Heroes of Land, Air, & Sea: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey Ron welcome to board games unlocked in today I'm doing a no run-through review of heroes of land air and sea and the expansion order of chaos so let's get order of chaos out of the way it literally just it's a five to six player expansion that adds four new factions which are the Limekiln lizard folk undead and goblins I have played with The Lion King the MV lizard folk and then so basically I'm going to be talking about heroes of land air and sea which is the 4x game by Scott homes and if you don't know Scott ohms is the designer behind all the tiny epic games a tiny bit zombies galaxy's defenders all those other ones that are kitten miss and some are really good and some are really bad in my experience I've only played the tiny epic quest which was basically Legend of Zelda but just didn't have it was just missing something and this is kind of like a no yep it was it was a game and unfortunately that's kind of where I'm at with heroes of land air and sea while playing this game I was constantly thinking to myself what am I missing here like like what what is wrong like am I missing a rule do I just not get it yeah just a lot of those thoughts went through my mind while playing this game
and even after thinking about it I still don't know what is wrong with this game so to elaborate a little further on this I'm going to explain basically how the game essentially works you have your own faction that is unique to unique I mean everyone that performs the same actions everyone does the same like plays the same way as the same capital none of that stuff changes but basically your buildings are different and over the course of the game you can permanently create these buildings they don't go on the board or anything you just have them they give you abilities and based off the level of York Capital is the level of abilities you get like five total two of them are the same for almost everyone because you need ways to build a ship and ways to build an aircraft and I mean those two are the same but the the abilities are different so you have three levels for each of these and then and then that's kind of makes your faction unique plus you have three unique heroes that are off to the side that based off the buildings that you build you can bring these heroes on they have abilities that also tie into your capital so yeah it's a it's a fort same expand exploit X terminate and I say explore yeah explore so you have those four things that are doing in this game and basically how you win is one of four ways through one of these ways either you can you destroy a enemy's capital they lose there's no
even if they had 50 points by the end of by that time if they lose a there they're the game you have exploit which is like revealing all of no no exploit was Oh three towers three towers on on the board expand was having all your people out your warriors and your serfs and explore was revealing these tokens on every spot on the map once that happens then you do basically one final round and whoever has most victory points after any absorbing wins the game um that's that's generally the gist so let's talk about things that I don't like about heroes of land air and sea and I'll probably be jumping back and forth between like things I like is like there's things that I like and things that I don't like and they kind of go in together of depending on the mechanism so the first thing let's talk about kind of where I am at with this so I personally feel that there is just a lot of stuff that is put into this game and it doesn't really know what it wants to do it knows it wants to be a 4x8 but it doesn't really know how it wants to hone all of these mechanisms in and what do I mean by that well not only do you have there's just no every capital like so you have to have your different levels of capitals which is going to be should be everyone's focal point get to level three because like and as fast as possible because if you don't you are
going to be behind so you have to worry about your levels then you have to worry about you know getting your towers out on the board because then your people can basically their adjacent like they can transfer between towers which is also kind of weird you have to worry about all the special abilities of these five different buildings and then this is all from the get-go so you have to read all this and then you have all these different levels of your heroes that you're also trying to figure out how to get on the board and then you have like the the the actual actions of the game that you have these five different action or these four actions that okay if you do these and people can copy those but then if you do these and you can do double actions so you have to worry about okay managing that then you have the resources where there's three different types of resources that are all for building and recruiting and all that they go up and down and then so there's just a lot of different mechanisms in this game that for me anyway sounded good like it sounded good on paper it sounded good when I was when I read the rules and watch the video and I was like great okay but when playing I felt like there was there wasn't really anything exciting going on like a lot of it was like okay did you do your turn you do your turn okay great now it's my turn now I'm gonna do this and never once was I excited to do anything I wasn't excited to to you know recruit people I
