Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 187: Thomas Malaby on Anthropology and Gaming

Transcript 1:08:22

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University Center for Learning through games and simulations they just success funded their most recent game Greg lauring Albright's keep the faith which is a light RPG about the growth of a religion if you miss the campaign do keep an eye out for a chance to late pledge in the coming weeks also if you'd like to support Beyond soliter please head to patreon.com beond soliter to help me keep the lights on for now though enjoy the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davids from beon soliter and this week on the pot of a very special guest this is Thomas Malby he is professor and chair of anthropology at the University of Wisconsin Milwaukee and he's also the Adent Cur of cultural studies at the Milwaukee Public Museum how you doing today Thomas I'm doing great thanks for having me I'm really excited to talk today yeah I'm I'm really ped to talk to you so uh is the edent curator position a new one for you yes uh our department the anthropology department here at the University of Wisconsin Milwaukee has had a very very very long running partnership with the Milwaukee Public Museum which is a natural history museum here in Milwaukee and nationally important one and we've run a graduate program graduate certificate in museum studies for around 60 years uh and that involved a lot of our archaeologists primarily sometimes our biological anthropologists but I'm a cultural Anthropologist but as the museum I think has like most of those museums um sought to Grapple with current issues of concern and how

material culture and Technology affects human experience today those uh relationships have built so I'm I'm more and more involved with what they're doing over there and they're about to move into a new Museum uh downtown in Milwaukee it's going to be very beautiful it's going open up in a couple of years excellent all right so I invited you on the podcast because I read your book gambling life uh dealing in contingency in a Greek city um so I basically just played a lot of back gaming somebody recommended your book to me because there's a chapter about back there um but for people who are not famili that book why don't you tell us a bit about it it's some of it's earlier work for you now but that's right that's right it was the based on the field research that I did for my dissertation it was an adaptation of my dissertation and development of it uh boy there's a lot to say I mean I suppose the most one of the most important things to say is that I grew up in a household that was where games were really really important uh where we played games all the time my grandfather was uh a railroad um Union organizer in the depression but he was also an extremely extremely good pool player in central Ohio he was the one the national pool players playing across the country in their circuit he's the local guy they would play uh and I remember watching him shoot pool after a stroke uh and he had lost the use of one hand and he had fashioned from a coat

hanger and felt a bridge so he could continue to shoot pool and he was just amazing uh my father also great cool player and we all learned uh and we played a lot of cards my grandfather also a great Pinacle player so when we would see my grandparents and and just even in our own home uh getting out a deck of cards and and that that being the occasion around holidays uh family trips that was just constant uh so that was the interesting games from one angle but my father was also an engineer at IBM uh with a number of patents for them over the years primarily in optical character recognition uh but because of that we are one of the first families I knew to have an IBM PC this is sort of just after the Radio Shacks that we saw around um and I was I was just fascinated by it and I wanted to play any game I could on it it was going to the local computer store and searching the floppy disc rack for games you could play and and they were all this is a you know Green monochrome screen it didn't have any graphics it just had characters from the asy character set there was a Star Trek game where you had a little grid and you would you would go around and a typing game which is why actually I pretty fast typist because I the only games in town those two so because of that I had a long running interest in games um and then when I became interested in anthropology as an undergraduate and under undergraduate school I was initially very interested in ritual and performance which has been one of our I think most successful

topics of study in cultural anthropology and uh I was learning as much as I could about that when I read a book by Michael herzfeld uh called the Poetics of manhood and then a book by his by him called place in history where he talked uh sort of in passing in his work on creit uh in cities and and the village in cre he talked in passing about the coffee houses there and all the games that were played and that really sparked my interest in uh an anthropological treatment of games because we had barely done it there were only sub scatter handlings of it uh so I wanted to understand games as a kind of project within anthropology to develop that framework but I also was excited about the way in which games could reveal something to us about how human beings confront the unpredictable nature of their lives always in culturally shaped in specific ways historically specific ways but uh to try and look at how human beings know that they live in an uncertain world and that they are facing an uncertain future and what does their playing of games teach us about those culturally shaped attitudes so that was the inspiration for the book uh fbite funded it um barely I think because I was studying something illegal but uh just barely got through as I Le learned later uh and then uh that's a whole story uh and then I went to Haya and uh

