Windmill Valley: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to boram like and today I'm doing a discussion over windmill Valley this is Danny Garcia's newest game to my knowledge and Danny Garcia has become a designer that I am pretty much going to start take no he that it's not his newest game he did release another one quite recently but one of his newest games that came out in 2024 but he has become a designer that I'm certainly keeping my eye on because so far he has not missed for me anyway like I just played arboria that was that was really unique and really good uh Barcelona of course from last year was fantastic and now windmill Valley is just equally as good it I mean it might be my favorite of the three that I've played I mean Barcelona again is very good but this one just does a lot of things that I very much enjoy um in in this game I mean it's so simple like to actually learn and play which is really good for a Euro game kind of like this where it seems like there's a lot of moving Parts but I mean there are literally moving Parts with with this sexy sexy wheel that you're rotating around um but in all honesty it's really not that bad like you have your six actions on on your wheel but your entire turn is
kind of just dictated by hey how many spaces do you want your wheel to move one two or three and do you have the money to kind of control where that's going if you don't have the money you have tools that can modify it as well so you pretty much have full control over where your wheel is going to be but because because you have a bigger wheel that moves a smaller wheel uh the actions aren't going to quite line up in the same order that you want them to but I know that this has kind of like a I was going to say to walkon that's not true a Zulan feel I I feel like to some people because of the spinning gears I have not played Zulan uh I own it and I own the expansion 2 and I just have not played it um this wheel mechanism is amazing now I don't think this game is perfect uh we'll get to one of my kind of main complaints that's mainly kind of a it seems a designer uh flaw uh for My Personal Taste but overall like I really really enjoy this game the spatial awareness of where your windmills are going the constant resources that you get basically every action you do just feels good you're always progressing towards something and every everything you do actually matters um it's not a tight game so you're not ever struggling really for money if you don't have money if you find yourself always at zero then
you can always lower the water to get money um now it is kind of a burn action because the game is not long either uh as you make a full circle of your wheel which could go faster or slower depending on how you want to move it if you want to move it three three spaces every single time then the game's going to be over super quick and you're not going to get much but what I love about this Dynamic is the game length is kind of dictated by the players which is seen in other games but I've always loved that where you might be trying to do certain actions but then you realize oh the game's about to end I want to slow it down as much as possible um because you eventually will realize I'm trying to Do complete certain end game scoring I'm trying to complete the Queen's uh desire uh card I'm trying to maximize my victory points by the end of the game so I really want to lower the water so I'm go in one space at a time which then everyone's doing that so that allows the game to kind of have an even Pace until one person is trying to like maybe they might be mathing out where everyone is at but if they're it's kind of like the player who thinks they might win is going to be like now I'm going to end it because I I think if I let it go on too long I'm not going to get enough uh victory points to win out this game but the overall theme of it is just very Charming very delightful this art
cover is fantastic but there's always something that you're able to do whether it is plant your tulips and you have this nice organizational aspect of wanting to keep tulips the same color tulips in the same row uh but different tulips in different columns trying to maximize victory points by placing windmills because you have a score mechanism for each one that you plant you have the kind of almost oron kind of spacing of where you're placing your windmills but I can think I think the windmill aspect is going to be a little bit more um interesting with more people uh the last game I just played was a two-player game and it was basically like here's our section here's my section here's your section but in a multiplayer game you're gonna have people who are gonna be kind of banking off of where you're at because you've built that path for windmills but then they're going to give you a few victory points for doing so but by placing a windmill in a certain spot and spending money which again is pretty easy to get you get rewards for just adjacency the helpers you get this is something I also love you can either take it as a helper to give you a special benefit which kind of gives you a unique engine or you can get them as a contract which will get you victory points and potentially some ways to score those contracts during the game which could be really crucial like one of these for example could be like hey for a full row
of yellow you get 10 points well if you can position that in such a way that you can score that in the middle of the game and you have that completed that's 10 points and at the end of the game it's going to be 10 points um if you are getting tulips that don't really work for your patches you can go to the foreign market and sell them and get a combination of of rewards that way or if you're not if you're kind of getting over by people placing windmills in spots and you're not getting certain color tulips one you can always go to the market the market has it it's super simple to just go and get them and you're actually rewarded for having a diverse number of people there cuz that amplifies the market action but you can also take tulips from the foreign trade if there are any there and just pull them off so that's really cool but really where this game sings is in its its wheel mechanism cuz not only does this you know move and that's cool uh you can actually get wheel enhancements and there are common unique and rare enhancements that just allow you cuz normally whenever you line these up you can only do one of the two actions so in this case I could either take an enhancement or I can plant three tulips um but some of these enhancements typically the rare and the not yeah the rare and the uh uncommon those are going to allow you to do both actions and if you can line those up again it's not
