a flick that misses the target box or leaves the court is classed as out. That places Set & Match in the dexterity tradition Porter describes, where the playing piece is the design's starting point and shapes how every flick behaves. Here the piece is a ball, and the reviewers' experience suggests the game rewards a steady hand more than calculation.
Target Zone Scoring and Rally Tug of War
The scoring system is the idea BoardGameBollocks singles out most. The game follows the tennis sequence, with three games to a set and three sets to a win, and each serve adds a point to the serve total based on the box it lands in. A first serve that lands earns a one point bonus, while a second serve does not. After that, rallies work as a tug of war: players flick back and forth, pushing a marker toward the opponent's end of the track until one player lands the disc in a points box. A shot from cross court to cross court earns an extra point, a shot from the back of the court into the opponent's drop zone earns one too, and ace boxes let a server win a point with a single shot. The reviewers describe this as a unique points mechanism that replicates rallies, and they say it gives them the feeling of gaining momentum.
The Set & Match Experience
Tension
Tension is the feeling reviewers return to most often. Porter calls the game incredibly tense whether or not a player follows tennis, which suggests the pressure comes from the scoring rather than the subject. BoardGameBollocks describes the same pressure from the other side of the table: when a player is struggling to win the point that closes out a game, every flick has to claw back the two or three points needed to push the disc over the line. The reviewers also note that the game rewards risk. A player who goes for a corner box worth three points is tempted to gamble everything, and the cost of a miss is an out.
Momentum and Pace
Momentum is the other side of the experience. Players flick the disc across the board and then simply pick up where it lands, so games progress very quickly. BoardGameBollocks contrast this with Afintennis, a game they felt tried to recreate tennis without fully succeeding. The pace is one reason they call the game fast and exciting, and they say it never seems to get boring, even though they found its appearance unappealing.
What Makes Set & Match Stand Out
Tennis Rules Built Into Play
BoardGameBollocks praise how far the rules go beyond the flick itself. The first serve bonus, the tricky shots into the drop zones, the accurate cross court shots, and the ace boxes all echo real tennis, and the reviewers describe the design as dramatically sound. They admit it took them by surprise. They had expected a simple flicking game and found that the designers had thought carefully about the finer points of the sport.
Doubles Play
The reviewers also highlight that Set & Match supports four players. The court has an extra area that, as in real tennis, comes into use when playing doubles, and the rulebook includes alternation rules that govern who serves to whom and who plays next. BoardGameBollocks note that this widens the group of people who can share a match, which many flicking games do not offer.
Potential Drawbacks
A Hard to Follow Rulebook
The most frequent complaint from BoardGameBollocks concerns the rulebook. It refers to figures and diagrams that the reviewers could not find in the main text. The visual aid they needed was stapled into the centre of the book with no indication that it was there, and they spent around half an hour searching before stumbling on it by chance. The staples also caused an injury, as one reviewer cut a finger while trying to remove them. The reviewers describe the rulebook as disorganized, and that frustration shaped how they first experienced the game.
Court Size and Presentation
The court is a touch too small for the reviewers, which makes it hard to judge shots. A larger version exists, but BoardGameBollocks would not pay roughly 70 quid for it. They also point out that the base game has no marker showing which side to serve from, a gap that could ruin a match with a player who follows the rules closely. On looks, the version they played tries to replicate a clay court, and they find it unappealing, although they note that the larger edition appears to look better.
If You Enjoy Set & Match
Players who enjoy Set & Match's tennis flavor will find Afintennis a natural comparison, since BoardGameBollocks reviewed it as an earlier attempt to capture tennis on the tabletop. Set & Match avoids the difficulties the reviewers saw there by having players flick the disc and pick up where it lands, which keeps games moving at a much faster pace.
Players who enjoy the head to head tension and the way Set & Match's scoring builds momentum will find similar satisfaction in Pitch Out. Porter calls it great for a competitive head to head, and they describe its elimination goal, where players try to knock out their opponent's captain or every other piece. Players who want another flicking game with that sense of contest can also look at Light and Dark, which Porter recommends alongside it.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"But the risk reward mechanism when you're trying to get the market in the zone that's going to score your points is utterly utterly compelling. It's exciting, it's fast, it's interesting, and we really really enjoy this game."
— BoardGameBollocks
"We were really surprised. We thought it's just another flicking game but it isn't."
— BoardGameBollocks
"Set and match is an excellent recent sports simulation game which has players flicking a disc back and forth across a tennis court, but of course if the disc ends out of bounds then the opposing player scores points just as in real tennis."
— Adam Porter, Adam in Wales - Board Game Design