started trying to find the gambling Dan there of all kinds uh which took some doing but after about three months I started to be allowed into these places and to see the kinds of gambling that was going on yes so this is one thing I was wondering about as I was um as I was reading the book actually it was very funny is even from the start I was like this kind of reminds me of like Gear's notes on a BAL fight and then you like mentioned it part way in I was like oh there it is yes yeah it's ironic really because that's a very famous piece uh deep play notes on b b fight one of the most famous essays in the history of anthopology and it's about a game it's about gambling uh but he doesn't really treat it as a game is kind of my argument it ends up being something that like a ritual tells a story of how a society likes to tell a story to themselves uh so that was also maybe that kind of piece and that kind of treatment was behind my desire to treat themes on their own terms we will get back to that but I'm just so curious how did you choose where to do this project and then how do you actually manage to put down enough roots in a place to get people to let you see their questionable sometimes straight up illegal gambling activities right uh well I'd always been interested in the Eastern Mediterranean I had taken a course as an undergraduate on ancient Greece uh and I was just um maybe it because I was into mythology as a kid I played a lot of D and D there's there's

a lot of uh cultural imagination stuff maybe behind that interest but I was very fascinated by it and when I arrived for my PhD program I was initially assigned to an adviser called Anthropologist who had done his work in India actually but was himself Turkish Nur yman uh so that's what who I thought I was going to be working with and that was uh let's just say we weren't on the same page he he was from a he was not a performance Theory ritual kind of person really in that in that more modern vein uh and I was starting to become a little bit lost uh and then Michael herzfeld happened to arrive and he had done his research on Creet and that was right there I was interested in Greece or turkey uh so I I took a lot of inspiration from that and a lot of mentorship from that um now as far as where I chose to do my research I knew I wanted to do it in Greece I did a summer language program and traveled around Greece after it ended the program was in Athens looking for a uh a city that would be the kind of place with a lot of gambling and needs to be large enough for that um and as soon as I walked into haa which is about 100,000 people at the time I immediately knew this is the place for me it's also a relatively wealthy part of Greece and and and Creet because of all of the olive Groves and orange groves especially in that part of the

island so there's a lot of money uh so you that shows up the gambling that takes place uh so you noted a couple of times uh in the book that people will kind of tease you about wanting to watch the games as opposed to play them um so to what extent did you participate versus observe while collecting notes for this oh boy a lot a lot um so I there were many many hours of playing games uh there was many many hours of learning back Emon uh which is one of my very favorite games they play three different games of with the back am and Set uh whereas we you people who learn it in the states tend to only play one uh they play that one but they play two others which are even more have more skill in them so a lot of playing a backham and a lot of playing cards there was a um there were three brothers who owned a very small hotel with a cafe on the first floor in the old city of Kya and um you know I was just sort of walking around who could I talk to right uh and I met this guy who usually was one of the brothers who usually did the morning through afternoon shift Onis and uh he just I think took me under his wing in many ways didn't speak a word of English uh which was helpful and uh for me uh to get up to speed on the language and taught me the card games taught me back gamon taught me many of them and then when I would go to these places I would play if I could um a number of them I talk about in the

book are they're already structured for participation in important ways um so for example the the clubs as they're called are places where couples go and play as couples uh certain kinds of higher Stakes sort ridg like gambling games and uh I was alone so that wasn't a place where I was going to be able to participate uh but I got to play uh a lot of the card games uh poker um and uh Zia a little bit uh but uh that was to get a sense of how the games worked and how that what was the relationship between how Greeks talk about the unpredictabilities that they face in the games and how they talk about unpredictabilities elsewhere in their lives uh and to sort of from my own point of view experience that and understand the rhythm of that so how much Fullbright money did you gamble no time that was always the joke right yeah it was that was yeah uh that it was was a bit of a a strange thing you know people used to ask do I have a line item you know gambling losses or something like that uh but uh I I I most often played for for drinks and things like that uh but my adviser was very smart about this he had a line item in all of his budgets called obligatory Hospitality which is a wonderful phrase and basically it was a way to justify to whatever University Administration that look if you're somewhere doing research

