Skip to main content
Loading video...

Perfectionism in Board Games | A Board Game Rant

Transcript 30:18

You're so 90s.

You ready to get spicy?

Yeah.

Good.

Can't wait for these.

Fired up.

Can't wait for these pomies.

Here we go. Hello everyone. Welcome back to Foster the Mele, a channel all about

and hot

spice. That is spicy. We are here just to have a discussion. It's a discussion video, hot topic in our household right now. And that is perfectionism in the board game world, board game hobby.

And you're probably like, what do you mean? We mean so many things by this. But I don't know if this is and actually I I think I know it might be more relevant to us in the creator space because we are exposed to this.

I think I would also throw it out.

It it is definitely in the realm of working in the board game space as well. I see it a lot.

Yes. in the consumerism aspect of the hobby as well.

Yes. If you are just like gaming casually every now and then, you know, with your friends or whatever, and you're not really deep into the hobby, you probably aren't going to know

Sure.

about this aspect, the dark side.

I don't know if it's like you don't know or I would say it's just more so like it's not a relevant

not relevant. Yeah. So, what do we mean by perfection? perfectionism in board games. I think that it has become more and more prevalent or at least more and more noticeable

defin like year or two

that people some people out there not all people we are generalizing here please do keep that in mind and please also keep in mind these are our opinions

yes

your opinion can be different that's fine um that per people expect perfectionism all throughout the hobby perfectionism in gameplay perfectionism in uh quality in rules. Even if you're just playing games casually with friends, like perfection must be achieved. Otherwise,

you're not you're not experiencing the hobby properly.

Exactly.

Which is the problem.

Which is the problem.

Because I would argue if that's your

Mhm.

by all means do your thing.

Don't hang out with us.

But not everyone needs to just like not everyone needs to cater to the way we play games.

Sure. Yeah.

But it's the outward expression

Mhm.

and viciousness

that I think can come from people that believe that board games should be played perfectly.

Yeah. And so some ways that we experience this as an example because obviously we do playthroughs and we have said a billion times when we do our playthroughs this is not

to and to be clear a playthrough is distinctly different

yes than how

than a how to play

which is what I was just about to say that we very we usually always at the beginning say this is not how to play video

but it makes you a general overview and I we're speaking for ourselves but we know that we're not alone here in the space for this. I think people need to keep in mind that a playthrough is now I'm not talking about how to play. How to play should be pretty much close to perfect, but if somebody makes a mistake,

I just also want to quickly die.

Two things. One is board games. Let's all calm down. Two, we're all human beings.

Like,

we are inherently flawed.

Yes.

So, no one's going to play a a board game perfectly every freaking time. Nor should that have ever

been an expectation

been the expectation. fly just flew right on my face. Okay, so for playthroughs, that's what I'm talking about right now. There is two expectations that people have. Number one is that you play the game perfectly

without looking at the rule book

and you don't make any mistakes ever.

And the second is that people expect you to have a perfect strategy

or be good at the game.

Now, we get this in our comments all the time. at 11:07 you did this at 12:05 you should have done this instead like we you know we experience this a lot because like I think part of the beauty of our channel is that we're just people playing board games we're not prof like we're professionals because we do this for a living but we are literally just two people trying to enjoy a game and when you know Matt and Jason or whoever and oftentimes Jeff we do a playthrough, that's going to be their first time ever playing the game. Because

I actually kind of prefer it that way. Like, I know the rules. I will teach the game. And we've had some viewers that have said, "Oh, I really like that you do this." Because then they can ask questions and it makes them not feel dumb for having the same question and it shows you the actual experience of what it would be like for real people to play the board game.

Yeah. I mean, we'll we'll we'll get similar comments like we've had in instances where like we do board game weekend videos

and Jamie will do B-roll of a game,

you know, just a pan over a a board

and like people will like comment and be like they'll like pause the video, look at the board state, and comment and be like, "Oh, you're playing wrong because this piece is here when it shouldn't be."