wasn't excited whenever I could recruit heroes I wasn't excited to have him on the board I wasn't excited to go march and battle someone I wasn't excited to build it was just I I don't know what is it was wrong about this game so you're sitting here waiting for your turn to happen and the game says 30 minutes per player fine that's probably closer the truth than then then fall so like the game is relatively quick for a Forex game but it just doesn't have that hmm now things that so what I don't like about this game is the so I mentioned that and then there was like there the game has spells in in in the game and like ever there's just one deck and then everyone draws and then you have a spell limit that you also have to worry about well you can cast less if you do a cast action or you can scribe it which means you put off to your site you can cast it multiple times you just have to pay everything as a resource cost so you're constantly fighting with your resources trying to figure out and these these spells cost to resew they cost mana and half the time I never wanted to cast them like I was like okay great they're just that's just one more thing to take care of and one more thing to just okay well this oh I have this and it's just not as intuitive as I would have liked the actions I I thought were okay like and and well the actions were your
standard ones move or crude stuff like that but build but what I mean by that is you have serfs you have these two different types of units you have serfs and you have warriors your serfs are used to build your buildings in and they're also used to help gather resources and they're also for doubling up actions or copying actions so nothing's really unique about that like the the copying actions other games have done it before and there was some strategy to that like you could look at your players boards and be like okay they don't have any serfs so like they're called capital actions and it's like I don't want to do those I mean I want to do them but I don't want to do them at the same time because other people have serfs and I understand that that's part of the strategy but then it's like I feel like I hits taken away from what I want to do and personally I didn't like that so like you could do these capital actions and then people could be like oh I have a serf ready and then so they'll follow up they'll be like okay you're gonna build great no I will also build and so it's like a lot of stuff that you're doing people get to benefit from and I'll explain another example of that later but so you have those Cabell actions but then it's like you have to have these in your capital not on the map to maybe double up on actions and so it's a very slow build because you you need food to recruit these people so it's like okay either you go all in on people but you probably should do everyone's move should be get as many serfs out as possible because you're gonna costly have an influx of resources and you're
gonna be able to copy people with their actions or double up your actions like if you are not getting searched out on the board you are probably not gonna do that well and then then you slowly get your warriors out because it's like okay well it's eventually that's what everyone's gonna do so then people have to fight and and that's what's gonna lead me into combat which i think is one of the strongest things about this game but also I have a pretty big negative that goes along with that so obviously exterminate is a part that the combat is part of a 4x game like a so half the time I never wanted to fight anyone I was like there is no benefit for me to do this and it kind of had that same it was a big complaint I had with like the Lords of Hellas where it's like I'm not fighting you to benefit me like I'm literally just bogging this game down just to make it last longer because it's like okay me stopping you like one of the moves recently was I was looking at Kat was her next turn she was able to trigger the endgame and I was like okay well I can stop her from doing that but I had to I was really like that I don't really want to because that's just gonna make the game last longer and I was winning like I I had the most victory points at that time and I was like okay great I'll probably pull a win out if we end the game now but it's like hey so though it's like but I mean who knows
like it's like but she'll she'll end the game and then she'll have these towers out so it's like maybe I should stop her and if you've watched any of my run throughs or any of these no run-through reviews you know that I'm a very competitive person so if there's an opportunity for me to stop someone from winning then I will do it but it's like god I really would rather this game end and there were a lot of times where it's like if this could have ended a long time ago and I wish it had but I mean I wanted to play and but at the same time I didn't want to play I was just like what it was was missing out of this game so I mean eventually I was like okay I'll do it I'll stop you so I went in with combat and the combat in this game is is actually very well done you have these cartons everyone has the same seven cards and it gives you almost perfect information there's no luck involved so you can look a lot of these cards have a resource cost to play it like manna or or or food and then they all have these different abilities but there's also restrictions it's like okay well if your army if I'm attacking you and you only have serfs you can't do some specific cards so it's like you're sitting there and you can look at the real okay they only have serfs so these three cards they cannot use so they have these four left okay they have no resources so these two are out great they have these two left okay I think
I'm in the clear so you how you can there's there's the process of elimination which I very much like and it's like okay well they're attacking a tower so they know I'm probably going to do a defense card so they can do that it's so they're probably gonna do this to counteract that and and there's just a lot of getting like reading your opponent and and the situation which are very much like the combat is is probably my favorite thing about this game but at the same time it has a pretty big negative and here's what it is both players play a card they flip it they pay the resources or you can use units to help pay the cost but then they they actually go off the board and go into your supply but the card has a point value on it so both players get the points that are listed on the card with its three points or two months or whatever and that's the part that I hate about it because if you win you don't get anything you don't I mean you they they're not there and that anymore but you don't get any more victory points you don't get any resources you don't get to stop them really you don't get to take anything can't you can just potentially destroy their towers which are not hard to get out and you should remove their units which are also really not that hard to get out because by the time everyone's fighting they're probably have an established source of like resources so it's like okay I killed some of you no I just stopped you for the time being until oh it's your turn now and you okay you recruit so they just came back alright alright but I do not like the fact that both players get victory points it's like no like that's not I I guess