you should also be paying for drinks sometimes and paying for coffees and treating people to to meals right so that's the obligatory part of it and essentially I was you know what was often on the line was who is going to be the hospitable one at the end of the game all right so you've talked you know a bit about uncertainty and how people respond to that in life and I've noticed like across multiple articles of yours you use the term like contingency very specifically yes so I guess is that just the academic term for talking about these things and what does that Encompass at this point yeah it's a real challenge in the academy because um you end up in a position when you develop concepts for analysis where you need them to be precise you need them to not um lead uh to perhaps misinterpretations uh misunderstandings uh and that it can be tricky because uh sometimes it's easier and sometimes it's harder when anthropologists started Ed studying ritual it was something everybody did but people didn't talk about rituals as an activity they did as a category oh I'm going to be doing some rituals this weekend I'm going to go to a wedding and then on uh Monday I'm going to go to the DMV you know they they don't talk about rituals as a category so it was kind of an open space for anthropologists to make that concept their own and make it workable whereas games boy do people talk about games they talk about their playing as games and they talk about the uncertainties in games and the risks and all of that stuff so that language is

very freighted around games and in order to carve out uh language that would be precise for the purposes of social science research we often have to take a step back from the most common lay terms or be very careful and how we Define them if we use a word like game uh so contingency is a good example of that often people will talk about uncertainty right and that what they mean is unpredictability or indeterminacy or contingency but certainty is not knowing if something's going to happen that's not the same thing as whether something is uncertain out in the world right whether it is actually indeterminate so unpredictability indeterminacy contingency are all interchangeable um so at least to give your your reader some relief you can move between them but contingency is the one that philos philosophers most often use to differentiate it from what's determined or they would say necessary so you have necessity and contingency and necessity are the things that have to happen and contingency are the things that could go one way or the other and that's not strictly speaking just Randomness because there's other sources of how things can go the other way right if I make the wrong guess about your point of view that's not about Randomness that's about the social contingency between us right or if I go to make a shot in a basketball game and I miss probably very likely uh that is not Randomness and it's not that kind of social contingency is actually what I would call

performative contingency um so there's a number of those different sources of how our lives feel open-ended and contingent and I uh developed a sort of a language and a framework for helping us talk about that as social scientist and part of the reason for that gets right back to gambling because games have an a different array and calibration of these different sources of contingency poker relies a lot on social contingency right and to a certain extent on the randomness the stochastic contingency of a um Decker cards and they're all in there performative contingency too but by contrast uh something like um B gamon has may still have some social contingency but quite a bit less because everything's right there on the board to see your resources are as plain as day as mine right uh so my framework was uh intended to get us thinking about the various s sources of unpredictability not just in games but in our lives and the different games that we play in any cultural context do they generate different ways of talking about those indeterminacies and what do we learn from that when they especially when they link a particular game to a particular domain of their life their business their romantic relationships their politics and all that so when you talk about looking at games as games but also you know we've had this like kind of wider ranging set

of connections between games and other parts of life what do you mean when you say that and how does it distinguish what you're trying to do from other anthropological work oh sure um well from my my interest in games really owes a lot to anthropology in in the sense I referenced before when we undertook to identify ritual and also bureaucracy we could also say theater but Al talk primarily about ritual we developed kind of along the way um but also because of some really smart people who saw this an approach that said hey this thing ritual is a cultural form it can appear in a lot of different places but wherever it appears there's an institution behind it there's some kind of social institution a formal institution like a church or an informal institution like a family that has their their ritual Gatherings uh a National Institution there's always an institution sponsoring rituals and those institutions are looking to accomplish something through those rituals now they may not it may not be successful but it's often something like belonging and legitimacy especially for things like nation states and churches so that approach to cultural forms ritual bureaucracy theater highlights the fact that they are uh an available framework for institutions to use to accomplish their

project so when I came to the study of games I was very much steeped in that and it was very obvious to me even as someone who loves games that the academic treatment and the popular conception especially in Western societies of games was really shot through with a player focused individual account of games now that has a very trated history in modernism the modern individual the choosing self everything is a rational choice that we make John Lock and a whole bunch of ideas that uh have informed the woodwork of the western Academy many many uh for many many years so what I wanted to do was develop a definition of games and a and a framework for handling them that let us understand not only how games teach us how people experience and confront indeterminacy in an across domain but also be available for you to study how institutions are using games to what end are they using those games what are they trying to accomplish to them uh now that is um what makes my treatment of game uh games pretty different from the popular conception uh but what from my point of view it opens up a lot of exciting territory for exploring those con ctions across what's happening in a game and what's happening outside of it for one thing because we shouldn't treat those

