Sheriff of Nottingham Board Game Review – One of the Best Bluffing Games Ever?
Transcript
Hello, welcome back to the channel. And this is a channel where we give you reviews, don't do unboxings, and we're not going to do any [ __ ] playthroughs ever again as long as I am alive. Just a quick note to say that I have come down off of my 3day LSD trip. You lot are a bunch of [ __ ] wing granny's. The amount of [ __ ] I got from my last video is like off the [ __ ] batshit charts, right? Honestly, some of you lot are the type of people, even though there's 100 seats in the room, you're going to sit in the same [ __ ] seat every single [ __ ] day, right? But there's no point in moaning to me about my [ __ ] videos. This isn't the [ __ ] BBC, you know what I mean? This isn't a [ __ ] professional outlet. This is just some [ __ ] aging bald ginger knobhead sat in a [ __ ] room waffling about board games, doing whatever the [ __ ] he feels like doing at the time. And if you don't like it, Tom Vassel's going to go and suck you off. Right. Today, we're going to be talking about a bluffing game. And we're going to be talking about the sheriff of Nottingham, not Nottingham, you stupid American [ __ ] And in this game, you will be loading your bag full of goods, hoping to smuggle contraband across the gates of Nottingham in the hope that you can grab the most money, and hopefully win the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules, telling you what we do like, what we don't like. Then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not the sheriff of Nottingham first edition, not the second edition, is still worth your time and bother today and in the future.
So remember, if you're new here, consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, all that YouTube [ __ ] We will see you after this bo. So, Sheriff of Nottingham, how'd you play this game? So, the Sheriff of Nottingham is a bluffing game for one to five players. Or if you got the Merrymen expansion, then you're going to be able to play it with six players. One player is going to be the sheriff. They are going to be the gatekeeper to Nottingham. And each player is going to get 50 gold. You're going to get six goods cards, and you're going to make two discard piles with five cards each. Right. So, the first thing that you're going to do on your turn, the sheriff isn't going to do this, but everybody else is in turn order. You can discard your unwanted goods cards in the hope that you can draw some new ones. You can take them from the discard piles or you take them blind from the actual draw deck. But if you take them from the discard pile, you're going to have to put your cards face up and replace them. And you can't take cards that are further into the discard pile than the top card. You have to take the top card first. And just to muddy the waters a little bit more with some shitty sewage, you have to take from the discard pile before you draw blind from the draw pile. Right? So get that into your [ __ ] thick heads.
Right. So, the second thing you're going to do is you're going to load your merchant bag. You'll choose one to five goods from your ad and you'll stick them in the bag. And as soon as your bag goes clip, then you can't open your bag anymore and you're done. Yeah. So, make sure you put those apples into your bag at your first opportunity. Yeah. There's no going back once you hear that little click. So, next phase is the declaration phase. Each player in turn order is going to tell the sheriff what they've got in their bag. Yeah. You can make any declaration you like, but you have to follow these three conditions. Yeah. You can only declare legal goods. So you can't say that I got a bunch of contraband in my bag cuz that would be [ __ ] stupid, wouldn't it? Yeah, I wouldn't put it past you like, "Yeah, [ __ ] moaning old granny's." You can only declare one type of good. So you could say, "I got five bananas in my bag even though there's no bananas in this game cuz they're all shoved at your [ __ ] ass." And you must declare the exact number of cards that you have in your bag. Yeah. So if you put five cards in your bag, you can't say, "I've only got three cards in my bag." Right?
because there's got to be some rules in a game and now it's not just a free-for-all where you can just like chuck a load of [ __ ] around. The next phase is the inspection. This is where the sheriff will be putting his finger up your bum and massaging your prostate. The sheriff will like to go around and turn order because it makes easier. They will try and make a bargain with you. They'll say, you know, you give us a cup of gold and that and I won't look in your bag. And then you go, well, you know, I mean, don't really want to give you any money. And then the sheriff will make a decision whether they want to look in your bag or not. If they don't look in your bag, they'll move on to the next player. If they do look in your bag, then they'll open the bag up and they reveal it. And if they were correct, you will have to pay a penalty of all the cards that you bullshitted about. And if you were correct, the sheriff will have to pay you, right? You can also make deals that trigger later on. These deals ain't binding. So, you have to make sure that you trust the player that is making a deal. So, don't ever play with me because I am a lying piece of [ __ ] So, then there's the end of round phase. We do a bit of clean up.
And once everybody has been the sheriff twice, then the game will end. You'll add up all the value of all the goods that you've managed to get into Nottingham. You'll add up all the gold coins you got left over. And if you were the player to get the most of one type of good, you'll get the higher value reward. And if you were the second player, you get the second lowest. There is an expansion for this game called the Merry Men expansion. Basically adds a bunch of modules. There's a lot of them, but they're really, really simple. If you're playing with six players, you're going to have a sheriff and a deputy there just to cut down on the length of time it takes to play the game. You got the black market, which if you are the first player to get a certain combination of contraband in, then you're going to be able to pick the car that's going to give you extra points. There's laws. The sheriff will have two cars. They pick one and put the other one down. This becomes a rule that is going to be in effect for that round.
