Skip to main content
Loading video...

Commander Stats with EDHRec | The Command Zone 61

Transcript 1:13:56

greetings humans you have entered the command Zone your destination for all aspects of Elder Dragon Highlander enjoy your stay music music music music we're starting the show we're starting the show hey everybody my name is Jimmy Wong and you are listening to the command Zone oh yes oh crap how's it it's Josh Lee it's only it's like the second or third time we've done this so we're not very good at it yet Josh I this is actually a solo show so you're not oh sorry it's just me I got fired could you imagine if I had to do a show for 60 minutes by myself you know uh Marshall unlimited resources there's one episode all right where it's the it was supposed to be the first John L episode and L like didn't show up or something and Marshall had to do that episode by himself and uh I'd never heard I'd never listened to it but recently uh Marshall mentioned it in one of of his episodes and I was like you know because we've been doing the podcast I was like I need to go listen to that because that would be so hard to do I would just be intimidated any blank space you're like and onto the next there's nobody to pick him up at any time or to move him on or to like quip in or anything and it's very interesting uh being a podcaster now listening to him do that and just like thinking like man that is so tough to do um yeah well big big props to doing that we plan to never do that with the show uh in fact we plan on welcoming as many guests as we can Jimmy if you're not here H I won't do the show by myself

there just won't be a show that week it would just end up by the end we're just talking about something completely not magic related it's like you're stranded in the in the desert you've just gone insane um but we do have a guest on today we are going to be talking about Commander statistics with the creator of edhrec.com if any of you guys are Reddit users you've definitely seen this bot pop up and around and we're going to be talking a lot more about that but before before that all gets started we have a surprise surprise surprise surprise surprise giveaway this is our first surprise giveaway we always premeditate them You' think we' do more surprises in general yeah because I'm we're all about surprises but well this may set a trend we may start doing surprise we cast an instant surprise prize giveaway uh the up it's one of those that cost nothing in the upkeep is you have to pay the postage to send the prize out so um we are going to give a prize away to a random iTunes reviewer oo nice so we're going to give a prize to gsman 73 gsman 73 congratulations you didn't even know you entered to win a prize but you just won one but you just won one so gsman you need to email us email us at command cast rocket jump.com we just grabbed a couple of random boosters we're going to throw them in the mail as soon as we know where to send it yeah and uh gsman was an iTunes reviewer so he was went on iTunes and left us a review uh which you guys can do as well we're not saying you're going to potentially win a prize we're be you could potentially win that's right you could potentially we have to keep it as vague as possible uh yes and by the way when the

by the time you guys are hearing this episode magic Origins is going to be fully spoiled so we're going to have a full review of that next week if you guys missed our spoiler episode last week very exciting we got to spoil a card called the Great Aurora it was super sweet and we talked about all five of the legendary Plaines Walkers and their viability in the 99 or as a commander of your EDH deck and don't worry we are going to do a full magic Origins set review yeah well not a full set review we won't review every card oh my gosh we'll leave that to Marshall yeah but we will do an EDH set review so just the EDH uh viable cards uh but that'll come out next week and these I I look forward to these episodes probably the most yeah they are super fun to do um they're very popular and they're hard on my wallet that's they are it's it sort of makes you as a player go through each card and think about them yeah and I always Miss stuff too which is great because you know you guys the viewers tweet at us or comment on the uh on the YouTube site or on Rocket Jump and tell stuff and that's always great to hear as well yeah it's great to sort of get the Brain Trust which is all our listeners on it so it's like we give our initial Impressions but we're basically seeing the cards you know not for the very first time all of them but but we haven't thought about it a ton and so you know there's a whole bunch of interactions people always throw at us where you're like oh yeah think that or just like yeah totally yeah totally thought of that just decided not to say it which is though the Brain Trust I like the term for that which is our Collective audience base which has a vast amount of EDH knowledge amongst them all which is great I was going to say hive mind but most a lot of people don't like that card so I didn't want to

you yeah I want it reminds me of the Zerg a little bit so which is not Magic the Gathering at all um anyway those are our announcements that's the upkeep set we're going to move on to our main topic Super Swift here guys we are talking Commander statistics with the creator of edhrec.com thank you so much for being on the show Donald Miner thanks guys I'm really happy to be here here and talk about some of this data um yes so I really want to talk about like how blown my mind is right now about Origins like before we talk about it what we're supposed to be talking about I'm just like I I I can't even like handle myself right now um but but yeah anyways some it does it does seem like Origins is more geared toward EDH than maybe any set since we started the show for sure I think it's more EDH than the commander product yeah that's it's interesting it could be it could be well I mean I just love what Wizards is done in general because they know I mean like it's a big set so they're allowed to put some crazy cards at Mythic that don't necessarily have to affect standard or whatever and uh it's going to be hard for me too because people are going to be making a ton of decks they're going to be uh trying all kinds of new cards flip cards are really hard for me to handle technology wise so oh interesting they're really going to stick it to you then Don um well for those for those people that don't know do you want to explain what edhrec.com is sure so EDH Rex basically stands for EDH recommendations it's pretty clever of a name um it it basically what it does is it takes a look at uh commander deck

lists and from all all over the place different people different places and puts all this data into one place and then you can plug in your deck so you can find out different information about uh different commanders or your deck and and it basically provides you a way to look at different cards so un for um well fortunately and unfortunately unfortunately for me as a engineer there's 15,000 unique uh magic cards about yeah this game has been around for a while hasn't it yeah yeah so so it basically provides a tool for slogging through all this data and figuring out what cards you should be playing that's cool it's super cool um if you haven't visited this site you can do things like put in a color combination and then it'll tell you sort of percentage wise what the most played commanders in those colors are and then you can click on one of those commanders and you can see what the most played cards uh in those decks are you know Don where does all the data come from like where do you get the deck list and everything yeah so when I first started it was only a Reddit a Reddit bot before it was a website as well and when it first started what it did was it looked for Tapped Out links in um in Reddit post and then I would go scrape the Tapped Out website uh scraping in a very um bad way like I I hit the website three times to do different things and um essentially like slightly dsing it yeah no no give you some traffic I I most definitely was and uh actually Tapped Out Bann me uh they banned my IP

at one point and uh I had an email hit him too often yeah yeah yeah what is this guy doing mining all this information it's useless right yep so I I contacted them and we ended up working out an arrangement where uh I so we Tapped Out deck stats and a couple of other sources I actually have agreements with the web Masters where they provide me a a standard way for me to pull data from their website once a request is made but I but I only pull Decks that are instigated by somebody trying to get recommendations from a deck so when you go to the website and plug in a deck I basically go take that deck and then I store it um and and then it's there forever so so that's that's basically where the decks come from and I've got 24,000 decks as of uh today so there's more decks than cards and Magic right yeah yeah so you got 24 decks or 24,000 decks if and I've been in uh business per se for a year that's about 65 decks per day wow and that's a grand total of about 2.4 million cards right because each of those decks has 100 cards yeah yeah not all necessarily unique but yeah that's amazing so you have a giant database of data um and it it filters all into EDH wck correct yep yep so it's it's actually in terms of what I do for my day job it's not that much data but um it it is it is a decent amount and uh but I have it implemented in a way that it's basically when you're plugging in a recommendation it's pretty much slogging through just about every other deck that exists of those 24,000 decks um to to

pull out the recommendations wow what is your day job by the way if you don't mind yeah yeah so so I so I do uh data analysis for like large so for for like large Fortune 50 companies um so uh yeah so so so mostly I'm doing boring things like uh detecting fraud or um like I don't know uh there's not much fraud in EDH deck analysis gu no one's putting up like f there's a lot of fraud in EDH play though as in like people forgetting how a card works so actually a lot of the stuff I do in edre is um like standard techniques that I use every day at work uh particularly uses these algor the same algorithms that are used for recommendation engines on websites like Amazon for example so so so uh a lot of the same techniques that I use for recommending EDH cards are used in uh in Amazon or other stores things like that which which it actually surprisingly worked very well I was actually kind of surprised it worked one of the first time I ran it that's really cool now I'm assuming because you took the time to do this website and everything on your own um that you're a big EDH player about how many uh EDH decks do you have Don 24,000 he has all of them I I many do you yeah so I play EDH a lot I only have four decks um and I think the reason for that is I'm a bit of a perfectionist so mhm I I get kind of frustrated when I can't put manac Crypt in all of my decks join the club yeah I get frustrated too except for that I don't actually own one yeah so actually you're you're avoid you

can avoid that entirely no no I'm just always frustrated especially when you get played against to you're like I could have been I'm actually being uh a bit smart but I I only have two Mana Crypts yeah do you actually take them out physically and put them in the other decks you you proxy what you do no I just I just deal with it and my other two decks don't have that's how I do it too I'm not a big switch out it just takes too long too much time yeah exactly yeah yeah no yeah yeah so so yeah just got to keep buying those dual lands and um yeah slowly increase the uh the the the power creep of your deck slowly goes up over time yeah and and also I stick with the same decks for a long time so I the main deck that I've been playing which is a five-color enchanters deck I've been playing since shards of arara wow yeah yeah so so I stick with the same deck for usually about a year I I kind of really narrow in on one so I I'm definitely more of a low number of decks but I play the same deck a lot right now do I'm assuming you use your website to tune those decks to you know the that yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah absolutely and uh I can cheat also because if I want to answer a question that the website doesn't answer I can just go like manually C the data um you're you are like the the most elite like beta user of your where you get to test out all the new features cuz you're the one coming up with them yeah yeah that's pretty great so I imagine this must be a pretty busy time for you how does it work when you have a new set coming in like Origins do you have to wait until the set like can you can you start doing it from spoilers or yeah so the there's a there's a

couple of problems with new sets so the first one is that for one of the new sets I think it was um I think it was like M14 I tried adding cards as they were getting spoiled and this ended up screwing up things because like people that create decks early they may pick a commander let's say that was spoiled early but won't use the cards that have been spoiled in the deck um so you get like a weird statistical bias yeah so so what I decided to do was um just basically I usually wait about a week after the set has been completely released which um stops a lot of the influx of like brand new decks people just brewing just out of you know just out of nowhere and and so I wait about a week week and then I do this bulk import of um of the the card data basically and then that's actually pretty easy process but I it is manual but it takes only about like 20 minutes and then um so the big problem is new problems that and appear in uh in every set there's something weird that happens so um one common thing so for example the one that's going to really mess me up here is two- faced commanders here um yeah yeah so I'm going to have to I yeah you know we'll see how that how this one ends up some new lines of code I'm guessing figure that out yep and then and then every now and then there's like a card that has a special character in it that hasn't been there before that messes me up so so usually it's I push the data live but then I'm always kind of nervous for about a day or two to see if something breaks um but but other

than that it's not that bad uh gatherer gets updated pretty fast so um so so I pull the data from that so it's it's really not that that big of a deal interesting well yeah wizard definitely tries to get it up on gatherer very quickly now um it's definitely one of their priorities yeah there's so many websites and dealing with it that it's just you know to have one Central Hub to where you can go how long does it take I mean I'm assuming when a new set comes out there's a big influx of decks uh based on the new cards um right like I can see a lot of decks being based on these new command yeah when do you have any any numbers um as far as like how many new decks come out out like in the early part like in the next couple of weeks basically like like out of the 65 a day yeah yep yep so it definitely spikes and it's been weird because it's I actually tried running these stats before and I wasn't able to get like a good answer because one of the problems is that every set seems to have a different Commander strength to it is I guess the best way to say so like some sets are so for example the con sets have been very Commander heavy you know there's a lot of legendary creatures um so there's been a lot of Brewing going on so I definitely saw some things there but for example when uh M14 came out was like pretty timid um so I I guess it kind of depends but yeah I I'll see a spike of maybe uh 10 to 15x number of decks than what I usually see that kind of first week oh wow 10 times more than normal wow that's a lot what do you know

what the average amount of decks you're adding every week is uh it it's right now it's about it comes out to about like uh about five 400 about 400 a week so you're going to see 4,000 new decks potentially in the next few weeks holy moly uh so that that's an overall no it's not going to be 4,000 I it's it's really like 10 times as much maybe in the first couple days maybe yeah so so I'll probably see like maybe 500 or so decks um oh the the other data source that I didn't mention earlier as well is uh I scrape all of MTG salvation as well so any deck list that gets posted in MTG salvation I'm also pulling as well so that Forum also gets a lot of influx of uh of Commander deex when they come out as well basically you're you're scraping like every popular EDH yep site I mean those are the top ones that you've named so yeah I wouldn't be surprised if you capture the majority of deck list posts online because these are the biggest websites that they usually go to I I mean I don't see too many people just posting random lists in random places unless it's a big form or unless they're emailing them to us yeah well well actually that's an interesting point so one of the things so I have 24,000 decks but that's the only the ones I keep I actually delete a number of decks so if somebody plays an illegal card in a deck let's say they play like a hybrid Mana symbol in a deck they shouldn't be playing I actually delete the deck because it's almost like a sign of incompetence from the user so so so I

don't want to have like you have quality control those your outliers right right right or so if somebody plays like an illegal Commander or they play like uh you know card they shouldn't be playing or prime eval Titan or something yeah exactly so so I actually prune a lot of the decks as well interesting well here's a question we had written down an interest a really interesting one is there a bias that you've seen towards like cheaper cards versus like better cards that are that are more uh expensive like how realistic are the deck lists uh very realistic actually this is a big problem because well it's like a I guess a first World Magic the Gathering problem for me but uh like for example I I mean I'm not going to lie I was kind of joking about the Mana cryts but like you know and I actually really enjoyed your uh your two most recent podcasts here um the high rollers High rolling yeah yeah so so like for example um finding recommendations for like really highend decks is actually kind of the recommendations aren't as good because not everybody's playing Moe right so let's say that I did have like a $1,000 to spend on my EDH deck and I was doing recommendations there's not many people playing Mo so Mo doesn't show up probably when it should if you weren't thinking about cost so there's definitely right because a lot of deck lists that are posted they would put mode in there but they just know they can't have it does it do the same thing with the Dual lands yep uh absolutely well well dual lands actually there are a lot of dual lands in in the eh EDH de

I think um I I guess I I don't know I just see them a lot um they are not necessarily as big of a problem as I would say like moat Tabernacle uh things like that um right just the big money spender cards but the the one interesting thing that does happen though is that uh the recommendation engine it doesn't really like look at the card itself like it doesn't know that Elvish mtic is the same thing as L War elves for example um all it knows is that these decks are played or the cards are played together so one one thing that interesting happens is if you put like Tabernacle OTE and like Grim Tor in a deck it'll recommend other really expensive cards because the same people that are playing those cards are playing the other really expensive cards gotta so that's a way to find those cards but you just sort of have to trick it almost yeah exactly so like five color decks for example if you put in a deck list with like 10 the 10 original Dual lands in it you'll get like a much less budget version of recommendations than if you were playing like gild Gates interesting that's really interesting to know cuz it's correlating what those other cards are being played with so if you put in four guildgates it's saying oh the with four guildgates are budget deck so I'm not going to yeah that that's that's cool that's really cool well let's just dive into the stats here I think there's a lot of interesting stuff that uh people will be interested to hear um Josh and I are going to try and guess uh some of the answers to these questions this is going to be tough yeah it is going to be tough

um and also just before we dive in it's important to note that there are a lot of decks that exist outside of the internet yep because not not everyone is necessarily going to tap down sub posting all this stuff but I don't know how much variance we're going to get off of that but I feel like these statistics I would assume yeah he's got a so much data go I think I think they're in my opinion I mean it's hard for me to tell I definitely think there is a bias towards the deck list that I have versus the deck list that I see when I go to my local game store so for example the the most common commanders I won't spoil it for you yet but I don't really see them that often in the wild to be honest like interesting uh I mean I see them probably more often than I see other decks but it's not like I'm seeing them in every pod you know so right or as heavily as it as it's favored in statistics and also too the other thing too is that I believe that a lot of my users are MTG users which which is I think like the Decks that people are building for mtgo versus like Decks that I'm playing in person there's also some bias and change in there as well so I think I think there's a lot of um variation too based on the fact that I think there's more mtgo users Brewing right now yeah it's I think it's easier to brew an MTG as well because you can have one copy of a card across all your decks instead of having you know five Mana cryts or whatever it would also I mean I don't know if this is true but my instinct would be that they would be a little bit more spiky um a little bit more tuned up on it's easier to tune on mtgo it's easier to just sort of do mean things and not worry about repercussions yeah so you know so so it seems like it would be anyway y all right well let's dive in here um we're going to start

with what are the most popular commanders should just do the top five yeah okay but we're just going to guess one each you go first Josh um well I have dabbled lately in a little bit of data collection because we've been doing the deck doctors Series right and so I've been actually writing down and keeping track of uh the submissions and just what um what Commander they are so I'm going to guess we have three that are our top right now it's uh it's naret mimeoplasm and and crap I'm forgetting the the third one but I'm going to say well let me ask you something Don really quick before I answer oh jeez just you're minding as much information as the data is the data biased towards um commanders that have been around for longer because that seems like it would be like oh this Commander's just existed for longer so it would have more decks it it is biased yes okay then I am going to say mimeoplasm I'm going to say kador ghost Chieftain Okay so M plasma is at 11 oh wow and Carro door is at 2 yes a round of applause for J our listeners are not representative of that well okay so so actually the one interesting thing that I've noticed uh because I I visit uh the the Reddit subreddit for uh EDH and I visit MTG salvation a lot one thing I'll notice is that for some reason they come in waves

so somebody will talk talk about like mop plasm or have a new primer that comes out and then you'll see like five or I'll see like five or six deck lists that follow like within the next couple days so it literally like prompts inspiration in other people oh cool yeah yeah well wait wait so what's 1 three4 and five yep yep so so number one is aoro aoro agel aesthetic people love life game don't they yeah well that card is so ridiculous and and and alloro Kor are actually not that far they're only 30 decks away from each other so so in 24,000 decks that's really not that far off uh the next one is anamar is three rku is four Kalia is five G PR derevi and then all the way at nine is naret do do you guys notice anything interesting about that uh it's a lot of the precons yeah so Nar prons Nar the top non- precon yep narset is the top non precon which also is interesting because it's also relatively new um so and the power level of naret I I is way up there it's it's super dumb yeah well I think narset's the most broken yeah right now I I had a narset deck for like one day and then I said this is done it's just broken well yeah it's interesting cuz I mean obviously the data we have from deck doctors is like a fraction of what you've got but naret is tied for a first in ours yeah oh really I think ours is not biased towards things that you know around for longer the other thing that I think too is because a lot of the deck

list I yet especially when the commander products come out are minorly tweaked precon deex because I think that's when a lot of people are looking for help so I think there's also a bias towards the precons just naturally other than the fact that they're good commanders that's a good point because somebody's brewing with a non precon Commander then they're already swimming in the deep end a little bit so they they're already a good swimmer so they might not be asking for help yeah so so I think even the more interesting question other than like what are the top non- precons and I think and so they're at nine is narset 10 is myel 12 is THX uh THX munder 24 is Rafi and then we got shum MC sadisi and RZ um so wow 24 is Rafi I thought Rafi would be way up there or I'm sorry 14 is Rafi oh 14 okay yeah but even then I thought he would break top 10 I think Voltron is very popular strategy but maybe I'm just wrong 14's pretty high yeah that's true yeah it ain't no kador I it's interesting too because alloro came out in a more recent Commander set whereas uh kador has been around from the original Commander set but life gain like if you're a new player new players are so Drawn to Life game not and alloro is also good so so if you're not a new player you'll still Brew with alloro but a new player is just going to naturally gravitate towards that and a new player is going to be more likely to ask for recommendations also so I can see how those two things would like add up to it being number one yeah definitely but but but naret is definitely the fastest growing that I've ever seen I I was watching that thing that thing

skyrocketed it was it was fun to watch interesting it's raw power I mean just the most powerful thing I think it's super easy to build too to be honest all right well let's go to the next one uh we're going to go for what are the least popular commanders Jimmy stop cheating I'm not trying to cheat clicking around numb I was just trying to see the thingies so let me just stop you guys on this one because the question's a little bit weird answers are weird so there's I I I went through there's about 60 legendary creatures in Magic that I do not have any deck list for so there okay so there's 60 commanders that are the worst or the least used Commander so just cuz they're old or just we so I have two examples that I picked out that I thought were kind of fun so there was this one called I've never even heard of these cards before there's one called uh Rashida scale Bane you want to take a guess what this person does uh scale Bane something does something to toughness of a creature what else has scales uhas dragons dragons Okay so so this this this creature has the wonderful ability that it costs two white and three and you can tap it to destroy target attacking or blocking Dragon it can't be regenerated you gain life equals to its power hey uh right now that's actually not too bad yeah I know right yeah which is actually what we'll be talking about soon is a tribal that's fascinating it's so specific that's probably why no one's

like h i don't interesting the the next one I mean there there's a ton of these are the vanilla legends from uh from The Legend set right right um but but one that I pulled out uh because it kind of reminded me of a conversation you had in your previous podcast which was uh Gast the Durk which is uh cost seven total Mana two white two blue three uh it's a legendary human Warrior and has first strike and it's uh I I didn't write down the power of toughness but it's not very good but the the ability is creatures with with Island Walk can block be blocked as though they didn't have Island Walk wow that is set specific if I've ever heard of card that set specific which completely hoses your guys's uh recommendation to use Island Sanctuary insteed moat oh yeah that's so funny no it's it's awesome actually cuz you use Island sanctuary and that card and now you can actually block the island Mary so only flying hit you yeah it turns Island Sanctuary into exactly moat doesn't Rex the hidden deep have Island Walk as well yeah I'm putting you on the spot a little bit because we did uh have to give you these questions beforehand so you could get the data but could we do the least popular precon commanders because we know you'll have those in there uh I'm pretty sure it's that white guy the Jal gold m i i or kmba car Regent I could see a lot of people doing K so so let me see no well well Kemba wasn't a pre-con it was the the yeah it was the the the guy that pumps tokens I think I it's just yeah yeah yeah yeah

yeah that's right that's right gold I I think he he only has Johnny's brother cousin uncle or something like that so he has 17 decks uh or 17 cards um or I'm sorry 17 decks uhuh and I'm pretty sure that's the that's the bottom five probably all monocolored I that's what I was guessing would be monol uh oh in the from from a pre-con perspective yeah yeah yeah yeah they it was mostly the secondary ones like um they weren't very popular well the Plaines Walker they would have enough because yeah people just trying to brew it's just something they've never done before so it's like oh I can have a plaines Walker I'm going to do that uh but I could see some of those secondary ones being so for for the the secondary ones of the monocolor ones I think Tania did the best and then Feldon and then the black one blue one then the white one of the not of the secondary one the second yep yep feldon's pretty sweet right um all right so let's go to what is the most popular color and then the least popular so go ahead jimy you can guess what's most popular and what's least blue is the most popular color no no green is the most popular color it's not it's a good guess okay and what what do you think is the least uh red I'm going to say blue most popular Red's white oh yeah white was my other go for it all right we do so so there's there's we're talking about the color of the cards not the color identity right combinations okay just

the yeah raw amount of cards so there are uh the most popular is blue and the least popular is red so it goes blue green black white red yep blue green white black red yep no no no blue green black yeah blue green black white red and there's almost uh not quite double but pretty close I would say like half you 3/4 of the way to double of blue cards versus red cards so it's it's a pretty big gap so so Blue's almost twice as popular as the last the least popular color basic yeah yeah yep and blue and green are pretty close uh blue is 412,000 cards uh green was 44,000 cards oh very close and then and then black is 380,000 which is still close and then it drops down to White which is at 350 and then red is 270 oh poor red poor red sorry Jimmy po I know my spirit color it makes sense though I mean red as we talked we we record Color Wheel episode for red and it just is not the best fit for a multiplayer well it's also a damage based color in a so everything about red is balanced for 20 life yeah it just doesn't scale so it doesn't scale great so the other thing too that I found interesting and I'm kind of jumping ahead on some stats I collected for something else which is the most popular cards for each color um when you look at Red almost all the most popular cards that are played in Red decks are artifacts yeah sense so I think red decks like mon red red deck for example or just not playing that many red cards

right so that they just immediately lose out on that part of the statistic monor red has DTI now which is a big artifact color yeah so but and Feldon too yeah yep um all right well let's talk about the most popular two and three color combination so what do you think the most popular Guild from Ravnica is I would believe the most popular Guild it's tough because I just don't know that I I'm going to say green white cnia okay good tokens I'm gonna say simic green blue all right the most popular two color combination is blue white blue white really yep wow and then black yo and and then black blue after that and then green white and then blue red well you were way ahead of me and then black green and then BL and then blue green then black red and then black white and and then red white is uh or then red white and the worst or the lowest used I I need to stop saying worst it's not necessarily bad it's just that's yeah it's just is H is green red green red okay interesting but you know red white makes sense to not be down there our friend is compiling he has all of the two color combination decks except for two and red white is the one he's like I just don't know what Commander I want to Do's good commanders there yeah I I tried making red R work a couple times and I just I just can't do it it's just it's just it's too hard we talk about all the time

on the show that EDH is so much about card draw and man ramp and those are the two colors that don't do either of those things so it's like you don't have neither of those colors covers the other one in that in either of those areas so um all right let's talk about the three color combinations oo what do you think is the um most popular three-c color combination I am going to say it is green blue red and Mar's colors teer teamer yeah I'm gonna say bant oh that's a good one too oh that's a good one so um in general the uh original Allied color three colors are pretty much more popular than oh okay than not so just because they've been those cards yeah yeah yeah so the the shards are a little bit more popular than the enemy colored ones uh so our good friend alloro is bringing in black blue white into first alloro single-handedly yep esper is first and then uh grixis is next not that far behind blue black red yeah and then B is a pretty far is a good step behind that and then you've got blue green red so blue green red is the most popular enemy colored one but only fourth in uh in in three color decks interesting and and then you get and then you get black green white after that you know going through Ed H wck and clicking on it it's it's true because the shards just have many more command

almost twice as many commanders to be played so it makes a lot of sense that because they've been around longer yep you guys want to guess what the the least used three color combo is umon no I'm going to say red white black col colors M yeah mardu just because it has red white yep just because it has red white uh so you can tutor into your awful red white cards so you can tutor into your off I'm guessing collie is just the allstar of that category yeah yeah she actually she accounts for about uh a third of the decks in in in that color combo yeah makes a lot of sense all right let's talk about the top five most played cards actually there's one interesting thing I found oh sure so when I so I also compiled how popular the the color combinations are against each other not only in the three colors and the two colors so one thing interesting I found was that uh uh mono black decks are more popular than mono blue decks really but there are more blue cards played than black cards so if you play Blue you're probably combining it with another color yep yep well that makes sense because of the color wheel red or sorry black is very prejudice against the other colors black rewards you the most for not for not going outside of your color so that does make sense yep and then uh yeah I play a mono black deck right now too and you know it's fantastic oh who's the commander I'm building one uh Cy oh nice that's pretty good your commander it's super dumb I

basically just like a m skell in every game it's it's pretty stupid ah very nice yeah uh so um uh red is actually the third most popular monocolor deck green and then white is last white last yeah white just doesn't have it just doesn't it's not as fun I think I think red has a lot more options just cuz you have Kiki gy and I feel like that stands for a decent a decent number yep yep so so frco and also too the the uh there's a lot of five color decks so mono black is the most po popular color identity and then five color is the next One Mono black is the top of the top as far as any wow and then five color is next yep that's interesting that it's a monocolor deck and then it's fin color I was I was actually really surprised when I saw it to that does make sense though because um it's almost like the three-c color combinations they take away from each other cuz if you're going to go three-c color mhm you have 10 or 10 choices right so yeah yep yeah all right all right so we so we may move on now okay excellent um let's do top five most played cards I feel like this should be a pretty easy gimme soul ring that I mean I got to say soul ring yeah let's say it wasn't soing what's after that okay oh geez um basic Island I'm just kidding um that doesn't count let me think here um it's way tougher after soing I know so are we not counting basic LS yeah let's not count basic lands get basic lands cuzz I guess it would probably go the same order SW so island is at three oh would swamp be at two then okay I I didn't actually notice