things as separate a game is not a special set aart place like any domain of Our Lives we're we're jumping back and forth we're we're managing the boundary we're establishing the boundary um so I it does that for us um and it also uh gets us talking about uh when not necessarily a game strictly speaking but game design elements are a part of the world that we experience and that's increasingly true through digitally Network Technologies game design is being used to inform a lot of the Technologies we uh we take take our actions through right and they're looking to capture our attention actually to them it's part of my argument so that's that's as short as I can put it I suppose for no that's good so there are two branching paths to go here but I'm gonna hop back before we hop into technology so you know we talked briefly before this interview about the the magic circle and you know I feel like we we've hit the point where it's time to talk about it because you mentioned like there's no such thing as a game that's like separate from what's actually happening in your culture and your life also I 100% still hold grudges from things people have done to me in games so magic circle my no kidding but right well it's it's not that it's not that the impetus behind the concept is misguided uh because boundary maintenance is an extremely important

part of how games uh are managed how they come to be uh but the concept kind of developing in its own corner and without a connection to the traditions of social science thought where we were already talking about boundary maintenance uh by institutions and otherwise because it kind of developed on its own it opened the door for treating that boundary M maintenance in games as if it really is its own thing and it's special and worst of all automatic as if you know as soon as you're playing a game this this thing is going on rather than seeing it as a social project a cultural accomplishment when it happens right as you found you played games you hold grudges right uh that establishment of some kind of semi founded I would say uh distinction between any given domain of our experience but for a game uh and the other Arenas of our experience is never hermetically sealed um and in fact often those things we are jumbled together we want them jumbled together uh when a professional sports team is associated with a local with a city with a state and is competitive and going late into the SE into the playoffs contending for a championship that is about the identity of that region it's bound up in it right uh what makes game professional

sports often interesting is not just the game itself but the stories around it what a player has overcome uh in order to be in the position that they're in uh so it's it's always been a bit strange that the academy has done this I know where it came from and it came from Johan heisinger and uhom UD but interestingly even in that book he contradicts any strict treatment of the magic circle later on he's talking about the play element and he says culture starts in a play element and it never leaves it that's a lot more productive if we want to appreciate human being's ability to always be ready to move laterally and across domains and um and frustrate rigid categories which they do indeed uh so you know speaking of so the this I actually think this is really nicely into talking about some of your later work and looking at games in a more digital setting um because you're absolutely right you know games and gamification and you know the way that even just basic apps on our phones and stuff work they take stuff from games so that things that were in the quote magic circle of I'm going to play game now are actually now very much embedded into our lives so how did you go from studying a small town in Greece to you know your second book which is about second life well right so I had mentioned before that uh technology was a big part of my life growing up um through the my

college Years and like in grad school in the 90s you know I was the guy in the dorm who knew how to fix the Windows computer you know I knew how to dig into the the back end of it and and make all that stuff work even though I wasn't studying or taking classes and that stuff I was just very um connected to it very interested in it so of course video games computer games consoles we had an Atari actually even before we had that PC uh and then uh computer games in the 90s especially I found just um terribly fascinating I'm also a huge fan of tabletop role playing games and I've played dungeons of dragons since I was a kid in the 70s first edition so when that became an available thing to do on a computer when I didn't have a gaming group for that sort of thing then that was very very exciting for me so there was a moment though I mean all that's background but there was an actual moment when I was in this very building different office but I was in this in this building I'd gotten my job at you Milwaukee I had wrapped up uh my first book and I was looking at the Google homepage uh the famously Spartan Google homepage and it it still has I believe I don't go there I guess that all anymore but uh it has two buttons right it has a search bar and then it has search and then it has I'm feeling lucky now it doesn't do this anymore because the ad Revenue it would sacrifice ad Revenue but that I'm feeling lucky button I just

looked at that I just written a book about uh a particular culture's way of talking about and confronting in determinacy and luck there multiple conceptions of luck multiple words for things that we called luck we're very much a part of that and I see this button says I'm feeling lucky that's interesting and back then uh before they changed it if you clicked that button after typing in the search string it would take you directly to the first search result you would not see a list of search results it would just take you right to that page right and to me that was fascinating what is Google saying about luck here they are saying that there's an alignment of A Sort if this works for you they're saying that your ability your performative contingency your ability to come up with the search string in your head of what you should type into that search bar the social contingency of the guesswork right that is also involved in that uh all of the actions of everyone building web pages and all the links that they're building and then Google's algorithm crawling through them and developing ranks right that all of those are in alignment and that struck me as almost a kind very anthropological certainly but it it reminded me of you know the idea of a state of grace you know even all the way back to the Puritans right yeah everything fits you you are connected to this system in an important way so that got me thinking