And I'm like,

why are we this way?

I don't know. Just it's okay. It's okay that we we are playing a game incorrectly. It impacts you 0%.

Yes.

I just find it weird

that we feel this obligation. It almost is like this like

it almost sometimes feel like it's this situation where it's like I'm I'm smarter than you.

Yeah. I know this game better than

and I'm going to show you why.

Yeah.

And that's a bit bizarre to me. Mhm.

Like why can't again if you want to experience that and play that way in your own group

by all means

but like other people shouldn't be made to feel like they're not gamers or they're not as smart or good at whatever because they don't play that way.

Yeah. And it's unreal like the whole

And it's unrealistic.

It's unrealistic. And the whole rule book thing like people don't want you to be like looking in a rulebook in a video but like

Mhm. H how am I supposed to memorize a 20page rule book? So many board games now are, and that's another point, like so many board games now

that are not just like simple whatever. It's like 20 30 pages and then you have to remember every little nuance and there's always a conditional thing on the conditions. conditions on the conditions. And yeah, like we've gotten, you know, feedback on playthrough videos where it's like, well, here's like 10 points,

20 points of why you played wrong

of how you didn't optimize this and how you and not even played it wrong.

Yeah. Just didn't play.

You played the game right, but you didn't show it off well enough or you didn't do this or you didn't do that or why wouldn't you do that. And like I'm not gonna lie and I'm obviously not gonna say anything and whatever, but like we've had feedback from like designers who've been like, "Oh well, you should have done this and you should have done this." And it's like

we haven't played your game 300 times like you have.

You were the you designed the game. You know this.

Also, if we've played it five times, we are going to have a similar experience to people that are going to eventually play this game.

Yeah.

Because we're just two people

because we're just two people playing board games. And I think like we choose to play and we've talked about this many times before, but we don't choose to play like we don't, you know, we want to win, but we're not like I'm gonna get the highest score ever possible. I'm going to break the game or I'm going to do whatever. We just want to have fun.

And if you don't want to have fun playing like

our slam throne video, guys who don't like to have fun, you need to chill.

Yeah, it's a lot of that stuff, too. Like this is kind of a a side tangent I guess, but there's a lot of like, you know, we've experienced it with slam. There's a lot of people that'll that'll and these people are always going to exist and they're always going to be the very vocal minority, but they'll be like,

don't

this is stupid. I don't I don't like this

without ever having played the game.

Um, this is a dumb idea and it shouldn't exist. And it's and it's like, okay, but that's for you.

Mhm.

Like we don't like this thing and it shouldn't exist. It's like who are you speaking for?

Yeah.

You know, and again, like why why do we feel like we need to put so much negativity out

into the universe? Like it's fine if you don't like it and it's fine if you want to express that opinion for yourself, but ultimately what it comes down to is like what is the point of expressing your disinterest in a game?

No one's forcing you to buy it.

No one's forcing you to have any interaction with it. Just don't buy it and just don't comment on it. just move on and be like, "Okay, well, this one's not for me. I'm just not gonna get it." Yeah.

Like, and that's like kind of this I think falls into this perfectionism thing where it's like every game needs to be perfect and it needs to be catered specifically to me otherwise I'm going to complain.

Yeah. And if if I don't like it, then it's not perfect.

Yeah. And it's a bad game. And it's

there's no perfect games. And and and sometimes like we will get feedback or like I've had this happen to me personally from like members of our community or like people on YouTube being like, "Well, I bought this game because you said it was

fun and you liked it and I'm mad I'm mad at you now because I hated it and it's your fault." And I'm like, "No, it's your fault.

You're

for making the purchase."

Yeah.

We're not twisting your arm. We're providing you information in order to make informed decisions, which we state in almost every video, do your research, make informed decisions, and if you buy it and you don't like it, that's on you.

Yeah.

