Skip to main content
Loading video...

Pandemic: Rising Tide Review - The Broken Meeple

Transcript 18:03

hmm okay hey another pandemic game like we haven't seen another hundred of these already yeah well because they they're pretty decent games Oh what are we doing now rising tide a now we're heading towards the Netherlands and the Dutch okay cool all right the area I want to see it more sounds like a cool game Matt Leacock and Jerome Duman sorry you pronounce it oh is that name familiar I know let me just check on that

no it can't be no no no no no no no no no no no hello and welcome to another broken meatball review yes whoever that first rant shall we say the designer of this game you know fair enough I'm sure he's a lovely bloke but the publisher is associated with let's just say they've not been on my best of terms I mean certain games that they mention and I'm going to too much detail have left me maybe just a little bit less than happy at times you know nothing substantial nothing crazy just maybe not quite as joyful as I could be but we're gonna look over that okay cuz this is another addition to the ever-growing never-ending pandemic franchise what are we at now to legacy games pandemic I

think that had three expansions were on the brink in the lab and that weird um come primer the other one that was a it was like it had animals and things like that I mean nobody really actually bought that one I don't think it wasn't that popular an expansion we've had the dice version you know pandemic The Cure now we have pandemic iberia that's actually the one I have on my shelf you know I do like that one and now I got rising tide another one that they put in this survival series as they're calling it basically how many more reasons can we Chuck pandemic outlet the viewing public sounds like I'm being harsh that honestly pandemic is a fantastic co-op game and definitely one that deserves credit for getting a lot of people into the Hobby who are brand new to games it's just so accessible it just works it's one of those streamlined euro games that the coop games even that just seems to work and deserves every bit of credit you get but can we like can we take it easy now this is starting to get ridiculous anyway pandemic rising tide now has us going to the Netherlands and helping out the Dutch with their flood problem it's based on historical events now I am very little knowledge about history you know as you know from my other reviews of games I don't pay attention to history but basically the way I see it the Netherlands is getting flooded you gather save them you know but you don't really need to know about the history just know that is the theme in the game when you're good and it definitely isn't a Netherlands not Norway as I put in my first picture when I decided to post a picture of this game I

was a little bit flagging at the time I was somewhat you know not entirely with it and I for some reason put Norway instead of the Netherlands at first I corrected myself eventually but yeah not Norway Netherlands so in this it's very much like a normal pandemic game you've got your roles you've got your action pawns you have four actions a turn you draw two cards you know bad stuff happens and then you rinse and repeat and like before you were building research stations now you're building for like gigantic water pumps / dams you know like for construction sites and you do this and you win the game of course if you let all the flood cubes onto the board then you lose and generally that happens more often than not actually we get onto that later once you've got used to the base game though which you know like I say pretty much like every other pandemic out there then you can throw in a nice little extra barium which mixes up the objective so it's not just about building the four you know dams and construction sites you might have to build some and you can still build them but you might also have to get a certain amount of population in various places you might have to you know clear out certain areas of flood entirely you know you can shuffle these cards they have the objectives on them you mix and match I think you draw anywhere between four to six depending on the difficulty level and you go with that it's a pretty sweet variant and one that I would probably throw into most games of this to be honest just to chop and change things up a bit but in terms of what it looks like

this is well I know Beauty any eye in the beholder and this doesn't look too bad and I have to admit I do wonder whether it's his influence yeah you know what the publisher games are like but this is probably the worst looking pandemic game I've seen not to say it's ugly and horrible but it's quite muted you know you can tell the different colors but they're very dark colors it's like the whole setting is meant to look quite miserable and gloomy maybe that's the theme they were going for you know dark stormy weather therefore you know everything does a bit gloomy in that but yeah this one doesn't jump out of the table quite as much as say pandemic iberia for example or even pretty much the normal pandemic when you've got like various expansions in there so this one isn't the best-looking one for me but you know it's not a massive deal everything else is pretty well produced though in the board is decent quality you've got translucent blue cubes for the flood you've got you know the role cards decent card quality you've got big thick chunky markers for the construction sites not just a tiny little Monopoly house and like I say generally the production quality of this is pretty sound you gotta give it credit for that how does it play out like a compared to normal pandemic well pretty much the same you've got one or two slight tweaks on the rules for getting your maneuverability around the map but rather than going across like different lines you know the show sea routes you're basically all in different regions around the Netherlands and you