this before this is blowing my mind right now so island is number one swamp is number two Plains is number three Forest is number four and Mountain is number five wow cuz Plains is the last monocolored but it must be played so much in the two and three well we know esper is number one yeah and the Loro is up there yeah yeah so I don't know what's going on with but but there is a card at number two that's not a basic land um it's it's pretty obvious soul ring ring oh no soul ring is number one yep soul ring is number one okay so then number two is pretty obvious go ahead he's saying it's obvious and now it's like I'm thinking it still needs to be artifact it has to be a be played it's it's not an artifact what okay um it's a land oh oh it's um command Tower there you go there you go yeah okay let's say nonland let's say nonland okay um I'm going to go with uh dark Steel Ingot dark Steel Ingot I'm going to go with crap I'm gonna go with oh you know I should have said something else I think but I'm go as Nev's disc I was going to say Swift foot boots actually might might be better equipment uh close lightning Greaves lightning grees okay so so the the top non-land cards are obviously soul ring lightning gaves is next far behind um Som simac is the next one oh I should have said that was my number one so so and and then Swift foot boots and then we have the first colored card do you

want to guess what the first first colored card okay demonic tutor nope counter spell nope oh cyclonic Rift cyclonic Rift yes oh nice awesome so so in the in in the top part here we have cyclonic Rift Eternal witness sword Supply PL shars are the only colored cards that I have on this list um dark number is cyclonic Rift uh counting lands and everything so cyclonic Rift including the basic lands was 15 15 it's 10 without um it's 10 without the basic lands it's funny because we haven't done uh top 10 blue cards in EDH yet I feel like we're getting a leg up here and saying cyclonic rft is going to make it pretty high on that list oh yeah it was already going to be yeah it was already probably going to be number one we might have to do the outlaw thing although blue has a lot of good cards yeah and again there's a well we have a we have a um dollar bias too we do the list do you guys want to guess which one's more popular uh evolving Wilds or terramorphic expans oh evolving Wilds yeah I was going to say evolving Wilds too yeah I think it's just cuz it's been printed more it feel like it has been yeah well I think it's also been printed more recently yes exactly there's just a lot of copies now yep yep but it's it's it's it's a pretty big difference interesting okay most popular tribes I mean dragons yeah would say dragons followed by goblins maybe goblins first actually I'm going to say goblins elves elves okay all right so I it's elves is is the answer but when I was looking at elf

decks I'm kind of concerned would have been a good one yeah so so the problem with elf decks is that when I was looking through the elf tribal decks there's a lot of Elf Decks that are look like elf tribal that I don't think are Elf tribal like in in spirit if that makes sense like uh like for example I found a there's a progenitus deck one of my users asked me like what because if you go to the website it'll tells you what what like popular commanders are for for the tribe and progenitor shows up progenitor shows up twice and and my users are like oh dude there's a bug you progen so I go look and it it was a freaking five-color progenitus like elf deck where the elves like ramped into progenitus and then like so is that that makes sense cuz elves will create Mana of every color yeah so so like is it an elf deck I mean I don't think they were trying to like overrun with elves or they were trying to kill with elves or do stuff with elves it was mostly just like ramping in progenitus so so I think elf might it's classified as number one but I think it cheated a little bit the the next one down which is most definitely the winner is zombies oh we forgot about zombies so mon black yeah yep dragons are only four decks behind zombies so it's super close um and then and then so dragons are after zombies just four behind uh then goblins then slivers oh gross sers slivers slivers are super popular in Our Deck doctoring thing they're probably like uh I put all the sliver decks together and I think they were in like fifth or sixth placees hold on how do you make a bad sliver

deck you just put all the I know that's why so with the new um the new indestructible sliver guy I saw a huge like the number of sliver decks almost doubled because before that uh you know like sliver Queen and Sliver Overlord were pretty inaccessible right um and so when the new one came out I saw like a ton of decks come out and a lot of new slivers came out at that same time so yep so but I took a little bit closer a dive at dragons because um and what I did was dragons was I plotted how many Dragon decks I got every month and because I obviously Dragon decks became more popular recently and um what I found was that uh right after KH was so this is really interesting I think right after K was released I got a a influx of dragon decks I got about I got about 50 which wait after K not after dragons of dark here after k a lot of dragons in it too didn't have any didn't have any the whole story line you're right ignore me people were getting ready yeah so I think what happened was people were getting ready for like the anticipation of dragons coming out cuz they were announc the whole story line yeah I I I went to the con spoiler because I was like this doesn't make any sense like what's going on here and it was just I guess people were were just speculating but uh when when fate reforge was released in January I saw a huge influx of decks and then when dragons and tarir so so this was interesting when dragons and tarir came in I did not see a huge

influx it was like increase but it wasn't nearly as much as when fate reforged or k came out and that's because when K came out like everybody had already brewed their dragon I I I think everybody was burnt out on dragons after nine months I guess right uh yeah so so so Canon become became like a very popular Commander it shot up in the rankings um everybody was building a Canon deck for it was number one in my weekly monthly rankings for almost three or four months wow that makes a lot of sense can I think definitely has the it's just like you get to have the spikiest Dragon for sure yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah well we we've talked about a lot of things the the website can obviously do a lot of like what's the most popular this or that um you know we wanted to talk about some things that are Beyond that so what can the data tell us that's sort of above and beyond what's the most popular this or that um one thing you mentioned Don was that um you can sort of tell like like how many Mana rocks on average does a deck have yeah so so this one was fun I had to go write some custom code for this one and I'm actually I'm actually going to keep it around and uh and add this because I thought it was pretty interesting nice and so what I did was I went through and uh calculated for each color combination how many R Mana rocks on average that color combination is playing and the reason why I did it that way was because you you guys also asked me how does playing Green affect the number of Mana rocks right yeah the assumption is that that would affect it a lot but we don't know if that's true or not yeah so so um

colorless by far plays the most Mana rocks I don't know if that should be a surprise or not so basically like k k and ulog and kleck are are playing the most at an at an average of 8.3 man rocks okay which I thought which I thought was kind of low because I think I think when I bought built a car deck I think I had like 20 man rocks in it we usually Advocates at least 10 Mana ramp cards cards not necessarily rocks but so so the next one that has the most um Mana rocks was black blue white and uh you know our good old friend ororo I guess um yeah that's interesting because it doesn't it has black which does ramp can ramp you yeah but black is very specific to swamps to ramp usually like that's true and if you're in a three color yeah you're running well and that's also just because that's the most like is it percentage of those oh yeah it's an average right yeah yep so it doesn't matter how many decks yeah so so the weird thing is I think it's actually kind of low the average for black blue white which is again the most Mana rocks is only 5.25 what yeah I I I think either a maybe my analysis was wrong or be I I think I I think people are not playing enough Mana rocks I think I think actually that's 100% true as we see more of the community we play with more uh different people from different walks of life and different play groups and everything that's one of the things I just consistently see I think is just not enough Mana ramp in general I I I

