Timothy Kleinert on The Mountain Witch
Transcript
Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire and I am here to introduce to y'all Timothy Kleiner. He is a game designer and author of The Mountain Witch. Uh how you doing today, Tim or Tim? Is it Timothy or Tim?
I'm doing all uh usually just Tim.
Okay.
Of course, this is an official uh uh podcast, so I put my full name down on the uh on the screen.
Just Tim. You can call me just Tim.
I've just converted to Liz to my mother. Um, so for people who have not heard about the Mountain Witch, uh, what is this game about and how does it play? Well, the good old elevator pitch, which I've given, you know, tons over the years, is um it is a I guess now and now nowadays it's not I would still call it a short RPG, but it um not a oneshot, but a short, but it's a short RP tabletop RPG where you play uh Ronin uh Masterless Samurai, and you are all hired to climb Mount Fuji and kill the mythical mountain which lives at the top except each of the player characters carry with them a dark fate that always creates some sort of ulterior motive for why while uh why uh why why you are there. Um but beyond that the actual rules of the game of conflict resolution involve the use of trust ahead of time.
the players have to give each other these trust points which then later the other players get to decide whether they're going to help or betray you. So, it does totally uh create this big tension within the group and within, you know, all of the evilness and all of that kind of stuff.
Nice. Uh and so this game has been kind of through a long development. This is not the first edition, correct? You've had multiple editions of this game. Well, this will be the second. Uh really, there was only the first. Yeah. The um again, for the people that aren't familiar, never heard of it, uh the game was um originally created in ' 04 for the Game Chef uh design contest. Um which I think is still going, but I don't know. Um, and the idea there was to the the the premise of the game is that you had to make a full RPG in one week that used uh um a number of elements. It had to be a fantasy game that uh used the elements of ice, assault, dawn, and island um were sort of you had to somehow incorporate those themes or images or whatever, however you wanted to. Um, and so that my idea of course very I mean I I in my book I do talk about the process of how I actually came up with the game stuff but of course the idea of of Japan an island Ronin who are sort of uh both um who are alone you know socially islands you know who have to assault a mountain uh in the ice cold um top at the top icy top of Mount Fuji um and all of that. Um, anyway, so that's uh uh that's why the
game came about. Um, I'm sorry, what was your question though again?
Oh, I wanted to know about train thought.
No, it's all good. I wanted to know about about its development process. So, that's actually perfect. Um, because you know, how do you go from game jam to publishable game?
Um, yeah, that's a good question. I I will so I'll say that this is my second that that the mountain which was actually my second um a couple years prior to that um I helped a friend expand a 10page RPG to a 100page RPG but I laugh now. You know we uh the term came up that that it was really just a heartbreaker. It was basically just emulating uh Dn D, but we had like instead of, you know, whatever four, six, eight classes, we had like 20s something classes and they all had their own charts for for like how to level up and they all had their own abilities. We just like made this huge uh collection of things that um you know, we had a lot of fun. I mean looking back you know um the way I I eventually got into uh got involved with the website the forge which is where um the indie RPG movement sort of began and where the mountain witch was made. Um me and my friends thought that maybe it would be really great if we tried to publish that that Heartbreaker game. Um, but of course after after actually getting into online discussions about game design and all of that, uh, you know, I realized that that wasn't a true like game. Not a game, but I realized it was this heartbreaker that I really was just trying to make another DND rather
than actually designing a new game. Um um but um I'm still trying to think like how how did the game development thing happened? Um you know it's tricky. So um on one level I did a lot of things at that point actually very instinctual. Um I was sort of like starting to have different uh um after after joining the forge. Um you know we had all these discussions about different styles of play. you know, back then it was sort of prior to that there was sort of assumed in the mainstream that there was sort of one way to play an RPG, but at the Forge, you know, the idea um of of um back in the day we called it the GNS, either gameism or narrativism or simulationism. This idea that there are multiple types of games that have different purposes and that players get different things out of it. And um after getting involved with the forge, I did realize how interested I was in the narrative sense of actually creating a real story. And even eventually it came more to I think about RPGing now much at least my style as being much more about improvisational storytelling.