always going to be the same pairing but at least in this case if you took this one for example this would let you get any color tulip you want and do the other action as long as you haven't done that action before so if that matches up it's it's paired up with the planting that would be awesome because you could take the the color you need and immediately plant it I really really like this wheel system it it it doesn't have like necessarily it has a timing element of the overall game but I like how you don't have to think so far in advance of being like okay in six rounds this is going to be here that's whenever I want to do this you can look and see okay this is going to move two spaces that's going to land on that action which will land with that H not really liking that you know what I'm actually going to pay two money to raise it up to three get three victory points for doing so and move it three spaces so it'll line up with this action and that's the one I want to do right now it just I mean I love the fact of how simple it is to learn and and play but yet has you involved the entire time but for everything that you're doing it doesn't overstay its welcome it's I mean what does it say on the box 45 to 90 minutes that's pretty accurate honestly uh and that's I mean 90 minutes with teaching the game too it's so it's just
so simple um but there is there is kind of a a slight negative that I have on the game and again this happens kind of in Barcelona kind of in in Arbor uh arboria but I really noticed it here in that Danny's designs we're on a first name basis Danny and I go way back um they feel like you're always able to do everything and it's it's weird because lately my my tast and Euros is I don't want the heavy heavy Euros but I don't want I don't want Euros to basically feel like oh I'm playing this for the first time and I was able to do everything I wanted that's not necessarily fun for me either now you can't do everything that you want but you can do a lot of it like if you want to dive into you can do windmills you can do a bunch of planting you can you know always get money I like there to be some type of decision making where when you're when it's your turn you kind of have to make hard decisions on which route do I want to go which strategy do I want to make um and stick to that versus kind of being able to put your hand everyone has their hand in the same cookie jar you know everyone can dive in and do a bunch of stuff and his especially in this one I felt that oh I want to do this okay it's very easy for me to do that and the latest game that did that exact same
thing was unconscious mind where I felt that there was oh I have all my workers I can do this I can wow 200 points that's that's the game I saw everything here again it's not necessarily that I seen everything because there's a ton of Helper and like there's an entire deck of Helper and contracts there's a ton of enhancements there's unique foreign foreign aid cards hell even the starting game has these starting Farm enhancements that give you a unique special ability and then the one that's not chosen becomes the Queen's desire so that's going to be a different overall goal uh public goal that everyone's going towards which I love um even kind of the of wanting to push forward because you get a unique benefit not only do you get something for advancing on the calendar you're the first one to do so so you get a unique uh upgrade so if you make it to the very end you can get five points or so or something but there there was this feeling of hm I don't ever really have hard decisions to make and some people that's not even really a negative for some people they might just love that I have complete control over my wheel and it kind of does come down to the wheel I think because whenever you're rotating it because not only do you can spend money to increase it you you raise it from one to two cost one coin you get one point you raise it from two to three cost two coins you get three points you raise it
from one to three costs three coins you get four points um but that's going to determine whether or not you are moving it one two or three spaces and if you want you can get tools that can give you you um that can modify that by one or two not one or two by one and if you are on the one space but you don't really want to spend the one coin to raise it then you can just spend two tools to move your wheel three or three tools to move it four but you can never move it more than four spaces the decision- making of course with that comes down to how quickly do you want the game to end do you think that moving at four spaces is going to benefit from ramping and and moving your wheel past the red line so you move up on the calendar um I I just I guess I would have liked some tensor decisions that kind of make the players go H okay do I want to do this if I do that then that's kind of going to let me you know get the get the Tulips that I need or oh man but if I do this that's going to like there was never really that kind of feeling that I had not again it's a it's really a Min complaint because when you're playing this game the The decision- Making does come to the enhancements where you're going to place them and how they're going to start lining up whenever you're rotating on top of the fact of the the way that you're going to get