And it's very weird that people have I just feel like as we've progressed, and maybe it's like a postco thing, I don't know. There's like this inability for people to hold themselves accountable for bad

behavior. It's like, well, it's your fault. And it's like, no, you're an adult who made a decision and it's okay.

Sell the game or get rid of it or do what you want, you know, and and learn from the behavior.

Um, but it's also like just to talk about the consumerism aspect of it too, like things I see with like Dice Throne is like

people also expect their games to be in perfect condition.

Oh my god, when we said that our library for the cafe was going to be our games, there were people that were like, "How could you do that? People are going to destroy your games." It's like games are meant to be played like they should be well loved.

You know, people keep games in shrink and I'm like, okay, if that's your thing, fine. That's great.

And you know, like, but isn't the point of these games to play them? Like we've had comments of like, oh, like these cards are worn down. It's like, yeah, I like that it tells a story that we've played this a bunch and then it's like, oh, remember that time we did it this way or whatever. But like this comes up in in consumerism of board games, too, where it's like this. Like I I've had people email our support line and be like, "Hey, I need a I need a new game because mine's damaged."

Yeah, I've seen that.

And it's like and I have to like zoom in 300 times to see a small nick on the box. And I'm like,

it's not perfect.

Are you Are you kidding me? And like another example of this is like, you know, um you know, with with Slam Throne, people like, "Well, what happens if the caps get damaged?" And I'm like, "Well, they're going to."

Yeah. because that's the point of the game. It's okay. It's okay if board games show a little bit of wear.

It's fine. I mean, these things are meant to be played with.

Yeah.

You know, like if you play with a toy or you play with like

a badminton racket or a soccer ball

or whatever. It's people aren't like, "Oh man,

I took my soccer ball out to the soccer field and kicked it around a bunch and it's got a bunch of scuffs on it. Oh my god, I don't like it anymore."

Yeah. Like I just also think, you know, the very first solo mode video that I did for Board Game Geek, one of the very first comments I got was like, "Ugh, she already made a mistake in explaining the rules. This is a hard pass. Not going to watch. No good." Like, it was literally a comment almost exactly like that. So bizarre. And all that had happened is I mis

spoke. I just mis said something because I'm not looking at a script when I'm doing those videos. I'm literally just teaching the game as I would teach a friend or whatever.

Um, and I played the game, right?

But like even if you just accidentally say something wrong, I think people are just very aggressive about it. And I know and that's why I said at the beginning, this is probably the most relevant to people who create

put ourselves in that public sphere.

Yeah. You create the content of showing a game and then people will literally go down into their board game room, pull the game out, pull it out, grab the rule book, flip to the page, find where you're wrong, and type it out.

And that's madness because if you're doing that in our comments, I just need you to know.

We don't care.

And like you can tell us and that's great, but

yeah, it's it's it's a somewhat similar aspect. And I bring this up all the time in like our Discord community and people ask questions about like what's the toughest thing to deal with and blah blah blah.

A lot of it's unsolicited feedback. I mean,

we're not asking and people I know someone in the comments can be like, well, you're putting out content, you have to have thicker skin. You have to deal with this. And I'm like, why is the onus put on the creator to deal with

people who are

people who are

like, I would like to think that if I was in a retail situation

and someone was being an

Yeah. to someone behind the counter. I feel like I would step up and be like, "Hey man, like calm down.

Like why are you being a jerk?" And that's a lot of the time that's what unsolicited feedback feels like.

Even if your intention is genuine and nice,

it's a really weird position to put yourself in to throw that stuff out there

because it never feels like you're just trying to be supportive. It feels like you're trying to attack a character or attack intelligence.

Yeah.

And some of that might come down to just how that message is put out with tone. And let's also understand tone cannot be interpreted via messaging.

It's really difficult. Yeah.

So just be mindful of that sort of thing. And again like mistakes are okay and it's part of human nature and it's fine and it needs to be fine in the board gaming space.