about what's going on here why where is what is contingency to the experience of digitally Network Technologies uh what kinds of meanings are being generated through it so I uh knew I wanted to work with a company that was designing an online or computer game at least if not an online computer game uh and so I began putting that together and applying to the National Science Foundation and got funded and I happened to meet the people who were the principles of Lynden lab now Mo thank God because most of the companies who design computer games and the like are not exactly very open to academics most of the time uh but they were at Linden lab they were very excited about their project and not it was even more fascinating for me because they were not designing a game but they were using Game Design Elements all through that project it was very much informed by game design in important ways so that's how I uh ended up working with the folks at Lyon lab for about a year and a half I was there so how did embedding yourself into I guess kind of an office Game Dev culture uh differ from what you had done before where you actually travel to another place you learn another language and right dig it was much more uh institutionally structured um there there were there were boundaries on it u

in a different way right so there were in in the gambling B in Haya I was studying a city and trying to get a handle on uh that City and games there and by extension fair or not uh cre or Greek attitudes toward indeterminacy whereas with lynen lab uh by the by extension was really silicon Val in that era right uh but I will you have so much to do um if you want to understand an institution on its terms because its framework is such a dominating part of the lives of the people who work for that company uh that it was very different right it was manage uh navigating a bureaucratic structure uh but interestingly because they were a tech company in the post World War II America they were also trying to deny any vertical elements to their organization and say that they were a horizontal organization where everyone got to choose their own work uh so that created to me surprising but fascinating tension in the company as well interesting so you've looked at Second Life you've also you know very clearly over the course of later work developed an interest in digital games and I guess like digital communities or worlds MH um

so I guess uh I I do regard them with some suspicion and fear to be real but okay interesting um but when you study a a digital world I mean you I think that we have lots of conversations now about like but it's not real but you know you need to connect to your own life like I remember reading so many articles about people whose second life became their real life um so as an anthropologist I mean how is there any change in the tools that you use to study these places oh and you know how is the field like treating them right now I think for anthropology specifically in the academy we are coming up to speed on it now uh a little later than I would have liked developing field research methodologies for highly mediated technologically mediated social action was always difficult right so before digital Technologies and the internet if we want to think back to an Era of phones and shortwave landline phones and shortwave radio and television stations radio broadcast newspapers that was always those were always media through

which people were doing important things and there were important things at stake but you don't get to just sit somewhere and see that social action in front of you right uh and see it unfold it's distributed and it's asynchronous as we would say now uh so that was always creating some challenges and I think part of what anthropology did was a little bit of a retreat I mean there were some great people trying to do work in those areas but uh a retreat to the face- Toof face and the small scale and the village and those kinds of places but now uh I think it's very clear we don't have that luxury anymore so developing the tools to look at Human Experience when it's so saturated with digital affordances is is very difficult one of the things that guides my training of my graduate students my PhD students especially who do full length ethnographic research is to remember that one of our strengths as a discipline has always been this element of our methodology that we call participant observation right we were talking about the fact that I was observing games but I was Al also playing them and what participant observation does really really well is give the academy not just anthropology a window into social practice what people do their habits uh now when people report on what they do when you ask them why

they do things they're not very accurate right uh I there was some one of the famous early anthropologists said something like an oceanic golf separates what people do from what they say they do right uh so that methodology was always very very good at capturing that Dimension Of Human Action where there's a lot at stake there's a lot of consequences from that social action in Social practice how do we do that in digitally mediated contexts I think we have learned learned how to first of all treat a lot of the typed communication recorded communication that circulates on forums and in virtual world social media as its own kind of action I mean words are not just describers of things they don't just represent the world we actually accomplish things by saying things right there's a famous set of lectures called how to do things with words about that right and I think digital Technologies have foregrounded a lot of what are called uh representational uh Technologies like writing and video and audio so we have to look at that with an action-oriented perspective and uh treat it performatively same way in many respects we would treat someone you know walking across a room and slamming a tree down on a table right uh we have to be ready to see it as social action uh there's