Um and the mountain really really does that. I think one of the reason it reasons it is so good is because it really is made um in it's it's made to inspire play. It's not about you're playing some competitive game and you got to follow the rules in order to win, but really what the rules do is um inspire the creativity within the players. and it does sort of direct the that those ideas and the direction of the story in certain ways.
So, um, now we're, you know, you had a first edition that came out,
uh, and then you had a second edition that was coming out, uh, but it did not happen and now it's coming out through CGS. So, let's kind of walk through that. Uh, what was going to change between first and second edition of this game?
Yeah. Well, let me real quick say too, um, so the game when when they when the game was made for the, uh, um, for that contest, um, it very quickly got a lot of attention at the forge and it actually did get quite a lot of play testing compared to other people. Um but the the hard part is uh or in retrospect the hard part is that at the forge everyone was a part of this big discussion. A lot of people had very similar gaming experience. So they very much understood what I was trying to communicate in the text. Um, so, uh, uh, so when I published the game, I thought that it was well written, but it was only when it went out into the public, um, and non-FGorge members started playing the game did the did the big questions come up. Um, and I always I have to admit I have to admit like the big one the big question is I realized in the book itself I didn't even talk about the um the ambiguity of the mountain witch themselves. See so part of it so like stereotypically this is the way the game works is it starts off it appears just like this standard sort of fantasy adventure. you guys come together and meet. Um, or you start off, it's like you you the game starts off right after you've met for the first time and you fight your way, you know,
through the haunted forest and you start to climb and it is this thing where you're like working together and you're killing all of these monsters, but then suddenly you hit the castle at the top of Mount Fuji that the m that the mountain witch is running and suddenly like I always like used to tell this this stereotypical thing like you fight up and you get to the gates of the castle and then suddenly ly it opens up and this very kindly fancydressed woman comes out and says, "Oh, I apologize for our servants. We didn't mean to harm you on your way up. Please come in. Come with me. Let let me give you dinner or whatever." And it's like all of a sudden you get you you get up there and the witch and his servants actually are trying to lure you into joining them, you know. And also the issue with this uh with these dark fates um the dark fates themselves so they're sort of outline they're not outlined like there's an idea the six faith there are six fates you could get you could have uh you've made a deal with the witch or uh or a past allegiance. Someone you know from the past is going to come and ask you to uh repay an old favor. And of course one of the popular ones is you want actually are there to get revenge on one of the other Ronin. Um, so the idea is that like the game looks very uh uh black and white or the morals of the game look black and white as you are fighting all these monsters and climbing up the mountain, but then you get to the top and everything turns gray. It
actually turns into well, who really is good and who really is bad? Because you are, you know, these sam you are these samurai who want to be um loyal, but then you realize you're Ronin. You have no you have no master and the government themselves treat you like a nobody. You're as low as you know they treat you as low as you can be. Are they actually the people that are willing that you should serve or is it better to actually join this this witch who is willing to actually give you whatever it is that you want? And one of the points in the I um when I when when I went back and actually sort of wrote this like couple page little essay or whatever about the the uh ambiguity of the witch is I say the witch will never break his promise.
If the GM says says that the witch is going to do this thing, you know for sure he's actually or they I should say they are absolutely going to do the thing that they said they would, you know. Um, so that was like the big one. Like all of those discussions I'd had at the forge, they all understood to create that uh drama tension, the witch needed to be um uh uh not obviously evil, but sort of that either um he had to be somewhere in the middle.
Yeah.
Or um and also at the same time, you start off thinking that the government is good and Japan is what you're trying to save, but then it's like really is Japan actually being good? is the country actually being good to these Ronin, you know, and everything gets blurry and that's why and then in the end every even though the characters are all working together in the beginning, they all decide on their own individually like who are they going to side with and who are they going to help and who are they going to turn against?
Nice. So, the second edition, I suppose, was going to address
I keep getting distracted by all of these other uh uh um little rants of mine.
