TDG: The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing
Transcript
Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, my family is really upset because I'm dating my third cousin, but they didn't say anything when I dated the first two. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at the Plum Island Horror, more of a bad thing expansion from GMT Games.
A woman with a hand from a demon's chest warm [screaming] unic Making love to every
blow your mind [screaming] and obliterate your soul. [groaning] My Christmas was lost to hell. My Christmas sweater that you ever saw by the monster.
All right, ladies and gentlemen. More of a bad thing is an expansion to your game of the Plum Island horror. This is a cooperative horror themed game from GMT Games. A little bit out of their wheelhouse, but it is by Herman Lutman, one of our favorite designers here. Uh, I'm not going to delve into a lot of the the weeds here as far as the rules go. I'm just going to tell you a basic overview of what this expansion brings to your table and tell you what I think. All right, ladies and gentlemen, you got three new factions here. You've got the uh construction team, which is blue. They can do things like set up detour markers or actually uh set up uh explosives that can actually blow up everything essentially in its spot, cause all sorts of damage, but it can slow down the horrors. You've got the Monkey Island cult. they can actually attempt to dominate uh horde stacks.
They can actually if they if they're dominating horde stack, they can actually move it around the board. You've also got the ZZ top, that's not their real name, but the ZZ clown circus company. Uh they've got a cookie clown car uh that they can use to just pile uh people in there and move that around. So, there's a lot of different fun and new characters that each of these factions brings to the game. And again, some great new abilities. You've got three new mutations that can come after you. They've got the grizzly bear, the moto monster, and cockroaches as well. And they're all bad guys. You also have these little alpha horror tokens, and sometimes you're going to put them on the horror stacks, usually at the behest of a an event card, and the event card will tell you kind of what specific properties this alpha tile that you place on the horror stacks will give them. So, in some ways, it kind of beefs up the horror stacks and gives them a little more uh abilities, make them a little more scary. Now, the game also does have some different modes and optional rules that allow it allow you to make the game a little more difficult. You've got an alarming mode, which has all sorts of difficulties.
You've got kind of nightmare options. These are optional rules that you can bake into the game uh that will again just cause it to be a little bit different, a little bit scarier for you. Now, you also have scenarios in this game. Uh some of them are shorter scenarios like one day scenarios. Uh some of them will add kind of new and interesting aspects to the game you're playing. And critically uh they have their own victory conditions in these scenarios. Now, in addition to all of these things, you've got new fate cards, you have got new event cards, and you've got new search cards. And all of these things are going to contribute to the madness that is the Plum Island horror. More of a bad thing. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen. So, like I say, not getting into the weeds, just telling you the basics of what this game uh this expansion brings you. Now, uh, I got to tell you, so we played this expansion and we haven't played with everything in it because there's a lot of different things you can do, a lot of different combinations of things you can do. Like I said, the different scenarios, the different nightmare options. You want to play alarming mode.
Haven't played alarming mode yet. Uh, I I got to be honest, the game is not a super hard game. The base game is not a super hard game, and I do think they included some of those uh options to kind of to give you some more difficulty here. Uh, and some of them do make things more difficult. Now, I got to tell you, first of all, this expansion for me does what a lot of good expansions do, and that is they they give you more of a good thing, right? They give you more stuff, more of the stuff you like, and that's what this one does. Like I say, you've got the new cards, um, you know, the new search cards are going to give you some some really cool things. They've got the um event cards. I will say, you do trigger some of those alpha tiles, and the way those alpha tiles interact with the stacks are are pretty fun. It's kind of fun to see how those things uh kind of can make those stacks a little scarier or give them other abilities. So, that's that's a pretty cool aspect of it. Generally, um the factions we we thought were pretty fun.
Uh you know, the the monkey where it can dominate uh some of the horror stacks. Uh the the construction was uh really cool and again fun characters, interesting characters, and critically they've they've got the the explosives that they can use in the game. Uh, so there's a lot of really cool and fun new things here. Now, Plum Island Horror is a great cooperative horror game, and it's what I like about it is it's a great cooperative horror game that doesn't take itself too seriously. This is like a Bad Be movie. There's a lot of jokes here. There's a lot of just funny, kooky stuff going on in the in the flavor text. And yet, it's a fun puzzle. It's a fun puzzle to sit down and try to understand. Okay, we're going to move here. I'm going to do this on my turn, but you know, we'll do follow-up actions with these characters to do this thing.
How can we maximize the guys we're getting off? Now, in some of the scenarios, for instance, uh you're trying to get more of the uh survivors off the island, trying to evacuate more of the civilians off the island, uh then points the horrors are going to get and the points are going to score horrors the further down the track they get, and that's going to be added to the their biohazard score. So, uh, it's fun and it's intense and you are trying to to to to work out that puzzle with your friends. I haven't played this one solo. Ray has. Ry loves this game solo. He absolutely loves it solo and he loves playing it with people. This was I think the Plum Island horror was Ray's number one game of 20. Was it 23 when this came out? 23 or 24? I can't remember. But it was his favorite game that year. And I can understand why. It's it's a hoot. This is a great horror game. Like I said, there's a lot of laughs in this game, both situationally and from flavor text.
It's just a lot of fun. And this expansion, as I say, does what good expansions often do, and that is it doesn't radically change up the game, but it gives you options, and it gives you more of a good thing. In this case, more of a bad thing. As an expansion, I'm going to go ahead. I'm going to rate the Plum Island Horror uh more of a bad thing. I'm going to go ahead. I was kind of on the fence. I was thinking maybe an eight, but the more I think about it and the more stuff this gives you, I'm going to give it a nine as an expansion on the Cody scale. It's a lot of fun. Thank you once again for joining us today on the Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear what you have to say. And please like and subscribe to this video and our YouTube channel. It would mean the world to us.
Now, if you do really like what we do here, I'd urge you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history. I even post some of my lectures on that channel. It would mean the world to me if you'd subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what we do here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave the tip. You know, I recently watched a horror movie about pogo sticks. Too many jump scares. help me on my feet again. AND I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody