Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Broken Meeple Podcast - Episode 79 - Value For Money

Transcript 58:38

you're listening to the broken meeple show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top tens and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game morning everybody whoa camera's a little bit close to my face there let's pull that back a bit which obviously doesn't affect you in audio country yes this is Luke Hector doing another podcast on 17th of September 2023 and oh it's been a bit of a long few long couple of weeks I must say but in a 99 positive way I mean so you know there was one blemish but for the most part pretty sweet um I basically well I'll talk about it a little bit later but uh suffice to say all pretty good um obviously things are pretty hectic at the moment because you know September is quite a busy month for me job wise there's a lot of reviews to get done there's a lot of games on my shelf of shame I want to get played for personal reasons but then there's also you know Essen is coming around the corner which means I'm trying to prep for that I've got you know some time set up with uh some you know Publishers trying to arrange you know if review copies are going to be collected there or posted after the fact or if I'm going to get

them a tool you know which ones will I buy you know what I've got to take arranging transport you know I got a shipball roaming across the across the channel again you know we tend to go as a a twosome I drive and he sleeps is basically the arrangement but if it cuts my travel costs in half then you know what the hell and then we'll be at the I think it's the holiday I think it's the premiere in it's the Premier Inn in the middle of Essen which is right next to the train station um you know Paul's usually in there I'm in there Hill Mark and midgard's in there mark monk from Ninja geek games will be in there there's quite a few people uh that tend to hang around in that specific Hotel so I'll be in there sharing a room with Hilma and it just means that in the evenings if we're not out at the pub we'll be there playing games table permitting and it'll just be a good social time so I think the evenings at Essen are going to be pretty sweet once I'm done with the day uh I will be helping uh at uh greater than games again at Essen now there was a meet well before I get to that no actually let's continue with that you know great in games yes I'm there on I think Friday afternoon and Saturday afternoon so I'm doing two afternoon shifts for a middle of the day to end of the day and I'll be at Great and games Booth unfortunately I won't be demoing some Sentinels like I normally would like to um I guess maybe they're not demoing it this year or perhaps people just took up the slots before I got in on it but apparently I'm demoing something called pyramid pyramido or pyramid pyramid deal or something I don't know it's like a new abstract game that they've uh kind

of bringing out or are bringing out in conjunction with someone else don't know the game very much at all is it good is it bad I have no idea I've literally just got to learn it in advance somehow you know and teach you over those two half days but you know if you want to say hi and by all means come along and play the game because it's a short game won't take you very long to learn it's only uh it's pretty much like a two-player abstract game as far as I'm aware so should be pretty easy enough to teach and play and then you can chat to me while you're there now I did look up meet and greet events but there is a meeting great event but it was so poorly advertised that I don't think anyone's really in it because last year I think Spiel did it I'm not sure but then this year it seems that somebody else is taking over like a third party is arranging this at Spiel and it's taking place there and it basically allows you to go for about four hours and you know meet and greet people as a content creator the problem is is that I never heard about this event it's not advertised anywhere on a Spiel site so we don't get any emails about it literally I found it by chance I Google searched it and by fluke found it that was the only way I found it and you know it's arranged by someone else and I could have signed up but the problem is Saturday afternoon I'm helping out greater than games then so I can't really pull out but also when you look at the exhibitors that are there apart from maybe one or two there's really no one I recognize there it is mostly I think for German creators so I've never heard of a lot of these people you know there's a couple of American ones there but other than that there's just so few like well-known people as far as I'm

aware in there so it just seemed pointless for me to even try to get into the event you know if people can just find me inside the convention and say hi and shake my hand that's perfect you know or find me at Creighton and games Booth that'll do frankly you know I'll usually sort of message it on Twitter and you know Facebook posts you know where I am and stuff but and availing that you know come to the Premier Inn or whatever it is um see if I can find it actually while I'm on the screen but you know it just didn't seem necessary to bother with it so let's see Premiere in Essen and see if it is the one I'm thinking of uh Premier Inn Essence City Center Hotel like the problem is I can't tell if it's Premier Inn or Holiday Inn or Holiday Express or what they all basically are the same to me so I don't know what the difference is between them but let's have a look so let's see Essen that's the SN help banhof or whatever so somewhere around here yeah there's a little location here there is a all right yeah so it's the Premier Inn Essence City Center Hotel that's that's where we'll be so you know I'll be there in the evening so you know you'll look it up on uh look it up on the interweb it's this one with the picture here but um yeah Premiere in essence City Center hotels what it will basically Google as that is where but by amhaft banhof which is basically the main train station so by all means you can always catch me in the evening there if you happen to be in the area and you just want to chat or play some games so you know I am available to find shall we say all right uh so in terms of the uh

blog not too bad 28 4 8 in terms of subscriber count that is climbing we're getting very close to the 21 000 Mark already so you know great to see that another huge amount of content in the last couple of weeks mainly because of midgard but uh you know I was able to at least resurrect my keep or coal series which I'm so sad to say got sidetracked you know I will keep that going uh did the other podcast did nature incarnate be on the base game review so I played the hell out of spirit Island when that expansion got released in the UK that is I know backers are still waiting for theirs I'm so sorry about that and you know I just basically had a lot of you know time to play it and yep I did the review for it and it's doing pretty well nearly 3 000 views it's taking a little while I published it over a week ago but you know what beyond the base game videos do not get a lot of um uh was it a lot of views a lot of the time because it's expansion so for a beyond the base game video to get as many views as a typical review I'm pretty happy with that and then Leaf check that video out this is a small Gateway game that I swear is going to fall under the radar for so many people and it really deserves not to because it ticks all the boxes that a good Gateway game should I think it's going to be horrendously underrated because it's you know weird City Games it's not the most well-known publisher in the world and you know Gateway Games these days get you know so much like not so much stick but they get ignored you know you go on go on board game geek and browse all the games that have been released in 2023 so far just

2023 no expansions go to that list on BGG look through the first say 200 games that you find on there and tell me how many of those you would consider to be a Gateway game there's loads of them that are all Epic RPG simulators open-ended games giant Euros heavy euros and it's just like Gateway Games I've just forgotten about now as if like we're we're almost closing the doors to our hobby now and just sticking to ourselves which is not the way I want the things to go so check that leaf video out and thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek let's get it in the Hat review section because I think the game needs to be talked about more and if you want to know why then check out the review itself uh you know it's not doing too well at the moment but there is more content on the way you know I've got the beyond the base game video for lost Runes of aranak uh hidden Expeditions is recorded I just need to edit it hopefully I'll get time today but that will be the next video to really release and hopefully with a new promo not to say that kienda is not a sponsor anymore no no there's still a sponsor but uh I have gone out of my way to try and find a couple of local people to sort of sponsor a video every now and again and I found a local coffee supplier that does uh coffee for gamers so they're called meeplecoffee.co.uk I won't say too much more now but when that video comes out you'll see that as a promo at the start like for about 30 seconds just like the normal qienda one is you know it's not going to be quite as like extravagant as the key in the one because this one's just going to run for a short time and then it will stop

but oh I might bring it back every now and again but it's just like it's basically a cheap promo so you know by all means check that out when it comes out other than that nothing else is recorded but I have everdel far sure on the uh review pile from kinder so yep that's gonna get reviewed fairly soon actually because frankly the re the rules are so similar to everdale it's basically everdale 1.25 and so realistically it's not going to take me that long to learn the game you know I've already like because if I know Evadale which I already do I already know 90 of this game and then you know I just need to get it played and getting it played solo be easy at my house and getting to play multiplayer will be easy peasy because every Club I go to has everdale fans so people are going to be gnawing at my arm to try and get this plate so that one should see a pretty quick turnaround in terms of its review other than that what else oh yeah city of the great machine that still needs to get reviewed also from kinder actually and that one is going to be tricky because there's quite a few rules it's quite involved it's a one versus many game that might take a little longer to get reviewed so you know you'll just have to bear with me on that one uh maybe I'll do a solo review perspective of it I don't know but it's just a hard one to get done and dusted trying to think if there's any others I mean I'm trying to get stuff played off my shelf of Shame like massive Darkness 2 that needs to get played very soon uh the Lost rooms of aranaka Mansion you know I was playing that a lot lately so I had to play lots of iron act games and I

don't think there's much else I desperately well planetarium planetarium is like another Euro game that I bought ages ago randomly on sale and I've still yet to play it um try anything what else I swear I've got other stuff oh yeah of course um Deep Rock Galactic finally arrived on my doorstep finally I mean for crying out loud how long have I waited for Deep Rock Galactica to come through this is the last time I am doing a group pledge for anything because it just delays things so much and it's too much faff that I refuse to just bother with a group pledge again I don't care if it gets you a small discount it's not worth it I'm just gonna bid solo from now on but yeah finally this is now in my collection I have now unpacked it I just need to learn the rules and play it and I care not wait I have not played this computer game for a while now I must admit I mean playing other stuff lately like valheim and Hades Hades I bought recently I'm trying out which I'm enjoying so far and a couple of other PC games but yeah Deep Rock Galactic is still something I've sunk over 500 hours in it's still fantastic so you know it's still a game I cannot wait to get to the table on top of that uh snow down designs after I asked them and I asked them to review copies and sadly I couldn't get a copy of the prototype for um peacemakers or whatever it's called the uh new game they've got on Kickstarter but oh when I get around to doing a Kickstarter review for September because I can't remember if I did one for August I need to do one for September sharpish but you know when I get there I'll talk about that Kickstarter then but it was they wanted

a very quick turnaround and there was no way I was going to do it before Essen it was just not going to happen so I said you know what just send me a release send me a proper copy when it's out on retail I'll review it then but they have sent me lands of gaussier and this one's had a decent amount of buzz from some board Gaming Community particularly uh Dice Tower Mike delicio particular really like this one and I love daila merchants it's one of my favorite deck builders and I love this sort of cutesy animal sort of world and artwork an open-ended light game I'm down for it I've unboxed it it looks beautiful and I really need to get stuck into this solo so uh this one should be pretty pretty cool and wait a minute oh you can get this on the app as well oh right oh yes because there's learning tutorial videos I better get stuck into this one sharpish because I mean look at it it looks so good doesn't it can't wait to stick my hand in this one and I probably need to do it sharpish because it won't be too long before earthborn Rangers comes out on uh Kickstarter which is really annoying because originally when I arranged to do a review of this we were hoping it was going to arrive in July or early August at the latest so that I could get a review done before even the Americans got it but because I live in the UK everything sucks here and everything coming to the UK sucks which means it's been delayed and I think we're gonna get it fulfilled in the next month I think or certainly in the next few weeks maybe even before fluorescent I should expect to see this turn up on my doorstep but sadly some people have already done written reviews for it I mean by the time I get around to playing it a ton

maybe the video reviews have already started coming out but yeah I'm gonna be a little bit late to the party with this one which is a bit of a shame really but that's not going to damper my excitement for getting the game I still think the game was fantastic from the demo I played and I'm definitely Keen to stick my head in this one but yeah the rest of the year is going to be pretty busy and uh more on that in a minute in terms of well I'll talk about that in a minute so yeah all pretty good lots of stuff to come so what was this midgar that I was talking about well I spent the weekend in midgard uh from like last weekend a few days thanks to my mate Hilmar for uh getting me as a guest to be invited to this Con it was smaller than I thought it was I mean the advertising makes it look a little bit bigger than it actually is it's it's probably in comparison to your local city con you know Portsmouth Comic Con you know stuff like that it's not like a huge thing but it is just a nice intimate Gathering I mean there's you know people selling various uh memorabilia for all the geeky stuff there's a bit of this Star Wars a bit of anime a bit of Cosplay a bit of sci-fi there's a bit of fancy bit of RPG bit of open gaming board gaming you know this there's a kind of a mixed bag of everything and it's just a collection of friendly people I mean man the Iceland the icelanders are friendly people you know they felt they made us feel welcome everybody at the convention treated us like royalty and as a guest I got the same treatment as the actor did with the exception of security details obviously but yeah they fed us like lunch and

dinner they they had alcohol for us on on demand we could get all the water we wanted there were snacks and we had our own room I mean man they treated us so well I did not deserve that kind of treatment I mean this is me some schmuck on YouTube you know with 20 000 plus subscribers what do I deserve in terms of that kind of treatment I'm not going to say no to it but it's still like really do I deserve that kind of thing you know compared to actors that were there I mean I was there hanging out with you know Jewel Stave and Sean Maher from Firefly you know that fantastic series I got to meet them and hang out with them and go sightseeing with them it was great and uh there was a couple of other guys really cool as well uh Joe Flanagan and Paul mcgillian I had to look those up because they are actors from Stargate Atlantis which I've sadly never watched um I'm not I'm not a massive uh I'm not a massive Stargate fan but you know you know Joe sort of kept to himself a lot but Paul was very chatty Paul was your quintessential stereotypical chatty expressive American you know like with the accent and everything it was just you know really it was all really or is he Canadian I forget but either way it was just like you know he's the he's the the light of the room he's constantly sort of chatting and talking to people and stuff you know and they were just really friendly folk all the uh all the security detail that they had you know they were friendly folk you know they were chatty I got driven to and from the airport and that's like a 45 minute Journey or something I mean man man they treated us so well there and you know I was mopping it up but it just felt weird

you know for someone like me to get that kind of treatment you know some schmuck but hey it was a good fun time and I basically just there hanging out with people like Dave and ilka loser from loser palooza and you know uh above board were there doing some filming sketches and we hung out we went out for meals we did some open gaming and you know I played a lot of board games tree uh taught a bunch of people that were attending the con who pretty much nine probably 100 didn't know me which is a bit of a shame some people recognize Dave and Elkins although not many which is surprising I mean you think that more people would know them but yeah pretty much nobody knew I was I mean it's like who on Earth knows me at all but at the end of the day that kind of helped because I meant I didn't really have to care too much about you know like publicizing the channel or anything like that I could just be like you know what I'm just here to help I'm a guest you don't know I am you don't really care but let's play some games and certainly the people who are teaching games too are very grateful for the teachers uh and it was just a good friendly time now it was and Monday we got to go sightseeing so I got to see gazers I got to see volcanic craters I got to see um you know like black sat well what the little there was of a black sand beach uh we got to eat out went to a viking theme restaurant I tried everything from fermented shark to uh you know boiled sheep's head and that weird sort of meat concoctions including one in one type of fish in particular that I won't say because it's a little controversial but you know other than that it was then I

got to have one of the best medes I've ever had you know a coffee and honey blend Mead oh that was very nice you know Icelandic beer very nice uh their fish is very good I had a fish pan like in cheese sauce it was like oh it was really delicious so yeah it was just it was just a good time it was slightly marred however because one touristy restaurant we went to on the sightseeing day which I just grabbed a fish and chips on kind of cocked up their service and cocked up the food because I got food poisoning as well as one or two other people now uh that was a problem because it meant that I had a very rough night and I was only gonna get three four hours sleep anyway because of the flight but yeah I mean I couldn't sleep and then I had to try and stay in a in one piece for a 45 minute car Journey uh for a 45 minute Queue at the airport just to check my bag in a further queue in order to check in itself and then the more queues and then walking around the airport and then a two and a half hour three hour flight and then you know a bus journey to my car and then getting home I had to endure all that with chronic food poisoning and yeah um not good had a very big dehydration fever headache uh you know I was I was Ill several times you know nausea took over especially after the bus Journey that just wiped me out and by the time I got home I was just like exhausted I had to get a kip had to get a nap thankfully I do feel better I do feel better for the most part I do have a bit of a swollen

tonsils problem at the moment though so throat issues as well but that's an after effect of the food poisoning because you get an infection and you fight it off and then something else flares up and basically as much as I'm over the food poisoning now now I'm totally recovered from that I do still have swollen tonsils now which flared up afterwards and it's just like oh great now I have checked myself for covid before anybody asks I'm negative so don't worry I haven't got covered it's just literally one of those things does not Mar my experience for midgard though it's a small convention you're pretty much there for a day Max and even then it's a wide breakfast stuff you're not it's not like games Expo or something huge it's a nice small convention with a big team that runs it with a few sponsors and a lot of volunteers they just they see it as a passion project and you can see that with the way they arrange things and it's just a good crowd there you know people who just want to be there you know because I can't imagine there's many much of this stuff in Iceland you know on an island so the fact that this exists is just a a really cool thing and you know if they'll help me back next year I'll certainly consider it because Iceland was just a really good place to visit hope to go back there for some proper visits and you know and do more sightseeing maybe some of the wintry stuff uh but yeah thanks for having me guys hopefully I'll see you guys again all right uh let's talk about the game I played at uh uh the convention actually because I taught mostly games I'd already played or Leaf I'd already reviewed I played that quite a few a few times quite an eye-catcher but finally

oh my God finally let me take a drink first all right give me tonsils a bit as well right Hilmar was very very very kind to teach me this because finally oh my word I've been wanting to play Mosaic a story of civilization for a long time because I've I've heard about it I saw on Kickstarter and I thought it was too expensive for the Colossus Edition and I thought I'm not spending this much money on a gamble somebody teach me this game and then I heard about the retail version I thought okay this seems good a nice cheaper way to get in but then I heard that components wise and quality of life-wise there was a few issues with the retail version it's like well I'm not gonna suffer to have this version that's more reasonably priced so you know I figured I'll wait and every time it's been on the table at convention in UK I've always been busy doing something else so finally Hilma said if you haven't played it by midgard we're playing it so we played his Colossus version the giant one so the one with all the Miniatures all the big thick tokens uh not painted but you know all the all the blast all the metal coins everything that costs like 150 to 200 pounds to buy you know this picture version and you know it's well let me get into the art and components first in the value I think the value is a little bit over the top here yes okay there are Miniatures with this stuff but you really don't need these Miniatures and it's hard to tell what city in town is what on these things anyway so unless you paint them they don't really help to

differentiate them anyway uh the tokens are cool and thick although more or not in a second and the artwork I find a little bit distracting anyway I mean this weird sort of I mean I know it's meant to be like a mosaic I know what they're trying to go with here but the sea looks really weird in this pattern you know you almost think it's like another country or something and so it just gets a little bit busy on the board uh the cards they've all got good artwork though and the cards are good quality and the tokens are great quality and the metal coin is fantastic you know there's certainly a good quality in this game but there's you know that does come at a price I mean this is the smallest amount of space that the game takes up because this is literally only showing the board a card and a one player board but when four of you are playing this game it's a massive table hog I mean the thing takes up so much space that on rectangular tables we had to basically take up about two or three tables it was ridiculous and on top of that the setup is an absolute pain because you've got to get all your Miniatures out and separate them all out which is not great um then you've got to choose like different you've got to shuffle the deck of cards and you've got to construct the cards and then you need to do your asymmetric Powers which are cool I like the fact that it's differentiated starts uh and various other bits and Bobs you notice a lot of that but these trade tokens oh my word this is a moronic way to set the game up you have to get all these trade tokens with different things on and some of them are blanks they got like x's on them and you have to get all of these tokens out of the box or which there's a ton of them and they're face down you have to shuffle them up face down every single hex on this board that you see here has to be covered with a

hex which is basically anything that is covering a bit of land so most of them aren't on this board here do you think it doesn't look like that many that's because this is part way through the game at the start all of these hexes have a token on them and it's like what's the big deal because when you have covered every single hex you then flip all the tokens over and if they have the X on them they're blank and you remove them you have to go through this process of shuffling them all putting them all out only to then remove about 50 of them from the game anyway this is a stupid way to set the game up and I wish they had a better way of doing these trade tokens this would drive me nuts in any setup for this game and so it's not a game that I want to own but as much as I have these negatives with the value and the components and you know the the fact that it's too big and everything I actually found this to be a very fun game to play very fun game um it's most I was basically following a heavy technology route with you know getting a bunch of Technologies getting so much money it hurt and using the money to get as a wild for resources I did nothing on the map I literally built one city and one wonder and that was it I did nothing else on the map at all I focused entirely on the cards and I had a good time it's pretty much and one thing about this game is that it's deceivingly light it's not a light game but it's medium at most I mean it's pretty straightforward rules I mean you've got some production tracks one action triggers them all the actions are written on the board as to how they work and what they cost most of them involve

the acquisition of cards and the placing of a miniature or something the Technologies and everything prerequisites basically work on the same Tableau building iconography tags as terraforming Mars and Earth and Martin over and all those stuff so you know the rules are so easy to understand the teach was not very long at all and before you knew it I was already into the game and trying something out now I do have as much as I enjoyed the game itself and the differentiation and just having some jokes and being like you know cool it's a civilization game it's abstracted but it's still a silver game there are a couple of issues I have with it though um firstly you know this tax tariff bit down here this is supposed to be a way that you can get money and it's based on your tax and tariff production as well as other factors I was the only one who took a single card from here and that was once because I had tax and tariff production tracks off the Wazoo so I could get a ton of money and I used it once nobody else used it the entire game why is it in the game then it just seemed a little bit weird but on top of that the scoring for this I mean there's different ways you score so you've got the Wonders score differently and you know you score for these um governments that you can do and you know some of the Technologies might score for tags and some of the buildings might score for various set collection stuff but there's a heavy emphasis on Empire scoring which is this like two or three times that will happen in the game as well as some endgame scoring which all focuses around area control on this board getting cities out in the different color

regions having military to bolster that and basically controlling regions area control now I'd be fine if that was just a side thing in the game that you could aim for but it seems to be the dominant way to win and I'm not sure I'm cool with that because that means the game's gonna play out very linear linear for future games you know I want to focus on a couple of other aspects I mean I focused a lot on getting money money is great for wild resources but it doesn't score you any other points that's it I'm a one for every 10 bucks and I'm like seriously money like one of the most important things you can have in the civilization money and it's worth next to no points why you know the fact that I could get loads of it as the artist seemed to be a negligible thing the player asymmetric Powers don't seem too balanced either I mean there are some that they talk about something called unrest and some of the leaders get you negative unrest you know meaning that you won't lose points at the end of the game by having unrest but the only way you get unrest is by using the tax Tower of things so if you don't use that road then unrest means nothing so this is supposed to be my advantage for my leader and it means nothing whereas other people can get much more useful stuff so that was a little bit of a hindrance but yet the scoring just felt really geared towards area control now we finished with very tight scores and I went for no area control whatsoever and I came second but that was because we had a weird game where only two empires scoring phases happened typically three happened in this game from what I've seen and what I'm told so had we had a third uh I mean I lost anyway with only

two Empire scorings and it was close had we had a third Empire scoring I would have been absolutely blitzed and probably come last because my Technologies and stuff like that just don't score enough compared to area control but what if I don't want to do area control what if I want to do Technologies and you know you know economy run and stuff I'm not interested in military well apparently you need to get interested in the bit of military be in a bit of error control because you're just not gonna win stuff and that's a bit of a put-off now I need to play this game more times to obviously come to a definitive conclusion on that front but that was just First Impressions but the game itself is fun I did enjoy it and you know I think it's too long with too many players I think they should be kept it free I think four is a little bit too many and five and six by the sound of it would just be moronic why would I ever want to do that but this game is interesting and I would like to play it again Colossus version or maybe even try the retail version to see but whether you know putting it down to retail would make it a bit more controllable but yeah I'm a little bit concerned about the emphasis on area control what are your thoughts on that is it really that dominant on the area control or you know is there a way to get around that problem I'd be interested to know your thoughts oh my poor tonsils a good thing this is a shorter video I think today all right everyone else have I got to talk about I've done mid guard done Stargate I've done that um yeah actually yeah going back to that

point I mentioned earlier about the uh you know games not being Gateway level look at this right I think this is me I think this is when I search 2023 all right so let's have a look here which are old world Earth Darwin's Journey void for hegemony Europa universalists Expeditions Beast castles burgundy special edition station four you could uh Star Wars a dick building game Mr President the American presidency from GMT horses Carriage yoi savarian guard Scarface distilled unconscious mind Marvel Zombies Age of innovation hop hop the mackers or whatever the hell Fury calls their game some Citadel Disney lucana earthborn Rangers Stellaris Legacy of you Heroes of Mighty magic 3 Dune War for arrakis terraforming Master dice game September fractal Thunder Road are chaos Lords of Ragnarok nuclear and Barcelona are you noticing something here where's the Gateway games that's just not in existence now you could argue Disney lokana is about a Gateway game okay but it's a TCG money money money money money that's not what I consider suitable for a Gateway game okay so what else is there uh anything here at All Star Wars the deck building game not something I would call Gateway level it's light but it's not Gateway level Castle the burgundy again light I wouldn't call it a Gateway game um it's and even then it's boring game but yeah where am I supposed to find a Gateway Games here they just don't exist and I go down further Great Western Trail New Zealand skyrise our chaos Society Rolling Heights zoovada sleeping guards uh the White Castle I don't know

there's total Rome War agemonia myth wind open-ended game which blends RPG project progression La Familia Village big box search for lost species free Wing circus it's a I mean oh wait steam up a feast of dim sum that's probably a Gateway game but I haven't seen great reviews for it but a time Bamboo nightmare Cathedral I mean that's just where are the Gateway Games seriously Publishers not everything needs to be this big sprawling epic mess you know simple nice light games are cool I like simple nice light games I like heavy games as well I like to play a lesser and a mine Clash game every now and again you know and I have them on my shelf for that reason I like open-ended world games I like you know sandbox games I like big epic games every now and again not all the freaking time so come on can we have a few more of these please right uh topic of the day I just want to talk very briefly about value so uh hear me out here there's a concept that gets talked about lately with value for money when it comes to board games and board gaming is an expensive hobby we know this but it's particularly come up because of the game that I'm reviewing soon everdale for sure Evadale farshore has an RRP of a hundred pounds 100 pounds hundred dollars or something like that 100 pounds for this and after opening the game getting the stuff out seeing its production

I can't for the life of me see why it's that much there's nothing to justify that yo yes there's some nice looking components in there and yes the artwork is beautiful but it is possible to do a gorgeous artwork game for cheap I mean for crying out loud talk to sit-down games talk to bomb bits talk to any European uh any European publisher talk to them about good artwork on the cheap they can do it all right how much does Dixit cost for all the cards and all the artwork it has you know it's artwork is not the defining reason why a game should cost an absolute Fortune the component wise you get metal anchors yo these little things here granted they look cool but they're unnecessary it's unnecessary for them to be metal you get some interesting little components for the resources yes but again some of them are just wood whatever the mushrooms are pretty cool they're little bouncy mushrooms and stuff but again 100 pound uh the seaweed is really annoying it's this tiny little green uh like Flappy sort of Bendy stuff it's really I mean it comes in a giant bag it looks like I'm smuggling drugs it looks so insane so the resources Aren't Enough the cards gorgeous artwork but the cards are pretty standard quality they're pretty thin and mostly it's because it's got that stupid Tower thing in the middle um I probably should get this on the screen actually for those watching but um I'll show you this this Tower remember the tree from Evadale um that stupid tree that was unnecessary and blocked line aside and you know people paid loads of money for it

whatever Del farshore has this Tower in it this Lighthouse which serves no purpose at least the Evadale oh sorry uh there we go um this Lighthouse serves no purpose at least the tree in everdale had some rules written on it this doesn't even have that it is literally there for the card deck to go next to which makes no difference and for meeples to go on it that you unlock during the game except the lighthouse is not big enough to fit everybody's meeple on it trust me it's an absolute chore to try and get them on there what is the point this component is completely unnecessary and if you're telling me that this cardboard structure you know two bits of cardboard with a couple of Ledges shoved on it you're telling me that suggestification for 100 pounds then get stuffed because that is ridiculous you could have cut that out of the game entirely and maybe shave some money off it but you know is the game good you have to wait for my review on that but certainly I am going to make a big deal about the value for money here and the you know the fact that this is way too expensive what it is people gave me jip for Marvel dagger for how expensive that one is and I said that was an expensive game you know it's still on my shelf I've still got it over here but Marvel dagger you know is still an enjoyable game and it still has a decent amount of stuff in it but yeah it's expensive what it is and that was at 75 80 pound and yet apparently far sure for a hundred is fair game now granted this is RRP so you will get it cheaper in the shops you well you'll get it cheaper on the line you won't get it cheaper in an flds but you're still

talking 85 to 90 pound to buy it in an online store it's ridiculous at least I can get Marvel dagger for 65.7 seen an online store that's still cheaper and there's more game in that than there is in Far sure so what exactly is the point of this being expensive it just feels like a cash grab now I'll rant more about that when it comes to the actual review more than likely but you know the the thing is with value for money is that some people will claim that it's one of those things that it's relative like it's relative to the individual you know expensive for you might not be expensive for someone else but um I would question that a little bit because firstly there has to be a point where it's expensive no matter what you know just because you might be a multi-millionaire with a ton of cash doesn't mean it's not expensive I live alone okay I live alone this channel funds itself effectively patreons are the reason this thing keeps patreons and sponsors are the only reason this channel keeps going because it doesn't make enough money from ad Revenue to cover its uh expenses and stuff patreons help keep it going and you know with that this channel able is able to fund itself it doesn't make profit it's not a you know it's not a profit making business or anything like that it's literally my hobby okay I have a job as a tax accountant to pay my mortgage to pay my electric bill and you know to pay everything else and to buy a bunch of games to get reviewed I spend my own cash from that so you know you know

value for me is obviously going to be a bit more stringent on that front but then also I live alone I have no spouse not but entirely by choice but sadly I don't uh but I also means I don't have kids I don't have a pet I'd love to have a pet Pet's greater than kids in my opinion but uh I live alone and I go out quite a bit so I you know a cat even a cat would get frustrated the fact that I wasn't in the house enough a dog would go insane I'd never be able to keep a dog it would just never get fed or played with enough so I choose not to have a pet living by myself as soon if I ever find Miss right and move in with them oh yeah first thing I want to do is get a pet you know hopefully they don't want kids you know it's like you don't want kids you want a cat or a dog perfect you know that's what I want to do but the thing is is that without those commitments it gives me a bit more cash on the hip because I got a well-paid job and I live alone so yes I've got to pay the bills myself but you get some reductions by living alone yeah like council tax and stuff not a huge amount but every little helps but also my expenses are lower in terms of my you know General stuff I mean I pay a gym subscription I get protein powder I go out to game cafes I go out for meals you know I yeah I'll go on the occasional trip I pay fuel which is expensive in the UK and stuff so it's not like I'm raking in it's not like I'm rolling in it but the idea is is that I can live a more comfortable lifestyle and that even for someone like me though I'm looking at a game and thinking well this is pretty expensive you know I feel like this is a a bit much so to have

you know if I'm thinking the game is expensive then once somebody who's not as well off who's somebody who's like got a lower paying job or has a family that they have to look after you know not so much spare cash on the hip what do they think the value for these games are they've got to be thinking that it's way more you know way more problematic so you know everdale Farah for example 100 pound just because you as a multi-millionaire might be able to afford 100 pound without even breaking a sweat that's still expensive I mean you're paying a lot of money for that I think what you can get for a hundred pound yo you can do quite a few things for 100 quid and you're going to spend it on a small box of cardboard and bits do you really think that's Justified I mean you know bear in mind let's uh take a like a uh let's take a tablet right I pay like several hundred quid and get a tablet you know a tablet uh digital thing you know Samsung Android or whatever and that thing will cater for games it will cater for productivity or cater for the internet it'll cater for uh YouTube it will get used constantly it's basically around me pretty much all times when I'm at home so okay cool that's getting a lot more value for its money than a box board game is that you might play a few times and then maybe get bored with it or it sits on the Shelf a hundred pound and you know and I mean you know I write on Far sure I'm talking about dagger as well but then remember Skyrim oh my God I mentioned about this and people were giving me dip on that review as well sort of like Uno

it's you know whatever about the cost I'm sorry but Skyrim the adventure board game sells for something like 150 pounds for a retail version and that's not even when the Miniatures that's just the game and as my review have said go check out the review the game is pretty lackluster it's not that enjoyable the components aren't very good you know it's a waste of components for the 150 pound it's asking for there is not 150 pound worth of game in this box you know and there's certainly not 150 pound worth of component quality in here you know you know Marek triby solo someone can do his best to make it try and look good on pictures but there's only so much you can polish up yeah if you know what I mean so it's yeah look at that I mean that is what I'm paying 1950 pound for blank canvas with a wall of text you know that is so Bland looking and the game is Bland looking so why am I paying 150 pounds of this and that's before you spend like 100 pound on Miniatures and like 75 pound for the expansion oh my word this is a complete rip-off absolute rip-off no value at all in this so I take value for money pretty seriously when I talk about the review for a game but here's something I'm noticing as I take another swig reviewers seem to ignore this a lot and I'm curious as to why and I also think it's a bad thing because you know I get the idea that some reviewers might go down this whole value as relative to the individual thing but I think that's

misleading to not talk about value I think it's better to talk about it from your perspective and make a comment and get the occasional person dispute it than it is to not mention it because more people I think are going to agree with you on the value front and a lot of people out there are trying to spend their money wisely so seriously reviewers talk about value for money more because I will and I shall continue to do so you try and stab me it's an important factor you know I want to recommend a game to someone and I could have two games that play relatively straightforward relatively easily uh you know but both are comparable games okay there could be two different titles whatever okay so I got two of them here and I've got to recommend them something like somebody say which one should I prefer I'm fine with both themes I'm fine with them the mechanics are roughly the same so which one do I pick if one of them gives you a decent looking game and a good experience for about 45 pound and another one gives you a similar experience maybe looks a little bit nicer but it's a hundred pound like more than double the cost I'm gonna recommend the 45 pound one in a heartbeat oh there's a bit of a noise outside I do apologize that catches on the microphone um gotta keep the window open because it's humid as all get out today I mean we have finally ended the heat wave in the UK we had a hot day yesterday and that should be the last hot day of the year thankfully but we're gonna suffer the aftermath for the next couple of days with some thundery showers and humidity so that should be fun but at least no more heat waves no more heat waves can be star Autumn please please

please please uh but anyway I do aggress so you know I'm gonna recommend the cheaper game and reviewers just ignore this you watch any reviewers out there and I see a lot I've seen it on downstairs I've seen on you know all the well I'm saying Dice Tower Game Boy geek you know some of the like other reviewers that I don't trust you know I've watched some of their content and again I see them not mention it again this just adds to the problem but you know I see it on a lot of reviewers that I do trust that I do watch and it's like okay cool I'll watch this content and again they don't mention it you know if and occasionally I see Snippets in the mentioning it and this could usually be from small creators small creators tend to do this hashtag Sports more creators but and I'm so pleased when I see it but man it's so rare and I feel like you need to you've got to rate a game based on its value for money you can't say that this is the best game ever and that's so amazing and I love it and everyone should have it if it costs 200 pounds and is a massive storage Fest you can love void for as much as you like you can love gloomhaven as much as you like you can love you know everdale with the complete collection as much as you like but for the amount of money you're gonna spend on it is it really worth that kind of money are you really gonna recommend this to everybody for that price tag you you're gonna tell your best friend yeah go on spend 150 pound on that I mean what you're wanting some spending money for your upcoming holiday now you don't need that go buy

this game for 150 pounds oh by the way you're gonna need a big shelf and you're gonna need a lot of hours to invest time in learning the rules and everything and you're probably gonna Commit This to this for Life uh hmm problem it's not a good thing so you know I'm curious to know what people's thoughts are I mean do you care about the value for a game in a review because I'm sure you all care about getting your money's worth for a game none of you out there could be like I don't care what it costs especially as the board game hobby is getting more expensive now kickstarters are now ripping people off it seems that I am back to Kickstarter in ages now because I just think they're just not worth the price which I must admit does put me off doing the monthly Kickstarter videos but I'm going to try and keep those going but the the fact that retail copies are still getting more expensive now you know when I see a game do such a good job for such a cheap price like Alice's Garden I remember that one I kept raving the praise of them out uh let me show you in that one and by all means you need to check out my review for that one if you have not already because that one is such an underrated game 2982 it needs to be higher ranking than that this is a 30 to 45 minute one to four player polyomingo tile Lane game and it comes in a small box and it sells for like less than 20 quid usually and like in the UK you can get it from less than 20 quid check out on key Ender I believe but I think other retailers might have it as well look at this game nice you know it's got thin cardboard tiles yeah fine it's not gonna like bludgeon someone to death with them but nice artwork looks nice on the table these green embroidered bags standard they're

standard in the game okay green embroidered bags with Unique Designs on them okay you've got simple boards but again nice colors the tiles on there unique artwork very nice and colorful and this is what you get in the game so not a ton of stuff but you get a Score Pad you get the rule book you get little tiles and stuff different shapes all for less than 20 quid and you want value for money that's value for money you know I cannot recommend this game enough as a Gateway level polyomino game check out my review for more details more people need to have this game I think it needs to be a Gateway staple and yet it gets no buzz whatsoever other than me because a is a gateway game which means reviewers just don't care about it but also Gamers don't care about it because they just want the next big epic hotness you know rather than anything light and you and it's a cheap game so people just sort of go past it but it's like come on this is value for money this deserves to be priced higher than 20 pound and yet it sells for like 15 to 20 pound it's so cheap you know so if they can do it why the hell can't everdale fire sure Skyrim and you know even Gloom Haven I mean gloomhaven sells for a decent amount of money and you argue that that one's probably got more value for money because it's uh you know a big sprawling epic game that literally takes your whole life to finish but component wise it's pretty lackluster and it's you know yes it's a giant box but there's nothing in here component wise that I would give

that much credit to you know I mean it's cardboard standees the artwork is decent enough the cards are relatively standard the dice are standard I mean it's is it worth that much money only if you're going to get a lot of plays out of it but if you can't commit to this game it ain't worth it so you know I'll leave that one down to debate I guess but you could argue that maybe the amount of time it's going to take you to get through the game helps with the value front but still there are games that can give you a lot of decent plays and don't take your entire life to commit to so you know reviewers just ignore this and I've seen like five out of fives I've seen you know nine out of tens I've seen all these really high reviews for everdale for sure now everdale fashion could be a really amazing game we'll find out but if I find out that the game is merely fine you know lackluster even and people are giving it nine out of nines nine out of ten sorry five out of fives and they're ignoring the value front I'm gonna be a little bit annoyed there could be a rant on that one uh because you know you are way too forgiving to say a game is that brilliant that amazing and not Factor the value front to just ignore it that's misleading and I think if you're a reviewer and you ignore value for money you might need to come up with a very good reason as to why in my book because I will trust your content a lot more for having that in it and certainly if people mention it in reviews I will trust their content more for having it in it and yet a lot of the

big names just simply don't do it and they need to start now oh well that's a little round on that but I'd be curious to know your thoughts you know let me know what you think you know do you think value for money is important in gaming in general do you think the reviewers should comment on it more you know I talk about it all the time is that a good thing bad thing you know let me know your thoughts in the comments on that one uh in terms of reviews I just want to quickly mention before I sign off um I am thinking about the format again of those reviews because there's just a lot of reviews to do and I'm getting a little bit annoyed I just don't seem to get enough time to get things like top tins done and the expansion stuff done and things like that which I really do like to talk about expansion stuff doesn't get a lot of views but it's important stuff that no one else talks about but then I also want to do more of the Shelf keep or color ones I want to do more of the other type of content not just reviews because reviews are hit and miss with their viewership you know and it hurts the channel to have low views no matter how many videos I put out so I am trying to think about how to do the reviews and I've had a detailed version which I've done for things like Marvel dagger and Expeditions and void for you know big games and I've had the Quick Draw review use of which I'm not still not happy with the name but I can't really do much else for it but a work and they allow me to do a review in a bit a quicker time but it varies as to the length and complexity of those as well because sometimes I can think of some good uh video skits to put in them and I'll put them in the video that takes time to edit but then sometimes I might be talking for a long time in