thematically you did fight but it's like you've lost why are you rewarded with her two points for losing I think it should be if you get points you win if you win you get those points so there's some risk rewards I couldn't try this because it's worth points oh I lost dang and I don't get I'm not saying you have to lose those points for losing but it's like you lose the battle I gain the victory points like there's some incentive there for me to want to go out and fight you because there's points of it and even the attacker gets one point for just attacking what for some reason there's like okay great Doug and that's not enough to okay I'm gonna go across this continent go across the sea to go fight you it's like why why whenever I can just do my own thing be doing all this other stuff and because you don't like if there was a big influx of points it would be worth it but it's like even then like the defender can still get more points than you based off the cards that they play so they can play a card that's worth like three victory points and you can play a car that's worth zero or or two and it's like why why they still get three if they lost I don't understand that so like best thing about it but it still even holds it back based off of that victory point thing because it's a pretty tight game because every spell you cast cost mana and has points every you know combat that you fight gives you points not a whole lot of stuff actually just gives you points throughout the game a lot of is end game scoring so it's just kind of like planning for that and
I mean that's pretty much the the negative so the things that I do like about this game is I love the aesthetics of it like so you're sitting there and all the ships are these little 3d models that you like kind of their cardboard that you fold up and fit together and they're on the stance of the ships or the aircraft's actually are on sands so they stand above everyone I think that's awesome the towers and the capital has three levels so it kinda it's a big piece I'm a mini medium piece and a small piece it goes up so the game looks beautiful very bright very vibrant all the spells have like this little drawing like artwork on it your your you know me book meeples your miniatures are different I mean they're not like they're different from everyone else's but like the surfs all are the same model but the Warriors are different and then your heroes are all different and I have the ones that are painted so those look awesome and the colors on the board are just very bright it's not the best looking board this is kind of their like essentially it's just color different colors and then to some different terrain like it's not it's not the most detailed board but it's very bright like if I were to walk by and see this I'd be very interested in what was happening because the ships are also 3d it's just a very awesome looking game from like a pull back perspective I mean the players Capitol boards all the buildings you know there's artwork there so it just looks very very nice however
I think that's probably the biggest thing has going for it because for me anyway none of the mechanisms wanted me to stay because even even though I said the factions are all different they are but some of them are kind of like they're essentially the same ability it's like oh I get a resource of my choice if I control swamp okay you have the same ability but it's for desert all right so it's I mean yeah it's different but it's not like it's not like unique player powers like I mean not even close to relation of this but like cosmic encounter or Rising Sun or it's like here's my faction and here's my ability or abilities and it's like this makes me unique I want to sit at a table with everyone's unique ability and and be able to like know what they can do but half the time since there's three different things for five different buildings that's 15 different abilities that you have to keep track of and this game goes up to six players so like listen well that's with the expansion so let's say the four players you play a four player that's three people so there's 15 so that's what 45 45 different abilities you have to cut can'tit keep track of Atmos that's ahead they build all their buildings so in the last game I played it was we each built two so okay that's that's you know I have to keep track of 20 20 abilities how am I getting my math they're not 20 I was taking five and
then five each it's uh it's three each so it's six so it's twelve abilities that's a lot of abilities oh and then they have their heroes out which was another negative I never cared about bringing there they're my heroes in like they were there and the crucial one that stuff kept from winning the game or at least ending the game was my hero was involved in he he racked up a bunch of attack power but I'm like it's like he was the only one that brought that only because I spell allowed me to but like I just walk without and like I just build buildings just for the sake of it I didn't even really care about them and that's that's really like I just didn't care I didn't care about anything that was happening cuz it just didn't have that focus and I compared this a lot to Twila emperium because int while impaired me everything just makes sense there's nothing confusing really about this game it's just that you have eight actions everyone has access to these eight actions it's like I pick one and then everyone does the secondary ability it's like great you have secret objectives which are awesome because it's like this is my goal so I now have a like whenever people will sit down to play this game they will have no idea what strategy to pursue and I think that's a problem like I like to think that most games I can I can learn the rules and even it's the first time playing I can be like okay this is a strategy I want to pursue and and then BAM I mean it may not be may not you