can chop and change from like one region to the next you can build ports in order to move yourself around a bit quicker you can build pumps which you know water pump stations which allow you to sort of mitigate the flood and of course you've got the main construction site so you're doing but other than and also dikes where you are blocking up certain regions from each other with basically flood blocking now the main difference I find with this game is the way the flood works we've been used to pandemic where it's all about infection cubes you put out free cubes they out break and then they spread to the neighboring areas and that's about it well here it's a little bit different and in a good way actually because you still have to draw infection box saying infection it's like no dynamic you still have to draw the two like cards off the top of the I don't know what to really call it but basically off the flood deck I'll call it and you draw the two cards and it gives you the region names and you have to put the cubes on and do things as you would at a normal pandemic game but the cool thing with this is that it has a specific rule where depending on how many flood cubes you have in a region if there's an exposed region next to you then pending on the number flood cubes appear in there so you don't need an actual outbreak happen I mean that can still happen you can still have a massive flood brush but even if you just had a couple of cubes in one region you could get a cube in the next one so it spreads very quickly because effectively it's simulating the water flow as soon as you've when you've

got water blocked up you know under the you know by the coastline or in certain regions with those dikes all is well but as soon as a dike gets removed and that's effectively what the flood debt cards do normally you were removing yo cubes and stuff like that now you're removing the dikes but as soon as those dikes get removed you have to check whether the water would flow from one region into the next you know just by itself and if they're exposed water passes in more cubes on the board run out of flood cubes and that's another way to lose but I find that really cool and a formatic sense because that's what would happen you know if you had exposed areas then the flood would just carry on you know what sir you know we got whose favorite line you know water always wins it does yeah it's very difficult to hold it back but it also does really ramp up the difficulty level I've played pandemic legacy 1 & 2 and the normal pandemic with expansions and raw birria this is on par with I'd say normal pandemic within the lab because in the lab was quite a tough expansion to beat when you had all those moving parts and everything else this is I think harder if not on par with that and I know some people have got different ideas about what they class is hard or not but this is definitely a tough pandemic and that's but for you up the difficulty level or change and you know chop and change the objectives I'm just talking introductory and standard mode in this is pretty tough particularly if you're using certain rolls over others I don't want to leave my you know my base

without the carpenter in this you know she can build dikes when you're in flooded areas which normally you can't that is super useful and he can also build pumping stations for free you don't have to get rid of cards and those two things together just make him such a perfect role for my style at play so I never want to leave the game without him but it certainly makes this one harder this is definitely one to think about if you need a challenge in pandemic you fought like maybe others were getting too easy want something a little bit tougher then go with it another issue I had with the component quality in this though is the way the map looks the dikes are put on these little X out spaces you can see where they got a go but you're looking at regions that are shaped all you know we give you wobbly lines and the dykes are laid out on them in straight lines it looks a bit weird when you've got the dykes on them like it's hard to tell where region ends and starts because you're putting a straight piece on a wiggly line it's kind of odd and it does make the map look a bit busy at times and to this the fact that you're in the Netherlands now I'm not saying anything else like the Dutch language or anything but every region in this is named after the proper meaning but of the Dutch word behind it so you're not just simply going Spain France Germany which are names you recognize these are all the Dutch names and their spelling pronunciation of them I know nothing about Dutch geography you know I've been to Amsterdam that's it that is literally my knowledge of the Netherlands and yet