Yeah. I just like, you know, so long as you're not playing like if we played a game and we got every rule wrong and someone was like, "You guys, what are you doing?" Like, I would understand that. But if we're like missing something cuz like

I've mentioned this before, I've played Final Girl

hund like probably hundreds of times at this point,

every stream I'm still like you guys are going to laugh, but I don't remember. do I do this or how does this work or I just can't remember everything.

And I just don't know when we got away from just like playing to have fun.

And I think that people look at people who are making playthrough videos and creating content as like well you should know all of these things. Anybody can make content. You know what I mean? Like we're not we didn't go to school to learn how to play board games. We've never And we've also never stated that we're like,

"No, we just want to have fun."

That we're incredible board game players.

Oh, we we're not we're not we're not very good at it.

Yeah. I think people just have the expectation that you're going to be great and if you're not then they think you're

bad people or they are bad or they're like this is stupid. I won't watch these again or whatever.

I'm never watching their content again.

No. And I want to be clear like those comments don't hurt my feelings in any way. When people are like, "You need to get a thicker skin." It's like, "No, I don't really care. It's just I don't really understand the thought process behind it because all you're going to get back from us is cool, thanks." Or a thumbs up or like people don't need to play the game.

I think this this video more so for me is just to like maybe draw attention to the fact of it like as opposed to like trying to fix it because you're never going to be able to fix it. It's just maybe second have a second like thought when you're when you're doing these things of like

oh look they made a mistake I should let them know and it's like ah you don't have to you don't have to because it doesn't it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things like again to Jaime's point when we played board games

all of the core rules and the core mechanisms the things that are going to break the game if we do it wrong we will get those right. Yeah,

for the most part

we'll try.

It's these little nuance things of like, well, at 15:45 you moved your pawn, you know, one space to the right and you weren't allowed to do that at that time. It's like we're playing this live.

Yeah. We're literally playing a game like you would.

And it's it's easy to pause something and be like, "Oh, what did they do there?"

Yeah.

Like it's okay, though. You you don't need to specify those things to content creators. Again, it's a bit different. It's if if it's a how to play versus a playthrough,

but it seems like in no matter the video type or video content type, people always want to make rules, corrections.

Yes.

And that's the stuff that I'm like just just

do it in your own head. Be like, "Oh, they made a mistake. Ah, caught it. Cool. Whatever." Yeah.

Um and move on. Because again, I guarantee you, no matter how perfect you think you play board games and how many times you play board games, I guarantee you you're going to make mistakes. Especially if you're playing in front of a camera.

Yeah.

Trying to also be entertaining people. Entertain people. Make sure all the equipment is running. Like I keep looking over here cuz our mic stopped working earlier. So I got to check. Like there's all of these different things to like think of on top of that. But it's like we started doing this because we enjoyed playing board games with our friends and family and we wanted to share that love. And that's what we're going to continue to do. And we do this, like I do this kind of professionally now in that I get paid to do some videos, but like even if it's a paid video, like we can't be perfect. And if we play a game completely wrong, will we refilm it?

Yeah.

Yes. If we've done it completely wrong. But if we make a couple of mistakes, I try to pop them up on the screen. And even when I do that, some people will still comment that I've done

that we've done something wrong. And sometimes the corrections are wrong.

Yeah, that's the other thing. Oh my god. It's just like, oh yeah, actually no, you're wrong. But anyways, I just like it's just been on my mind. And I think it's been on my mind recently because we did get an email with like a bunch of strategy feedback that it's like, oh, you never said that we were going to be good at playing.

We never claimed to be. Yeah. And I think for me like the overarching theme here

is just like there's so much negativity in the world in general

that I'm like do we do we need to inject it into like every video we watch or like tear down other people like there's all inevitably on our videos there's people fighting in the comments about something

and it's just kind of like can't we just like again if you don't agree with what we're doing or you don't agree with our values or like how we play games or if we get things wrong, you're entitled to just not watch us and move on. You don't need to also tell us.

Yeah. And we're not telling you that you can't feel that way. Yes.