Yeah. So, well, so what happened is so I wrote this book and also part of, you know, it's like when you actually make a game or a tabletop game like that,
half of the game is or half of the project is the actual um development, the game, the rules development, and really the other half is writing a book. And you got to know how to express certain ideas. Uh you got to know what is it that needs to be said versus what doesn't need to be said. And of course that was my first real book that I had written, game book that I'd written. So um I I very quickly realized I needed to go back and sort of revise and add a couple details here and there. Um, and in the very beginning I thought it would basically be the same book, um, just tweaked, you know, but as time went on, um, more and more it was like, um, I learned more about how do people actually play the game. Obviously, I wrote the game, um, assuming a certain, uh, style of play, but of course you actually get it out in the public and people sort of add their own little tweaks here and there, and they add their sort of house rules here and there.
So, for this second edition here, um that eventually that I eventually finished, they um the the big thing is I I've rewritten the book towards how people actually play the game is sort of the big one.
Yeah.
Um following that, I've added in tons of house rules. They're all optional rules. Um, like for example, one of these house rules is like uh the Ronin uh you start the game, you all have a zodiac sign and you all have a unique one and you know the different zodiacs sort of interact with each other differently. Some of them really come together and some sort of push each other apart. So at the very least the zodiac that your characters get creates that initial social network of who likes who and who doesn't, right? But um so like one of the house rules uh that someone came up with was how about you also give um zodiac signs to some of the major uh um NPCs, you know, some of these spirits or demons or whatever that you're talking to because then again that creates more immediately creates a certain amount of drama because what if this demon guy suddenly likes this person over here but hates this is constantly going against this person sort of over there, you know, or what if there's even some sort of tension between these these NPCs within um within the w rich's witch's castle.
Um so it's that kind of stuff. So it was um playing writing. So I rewrote the book to describe how people actually play and the issues that come up. Um I did these added all these house rules. Um and then there were a couple rules that that that I that I changed or tweaked. Um, I don't want to say like the game is still fundamentally all the same. Um, but like um, one of them is is um, one of them is about so so uh, the idea is it can the character be killed? And the answer is yes. And that is definitely a tension you want in the game. And I did actually create these rules uh where um even when a character is killed, the other PCs can still keep a relationship with that character that a pseudo relationship so that the other player, the player of the dead character can sort of remain in the game and influence play, right? Um, but it is like and that makes a lot of sense in the end of the game, you know, like uh definitely I've seen sort of where like one character killed another, but then when that the living character um the betraying character that killed the other, like when they finally go to to fight whoever in the end, the guy they killed of course wants to betray them and act against them. Like that definitely adds this fun dramatic
element of when these sort of, you know, dead characters can still spend their trust points to affect how conflicts run out, you know, but it is awkward if someone were to die early in the game. And there was a couple times where that possibility came up when I was GMing and I just sort of as a GM I knew that would not be the funnest thing. So I did I would sort of split the success rather than just coming down on one person uh and killing them. Um so one of the rules I changed is just that the characters um aren't um uh they can't be killed until they've actually revealed their dark fate. Um, and I guess that was something else about the dark fates is um I was saying the players do create what they are but in the beginning it is a secret. The cards uh uh the the cards for the dark fates get revealed um uh they are uh um dealt privately so that only the player not even the GM but only the player actually knows what fate they have. And then the players have uh through the first half or so uh they have the ability to sort of add in details that sort of for either foreshadow what their fate is or is somehow connected because like if a player um like I mentioned before the um
I if a um if a old if an old friend is coming in uh to ask for an old favor, you could you know like when you get out of the forest and you're at the bottom of Mount Fuji that you could add this factor where like oh deep, you know, as you're like uh sneaking around trying to find, you know, like sneaking away around, you actually see this troop of soldiers off in the distance or up the mountain who are already climbing up in front of you. Like the player is allowed to add that there are these other troops that are climbing. And then of course you get up to the top into the castle and the player reveals that he used to be part of this clan, this one particular clan and his all these soldiers were his old friends, you know, and they want to ask him to uh they've become some sort of rebellion or they're a part of a clan that is uh fighting the central government, you know, and they ask and they ask the player or that character to join them. Um so that kind of stuff. Um um sorry I just faced you.
So it's it's clear the second edition like adds a lot to the first one. So it's the same core game with a lot of optional rules rewritten so that it'll be more playable and more accessible. But um yeah
that version of the game never came out which we're going to get to. But people who are backing
the current project which is part of a a package of RPGs with uh Central Michigan University, what are they getting um compared to what you had intended to put out with uh with version two?
