Skip to main content
Loading video...

VANTAGE Design Diary Highlights: April 2024-February 2025

Transcript 30:31

hello everyone and welcome to the mill today today I'm actually filming this right before I have a big game day where we are doing wine chutery theme so I am all decked out in my vulture wear because of course vulture has to be our night cap drinking from my awesome mug that one of my friends got me tears of all the people I've beaten on Game Night hopefully I'll walk away with at least one win today currently Venus is on the table they'll start us off a little bit so I'm in a kind of ston me spirit with my viticulture shirt and today we are going to focus on a different one of Jamie's designs Vantage which is something a lot of us are super excited come out hopefully this summer is the plan that we'll finally get to dive and explore the world of Vantage so what I've done is Jamie started posting design Diaries last April of 202 for and there's a lot of information in there and I'm guessing some of you probably either haven't caught up or it's just been too much or you know that's a lot so I actually went through copy and pasted printed all of it because I like to read and I'm like oh I'll condense what he's actually written and when I printed it and I printed it before February so from April through January design Diaries it was like 30 pages front of back so would I say we've gotten a lot

of info we've gotten a lot of info so what I've done is I've have condense that to two and a half pages of notes for you so I'm going to go through those notes I'll do it month by month so if you just want the highlights of what we know about Vantage from April 2024 through February of 2025 this is the video for you and I'm going strictly off of his design Diaries so just trying to condense a lot of information and then I'll kind of tell you like hey there was a cool visual here in case you want to go back and look at which ones and without further Ado let's start in April of 2024 when you first let us know so April 2024 the design diary was named early Inspirations and movement so that's where we started and he said he was he kind of had this mind and then it was Zelda breast the wild that really just changed everything and really sparked stuff so he had initial thoughts and I actually printed kept this printing part because these were a couple of his initial thoughts when he did it he said you wake up in a small room carved into the side of a sheer Cliff you have no idea how you got there or where you are you the player don't even know the rules all you have is a card depicting the room when you look closer you notice some instructions in the art carved into the wall and that way starting small

unraveling from there you learn how to play at the same Pace that your character learns about the room in the world outside so that was one of his Initial Ideas the other one was you are on a prowed battlefield a mass of people in your field of vision the only person you can't see is yourself as you have but one card and is from the first person perspective of your character each other player had a similar card from the perspective of someone else on the battlefield game was about finding each player by communicating each perspective so that was kind of where his initial thoughts lied all right and then so he thought it was going to be Co-op entering a new location together and then face with a first person P scene all right so that's the initial thoughts and we know as I'll get into later ones that wasn't actually how it ended up being so kind of cool to see where it went um he also said one of his big overall goals these kept the whole times he wanted players to have freedom a ton of freedom of choice which we definitely had and he wanted a large Rich world that pretty much just said yes to players yes you can explore this yes you can look under that rock Etc he wanted to reward curiosity and Discovery and this was all like the ideas at inspiration that started seven years ago so a seven-year design and

that is where he just kind of kept us in April just that early inspiration so we could kind of be in that moment with him like a this was the initial excitement all right and then may of 2024 that was on Art and World building all right so arts and world building so he wanted this to be a whole planet with No Boundaries which is quite a feet all right and so when he was thinking about this like well that would mean it'd be very rare for people to actually find each other so going to that oh we don't we aren't together on the planet we can hear each other through later on he says what they have in their ear so we know how to find each other but he wanted this vast Planet he wanted it to feel organic and natural and just alive at this planet all right um so he wanted to be exploring this new world and that's when he started to find an artist who could help him start creating this world and that was Valentina phck I'm hoping I'm getting close to pronouncing these names and that was who started to kind of create the world in art to kind of help with all of that uh the other part they were trying to do is he always wanted people facing north okay um and they

invested in creating this planet before he actually did a lot of the design so he much just like this probably isn't always the best route to go when making a game but for this and going to explore this new world it worked however when they were kind of figuring this out they're like oh my gosh this is massive like you're going need more than one artist to be able to pull off drawing a whole planet for what this was and so that's when they got actually a couple other artists so they brought in sain meding I believe say apologize if I'm pronouncing them wrong um to come in and had a similar style so that they could make that work so they had two artists and eventually they also brought in ailan rivil um who did a lot of work on the discoverable cards and certain locations and this is where they were it is over 6 1,00 unique illustrations so these three artists had a ton of work and from the images Jamie had has shared so far it's beautiful and it seems from what we've seen to be melding really well with the three Styles um and then the other neat little part was because you wanted people exploring this and not necessarily all Landing in the same spot or ever really finding each other which I do know some people play tested they pulled it off but it was when Jamie says rare it was rare but they were so proud of