know cause me to win but at least I have a focus I can go this route here i sat down and and I was like hmm okay I don't know what I mean I know how to end the game but I don't know with the first time playing this I was like I don't know how to win the game like how am I getting points am I supposed to fight you all the time no that's not gonna work okay I need a bunch of resources I mean yeah but okay I guess I need to build towers as quickly as possible okay so say okay well what buildings do I need to build because I have to read all of these there's five here there's 15 abilities told so it's like okay well if I okay so I need to get to level three which and it's like I mean I don't think I have analysis paralysis but this game made me feel like I did and that's probably reason why I didn't like it because I don't like to sit there and really and not have a plan like in a strategy game especially in the Forex game no like you need to have a plan going into the game and I feel like whenever I play trial Imperium I have a plan even the first time playing it was like okay yeah no I get I get this with this this all makes sense when I have these secret objectives and then there's those public objectives that I can aim for and then oh I need to control these planets because they're gonna give me resources and info it just made sense here it's just he took a bunch of stuff a bunch of ideas probably from his other you know 15 tiny epic
games and just took took a piece from every single one and through then you say I wanna make a 4x game here we go the title is also not the best here is a bland air and see this is kind of a alright hey you're heroes of this like like the game has theme now there's a thing I do like the game is is dripping in theme through the rulebook I mean the heroes have a backstory like on the back of all of them I thought that was really neat one of the really cool things is if you win with one of the factions at the back of the rulebook there's the the origin the front of the rulebook is the whole background of why everyone's fighting in the first place but then there's the origin of these factions which is really neat but it says if you win with this faction like the humans if the humans win read this that's awesome like I think that's really cool I think a lot of games can benefit from doing that like because that kind of gives you a kind of like an epilogue like it's not like okay well I put like like oh I played the game this is what happened you don't have to try and piece together like and make up a story which is fine there's something wrong with that but I I do like the idea of that epilogue of like humans Juan this is what happens in in this world that's really cool so I mean at the end of the day like I have no interest in playing this again I don't think it's a bad game I was reading a bunch of articles cuz I'm like what the hell like but I do like I'm like I don't get it for all intensive purposes I should like this game and I'm not the only one a lot of people are
like what am I missing like what like like what why don't I like this game even though I like all these other 4x games who I mean and maybe you guys maybe you guys can be like I think this is this is Y or or you know yeah yeah maybe you can maybe you can give me some insight as to what makes you like this game or what makes you maybe agree with me and you're like now I didn't get it either but I have seen that not a lot of people are talking about this anymore I remember Tom Bassel was raving about it and they just got done with their top 100 spoilers and it wasn't on there so it's like hmm it must be a game that was kind of a flash in the pan and it's like all right well hmm I guess it doesn't really do anything intuitive so that's kind of that's kind of where I'm at cat doesn't like any of these games whether in case you're wondering and Devon did like it surprisingly but I think it's because he was doing well at the start but he actually kind of ran out of the gate running and came out of the gate running and I was like okay and then but he still was getting stopped and then all those other stuff so it was there was never a point last time we played where it was coming close to an end until it finally did like it was like oh my god just freaking someone win but I want to win just because we're competitive and so I Devin gave it a 7.5 I do not agree with that score at all but that's that's what he gave it Kant gave the 4 that was expected
because she doesn't like Forex games and I'm gonna give her the 5 so on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm going to give it a 5 I think it is an average game and but I don't I do not see myself ever like even if something like hey you wanna come play it suck now no I do not I think a 4 is a little too low and a 6 is too high so I'm kind of a it's a very solid 5 average game any expansions don't really do a whole lot it just adds more factions and there's another one that I didn't even know until I was looking it up pestilence which adds bird Fulke and merfolk but they're probably just other factions that probably layout is pretty much the same and I mean there's expansions for mercenaries which anyone can just hire and they have that mercenary but no one even touch them in the games I played there's siege towers that's or siege engines never even touch those so it's just this dancing there here's a heroes of land Aeryn see let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that is for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button is a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like
comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day it is for you