Well, I mean they are going to um I mean the the they are going to get a printed edition of the new book. Um, as I explained to them in in a message before, like at the time of the Kickstarter, uh, the book really was, I would say, 97 or 98% done. And I did send the book out to other um other, uh, designer friends to review. And, um, um, but what happened, I guess we might as well get into what happened with the Kickstarter. Of course, that is a big part of all of this. Um what happened is um when I sent the uh when I when I sent this new edition out to get reviewed or um um there there were a couple concerns that came up. one was about how the book was written and part of that was how I, you know, um am somewhat of an old-fashioned Forge Forge player. Like that is still all very much in my mind when I play, but that newer uh newer um players don't necessarily have all of that same sort of experience that that I had. And so I had to be really more careful about how things were being explained because I it might again have been like how I was um just making certain assumptions. Um
and um and the other thing was with the one big rule that um they had concern about is is in character. So a character I mean characters are very simple. The rules of the game in general are very simple but the characters basically they have the dark fate, they have a zodiac, they have um they do answer these two background questions and then they have abilities. Um they have two or three abilities. Um, and in the in the original book, um, the abilities were just whatever you wanted. You could just say whatever you wanted and you'd write them down. And it's interesting that sound like on paper that is so simple, but really in practice, it'd be like you'd be this like uh character creation be like bam bam bam uh you know, like what what should I have?
like it it suddenly slowed everything down.
And also it ended up being like half of the things people came up with really didn't have a purpose. They might have added color,
you know, uh to to the to the game and to who their character was, but it really was sort of pointless of what these abilities were. So, the idea I came up with was to actually have a list of abilities to um that both make things quicker and it would actually create purposes for what the abilities were. And the original um in that draft for the Kickstarter, the thing that I had done is the abilities I had made up were kind of fantastic or fantasy, I should say.
You know, they were the kinds of stuff you'd expect in anime or in kung fu films or whatever. And my friends both were like, you know, like these like how does this actually fit into the game? It's like you're trying to play like this like dark um very serious, dramatically serious game and yet you're willing to, you know, like let them fly or pass through walls or, you know, like have flaming swords or whatever. Um and I was like, "Yeah, you're right." you know, and um but it was like I I was having trouble like so, you know, the whole idea like having to rewrite what I thought was already done and then also having to rethink this sort of big idea. Um, I just had all of this difficulty uh doing that for some reason and that slowed everything down and then people started asking why things were slowing down so much. And um I just started freezing up.
Um, and here though I have to bring up uh if you don't guys don't know, I mean my um Kickstarter backers do, but actually I had undiagnosed brain cancer. Um, and that was definitely present. Um, it had um, you know, of course there's no way to know exactly when it came up, but I have, you know, even in retrospect, I was starting to have weird emotional and and mental Well, not mental issues, but you know, like um my emotions and the way that I reacted to things were starting to change.
And looking back now, it was like I I didn't know what was going on. I didn't know my I hadn't learned to process what had happened or how to deal with all of that kind of stuff. And um and even still, it's it's you know, when I started to freeze up in response to to those questions, which were legit questions, I just like I just froze. I I can't even still to this day cannot fully explain how I felt or why I just, you know, froze up like that. But um I admit I I just kind of ran away. I didn't tell anyone what was going on. And of course that was before I had the cancer and everything but but still when I was having this these difficulties uh I just sort of ran away and didn't talk to anyone about what was happening. Um and even then and and you know um even when though that initial period that's probably ended up being like the first year I couldn't get it over it. I couldn't settle down. I couldn't get back like I couldn't even think about the mountain witch. I had to push like everything off to the side
that concerned gaming
for whatever reason. Even uh when I calmed down with all that, it just for some reason at that time I just could never think of new ideas. You know, again, it was like my thinking was a was starting to change a little bit or at least the way that my brain was working was changing a little bit. Um um and so there was a uh uh the Kickstarter did end up stopping and there did come a time so there I did reach this point where I thought like the good thing to do would actually be to save up the money and pay people back. Um, but that's when uh basically this is all the short version. That's when I ended up having these seizures in in connection to my uh cancer and I ended up in the hospital. And of course going through all of that kind of stuff. Um I mean I'll save that for I'll save that for for another time. But obviously I I'm sure you all can imagine how hard and how difficult it is. I mean you see people go through that kind of stuff and it looks bad. than when you're the actual person that's sitting there. I mean, it is so much worse. It's so hard, you know. Um, and of course, you know, the money, like, you know, before my diagnosis, I still had the majority of the money. I still had plenty of money for the printing and all of that kind of stuff.