themselves when they pulled it off and it was a fun conversation I actually barely touched the play test so it was like I kind of saw Jam's intro and never actually had a chance to play it just cuz my schedule was really busy but I got to hear some of some from other people so I'm going to be equally surprised to explore this world with all of you and I'm very excited and the neat part is there are when you think of combinations of dice there are 126 different places you personally might crash land on that planet so tons of variety with this massive planet and even just your initial crash site okay so that was May of 2024 moving on to June of 2024 design diary 3 this was options and story books so Jamie said he wanted to as we said he wanted to give people that sense of Freedom like Zelda did which is a video game so it's very kind of different ways of having to do that um he didn't want the only choice people felt like they had was to fight if you kind of follow Jamie at all you know that he's really not big on games that are strictly fighting games especially with like the Dungeon Crawlers so we didn't want that to be the only choice and so he went with he won multiple skill options every time all right so it was a lot of theme first kind of planning for this game for six

skill categories he ended up with and then within those categories you would Branch out so for like the movement skill you might be hiking or swimming but it's all related to like that movement skill and then he dual coed for color and shape for each of those skills for making sure it was friendly for everybody and yeah so here went full on theme and World building first there's going to be a story book for each one of those skills that people are going to be reading from based on your choices so that'll be pretty fun to look through so that was kind of a more brief information month and then we get into that was June July there's a little bit more information here so July was winning and difficulty all right so kind of some of Jamie's ideas were it's a very different perspective with video games versus board games and so for a video game people might go into this open world video game and they have no issues with the fact that it is pretty much a 90h hour Adventure that you do in little spurts and there's really no necessarily winning in a single session all right so but it's a little bit different with tabletop but so he was kind of working with that he wanted to make that intrinsic motivation that you kind of get with the video games like oh I'm playing for an hour I'm just pausing my story for now and so the other part of that was he knows

there's so many great Campaign games it's like he didn't feel like we necessarily needed another one he knows how difficult those campaigns are for some people to get to the table and organize and get people together so he didn't want a campaign game all right he wanted to give people a thrill of starting fresh each time they came to the Vantage table and so there are ways of winning there are 21 different reasons that people come to the planet so that's kind of your mission there are 21 different missions to come to said Planet okay and then you can just discover up to 11 options to consider completing a destiny so he made it so there is like you win or you have like a super win kind of thing all right so you define yeah you define success through anything you and Achieve as well so even he wants people to have that freedom like hey you really just want to go and explore you don't want to care about this cool set up your own parameters or just have fun exploring all right so you kind of could design your own success there are ways of losing um you can lose by someone for the second time gting down their health morale and time are kind of your three measurements and so if you get to zero a second time then you technically do lose okay so a lot of vantages focus is about this emergent narrative which is part of the reason I'm excited because any game that can put in a decent amount of

narrative but into a one-off game I think is nice because I love narrative and as we've said campaigns can be a lot and you can't always get people there all right um there's also a difficulty of scaling so it's pretty neat when you roll the dice for like your initial placement or for um the missions the ones where it's the same side so if you have if they were a normal six-sided die if you rolled a six and a six that would be a harder one cuz the likeliness of that is less so people can kind of decide if you do want a harder one you know that the ones that are doubles those are harder or if you roll that you're like I'm not up for a harder one you can roll so that was kind of a cool little way of doing it and yeah that is July of 2024 moving on to August of 2024 this is replayability and Discovery all right so the way it's replayable there are 800 locations and I said he he actually put those so it'll be 400 cards you can flip over just because that's massive um so he said you will average in a game probably gain to 10 to 15 of those so massive amounts of replayability and then perspective your

perspective and how it's expressed impacts other players so you are going to it is has that Interac ability of it's a first person perspective so you're looking at your card and you are talking to kind of your crew mates who are on other parts of the island or sorry the planet I should say okay so there's that perspective in how much you express it that's going to change every game dep pay upon who you're playing with and then another part is options this part I just want to be able to read from this um so at the beginning of the game you will claim one of six characters starting with one of four difficulty levels the group will have the one of 21 missions each with a variety of ways to com complete them based on where you are in the world you'll crash on one of 126 locations so you're each in a different Escape pod each with 21 different locations that you could go to within the Escape pod and eventually you might pursue one of 11 Destinies even if you defy the odds and all those factors end up exactly the same on your first turn you have 13 different options four depart actions six location actions and three character actions so in total there are around 7,000 different actions just a just a little bit of variety there just a bit all right um the next part that he had was Discovery so there's no large map to spread out all right so significant aspects of the game you just might not