had a player asked me the other day he was pretty new he he was asking me why I played signets uhuh you're like they're awesome yeah yeah I mean I think a lot of people don't maybe realize how many Mana rocks there are and aren't playing them maybe they because like so so Mana rocks I I think the other thing too I um that's kind of interesting about Mana rocks is that they're not fun to think about so like if I'm if I'm building like a blue black white um you know like Sphinx deck let's say right I'm not sitting there like thinking oh man I I really wonder what Mana rocks I'm going to play you know or or if I'm leafing through my cards you know I'm may only pull out the Mana rocks that I have I'm not going to go to like the LGs and pick up like my three Mana rocks that I'm missing so it's not a sexy part of the deck for sure exact exactly so I think maybe that that's kind of my my theory um but but anyways going into the uh the greenness impact of Mana rocks the the the color combination that has green in it that plays the most Mana rocks is black green red and that plays on an average of 2.75 which is half as many as uh in in a gilded Lotus like what's happening guys yeah but that does make so it does correlate that green is using the least amount of manox in general yeah and then and then monog green is by far the least with 77 which they like they don't need it yeah they don't need a in there that that translates I think that's less than an average soul ring you still run Sol ring in man in monog green everybody

yeah you just run so ring no matter what guys on yep and then and then green white is at 1.4 which means that they're playing s ring and maybe another car they're playing soul ring and half of them are also playing to me because I feel like in green white with the popular commanders that are token generators you need Mana to pump stuff out with RTO redeemed and stuff right right but your your Mana ramp is EarthCraft yeah and it's it's stuff like that you know and and that's I think that is generally good deck building is going through you know when I build a deck I always pull every Mana Rock for those colors and put it there but then I also put you know other things like EarthCraft or exploration yeah or C's follower or fate Stitcher in the same row and then I'm like well do I want this Mana rocker or do I want fate Stitcher I always want fate Stitcher you know but that's that's sort of where you you take it out of that category as it were I think also people are Brewing online I think Mana rocks again are just going to be the last thing they're putting in it's true in a real life deck you might end up adding those Mana rocks that is really low though so the average deck the average deck overall runs what uh m I'm not sure if I had a guess it would probably be three or four wow that seems really low in fact blasphemy I don't know if I have a deck that doesn't have soul ring gilded Lotus th Dynamo cuz they're all cheap and they do and and they also fit in the curve like four and five even Titania has those three and you that that's the one that would least need it for me yeah um interesting

very interesting um how much land does the average deck contain I'm going to guess 37 I'm going to guess lower because I think people are late I'm going to guess 34 oh my gosh 33 even I'm G guess 34 though it's in between 36 and 37 okay so it's right right on that edge oh people run a lot yep yep uh they should cut one land for two Mana rocks that the map doesn't add up there something else yeah I think it does oh so I I kind of dug around to find um like some outliers I guess um there isua and I'm going to butcher this aigus right we just call yep he uh he plays 49 lands um some of the like what about Ashling ashling's got to play the most yeah like 90 uh Ashling plays an average of 39 what um which is so and this is an average so like you kind of have to be careful with that because a lot of people don't play Ashling with like 90 lands um some people play with it with a normal amount of land so I think I think some people are playing with 36 if I had to plot it you'd probably see like a a spike around you know 36 37 and then

you'd see a few guys out there playing 99 mhm but then again like if you had a 99 Mountain Ashling deck I don't know why you would plugg that into Ed trk yeah it would just be it's like oh cool that's a good point you're not asking for recommendations hey guys what should I do with this deck take out some mountains put in some other stuff yeah um so Aza was the the most amount of land play or BOS was B rigos was at 49 yeah that makes sense just because that's his tied directly to his ability yeah that's what he does yeah your lands are doing damage and a lot of those lands may not even tap for Mana necessarily they could just be specific utility lands or whatever so you brought up an interesting statistic we didn't even think about asking but this is I'm really interested to find this out um it's what's the most popular day of the week for Brewing so on what day of the week do you get the most uh influx of decks oh this is really interesting I'm going to say it's got to be a weekend but at the same time people want to play their EDH decks at F&M correct yeah so my well my thought is you go to F&M and then the next day so it's either Saturday or I would say Monday Monday would be like you're at work and you're thinking about magic from the weekend yeah but but again yeah a lot of young people play so on Monday they'd be at school so I'm goingon to say Saturday I'm going to say late Sunday night Sunday night yeah okay so I only have granularity to the day so I

can't tell you like late or early sure but you guys were really bad at this one it's like Wednesday yeah I bet th Saturday is the lowest oh wow Sunday is the second lowest cuz people are out and about you guys did you guys did as bad as you possibly could um so so so the most popular is Friday okay uh and then the next popular is Thursday and Friday is twice as popular as Thursday wow okay so I guess yeah F&M should have something to do with it I feel like or just the idea that it's Friday it's a magic day yeah it might be in preparation though yeah that makes sense I I think I do that too I think you know if I'm I I'll have like a deck that's half built you know that I've been working on over a couple weeks and then I'm kind of motivated to finish it you know before F&M so yeah I can kind of see that logic and then Thursday if I'm not a procrastinator right so uh so and and then after so it goes Friday Thursday Monday Tuesday Wednesday oh interesting so it's the pressure building up to that Friday feel we were horrible hey Eli let's read no just kidding just cut us all out let's make us sound smart well now you guys know when we Brew our decks is on the weekends I don't you know I should have thought about that way I don't think I've ever brewed a deck on a weekend I'm too I'm too busy doing weekend stuff yeah yeah it's always like Wednesday night or something yeah it makes sense but but I think it says something about our hobby right it's it it says something like man we're thinking about

this all week and then uh it's it's almost like like maybe it's not a hobby maybe uh maybe it's something else I don't know yeah it does mimic a work sched yeah it's a money snc yeah there you go but it does kind of mimic the work week schedule where we are once we get closer to the weekend we want to do it more and then when the weekend comes we find ourselves doing something else or you're playing it that might be not the time that you're tuning those decks it's like no that's why I tuned it so I could play it yeah yeah I'd be interested to see when the subreddit for EDH is the most busy if it is again Thursday and Friday or if it is the weekend m yep yep so so the one thing to note is that when a deck gets scraped off of the Reddit subreddit um you know that's counting towards this count and I see more deck help on Thursday and Friday in General on the subreddit as well it makes sense people getting ready you're about to go to battle you get to suit up yep yep yep so you mentioned some funny stories that you've had uh while working on the site some bugs you've run into or certain C cards that have caused trouble I mean like the Dual face planes Walkers are going to um any flip cards or any of the cards with like wear and tear and all that stuff yeah the the bad one so I actually haven't ever fixed the flip cards uh yet so so it's like I'm actually kind of lucky because I think flip cards just aren't played very much in general so yeah um so it's it's like really not that the Dual face cards we mean actually yeah yeah or both dual face and flip so so because so okay so the they're bad for