Um, but of course, you know, I I wasn't working and it was sort of like uh to help out the family, we did end up having to dig out and pretty much spend all of that money that was from the Kickstarter in order to make it through that like year and a half or two years of treatment. Um, well, a year and a half of treatment, but probably two or two and a half years before I sort of really got back into sort of a semi-normal life after that. Um, but that's where uh that's where that's where the Central Michigan uh University Press or um came in. And I I really have to thank them. Um and I really am not just sort of advertising for them. You know, it really is like I after I sort of got back into a normal life again, you know, I really did feel um for my backers. you know, it is um you know, again, it's it's after after getting diagnosed with cancer, knowing that you only have a certain amount of time left to live, money really isn't a big deal.
At least to me personally. I mean, of course, I my family needs the money, but I myself don't care, you know. Um, so I did my best. Actually, I cleaned up the text that I had for the mountain witch. And I actually did, it's interesting, you know, the last couple years, I actually felt more I feel more creative than I did, you know, in the past. So, I did at least for the ability for the um or the rules about those uh character abilities. Um I actually was able uh um I do have to thank Ron Edwards for this who wrote Sorcerer. He did make the suggestion that u I just make much more um like practical abilities like that a normal person would have. And that did lead me to what the new rule is in the book is is you have these two uh normal abilities that are very common. Those come on a those come from a list in the book. You know, there's stuff like obviously like you have armor, you have a bow and arrow, you you know how to hide and sell, you know, and and sneak around. Um those aren't the actual names, but you know, you have all those kinds of stuff. But then also if in connection with your dark fate, if you do want to have some sort of special ability that is totally made up by you, you're allowed to claim one of those as well. So, um yeah, so I cleaned up the text. I actually did I feel like I solved that issue with with with that uh with those rules there. Um and I do think like uh you know,
cleaning up you like I said, I actually could do kind of feel more creative now. Maybe I just know how to process things now and I've learned to deal deal with sort of what the cancer has done to my brain. Um but the book is a lot better now uh written than it was you know back actually during the time of the Kickstarter.
Yeah.
Um but again keep going off into rants uh with uh with the Central Michigan uh press. Um, so the point was is is, you know, after my diagnosis and all that, like I didn't have the money for actual printing and I really did feel really bad about that. I really did wish I could still somehow give the money back. Um, so I cleaned up the text and I sent out actually it was on January 7th of this year. Uh, um, did I say seven? 2, January the 2nd of this year. uh I sent out a you know the new book uh well not the book but a PDF of the new book um and apologized and really explain finally after all these years I had explained what had happened and you know what was going on with me and all of that. Um, and then later too, a couple months later, like just finishing the uh finishing up and thinning out um the mountain, which I I got the urge also like, oh, I should just reformat uh the other the uh um not companion, the supplementary book, uh Quaidon, um which um for those that don't know, you know, Quaidon actually it's not a book I wrote, but it's a collection of ghost stories. Uh there was this uh man of Hearn um he was European and he became this world reporter in the late 1800s and he went in Japan. I forget why but he like fell in love with the place. He
became a citizen and he got married. Um he was adopted into a family so that he could be considered a real um a Japanese person um or citizen. Um, but he continued to sort of record down actual sort of myths and ls and ghost stories and all of that kind of stuff. Um, so what I did was I took a few of his books and I selected stories from those books um, from his books and I, you know, compiled them into this uh, into a supplementary text for the mountain witch. Um, so I did that as well. And anyway, and then it was after that that I was approached by Timothy Hutchkins from uh from the Central uh Michigan Press. And um, you know, I say I'm so thankful. Um, they really were the ones that came to me and when I really did discuss my primary concern wasn't about money. It really was like I wanted some way to get the book back out to the backers, to the Kickstarter backers. They were totally with me. They totally understood. Um, they actually even were more giving than I was expecting them to. I just asked them to sort of have a lower price for uh for the backers and they actually said we'll do it totally at cost or we'll find some way. We'll find the best way to like get as get the price as low as we can which was that was even more than what I was expecting. You know, they really have been great to work with and they really do have a heart. they
understand um that this isn't just about making money and and all of that kind of stuff.