You got special orders, similar to the black market, but if you're the first player to fulfill the requirements on the special order, you're going to get some [ __ ] mental points. Yeah. And then there's a merry men where you're going to have one of these in your hand and the idea is to smuggle the merry man or woman or them into Nottingham and then you get some points for that. Yeah. So there's a lot of them. They're very very simple and yeah, like I said, if you're the player with the most amount of money, gold, points, whatever, then you'll be the winner of Sheriff of Nottingham and you'll get a rusty sheriff's badge just to prove it. Right. What do we like about the Sheriff of Nottingham? Well, aside from the smell coming from your rusty sheriff's badge, we found out that you can double bluff in this game yet. And that is a [ __ ] really good strategy, right? Because if you have got some legal [ __ ] in your bag and you want the sheriff to try and inspect your bag, you can actually offer them a shitload of money and then go, "Actually, it's a bit too much. [ __ ] it. I ain't going to do it." The only drawback with that is if the sheriff takes the bluff and looks in your bag at low amount, you're not really going to get that much out of it.
Yeah. So, you want to sort of start high. you want to sort of offer him maybe six coins or something to tempt him into looking in your bag. Second problem being is that once you've done it, somebody else tries it, the next sheriff and the sheriff after that is going to be thinking, "This person thinks I'm a [ __ ] idiot and I ain't going to go for that anymore." Which then works in your favor because then you can think behind that strategy and then if you don't offer the sheriff some money, they're going to think that you are bluffing or not bluffing. I'm [ __ ] lost now. So, the second thing that we really like about this is the bad click at the end of the day. Yeah, I just love hearing that bag go click yet. And I was a little bit pissed off with my copy of the game because one of the bags doesn't do that little clicky sound. It's just a dull sort of thud type thing. You know what I mean? But I'm not really a big fan of ASMR, but this one, I don't know. There's just something about it. Yeah, just that little click makes a little bit of we come out. You know what I mean? So, the final thing that we like about Sheriff and Nottingham is that the microphone is pointing away my [ __ ] mouth. You is that deals are not binding in this game.
How many times have you played a bluffing game where the deals have to be respected and you're like changed my mind now the whole game's changed. I don't really want to make the deal. But in Sheriff and Nottingham, you can do that. And we played this the other day and it was a case that I felt guilty for wanting to break the deal and I got [ __ ] over and I wish I had broken the deal yet because there's nothing more satisfying being a complete and utter. Right. So don't we like about the sheriff and not them. So the first thing that we don't really like about it is the game feels a little bit lightweight. It's almost as if they already had the expansion planned out and they took a couple of modules out of the original game and then dumped them in the expansion. Yeah, because the expansion feels like it's a little bit too much [ __ ] in there. When you play with all the modules, then the game feels a little bit bloated, right? So, the core game maybe could have had at least one of the modules out the Merry Men expansion and dumped it in here.
Yeah, cuz it feels a little bit thin on content. Yeah. So, the second thing that we don't like about this game is that the second edition came out when there was really no need for second edition. I mean, what year is this? I have no idea what year this was made, but I'm pretty sure the second edition came out maybe like a couple of years after this one. I never played the second edition. I don't know what it contains or whether they used some of the expansion material in the second edition. I have no idea. But it feels like another one of those examples where you buy into a game and then that game is whisked away from you before you've even got time to pull your trousers down and take a dump. They're trying to pedal you a second edition and your game that you paid 40 odd quid for is now out of date yet. Should it bother me that much? I don't give a [ __ ] because we're still playing with the first edition. But it's just a pain in the ass where you have these second edition refreshes that do nothing but try and get the people that suffer from fear of missing out or completionists to part with their money and that is [ __ ] So the final thing we don't like about Sheriff Nottingham is that this game can go on for a little bit too long if you playing with the players that drag games out a little bit. Easy answer to that is don't play with those [ __ ] morons.
Yeah, because they drag the game down. But sometimes you ain't got a lot of choice. Sometimes you haven't got that many mates. Or sometimes you don't have any mates at all. So yeah, it's not analysis paralysis per se. It's the equivalent sort of bluffing thing where people are like, "Oh, shall I look in the bag? Shall I not look in the bag? Shall I look in the bag? Shall I not look in the bag? Shall I sniff the rusty sheriff's badge or shall I just put my finger in their bum bum?" Summarize. Is the sheriff of Nottingham worth your time and bother today and in the future? So we are going to say yes. Absolutely. Sheriff of Nottingham is a fantastic bluffing game that always creates a buzz when it hits the table in my gaff. Right. You're free to be as much of an [ __ ] as you bloody well like, which is of course most of the time for me. Right. This game can drag on for too long if slow players are at the table and the core game feels as though there's something missing. Maybe that's fixed in the second edition. I have no idea. Let me know in the comments below.
However, Sheriff Anottenham still is one of the topnotch act like a [ __ ] and get away with it games. And if it's not in your collection, then I'm really really surprised because at the end of the day, you're all just a bunch of c. So, you go that is Sheriff Nottingham. Remember, if you're new here or you say Nottingham
to do please
consider subscribing to his channel, hit the like button, all that YouTube [ __ ] and we will see you next time.