different reasons so the Dual face cards are bad because in the card database they show up as two cards right so so what happens is that people sometimes plug in the card on the back side and it's it's kind of hard for me to tell like that this is actually the same card over here it's hard to sort of tie them together in the database yeah yep yep so sometimes you'll see recommendations for like the backside of Gro for example um just yeah so so that specifically yeah that guy yep yep yep sorry the one flip Walker yep and then you've got um uh the the flip cards through that that uh from Kagawa for example also have two names as well which is kind of annoying right uh the other one too is uh the um the split cards uh wear and tear and stuff like that yep so the split cards if you if you look up a split card on my website it actually doesn't have the picture for it because the code actually fails when it tries to go pick up the image because there's actually two images associated with the same card so it it's there's all these kinds of problems with these cards that I just honestly haven't gotten around fixing it and I've been doing this for like a year now um but like you said they just didn't get played that much so it's not a huge deal yep yep the other thing that really is super annoying are like fancy accents on cards like you know they add like a like an accent on top of an A or something like that snipe oh my God I and the AE thing is just oh like I it

makes me so mad uh it's like it's absolutely aggravating the the number of problems that are caused by that and the amount of time I've spent trying to fix that problem is astronomical because people type in AE sometimes sometimes people type in like the actual character AE and then there's like actually different character there's like lowercase and uppercase and it's it's an absolute nightmare it's absolute nightmare I'm laughing because uh you know if you don't you'll just go crazy yeah pretty much that's that's that's pretty interesting well you are have to figure out the Dual face planes walkers at the very least cuz they're going to be integral to the site now yeah yeah that's that's going to be a pain in the butt yep unfortunately I'm going to have to have special code for that I had to I had to add special code for the Plaines Walker um commanders because uh originally my code just looked for all legendary creatures so there's somewhere in my code where it's like all legendary creatures plus these five cards right so just just really obnoxious yeah just those small exceptions and they're only going to get gr y y so so the one that the one kind of uh funny story that stands out for me where I almost fell out of my chair when I found it was um the website was failing and I went in the logs and I couldn't figure out what it was it was kill me so I I vented ended up pulling up um all the deck list for a particular Commander I think it was it was something really obscure I don't even remember it but uh it was only like 14 deck list and what happened was was somebody was playing little girl which

has a half a which oh from unhindered Ed right yeah yep and it has a converted Mana cost of 0.5 which which uh complet which it screwed up my um my Mana curve calculation and it was just yeah like when I found that I was like why did somebody put little girl in their deck and submit it to my website just to mess with ehh that's why Chey face finds his way in there I'm sure yeah actually those cards are are are uh uh super annoying as well because they they do show up and I can't really like filter them out so but but luckily not not enough people play them that they actually show up in the recommendations yeah yeah clearly yeah I don't think there's any unhinged outside of maybe if they're trying to specify that they have an unhinged island or you know a land in their deck specifically some people do play them and some people will like ask you if they can play them and I'm usually fine with it but yeah it's not very often it's rare yeah yep yep I just want booster tutor to be in every EDH deck just I have a reason to crack more packs always looking for an excuse always looking for an excuse okay well let's talk let's move on to the final uh sort of section for talking about EDH wck and let's just talk about criticism the site has received um because there is an interesting thread of debate uh that people may not necessarily like this kind of program because it sort of recommends what people are criticizing at as for Conformity so netdecking is a term that we use for when someone goes on the internet finds a deck that they

want to play in standard modern whatever sees it top a the GP and just copies the deck list right it's very common in competitive magic um I think because Ed a casual format that it can sometimes have a negative connotation um this is something you brought up Donald I don't know if you want to expand on it a little bit more is this something you've been confronted about yeah uh actually it uh so every now and then on Reddit uh some posts will come up about EA TR it it's usually something random like hey do you guys trust ed8 TX like generated decks for example was one that came up um or or yeah his it's spet I get that comment all the time actually um that's yep uh the the one thing that happens is is like I post announcements to the to to to the to the EDH subreddit because that was my original community and they always provide me really good feedback and and they've always been really supportive so like like I definitely shout out to those guys I couldn't do it without him and um uh but every now like there's always like two or three guys that always show up to these threads and some some there's a couple repe Defenders and they always have like some sort of Doom and Gloom kind of like you're going to kill the format basically um and I think one of the big big things that people are concerned about actually too when I I first started running the bot and people were like what what is this thing um people were really concerned about like hey because before when you built an EDH deck like there wasn't really any tool maybe on gather you would like search

for cards like I'm building enchantment decks I search for enchantments and stuff or you can look at other people's deck lists but there wasn't really a good way so effectively like I mean I use my own tool and it pulls out the really obvious cards that I should obviously be playing and so it really recommends a lot of the Staples when you look at it you're like I there's no way I can't play this card because it's so good and so I think it definitely it has Conformity because it's so hard to be um Crea in EDH it it kind of it yeah it makes worse deck builders honestly with less knowledge of the pool card pool make better decisions which I don't think is a bad thing yeah I agree and it's like hey look if you want a Mana Rock and you're like I don't know what to put in and thing's like soul ring you're like oh right of course that's not a bad Conformity by any means I mean why yeah I don't understand this at all because people can already find the cards you're just making it easier y mhm it's not like it was impossible to find them before and now they're findable that's it's you know it wasn't binary so it's just like don't we want to just make things easier it's still people are still making choices yeah yeah you know it's just it's just you're giving them the choices in a more convenient manner yeah and again it's like this is the utility that you can use to however you decide you so if you want to use it in a way that just makes you make the most vanilla version of a deck possible you only use the recommendations and that's your decision and not the bot influencing that to you the bot's just telling you what the information it has and what's what it's collated so yeah that's really weird

it's it's interesting because when I go to EDH Rec and I look at all almost a lot of my decks have no like like if I look at a rku deck well my rku deck is a prodal sorcerer it's a Tim deck yeah so none of the recommendations matter to me when I go to a chromat deck or nekusar you know it's totally different because if I go to nekusar well it's missing two colors that I'm using if I go to Chrome app they didn't build a nekar deck you know so it's like don't that's just like I've made choices the EDH Rec doesn't force me to do anything so I don't understand this argument at all yeah y well I think I think too I think it really comes down to them more novice players where right they they're they're plugging in a deck list and you know I don't think they're knowledgeable enough about the pool to come up with something interesting to be honest like hey oh I really thought to make a five-color necar deck I mean people probably don't think about that off the bat right so right right I think I think that's kind of maybe what's going on so so actually one example if you go to to the uh a commander page for Commander on my website and you click on the generate deck list it basically creates like a deck list out of the 100 most popular cards um for for that commander and you can like literally copy and paste that into tapped out or mtgo or something and it'll be a really good deck probably yeah it's it's like pretty decent it's it's really not bad um and I I think some people have yeah some people have been kind of creeped out by that a little bit um cuz and I do know that there's people basically on mtgo in particular that are like oh I