know for dozens of plays because you just haven't hit those locations you don't have that massive map um I think it was well Travis and Garrett who did a lot with the development of it I can't remember which one said but I think it might have been Travis mentioned that it's like they're very well could just be even through going through everything like stuff that they didn't see or there would be like a play session that something big would happen they're like what what I've been playing this for how long and now this happens so there's just a ton of discoverability in this one um and then um the rule book is separate from the glossery to kind of help with keeping those surprises and also Randomness some parts you have no control and so that always gives you variety when you don't have control over something like dice okay um every game starts on the spaceship the ship malfunctions and each player gets in a different Escape pod you only perform one location action per location so that's kind of also that big thing is that so I know there are some games where I've been I'm like oh I don't want to leave the spot till I've done everything I can here you can't do that advantage in a single game you do one action on the card and then you have to move on so that'll lead to a ton of variety all right we're getting there now we're on design diary 6 September of

2024 all right this one was focused on characters all right Vantage you kind of build your character while you play essentially so there they have a little Affinity to kind of one of those skills but it's not something to make or break or really push you in a direction you get to do what you want to do um but he felt this led to a speedy setup and so the you have that very light asymmetry and then it lets your character grow so you're going have like a 3X3 card grid and that's how you're going to have your character grow and build how you want your character to build and that way his idea was then you get to experience your character's growth it's not just given to you all right and cuz he was saying there are kind of two different types some people you build your character before the game or you do it during he went for the during one for this one and he designed them around our six skill types so he wanted them to feel distinct he also didn't want to Road us into like a certain thing like oh you are really good at movement you got to move this whole thing that's your job you don't want you to have that feeling maybe you're a little better at it but it's not that big a deal you can do whatever you want so those were kind of the highlights from character October of 2024 was seven this one's on cooperation and this was a big one got some notes from another one here yep all right so as we said Vantage does

a firstperson perspective and it's more of a player-driven puzzle it has meaningful limits on information you can only see your current location and the entire world is a mystery you communicate between players making a huge difference as to whether you'll complete your mission and or destiny however while the game isn't actively trying to win players must work together to avoid any player from dropping to zero time morale or health and there's a fair amount of risk mitigation so being that you're using dice sometimes there are ways to try to mitigate that risk that you could get from those dice all right um and that's kind of part of why he did why it's Co-op all right um he said at the time he was really starting this you had seventh continent and time stories were kind of some of those early Inspirations but there wasn't as much like this and that's why some of those video games really helped like Zelda breath of the wild Witcher 3 and he mentioned a red Dem Redemption okay cuz he won more of a player driven puzzle as a type of Co-op not the kind of pandemic the game is trying to kill us kind of thing all right so oh yep here's my other part of this Vantage is designed from the ground up as a fully Cooperative game with the core premise you are separated by vast distances and thus can only see your

current location from a first-person perspective implemented at least partially to prevent quarterbacking so a lot of people struggle with co-ops because someone can quarterback them they can't hear they can't see your car so they only know what you tell them all right so that Clos first perspective eliminates the alpha player um okay it's audio implants I knew I had somewhere in my notes that they have in their ear so they can talk to one another and describe what they're seeing okay and it kind of one of those goes was that you are alone but together kind of that oxymoron which I love um kind of that trying to give you that Lo alone and loss feeling but also a little bit of togetherness so you have the freedom but you still have other people you can talk to and bounce ideas off of all right uh he says kind of compare it to giving someone advice across distances in kind of our real world so how you cooperate you cooperate through skill tokens and dice impact dice slots share Challenge Dice actions with Benefits that help others completing a mission in Destiny all Shar discoveries and info and show Dice and character cards so there are different ways that you are sharing information um you can mechanically discard tokens to make

something easier so it's like you're giving knowledge or advice when you discard something that you know about uh to the other person and he says it obviously it feels a little bit different solo but it still has that camaraderie and Collective problem solving with trying to get rid of some of that you can't quarterback me because it's my decision it's my turn and I'm the one looking at the location so that's kind of that neat part with the cooperation all right we're getting there uh eth entry November 2024 this was the final prototype overview uh and so this is where we started having pictures for that um so the kind of the so he has the pictures figuring out the organizational puzzle so he has those online but he got the stuff and he had to figure out the organization uh they built the box to go on the table which I found interesting so you're literally going to have that box on the table for that ease of the cards there are 10 books including the rule book you there are it didn't mention in there there are going to be upgraded wooden tokens so I'm kind of curious what those are He also mentioned that there's not going to be room for sleeves because with how much there how much space all these cards take up there's there was no way to be able to put it on and then he had this kind of four-step process so the first step of the process is the ease of setting up the game so Vantage past that test because you literally just have that box of cards on the table