Nice. Obviously, they're my friends, so I too am biased. Um but uh I guess this kind of leads me to a final question then, which is um you know, what does your gaming life look like now, both as a gamer and as a as a creator, and how do you see that developing?
I had a feeling you'd ask that. Uh, you know, I don't play that much. Not because I don't want to, just, you know, the way life has run. Um, it was, of course, it was a lot easier before I have children, but now, you know, these last several years, I have children, so I have less time. Uh, and a lot of the friends that I used to play with him have uh moved away. So, you know, um, I don't play that much. I hate to say I I I've been toying with I did have this other idea which I've actually mentioned a couple times o over the years. It's like it's not a new idea. It's an idea that's been with me for a long time which uh shortly I'll just say it is cardbased and it does use a um a sort of madeup tarot deck. I'll say it that way. And it's sort of like it's a it's the the meaning of the cards um it's a fantasy game. I should say that right. But it's you the meaning of the cards themselves get developed through play. They they'll start off with these words that you write down. Uh but then as you play you will change the words and add the words and name these cards as you play. Um, and the the the desire there is to create a game that inspires you rather than having all these mechanics that tell you yes or no, but having more a game that really is about giving you um well, again, inspiration,
giving you these thoughts, these feelings, these pictures, and then thinking of like letting that be where you jump off of Um so that's but I call it in a land called you know dot dot dot is is the name of this. Um but yeah I have mentioned that in the past originally the idea was to it was to emulate a Final Fantasy game. Um, but the uh over time the the idea was like what is the Final Fantasy world? And it was really that it the Final Fantasy games have these images or these symbols or objects or characters that get repeated from game to game even though the world itself is different. And that's one of the things that led me into this idea of you're creating these symbols or images or metaphors that become the inspiration for for your game for your for your play. I mean, um, but who knows? I don't want to pretend like I'm immediately trying to restart my own my, uh, my own game making and everything. Um, but that was an old idea that, um, again, you know, the last, you know, over the last year or so, I started to get new ideas for for how it may or may not work.
Well, we'll see what the future brings. And then just one more question. Um, you know, if people want to kind of follow you and your work, uh, is there a place where you can currently be found online or are you not a social media guy right now?
Uh, right now I'm not a social media guy. Um, you know, again, you know, with the Kickstarter and the running away, I totally sort of left the scene. And so honestly, I'm even kind of I'm not even sure where all of this the centers uh um where all the centers are for different both game play and game development and all of that kind of stuff these days. I got to admit that I'm out of the loop. Ah, that's all good. Uh but uh any any last things you want to say to people who are either um former Kickstarter backers or people who are thinking about uh backing this game on backer kit? Um yeah, I'm I'm well again uh you know I it's the guilt of I still feel a guilt about the Kickstarter. So of course I want to say I'm sorry, you know. Um but again uh you know for for uh this new series that the Central Michigan Press is starting you know they aren't just trying to make money. They really are trying to uh both bring um game design and tabletop role playing into sort of the academic space.
you know, they're trying to emphasize um you know, how uh um significant certain games are and which games are actually trying to sort of move things forward and everything. Um again, they're not being this isn't just about a business. They really are trying to do a good thing. Um and um again that's why I feel really appreciated that they invited me to join into uh into the I think it's the art and system series is what they're is what they're calling it.
It is uh Tim. Thank you so much for coming on. It's been wonderful to talk to you and uh I really wish the best for you for your health and also for this project and future ones.
All right. Thank you very much. I really do appreciate being able to come back and talk on a on an iPod or anything. All right, everybody out there. Please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, check out the backer kit, and uh most of all, happy gaming.