feel like playing uh you know Ashling today I'm going to go copy and paste this deck list and get started within five minutes which is that a bad thing I mean what amazing way to get someone an easy way to just play a deck and then find out what they like don't like about it and then make their own decisions from there and if you are an obvious player what a great way to take that pressure off for the first deck you made yes exactly and I think also like there's this uh there's this Evolution that happens and all novice players go through it which like they start out they don't know a lot of cards they they're learning the format they you know they don't know how to build a deck and then you know somewhere along the way two or three steps down they end up building like a super powerful crazy mean EDH deck because they that's the point at which they sort of start to understand cards and they understand interactions and then they just build the most highly tuned thing and they and they Google like most powerful this is where they build their naret deck you know and then you and then they realize oh that's not actually that fun because that deck just does crazy broken things super fast and and it does the same thing every time and then they actually evolve from there and so what you're doing is just speeding up the that Evolution to that point yeah but everyone's going to go through that anyway so there's there's no problem with a newer player building a really powerful deck because they have tools available to them because they're going to do that anyway yeah you know you see almost every player build that deck you know somewhere when somewhere around their sophomore area of of learning to play yeah just

the busted deck that they that they just want they want to have that powerful deck that just wins or whatever yeah exactly because you're the new player and you're getting kicked around for a while and then you start to understand cards and and Synergy and stuff and then you start to really brew and then you start to Google things like most broken EDH Commander I mean it's not that hard to do it once you have that aim and so yeah I don't know I I I'm going to say that all the sers are kind of crazy yeah I the the one thing in particular to the Reddit bot which post if you if for listeners that haven't seen it on the redit when somebody posts a link it responds to that link with recommendations like in line in a comment right there's there's been a couple of people in the subreddit that say that um uh it kills conversation because um you know my bot is responding and my recommendations are actually take it as a compliment are so good that people don't need to respond in the thread interesting I feel like that's a great way to Kickstart a conversation do you agree SL disagree you know yep it actually and this actually goes all the way back to what my initial motivation was this was I was sitting on the EDH subreddit and there was people posting like deck lists that were like missing soul ring for example like and I'm typing out hey you should probably play soul ring I mean what a waste of time right so instead what I wrote was a program that did the obvious thing so that we could conversation wise talk about like maybe the more interesting choices versus you know like making sure

that people are playing so ringing enough Mana rocks yeah absolutely that's so true that's a great Point yep um awesome very cool man this this site is really cool was not super familiar with it before you reached out to us so I'm glad that you did uh glad we could highlight it if you haven't checked out edhrec.com definitely a very useful tool for all uh your deck Brewing needs and it's just interesting to click around and and look at the data too and just see what is popular what a lot of people are playing you know mhm so and Don what can we find you online if someone wants to give you recommendations or ask a question about statistics on the uh the the bot yep so uh I think typically people send me messages on uh my Reddit handle which is just edre uh it seems like people you know hit me there a lot uh the other thing too is there's a link to an email address at the bottom of ed.com that can email me at um uh it's edre minor.com mineros is the company I work for and then and then um I'm also on Twitter uh Donald P and we will have all those links as well for you guys in the show notes um this is fascinating I really love the that that it's a you know it's this is a player generated Act of love for the game sort of thing that Wizards would never kind of just do on their own unless they had you know some kind of upstart person there that wanted to do this specifically because it requires such a specific skill set and like to thank you Donald for putting all the time into this and also making the website as well as the bot so yeah I

think it's a I think it's definitely great for the community it's great for just aspiring deck builders and stuff and it and it start kick starts conversation which is we couldn't ask for anything more awesome all right so time to move on to the end step where we talk about something cool outside of the World of Magic Don I uh I understand you got something new that's cool yeah so I've been playing a lot with this big green egg thing which is this kind of fancy ceramic Grill ceramic Grill oh cool how does it work exactly so it's kind of like a a smoker I guess so you put it's pretty straightfor you put charcoal in it you set the charcoal on fire and then you put food in it and you close it and then it grills some stuff oh yeah I'm looking at pictures of it right now it looks delicious like what kind of stuff yeah but the the thing that's really cool about it versus other charcoal grills is that it's really good at holding the temperature at a low temperature which is I guess hard to do on a normal Grill uh so you can keep the grill at like uh 200° 250 15 and cook ribs over the course of like seven or eight hours and get oh I bet they're good yep so I've been uh I've been doing that a lot uh outside of magic and work and uh where do you live Don I live in Maryland okay so next time I'm in Maryland I'm I'm having some ribs right yep yep yep that's awesome and hey you know we're recording this before July 4th um and we'll release the episode after but I'm I'm assuming you've got some tasty July 4th plans oh man I bet there's going to be something awesome coming out of that I'm I'm going to try chicken like a whole chicken I I haven't tried it yet and I'm kind of scared because chicken's really thick so um so chicken's scary to cook that way yeah

I'm kind of nervous about it because if you undercook like beef you're probably okay if you under a little if you undercook chicken it's just not good at all hey hey undercooking is not that bad you can just throw it back on but that's a good question like I'm far more worried about overcooking I actually overcooked um uh I I'm starting to realize how into cooking I am I I never quite realized until talking about it but uh I I I bought like $200 in lobster and I overcooked all of it um oh yeah Maryland is a good place to get Lobster though that's for sure yeah they're actually shipped from Maine like fresh shipped from Maine uh sounds so good yeah well it was it was not hungry yeah it's not good to overcook it though yeah you're going to get some you're going to get some squishy lobster right it was actually it's actually really uh it turns into rubber yeah rubbery the um the trick I always learned was you pull on one of the antennas and if it just pops right off then it's done oh man all right I I'll I'll try that actually that's but I've I've I've steamed or boiled them so I have not put them into a uh did you put them in your smoker thing no no no these are boiled I you know I'm probably not going to try to cook lobster again it is a challenge and an investment in case you don't do it right excellent so you guys can find that more about the Big Green Egg just by looking up the Big Green Egg I'm not getting I'm not getting paid I'm not getting paid for that don't worry this was not a sponsor the next time you use EDH wreck it's going to just recommend the Big Green Egg it's like wait what the this is in the card all right uh be sure to check out the masters of modern our sister podcast with Alex Kesler and Ben baitman you can

find them on Rocket jump.com you can also find them on Twitter atth mmcast our editor for the show is Eli quas and special thanks to Jeffrey Palmer for the living card animations on our videos yes we have videos you can find them on YouTube and you can find Jeffrey Palmer at Living cardsmtg Don thanks so much again for coming on the show it was a pleasure yeah thanks for having the podcast I really enjoy it a great that's always awesome to hear all right everybody thanks for listening and we'll see you next time peace thank you for your attention for further inquiries send an email to command cast rocket jump.com or ask us on Twitter at JFW and Josh Le see you later alligator greetings humans

Progress saved