Legendary Forests Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Legendary Forests
Legendary Forests, the 2019 tile laying game from Iello, comes across as cute, light, and quick. Reviewers generally enjoy the puzzle of building a forest where every tile edge has to match, but the enthusiasm rarely carries past a first session. John Gets Games was positive about the design in the moment and still concluded that the game did not earn a permanent place on the shelf.
In a July 2019 update, John Gets Games described the game as a simplified Kuba style tile laying title that proved more appealing than expected. By the November 2019 update, the same host had removed it from the collection. The verdict was that the game was "totally fine" and would be no hardship to play again, but the host could not see reaching for it over other games. Chaz Marlowe of Pair of Dice Paradise approached the game from the Origins Game Fair side, anticipating a satisfying puzzle rather than reporting on a long play experience. The overall sentiment is that Legendary Forests is a pleasant puzzle that works on its own terms and then struggles to justify its space on a crowded shelf.
Core Mechanics That Define Legendary Forests
Simultaneous Tile Placement
The central mechanic is simultaneous tile placement, and it is the feature every reviewer returns to. One person pulls a tile from the shared pool, and every player at the table places that identical tile into their own growing forest at the same time. Because everyone receives the same input, John Gets Games frames the appeal as watching how each player turns the same draw into a different result. Publisher Iello puts this tile system in a space that John Gets Games directly compares to Kuba, noting that Legendary Forests is even simpler than that game.
Forest Building and Closed-Area Scoring
Each player builds an individual forest world by connecting landscapes across the edges of their tiles. John Gets Games describes planting trees that score for different things depending on how they end up placed, so a single tile placement can pay off in more than one way once the forest closes. That payoff, not a single fixed point value per tile, is what gives the tile-matching its weight: a tile is never just a shape to fit, it is also a bet on which of several scoring conditions it will end up satisfying.
The Legendary Forests Experience
Puzzle Satisfaction Without a Heavy Commitment
Chaz Marlowe of Pair of Dice Paradise framed the appeal as a change of pace. Chaz described the game as a puzzle that can be a welcome break from the hack and slash, dungeon crawl, and miniatures-heavy games that seem to appear often. The matching of edges and the choice of where each tile goes give the game a focused puzzle quality with low stakes, and Chaz hoped it would deliver a genuinely good puzzle. John Gets Games also found the puzzling moments enjoyable, even though the enjoyment did not last beyond a play or two.
Cute, Colorful Presentation at a Quick Pace
John Gets Games described Legendary Forests as a cute little game, with forests taking shape from tiles in a variety of colors. Its runtime of roughly 20 minutes keeps the experience brief, so the game works as a short opener or filler between heavier titles. That same brevity is also why the reviewer felt it had to be especially strong to earn a lasting spot in a collection where heavier euro games take up more of the table.
What Makes Legendary Forests Stand Out
Watching Everyone Solve the Same Puzzle
Because every player places the same tile, the random element is a shared constant rather than a source of unfairness. John Gets Games highlighted that this makes the game a test of who handles the same output best, which creates a direct comparison between players: each one watches the others' landscapes and wonders whose choices will hold up at the end.
A Game That Never Has a Bad Play
John Gets Games was careful to separate liking the game from keeping it: the single play was enjoyable, and the design itself was called "totally fine" with no complaint about how it actually played at the table. For a light filler that gets pulled out between heavier games, delivering exactly what it promises in the moment, even from a reviewer who ultimately passed it along, is a real point in its favor.
Potential Drawbacks
Very Light Weight
Legendary Forests is a very light game, and that is the first concern reviewers raise. John Gets Games said it is a rather light game that plays in about 20 minutes, and noted that a host who does not play light titles often needs a game to be really strong before it stays around. Players who prefer deeper strategy or a longer, more involved session are unlikely to find much here to hold their attention.
Limited Long-Term Shelf Appeal
The removal decision is the clearest signal of the game's staying power. John Gets Games said they never found themselves going back to the game and did not see themselves pushing to play it instead of something else. That is the concern for any light puzzle with a short arc: the first session delivers the satisfaction, but the reasons to return are thin, and tight shelf space makes that gap decisive.
If You Enjoy Legendary Forests
The clearest comparison reviewers make is to Kuba, and John Gets Games places Legendary Forests as an even simpler take on that style of tile laying. If you enjoy Kuba style play, this game offers a faster and more approachable version with the same satisfaction of fitting tiles into a shared pattern. It suits players who want a short, puzzle-first game with a simultaneous turn, who enjoy seeing how the same draw plays out differently for each person, and who need a light title to open a session or fill a short slot. Players with tight shelves or a taste for long-term depth may find the game less lasting, as the reviews suggest.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"It's the style of game where everybody places the same tile at the same time so it's simultaneous action selection and everybody gets the same random input and you're curious to see who does the best with the output."
— John Gets Games
"A puzzling aspect to this game which I must admit can be a nice deal for a refreshing break from hack and slash and dungeon crawl and miniatures infested games that seem to crop up a lot every now and then."
— Chaz Marlowe, Pair of Dice Paradise
"It's actually a Kuba style tile laying game, so one person pulls out a tile and everybody puts the same tile down, but it's even simpler than Kuba and I liked it more than I expected."
— John Gets Games