you have all these names in here which does make life a bit tricky when you're trying to locate anything on the map even when you draw the cards and they've got like a very zoomed in picture of what it is you're trying to look at you're still looking at the name going I have no idea what that is where is it on the board and you're trying to pick it out out of a lot of words that actually sound and look quite similar so the board gets very busy it's a bit harder to work with it's not quite is I'm not saying to of it but it's not quite as easy flowing to look at and maneuver around as maybe other pandemics have been with you know I would dare say more widely known areas and countries and regions you know if you I mean if you're from the Netherlands do you know anything about the does you'll recognise all these names anyway but if you're if you know like me you know nothing about the Netherlands you're probably gonna have that little bit of an issue when you're trying to work out all these names on the board but it's a minor niggle it's not a big deal you know the card maps are there they show you where it is on the region and eventually you will get used to the board and you've still got everything color-coded by region one thing I do quite like is the those station markers station D like the dam markers the ones you got built to win normally in the previous pandemics you built four stations and you want and that was bad it every time you cured a disease that was it you cured the disease great you had a slight benefit that's about it here each one of them gives you a special bonus one allows you to build those of dikes one allows you to clear a bunch of cubes one allows you to block off an entire section you know and so on

and even when you use the variant which we'll get onto later you can still build them you know and building each one can become a little bit more strategic they're fixed so you have to go to the actual location again this is a tougher pandemic but once you build them you might time it so that you can get the most out of their extra benefit it's a cool little feature and I wish they had that in previous pandemics I know they well I'm not going to spoil anything but you know it would be nice to see it in more pandemics going forward it was a nice little addition the variant is where you shuffle together a bunch of objectives and you deal them out randomly to start and that dictates your winning conditions so you can still build those sites but you might not have to build all forward now you might only have to build one or two and instead you might have to keep a certain area completely free of tubes you might have to get an area filled up with dykes you know sir you know sealed off or there's a little mini population variant which is that you have to get it's kind of weird a little bit fiddly you have to get these population cubes into a certain area and make certain that they don't get flooded over otherwise they die off and that's another way to lose the game it's neat but I don't know I I can take it or leave it I'm not a fan of the population like cubes and stuff like that I think it's like one step too far you've already got enough to deal with it's tough enough as it is do you need to throw that in but I do like being able to chop and change the you need to control certain areas keep them out of way and those sites that's what I like to use this variant for other than that

there's not much else to say the game is your typical run-of-the-mill pandemic game except now you have a water theme instead of a hospital theme and it's certainly a lot more challenging even if the whole sort of board and everything looks a bit muted and bland compared to other pandemics so overall I did enjoy it I found it probably a bit too tough for a pandemic game I mean to certainly I don't think you should get this if you want to show it to new players I think pandemic Iberia did a pretty good job of that you know as a standalone one failing that just get the original pandemic it's good for what it is you know it is a perfect way to introduce people to the hobby I would say this is a next step pandemic I wouldn't want to show a new player this it might just be a little bit too tough for them a little bit too like oh my god we are getting destroyed tight so again I mean it could be wrong maybe they're from the Netherlands maybe they like the whole flood theme rather than the infection theme I certainly do like the way that the water acts in this one where it floods from one region to the other so you can have these massive cascade effects where if something just gets removed and suddenly it causes a complete flow of water across your land that you weren't expecting or you didn't plan well enough for yeah that sort of thing I like and I would like to see that maybe using another pandemic setting and it's certainly the one thing that elevated this one to a decent level for me but yeah I'm kind of mute on it and it's got nothing to do with the whole you know designer thing you can tell his fingerprints on this game

probably by the you know the color scheme in that and obviously because obviously he's Dutch therefore it makes sense to have a Dutch designer work on a Dutch Netherlands game so I'd say I enjoyed it but I'm probably only gonna go as high as a six for me personally I think it's okay but I've got pandemic Iberia and I still think that's the superior one of the survival series so far the legacy games are kind of a separate deal so I'm not really including those and I would certainly play Iberia over the original pandemic now even with the expansions included so this is probably one of my least favorite of the range but it's not to say I think it's bad I think it's still decent if you want the Netherlands flood theme go for it if you want the a very challenging pandemic then go for it you know if you want the ability to chop and change objectives then go for it because that hasn't happened in the normal standalone pandemics yet so yeah whoa decent enough probably not suited to me really but you know I probably won't hang on to this one I'm gonna keep Iberia and okay so hopefully somebody else will enjoy it so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken meatball review hopefully my house has not been washed away by the time I do this cuz it has been somewhat wet lately I must admit so whether you are flooded the way into the sea never to be seen again it was only a game hope I go mentally there soon guys

you

Progress saved