there's more to it I don't want to get it we probably don't have time to get into the technical details but you have to contend with the fact that a lot of Communication online is onetoone you know what we used to call onetoone phone calls right personto person phone calls where you wouldn't be charged for the call way back in the day of the early phone system if you didn't reach the person you were trying to reach right uh that was person to person well that's how a lot of communication happens through digital Technologies now direct messaging right uh text messaging they're like how do we handle that as anthropol ologist it's challenging uh but people have done good work uh and not just anthropologists ethnographic work by people like TL Taylor who to me is the preeminent ethnographer of our digital lives and and every every book she's done has been uh tremendous right so that would be someone I would point to excellent so how do I ask this question I've just been like sitting here wondering about it so I'll just ask uh so you know before we got officially started according this conversation you mentioned that you you also have you you you're part of a certificate in digital cultures and you know we're talking about ethnographers online uh we're talking about studying human habits I guess my biggest question about how would you study a virtual community is that so we're all kind of embedded in different contexts this is true like I think that I make very specific assumptions about how I should proceed with my life because I I'm an American I grew up in Texas you know I have a very

spefic ific like cultural and economic background and like you know Society puts things in place that seem natural but we're following Pathways that have been kind of worn by you know many previous generations but when you're looking at digital culture how do you determine which human habits are really our habits and which are conditioned by the company or the creator of the digital product because I feel like when you when you look at a digital artifact you're looking at two things right you're looking at the the reaction of the person but you're also looking at the sculpting of the actual game World in order to elicit those reactions this is one of my PR primary areas of interest and especially my recent writing uh I guess I would start by suggesting that we don't want to draw too hard of a distinction between any of our habits uh our repeated practices our our competencies and the idea of something being constructed for us because everything we learned how to do how to walk how to ride a bike uh how to write uh were inculcated in us you know by uh people who taught us how to do things we learned often through my mises by observing people and following how they do things uh there's some wonderful examples out there of this kind of thing Body and Soul which is about a boxing gym on the south side of Chicago by Lo walk h great example of this learning

how to remake your body in order to be a boxer uh well shape how you move through the world right so I think we have we were always already having our habits our practices shaped by the institutions around us but you're right to point out that we belong to an increasing array increasing in number array of meaningful communities of practices they're sometimes called that can be dizzying right uh it was always true even in smallscale human societies before massive industrialization and capitalism it was always true even in those societies that there were multiple domains of life right multiple affiliations that people had to their age cohort right to a a gender identity however defined uh to a number of to to one local versus a whole bunch of different distinctions right but right now those distinctions are multiplied enormously and they're again distributed right so digital cultures to get back to that term is not meant to suggest that there are cultures that are online and then there are cultures that are not online but rather to get us to think a bit more about the way the digital Dimension is shaping all of our uh cultural experience and those cultural experiences are always multiple we belong to multiple cultural contexts

each of us cultural domains now that getting back to the point you concluded on right which these things are constructed for us how do we take them it's a great question why do we end up taking some dimension of the architectures that we use as natural we stop thinking about it stop questioning it take it for granted right uh sometimes I've heard culture defined is everything that goes go without saying right so when do we treat the architectures through which we move as things that go without say now that is in some ways a very old question if we think about something like a road system or a built environment those are infrastructures or architectures that we just take to be the background natural context for the action that we um that we make but the thing to notice about those built environments and infrastructures that but they are incredibly expensive to change they are uh durable and they they require a lot of moving of material uh to shape them you got to do a major renovation on a building that's that's a big ask right so the design decisions and I think the anthropology of design is a really exciting area to think about the design decisions behind those kinds of architectures and infrastructures are uh shaped by that invest and the durability in the time right but if we start thinking about

digitally um mediated or digitally even born or usually uh saturated infrastructures right a phone is a material object I guess what I'm saying here it's not just digital stuff right but so much of it is shaped by digital architectures well those digital architectures which we also easily take to be natural right and shape how we do things they can be be changed very very cheaply they can be updated they can you can have uh a what is it co-pilot AI uh appear in the browser you opened yesterday or they the uh word processor you opened yesterday where it wasn't and today it's there right because a decision was made somewhere else and that is a sweeping change to you your digital infrastructure that be tried out as a Gambit for you uh and for millions of other users and if it doesn't quite work the way it's intended it can be changed the next day those I those U moves that are made by institutions which can uh so quickly and so easily alter their commitments on one front or another uh mean that it is vastly easier I think for the those institutions to shape our expectations to shape our habits to get us locked in