and then you have to be able to teach the game walk players through a turn and then simply play for a while um so those were kind of some of the pieces he was looking at for for that stage of the process all right so that's kind of how he felt it would go and it should be really quick kind of when you get to setup and gain into the game all right last big page of notes but December and January were pretty big so December 2024 diary 9 this was the Action System part one all right so they were in the pre-production process as we've mentioned 7,000 action options so they had to study the actions and skill tests all right they wanted the vast Freedom some key factors were input Choice ways to increase the odds of success before you tested yourself um random elements so you wanted some imperfect information then output choice so you wanted a way he wanted a way that may maybe you could salvage some bad luck so there was kind of those key factors when you get to a skill set a skill challenge was the input Choice the random element and the output Choice all right and then the last part that they needed to add was some varying degrees of success and failure so multiple outcomes and it just depended how well you did on that skill test all right so

your six main action options are move Look engage help take or overpower um he said he got some inspiration from one deck dungeon they gave a solution where you only succeed it's just what does that look like and so that was the philosophy he went with here so you're always going to succeed except you might lose some time morale or health just because of how that skill test went um and this was also uh where we got a sample turn okay so I'm not going to go through all of that here but if you want to look at what a sample turn looks like that would have been December 2024 one okay and then January 2025 10 how we play test Advantage was this one um and that was he did mention there his best guess for the web store in January was hoping for July of 25 so fingers crossed um so play testing non-location cards you can gain in a grid to assist with challenges was something he brought up they had the art and theme but needed the mechanisms originally um over 900 cards to discover and we already mentioned 800 locations and so he couldn't do a normal play test normally it's hey here's the files print them and do at least three play tests within a few weeks can't really do that

with that many cards so um Ira is the one that went to who was able to make a web app okay and you could type in the location number and it would pop up and you would see the location you're on so the journey was to export their cards then they had to get them from in design to the app and he said this is actually where they came up with that nine card grid because they needed some sort of limitation and they realized that actually works really well um to help with time and scaling so um he said he was playing this every day for 5 months and then like went out to the rest of us so it was really interesting for the blind play test to eventually come out that was on this app so he said while it was kind of a web app that we used to play test that Vantage is not going to be online because it's an invitation for people to turn off their screen and escape to a new planet um but what's cool and I I'm hoping Molly and I will be able to kind of pull this off to show you how it could work if everyone has a copy you could play remotely because you're not seeing people's cards anyways um he also that was a he had people play it at geekway mini all right so finally I'm going to go back to the current one because we have not gotten marches yet so February 2025 this was the Action

System part two and February was also when Jamie put in a gameplay video so if you want to see a non-spoiler gameplay video that's out there that was part of this design diary and then people were asking for a spoiler one so we did actually do a spoiler one too so if you're kind of curious and want to see the visual I highly recommend those videos um so the core philosophy Advantage as we've kind of seen is the freedom to choose what you want to do and where you want to go so no sort of event system that's kind of a key piece there and he didn't want the to be teaching before you start it's literally going to be you learn as you go because you're going to get your spot get your stuff and you land and you make your decision where you want to go so really not too much teaching um he also had eight quick steps to a turn P pausing only to collaborate and discuss cooperation and I'll put this up here I thought this was really interesting I printed it he has this so if you want to pause and get a better look at it um Jamie has this is part of that figary design diary and it's a kind of a flowchart on your decision so as some new is very visual I thought that was really helpful because first you choose the action read the cost of the action reduce the cost per matching skill roll dice from a challenge pool place roll dice on slots suffer penalties read the action result and maybe your result will say to continue

so once you make that decision of what action you're doing There's No Going Back come say hi yeah there's no going back no going back say hi all right so brief Luca Interruption all right by I'm almost done okay all right so if you've seen Luka in some other videos he likes to come in and say hi so you get a special LCA hi it's like almost like when the cat's come and say hi too all right so no looking back after you make that choice of what to do and they said there's a very very small percentage of continue action so sometimes you might get that and then there's more than 10,000 references all right and oh yeah he had mentioned they were in full production full production he said usually takes about 3 months and then it's usually 1 to two months for freight shipping so once again we're kind of hoping for that July uh coming out and wow that went a lot longer than I thought it was going to and that is summing up all we know Advantage so if you have any questions put them in the comments below hopefully I know them if they're in design Diaries I have them printed I can try to look them up for you but hope you're as excited as we are at the Mill and we'll see you next time bye

Progress saved