Skip to main content
Loading video...

How QE's Commodities Expansion makes a good game great - Base Game + Expansion Review

Transcript 9:33

a lot of ink has been spilled or the video equivalent thereof on auctioning in board games this Central mechanic that oh so many games have been based on is curious in that many of the very pillars of the genre are decades old but QE here is one of the great modern implementations of auctioning a really good game that just emphasizes at its Central core this minimalistic auction design with a really clever and inventive implementation that stands contrary to its predecessors while squarely being an auction game we haven't covered it yet on the channel which is why we are covering it as part of this review leading up to spoiler but first let's get a baseline for what is QE so that way we have some context for what makes the expansion oh so remarkable so QE is a game that stands for quantitative doing some research on the computer here a term that stands for quantitative easing you as players are countries that are bailing out corporations that are too big to fail during the 2008 recession the absolute crash that was devastating for so many reasons and many companies were bailed out as such now that's already a cheeky theme for what is a very cheeky game because you have

this stack of Corporations Affiliated to different Industries and countries which you can get bonus points for collecting different sets or collecting companies that are affiliated with your country or for your secretly assigned bonus industry and the way the game works the major thrust of it in the central gimmick is that the auction player which rotates from round to round flips over the top tile so everyone can see its point value it's country it's industrial affiliate in then they set their opening bid what they are willing to pay for it then all other players on their wonderful dry erase boards write down secretly what they're willing to bid past that amount over to the auctioner and the auctioner looks at all of the bids as well as their public bid and then decides who's the winner if another player won then they take the tile they write down the amount that that person paid they secretly hand that to the winner without revealing how much they paid and then push all the boards back to their respective players if the auctioner won then they write down publicly what they paid for it and then keep that token in front of them and how are you spending money how much are you willing to bid well that's the thing about the game is no amount is too much in QE you can set up any amount there is no finite currency that you have you're not checking how much you're able to spend you can spend seven dollars or 70

dollars or seven hundred dollars or seven billion dollars if you want to which is hilarious and awesome and a huge part of the game see the way you calculate the winner of the game is the point accumulation through these various sets that you're building up the points listed on the tokens how much you got that was affiliated with your country or financial sector but the player who paid the most money throughout the game tracked by the tokens that they have accumulated on the back of them is knocked out of the running they cannot win so as you play you are wondering how much other people paid in order to win those tokens and only the auctioner gets to know how much people paid and the auctioner is rotating so you have very little information but what you do have is how much the auctioner was willing to pay and whether or not you won it creates this incredible social deduction cat and mouse among players where you're like I think that they think that they think that I think and I know this and they know that and if they do this so that I do that it's this dizzying circular logic that is hilarious and awesome and so enjoyable especially because you can pay any amount of money of course the auctioner kind of sets the tone with a smaller amount of money maybe they say 700 or 7 000 or whatever but that kind of sets the tone for the rest of the game after that first auction it's hilarious it's clever it's interesting it is fun and it is minimalistic presented beautifully with

these great components if you like auction games then QE is a game you need to check out but there is something holding it back from being just an unequivocably great game it is very good game but there is a certain situation you can get into where you want to bid low because you don't care about winning the thing you want other people just pay out money you don't need to compete in something and that kind of takes away the Intrigue and interest for a turn also as the auctioner you don't always know exactly what you want to do as far as setting up the opening bid so there's this this feeling that as long as you know that someone else is really going to desire something you can just kind of let them have it or goad them into paying and that is where Commodities comes in this is an expansion that expansions so hard doing the expansion thing to make a good game into a great one so Commodities adds three sets of commodity tiles that are scooped up by the second player in each auction you have gold which is the most valuable of the Commodities but if the gold market is entirely depleted before the end of the game then each gold token is worth three fewer points you have oil which is great it's not quite as valuable as gold but if you have the most of it you've cornered the market and you get a bunch of bonus points and then there's crypto because you know crypto Bros need some representation in

board games I guess in a cheeky sort of way it could be worth zero or it could be worth the most 10 points which is awesome but also really risky for you to invest in crypto and has no other inherent value or you know collectibility or sort of rules associated with it you know it's crypto I have a hard enough time tracking what's going on with that stuff in real life let alone in a board game the way that this is implemented into the game is that when someone wins an auction they get the corporation token as normal but the second place player gets a commodity token of their choice using the value of their second place bid just like it was one of the corporations but the other exchange here is that the auctioner gets the benefit they get paid for the amount that the commodity winner paid for that commodity they made a sale so if you had a second place bid of six thousand dollars that got you a commodity then the auctioner gets to make a credit on their account of six thousand dollars that then reduces the amount that they've spent so that way you can kind of do this ebb and flow and dance with that sort of dodging and weaving to avoid getting knocked out of the final placement it's brilliant it emphasizes the already best parts of QE that sort of social deduction meets auctioning that is so potent and makes it feel so unique and then fills in the gaps the gaps are filled suddenly you

care about what you're bidding in every bid even if you're intending to get second place sometimes you want to get second place and you feel disappointed when you got first place because you were trying to go to someone else into getting something you also as the auctioner care so much more about what position you put yourself in because if you get a commodity sale that can be really meaningful but you want a substantial chunk of change you want people to pay out for those Commodities on the other hand if you win the commodity sale as the auctioner you don't get that price reduction but you do get the commodity so there's again some sort of mental arithmetic that goes into figuring out how you want to position yourself there's hardly any overhead it feels totally organic within the original system such that even though they are by different designers I feel like they should be packaged as one game going forward it knocks it out of the park that much more this is what I think expansions can really bring to our Hobby in taking a good game and making it better and emphasizing the great things that are already great about it if you like auctioning and social deduction especially as presented in minimalistic games then it is hard-pressed to find something better than QE along with commodities it's hilarious it's Spartan it is fun and that is our review but let us know what are your favorite expansions that

absolutely feel like killer expansions that heighten all the best parts or resolve some of the weak parts of the game that it's made for and what are your favorite auction games I want to hear all about it put it in the comments below thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for doing all of the amazing Community things you know I've been Jack for the cardboard Harold

Progress saved