The Sherlock Files: Elementary Entries Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About The Sherlock Files: Elementary Entries
Community coverage of The Sherlock Files: Elementary Entries is still thin. Tim Chuon mentions it in two Gen Con videos, first as one of several demo decks received at the convention and again during an unboxing of the same convention goodies. Those mentions are brief and do not offer an opinion on how the game plays. The title comes from Indie Boards and Cards, a publisher known for cooperative and social deduction games, and its published player range stretches from a single solo detective up to a table of eight, which is wider than most card-based mystery games attempt.
Watch It Played gives the most substantive perspective. Answering a viewer question, the channel lists the mystery-solving games its hosts have played, names The Sherlock Files among them, and says the hosts enjoy puzzle-unlock and exit-style games in general. The overall picture is one of curiosity and goodwill rather than a settled verdict.
Core Mechanics That Define The Sherlock Files: Elementary Entries
Cooperative Clue Identification
According to its published description, the game is cooperative, with players working together as detectives to decide which clues are relevant to a case. None of the three videos go into detail on how that selection works, so this is the game's stated design rather than a reviewer's account of play.
Solving Three Victorian Mysteries
The game is built around three Victorian-era mysteries. Each one is a self-contained case that the group works through, and the published description frames success as identifying the clues that matter. Reviewers have not yet described how the three cases differ from one another in practice.
The The Sherlock Files: Elementary Entries Experience
Group Mystery Solving
The one reviewer who describes actually playing the game frames it as a group activity. Watch It Played says they played through a few of the cases with family members, which suggests the game is meant to be shared at a table rather than played alone. The reviewer also places it within a broader taste for puzzle-unlock and exit-style games.
Light, Quick Sessions
The published listing gives a playtime of about 50 minutes and a weight of 1.80 out of 5, which points to a light, short-session deduction game. No reviewer has commented on pacing or on how the session length feels in play, so this comes from the listing rather than from reviewer experience.
What Makes The Sherlock Files: Elementary Entries Stand Out
Presence on the Convention Floor
Tim Chuon received a demo deck of the game at Gen Con, alongside other titles from the same publisher's showcase. Being included in a convention demo deck signals that the game was being actively promoted to attendees, and it earned mentions in two separate videos from the same creator.
A Fit for Puzzle-Unlock Fans
Watch It Played's comments connect the game to a specific audience: players who enjoy puzzle-unlock and exit-style experiences. For that group, the game's case-based structure is the element most likely to stand out, though the reviewer's remarks are general enough that they do not single out a specific feature.
Potential Drawbacks
Few In-Depth Reviews
The clearest limitation is the lack of detailed coverage. The three available videos mention the game only briefly, so there is no reviewer discussion of its strengths or weaknesses in depth. Both Gen Con mentions come from the same creator describing the same demo deck rather than from independent voices, and the one play report is a single sentence inside a wider conversation about other games. Anyone deciding whether to buy the game should look for longer, dedicated reviews before relying on these impressions.
Unclear Replay Value
No reviewer addresses how the game holds up after the three mysteries are solved. Because replayability is a common question for case-based deduction games, this gap is worth noting for anyone who expects to play the game many times.
If You Enjoy The Sherlock Files: Elementary Entries
The game is best suited to groups who enjoy solving mysteries together, including families and friends who like puzzle-unlock and exit-style games. The reviewers in these videos do not name any direct comparison titles for The Sherlock Files, so this section focuses on the kind of player the game appeals to rather than on alternatives.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Also got a demo deck of the Sherlock Files and Finger Guns and High Noon. All these three were given to us by Indie Game Studios."
— Tim Chuon
"We got Sherlock Files a demo deck."
— Tim Chuon
"mystery solving game Sherlock the Sherlock files we me and Andrea and Lucas played through a few of those I enjoy the the puzzle unlock style games and exit games"
— Watch It Played