Up Front Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Up Front
Drive Thru Games, Zilla Blitz, Legendary Tactics and Board Game Hangover all write about Up Front as a demanding card-driven game from Avalon Hill's 1980s catalog. Drive Thru Games places it 50th on its top 100 list and says it delivers a visceral sense of close-quarters infantry combat. Zilla Blitz ranks it sixth on a personal top 10 of Avalon Hill war games and says it holds up well today. Legendary Tactics ranks it third on its own list. Board Game Hangover calls it a classic it has not yet played, and says it is hard to get into. The praise centers on how tense and immersive the close-quarters play feels, while the complaints center on the rulebook, the learning curve, and how hard the game is to find today.
Core Mechanics That Define Up Front
Hand Management
Board Game Hangover explains that units are activated by playing cards from your hand, and that cards drawn from the deck also set the random numbers used for attack and defense. Zilla Blitz notes the cost of that design: at times a player can end up waiting for the right card before doing what the position needs. Legendary Tactics credits the same card system with carrying the game's fog of war, because the battlefield is built up through cards rather than a fixed map. Since the hand is the main way to act, each turn becomes a decision about which cards to spend and which to hold back.
Multi-Use Cards
Drive Thru Games says it is not sure Up Front was the first game with multi-use cards, but argues that the cards do a great deal, and that even their backs can act as terrain. Board Game Hangover sums up the design by calling the game one giant card game, with cards for actions, cards for units, and cards for terrain. Together these two descriptions explain why the design stands apart from the other wargames discussed alongside it.
The Up Front Experience
Chaos and Anxiety
Zilla Blitz says the game captures the chaos, frustration, anxiety, and drama of man-to-man combat in World War II in a way that transcends time. Drive Thru Games sets it against most wargames, which it says tend to feel reserved and pulled back from the actual combat. Legendary Tactics praises the fog of war, calling the way the game handles it a great achievement. Together these descriptions present the experience as tense and uncertain rather than detached.
Squad Leader Lineage
Zilla Blitz calls Up Front "the squad leader card game" and places it beside Squad Leader on its top 10, where Squad Leader sits at number five. Legendary Tactics ties the game's rules to the same design era as Advanced Squad Leader, saying the rules of that period were all about adding as much chrome as possible. That heritage explains why players who know the older titles tend to recognize the design right away, and why the rules can feel dense to everyone else.
What Makes Up Front Stand Out
Cards as Terrain
Drive Thru Games says that when it first played the game the terrain idea seemed odd, but it became fascinating over time, because players can play cards to become the terrain and build the battlefield as they go. Zilla Blitz points out the practical side: there is no map, so players move cards around the table to show different distances. Legendary Tactics adds that the whole map is drawn out essentially with cards and imagination, and that a recording of a game would show what the final board looked like. Together these accounts describe a battlefield built through play rather than set up at the start.
Design Innovation
A panel on wargame innovation, recorded at SD Histcon and posted on Zilla Blitz's channel, names Up Front as a card-driven breakthrough. The panel credits the game's designer, Courtney Allen, with both Up Front and Storm over Arnhem, calling them giant innovations in their time that stood on the shoulders of earlier work. Another panelist says that placing a hand of cards at the center of play, combined with a point-to-point board, is a fusion of ideas that shaped how later designers approached cards, and says that approach influenced their own work.
Potential Drawbacks
A Hard Rulebook
Board Game Hangover says the rulebook is an accomplishment in itself, with a very small font and no pictures, and that the game rated just four out of ten in difficulty when it came out in 1983, leaving the speaker wondering what ten out of ten would look like. Zilla Blitz says the rulebook is not one of the best in Avalon Hill's catalog, and that a friend, Mike from Pub Battles, taught the game when the rules were hard to follow. Legendary Tactics says the rules are maybe a little more fiddly than they should be. Drive Thru Games calls the base rules good but dense, and says later reprints and living rulebooks make the game easier to get into.
Limited Availability
Drive Thru Games says Up Front is accessible and readily available, though not always through normal retail channels. Its own store offers a print-on-demand version of the game, produced after a dispute with Wizards of the Coast and the original artist was resolved, that includes the cards and counters. The only thing missing is the original box, which can be replaced with a custom one. The Drive Thru Games video on 2013 games recalls the Up Front Kickstarter as a mess that left some backers without copies and became a running joke in the industry for about two years. UndeadVikingVideos describes the publisher history as a tangle: Valley Games and Radiant Gaming were involved, the Kickstarter raised about $339,000, and the speaker says some backers never received their games. The speaker admits to not being sure of all the details and says they may be wrong on some points, so this account should be read as recollection rather than settled fact.
If You Enjoy Up Front
Legendary Tactics recommends starting with a basic game that uses only the soldiers, without vehicles or artillery, and says the game is still excellent in that form. Drive Thru Games says it cannot recommend the game enough, and suggests that having a regular partner to play with helps make it enjoyable. Players who already know Squad Leader will recognize the lineage, and Zilla Blitz says the host found Advanced Squad Leader intimidating and owns only the base game of Squad Leader. Drive Thru Games says it would rather play Combat Commander, which it describes as a better game that borrows elements from Up Front. Newcomers should expect a steep learning curve and a dense rulebook, so starting small is the most practical path.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Even the backs of the cards can act as Terrain. This is the kind of interesting thing when I first played it I was like this is kind of weird but then I've really become fascinated with it."
— Drive Thru Games
"This game is so good. It's man-to-man combat. You take a squad and you're going against a squad of your opponent."
— Zilla Blitz
"Upfront is one giant card game. You have cards for actions, you have cards for units, and you have cards for terrain."
— Board Game Hangover