the the color tulips that you need so you can get your rows of the same color all that kind of is more apparent in a multiplayer game it's because people are going to start taking spots that you want so it becomes a little bit more difficult for you to get uh the the Tulips that you need and then whenever you need to plant them that's going to be your whole Turn versus getting bonuses for going to the market and stuff like that it's it is just yeah it's it's it's a little bit easier to kind of do the things that you want to do which might sound just weird to a lot of people they're like wait so you don't want to be able to do what you want to do it's like no I do I just want I just want two options I want to do both but I can't do both is kind of where it comes down to and here it's that's not really there not really a huge dock on the game I still think it is fantastic it Blends a lot of other stuff I've seen in some euros but while still feeling like it's not taking from them I'm not sitting here going oh that that's completely ripped from that game that's ripped from that game it's just oh I've seen this kind of somewhere but it's it's not quite the same um and and I just ended up really really liking this game so I mean that's pretty much it like there's not really much else uh I know that there's some there's there are some I he I I'd say promos or maybe
expansions I haven't used them yet CU they're actually still in the shrink but this one looks like it actually changes the way the calendar looks which that's fantastic give some different different uh rewards and then this is just more more enhancement tiles more unique and rare enhancement tiles which looks like they're a little bit more complex but that's really neat too I'd be cuz I'm trying to think arboria arboria has an expansion had the midnight Rivers expansion Barcelona got a small expansion I'm curious to know if windmill Valley is going to get a small one it seems like almost all of his games get get small box expansions let's see windmill Valley let's see new wheel enhancement new calendar tile oh blooming sales there it is right there right in my ass is is there there it is 2025 raising sales to ra raise sales to raise okay I was like is that a typo raise sales like ship sales to raise sales you know Merchant sales and expand your tulip business business significantly changes how the conduct foreign trade action works players now sell with their ship between ports and may spend their tulip bulbs for various rewards moreover the position of their ship determines the benefits they may gain when advancing on the calendar cool yep and that probably I mean looks like a small it feels like this would be kind of a small box
expansion which I mean honestly I think that might be the route to go with his games like you don't need anything massive for these like these games are enhanced and and really done super solid as the core game but if you want a little bit more variety than a small box expansion probably similar to the one that the Barcelona passi Deasia is I I would imagine and that would be cool I think actually out of everything here the foreign trade while I like it it's just somewhere to put your your tulips to get you know two rewards um something extra for that out of all the actions here that would probably be the one that is the easiest to expand upon um but his games are points sality is anyway a lot of the stuff everything you do gives you something which is again very nice I like the helper cards are super cool I I I love Euros that give you a solid engine of oh when I do this like the build I was just going for was every time I planted windmills I was getting like four points and money I never had to want for money and I was getting a bunch of stuff on the uh you by placing the windmills so I was kind of incentivized to do that and I think that that's just really cool to be able to look at the helpers and the fact that by gaining helpers um you I mean you actually get victory points for having more you get one Victory point then three then six for
um for just getting helpers and that's really neat so it is a fantastic game might be my favorite of his right now I don't know what is his newest one that I'm now going to have to buy just because he's three for three on games of his that I've played it is daoshi that's the one that is yeah that's that's his his new newest one so going to have to give that a shot uh but other than that on a scale of 1 to 10 um I think I'm going give this I think I'm going give it an eight I think this is a very very good game I could see nine I think I will Reserve that nine to see what the expansion the expansion brings um because again while I don't want heavy heavy Euros I also don't want super light euros I like some some tense decision- making every now and then and maybe maybe the expansion might bring bring this up to that to that coveted nine spot uh but I mean other than that like his this game is staying in my collection and God it's just so pretty this cover is is amazing it's so peaceful to look at and what he also does that I absolutely love and more games should do is he always throws
in some historical notes in his rule book that for me makes reading the rules a lot more fun you get to break up the minutia of reading the rules and with a nice fun historical fact which the historical fact for windmill Valley is that you can't make a black tulip apparently it's just never been done the closest was it was still a shade of purple it probably looked black to the naked eye but it was really just a super dark purple what color is the dress is really what it came down to back in the 1800s or whatever it was but I was like huh that is fast ating I don't know about tulips uh I wonder why wonder why you can't just keep breeding darker and darker purples to eventually get black no idea but that was the fun fact and I enjoyed it so that's it everyone that's my thoughts on Windmill Valley let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time up day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you