those reviews because there's more to cover than I originally thought there was and so it's not so much a quick draw review it's just a slightly less detailed one and so I feel like having two different formats is also problematic and the thing is I really like my intro the uh yeah that that intro that plays it's kind of a defining intro to my channel and yet it only plays on top tens which I don't do enough of and some of the other content and detail reviews so you're mainly seeing the Quick Draw intro mostly with my content and that's not my channel that's just another type of intro so I'm curious as to whether I kind of need to condense the two like really just have one format for reviews and cover all of them in that whether it's a tiny game or a big game and try and keep the links down not to have 30 minute extravagant answers if I have to do part one part two part three then I should do that maybe I should stop having one giant long video for a review and instead do it in part if it takes me a long time to talk about it then fine have voidable part one void for part two and then cover it in two separate videos release them at the same time but just keep them in two shorter segments or maybe don't keep them at the same time maybe leave a week between them I don't know like a cliffhanger but the the idea is is that I do need to think about this a little bit and I'll be curious to know your thoughts now part of the thing that hurts it is what to include in the reviews because obviously I want to get a decent amount of detail in there pros and cons are a must you know I've got to do that and having a pro and cons

section like in the detail reviews does allow me to structure my videos a lot better so you know I do like having those in obviously you need a final summary and verdict but with regards to the other bits especially in the detail review are they needed now I always give a little bit of a background on the game so that's fine that's just a standard thing but then they also do the rules overview in both and I find that the rules overview is what is taking up a lot of time in both styles of reviews and the quick draw on a detail one and in the detail one especially it takes a long time to edit that section because I gotta get all the photos I've got to do Zoom ins and Scrolls and all that lot and I've got to do I've got to figure out what I'm saying I mean I don't script it entirely but I still need to you know research what I'm doing for that and that section takes a lot of time and do people really care I mean if you want to look up the rules to a game can you not just go on BGG and find it you know I try to give us very brief of rules overview as I can in that section maybe I need to make it briefer maybe I literally do need to give the absolute Bare Bones brief for a rules overview and keep that length down meaning that I don't have to do the separate section with all the scrolling pictures enough I could literally just do it with pieces on the table because after all I'm doing more of my videos in this room with stuff on the table so I could show you the stuff on the table as I'm doing rules explanations so try to keep that down game comparisons do you like that section where I compare it to other games and say like this is similar to this and all that I mean if it's useful I'll keep it fine you know I'll still keep things like player scaling and stuff at the end you know that's always

useful always like reporting on that but maybe I just need to do one format for all of them and find a way to condense the time down like really condense like right I've gathered condense these points down not do a massive long rules overview I mean maybe I should just stop doing the rules overview I don't know it saves a good three minutes four minutes in the detail review it saves a good five to six and a quick draw review because it's a bit more tighter in a detailed one so I don't know I need to figure out what to do and if I can figure out what I want to do and what people want to see and come up with a good uh compromise then I would like to hope that I could make reviews a single format you know use a pro and con different section have a brief rules overview if necessary have game comparison if necessary but keep a brief keep them shorter try and condense it or just have two-part videos I don't know but I need to keep it shorter in the sense that I have obviously I want to be able to edit these very quick now another one alternative is that I have a normal review format for the majority of games but then for a lot of these smaller games that don't get a lot of reviews I mean I did Leaf recently and I think more people should play it but this is a small game that no one's really heard of and I did like trick takers like aurum and you know various little card games like District Noir and stuff like not that many people are interested in but they still I still wanted to talk about them they are the ones that probably should be quick draw reviews and maybe I should just consider

not doing singular videos for them I don't know but the problem is if you don't do singular videos you can't put the video up on Board Game Geek because it won't let you do the same video twice on the site so if I do a group video I can only put it on one of those games I can't put it on all three of them for example and that's annoying so do I do like uh I mean the alternative is that I do a quick draw review style where I basically talk about five games at once in the video and then I split it into different parts Hearts solely for the purposes of BGG so on my YouTube channel you would see a compendium review of a bunch of small little games that I could talk about in like a couple of minutes each but then on BGG it would simply have you know the excerpt from my thing it would like it would have the intro maybe and then it would have that segment and then it would just say check out the rest of the video on YouTube or something yeah I don't know like put a little Banner or something and then I could just literally chop the video into little segments and use that for BGG it depends how much traffic you get but then putting on BGG is noticeable so it's something I want to do I don't know things I need to consider food for poor but let me know your comments let me know what you think because obviously this channel was made for you the viewers it wouldn't be here if it wasn't for you guys so by all means let me know your thoughts that's it for me I need to rest these tonsils now they aren't getting a bit sore so you know probably no more recording today but I'll try and get on with editing that uh um lost ruins of arnac video see if I can get that edited today and release it

something like on Tuesday that'd be good you know it should be able to get it released on Tuesday I reckon maybe no no I reckon I could get it released on Tuesday even if it's later this evening Tuesday I reckon I can do that then so uh yeah I'll try and get it released for them but uh you know with the new promo so that's it for me I'm gonna sign off now hope you enjoyed this podcast hope you enjoyed it on YouTube if you're watching it on there by all means consider subscribing to the channel keep that number going let me know your thoughts and everything I've said and check out those reviews uh leaf Alice's Garden Skyrim you know all these various games I've talked about on the show void falling that check out those reviews because I think they're quite important ones and hopefully I'll be able to get some more content out soon so uh take care and remember as always it's only a game bye for now spend your money wisely

Progress saved