Because like we and we've always said this and when we used to do the share the love videos, that was like a big part of it that we're not for everybody. We know that.

Um but there is somebody out there for you to watch that you're going to enjoy and you can relate to. And we're not saying that if you don't like the content or you don't like the playthroughs or whatever, like that's perfectly great and fine. I just don't need you to tell me.

That's the thing for me. You It's like you don't need to tell people you're leaving.

Yeah. Somebody pe We have so many comments who are like, "Uh, blah blah blah, stupid idiots unsubscribed." And it's like, you could have just left.

Yeah. Like you again, you don't need to announce you're you're unsubscribing or not watching our content or that's like

that's fine. Go ahead.

Totally fine.

It's like me being again in a like store being like

this cinnamon bun sucks. I'm leaving.

It's like okay.

Everyone's going to be like

or if you walk into a bookstore and you're like I hate reading.

Yeah.

Yeah. That's a great I hate reading.

It's like Why you got to do that?

But anyway, yeah, I just I'm like, listen, experience the hobby how you want to experience it, but I just don't think on other people,

you don't need to subject people to the way you want to experience the hobby, just like we don't need to subject people to the way we experience the hobby.

Yes. And I want to mention too because we're talking a lot about the content creation side. This also does leak into the real world and I'm talking to the people who are like, "Can I see the rule book?"

Yes.

Can I see the rule book?

Are you sure you did that right?

Yeah. Don't do that. Oh, wait. Can you explain to me exactly what you did to make sure that I know that you did it right?

Yeah. Don't do that. Don't do that mid game. Just if if that is a thing in your brain that you need to satisfy, wait until the end of the game or be like, "Hey, like hey, like I'm just like I don't know. Just don't ever ask for the rule book. It's so demeaning."

I do think like if you think you're doing something wrong and it's like I don't really understand. Can I see the rule book? You could do that because people learn differently. So if like I taught you a game and you're like I don't think I understand what's going on. Can I see the rule book? That's not what we're talking about. I'm talking about like oh what do you can I see the rule book cuz I think you did something wrong. Oh like I think we're doing this wrong. Oh like

it's just annoying. Let's just play like how we typically play is someone like are you sure we're doing that right? It's like I don't know. We'll look later.

Yeah. Yeah, we'll look after. Again, if it's not like breaking the game,

Yeah.

If it's some little like weird strategy thing being like, I don't think you're doing that right

or whatever,

we'll just wait. Just wait until the game's over. And then we'll check and then be like, oh yeah, we were doing that wrong. Oops.

Yeah,

we'll get it right next time.

But yeah, it's just like it's just such a thing. It feels like

everybody needs to calm down. Even like when people are like h this game I don't I don't like deck building it's like okay I don't it's deck building is a or I don't know I just threw deck building we were talking about it but it's like this is a a flawed type of mechanic and it shouldn't be used in it's like

to you

just it's just chill it's it's we're we're adults playing with toys

it's soccer Greg

it's soccer Greg

okay calm down everybody needs such as calm

adult. We're adults.

Does I'm not going to lie, it sucks some of the joy out of it.

It does definitely.

And we have said numerous times like and I'm not we're not stopping doing this, but it's like if this becomes unfun, then we're not going to do it anymore. Yeah.

And parts of this have become unfun

because of this.

Yeah. It's definitely seemingly gotten worse.

It's gotten so much worse over the last

I know some people might be like year and a half. you know, there there is definitely a correlation to our channel growing and getting more eyeballs on it and whatever, but like I don't because I'm noticing it more in like our Discord community, like there's more people complaining about games that are coming out and they're not happy with, you know, A, B, and C that's coming out. I even noticed like with Vam Ryder as an example when they switched from doing like the big boxes to like the um they're doing like quarterly releases like

some people it's as if we killed their cat. Yeah.

