Trick or Bid Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Trick or Bid
Reviewers agree that Trick or Bid is a fun trick-taking game with one memorable twist, but they disagree about how far that twist lifts it above the crowd. Board Gaming Ramblings, hosted by Sonal and Johannes, placed the game in its Keep or Cull series and called it a good way to introduce people to trick-taking. The hosts found it more interesting than they expected, yet still ranked it below the titles they wanted to keep in their collection. That qualified praise is the Ramblings position in a nutshell.
Board Game Buzzz, hosted by Kari, was considerably more enthusiastic. Kari sat down with the game's designer, Jeremy, at the Buttonshy convention in Seattle, where the game surprised them and left them eager to add a copy to their collection. Both channels highlight the same core idea. They differ mainly in how strongly they would recommend it to someone already deep in the hobby.
Core Mechanics That Define Trick or Bid
Trick-Taking
The foundation of the game is the familiar trick-taking loop: players contest tricks, and winning one carries real weight. Board Gaming Ramblings called the game a good one for introducing newcomers to trick-taking, which is a large part of why the channel saw it as a welcoming entry point. Kari compared the feel of play to Skull King, a title many trick-taking players already know, which gives experienced players a reference point even though Trick or Bid departs from that model in important ways.
Winner's Choice Bidding
The distinctive system is the choice the winner of each trick makes. Board Gaming Ramblings explained the decision directly: the winner can keep the trick as a trick, counting it toward tricks won that round, or skip that and take one of the cards in the trick, using its number as the bid for the round. The Ramblings reviewers also pointed out that the first time a player makes that choice, the color of the trick becomes trump for the rest of the round. Kari emphasized that this makes the bid something you decide during play rather than at the start of the round, which separates it from Skull King's opening bids.
The Trick or Bid Experience
Playful Tension Around Bidding
The bidding choice creates a constant sense of calculation. Board Gaming Ramblings speculated that the table might drift toward extremes, with everyone bidding high and getting caught out, or everyone bidding low, and the reviewer described that possibility as something that might change how the table plays. Because the winner of each trick can change the target, no one can settle into a comfortable plan for long. The feeling is less about grinding out a perfect score and more about watching the table react to the last trick and adjusting on the fly.
An Easy Gateway That Still Surprises
The second feeling is a light, approachable surprise. Board Gaming Ramblings described the game as more interesting than they expected, and Kari said it surprised them outright. Neither channel framed the experience as heavy or demanding. It reads as a smile-inducing trick-taker that rewards a little curiosity, the kind of game that a group can pick up quickly and enjoy without a long rules session.
What Makes Trick or Bid Stand Out
Choosing Between Trick and Bid
Reviewers consistently point to the decision made after winning a trick as the element that sets the game apart. Kari described the bid as something players decide during the game rather than at the start of each round, a timing choice that keeps every trick consequential. Because the same trick can either count directly or set a target for the round, the choice feels meaningful even in a short session.
Trump Set by the Table
Board Gaming Ramblings singled out the rule that the first player to use the bid option establishes the trump color for the round. That one addition means the trump suit is not fixed in advance, and it gives the first player to make a bid a special kind of influence over the rest of the round. Combined with the winner's choice, it adds a layer of planning that the Ramblings hosts found more interesting than the rest of the trick-taking titles they had just played, even though they still kept the other games higher on their list.
Potential Drawbacks
Less Distinctive Than Favorites
Board Gaming Ramblings was clear that Trick or Bid is less interesting than the titles the hosts wanted to keep. For a crowded collection, that is a meaningful verdict. The game is enjoyable and worth a play, but the reviewers did not see it as a must-own experience that would displace stronger trick-takers.
Uncertain Release Status
Kari noted that the game was listed on Board Game Arena as coming out in 2025, and that they were not certain whether it was available yet at the time of the convention. That uncertainty matters for anyone who wants to buy it immediately. Readers who want to try the game should check current availability before planning around it.
If You Enjoy Trick or Bid
Players who enjoy Trick or Bid's winner's choice bidding will find a similar sense of play in Skull King, the game Kari compared it to. Skull King asks players to commit to a bid at the start of the round, so the satisfaction comes from reading the table and hitting that target. Trick or Bid moves the bid into the middle of play, which rewards players who like to adjust their plans as each trick resolves.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Yes, the winner decides if they want to keep it as a trick or if they want to not have a trick but take one of the cards and the number of that is their bid for their round. And also the first time a player does that that color also becomes the trump."
— Board Gaming Ramblings
"Kind of reminded me a little bit of Skull King where at the beginning of the round you set how many tricks you think you're going to win and then you play it out. This one is interesting because you kind of decide that during the game."
— Kari, Board Game Buzzz
"It's so good. Especially if you like trick- taking games, this one's really, really fun."
— Kari, Board Game Buzzz