It's like this this is not that big of a deal. And I know that part of it is just again to to to go back to like society things are challenging right now and people have

or require an outlet for frustration and sometimes that's the case. But

I just am like no this should be our solace. This should be our area to just

be in our bubble and have fun with each other and and laugh and and joke around. But it seems like, yeah, in the last like year, year and a half, things have gotten way more tense,

so aggressive

and aggressive with like games that are coming out and mechanisms and like themes and

and how people uh deal with the hobby and like

X Y and Z, but anyway,

it's a little bit wild.

Yeah,

the night is dark and full of terror.

That's how it feels a little bit sometimes. But yeah, just have fun.

Yeah. And if if people make mistakes, it's okay.

I mean, if you're playing board games and it's causing you more stress

than anything, then it's you probably shouldn't be doing it. Like,

yeah,

the hobbies are meant to be an expression and release of

an outlet,

anxiety and tension and frustration and whatever. And if it's not providing that for you, then maybe it's time you sit down and be like,

should I be should I be doing this? It reminds me of that like there's a Tik Tok video of this interview where the a girl is like yelling and she's like I need to calm down.

Yeah.

This is not that big of a deal

cuz I like and recognizing that like when something is triggering you as simple as somebody playing a card wrong.

How silly is that?

Yeah.

It's like what?

And listen, I I'm guilty of that, too. Not necessarily in board games, but I'm guilty of like little things setting me off. So, I understand that completely. But I'm I'm also

You don't let them set you up on the internet.

No. And I'm also aware of the fact that that's a me problem.

Sure.

It's not a you problem.

Yeah.

You know,

I think people also like and I I don't always think that this comes from a malicious place. I think most people genuinely are trying to be helpful.

It's just that it's not helpful. But like even even in like Jeff's video game streams

where people will be like, "Oh, go over here. Go over and they're so excited because they love the game and they want to help, but then you're ruining the experience for the person that's playing the game.

Yeah. So, I actually have a rule on my stream that you're not allowed to provide that feedback unless I specifically ask

for that. Be like, "Hey, I don't know what I'm supposed to be doing right now. Can you help?"

Like, I'm flagging you guys now. Like, somebody help. Even in my final girl streams, I will always say because another thing with like live streams and live plays and whatever, there is a 60-second delay on the chat.

Yeah.

And so you might tell us something.

I have I've moved on. I've done so many things since then. And so I will always say now in my live streams, it's like if I make a mistake, you're welcome to correct me. I'll see it in a minute later and I won't

I won't be able to do anything about it at that point. It's also very challenging to not only just play a game and deal with the audience at the same time and pay enough attention to both, but then to on top of that

try to be.

No way. No way.

Yeah.

Anyway,

and I get very distracted by the chat.

Yeah,

extremely so. Anyways, yeah, it was just a topic that was on mind. We'd love to hear kind of your thoughts in the comments. And I know some people are going to have different opinions. Some people are going to go off on us.

And I think like as always, you are welcome to put whatever in the comments. Just be respectful and just know that we might come back and say, "Yeah, we disagree." Or, "Cool, thanks." or whatever.

Yeah.

You know, it's our channel. We say whatever we want to. So,

um, yeah, that's kind of what it is. But, yep, it was a topic on mind and I wanted to talk about it.

Yeah.

So, that was our rant for today. Jeff is feeling better. We got to start filming some more videos. Um, coming up, I'm hoping to do a video about our 10 favorite games of the year so far.

Yeah.

Have we even played 10?

Definitely we have. We played a lot.

Yeah.

Anyways, that's everything we have for today's video. Put down in the comments your thoughts. We'd love to know. If you're interested in buying board games that you don't need to play perfectly, you should first start by checking your friendly local gaming store. And for us, that is

the Boardroom Game Cafe.

Heck yeah, it is. If you like what you see,

please subscribe.

Hope to see you again soon. Now we say goodbye. Goodbye.

There it is.

Oh, you're matching me though. What the heck? So rude. Oh no, my my leg is stuck.

Yeah.

You need a hair.

Need a hair last. What?

I don't know.

Progress saved