to grab our eyeballs and get us Doom scrolling make use of the wonderful uh work and insights of someone like Natasha da but make use of the technology she studied uh in the production of video game and uh video poker and video slot machines how do they command attention press after press of the the button nickel after nickel of the slot that is game design behind the taken for granted architectures of our digital lives that's really interesting way to talk about it and you know as we're talking about digital cultures the other thing that's been I guess I think it's probably been on everybody's mind who like uses social media right is I would take like Twitter now X as an example of like I guess an interesting tear between the people who feel they do the culture on a site and therefore have ownership in it versus an actual physical owner it actually kind of makes me think of um uh actually all the way back to uh gambling life because you have people in Greece who are playing their games kind of under the radar they've got their own like little private gambling cultures and then you've got people who choose to engage with the lottery and with State gambling um and so I mean I guess yeah let's go back to that what's what did that initial research teach you about how people understand engaging with like

official or like institutional gaming or gaming that's owned or controlled by somebody else versus what they think they own themselves right uh the the work on Greece I didn't realize when I wrote the first book I never come across the specific history of it I wrote about it in a later piece that uh the development of the state sponsored Lottery was initially something that grew out of the very beginnings of the the Greek Republic after the Greek Civil War right so that was in the early 1950s the oldest of those state sponsored games is propo which is a soccer gambling game and the idea is that you will get a card for the week with all a set of Select matches from different leagues from very famous leagues to more and more obscure leagues right and you have to try and pick the winner or a tie for every one of those matches and then that gets fed into an algorithm that the state um had made use of now from the when institutions play games there's an expression in Greece Masia they're playing games with us right captures this idea very well when the state plays propo it's not playing

the same game as the citizens it's trying to establish an algorithm that will pay out properly right that will make them money but also incense participation from the from the winners so that's one of the big lessons of any kind of formally institutionally sponsored gambling whether it's casino gambling or state gambling nationally sponsored gambling is that at that point it's it's very different from say a hosting fee you might as you might call it so most of the gambling coffee houses that I did research in you know once an hour you are paying the proprietor for the time to play the game whereas institutions when they can uh structure participation in those games but also architect the uh actual algorithms and systems behind how that games generate the contingencies that engage their players they stand in a different position now for the Greeks there was this strange inversion you could say between probably still is you could say uh between their relationship with the Greek State and their paying of taxes and their participation for those who did in the state sponsored gambling not just the soccer game but also State sponsor lotteries and scratch ticket games and it had to do with the fact that they don't trust the Greek

State the United States for those who live in the United States the United States is a little odd in the way in which its idea as the idea of it as a nation and its political uh institution are the same thing they were born basically the same time but if you're country like Greece and many many other countries are like this too the idea of your nation the Greek nation has only an arbitrary uh and and contrived to many in Greece relationship with this particular constitutional Arrangement running the country right now right so there's a a very contentious and rebellious relationship with the Greek state which goes back to a bunch of Greek history and there the history under the Ottoman Empire and other important parts where a kind of resistance and rebellion was very rampant across modern the current territory what is modern day Greece but so this resistance against the state means that there's a lot of tax evasion in Greece and for them it's a game in a way right but it's an inverse game from participating in the state lotteries and gamblers would say to me you know um when I talk when they mention maybe they don't pay their taxes um actually was sorry we restate that and gamblers would mention to me when we talked about their losses and I would ask them about them they would say well those are my taxes I don't pay any the normal way

anyway so there there was a very uh complicated relationship but I think the idea that a nation state is going to run gambling and offer to its citizens these opportunities to get ahead uh has been a there's some great books about it but it's been an under examined aspect of nation state history in fact the Greek protests uh in GNA get the year wrong want to say something like 2011 uh right around the time of Greek austerity and there were massive protests in Greece uh began at the lottery story four reasons I talk about in one of my pieces so there's a there there's a charge relationship between the state and and games like this there's a wonderful book by Amy chazel uh about the an underground lottery in Brazil that's been running since the 1800s uh it was started by a baron who owned a zoo and it was a numbers game essentially people would walk around with this sheet with numbers on it and every number had an animal so numbers became associated with a different animal in the zoo to market the zoo and people would pick their pay their money and pick a number and if their number came in in the drawing they would win money and that had became the basis for the underground economy of Brazil and

was the focus of national efforts to wash it for many many many many years as she writes about so there's this fraught relationship uh between games of chance and institutions and from a players point of view I'll just conclude by saying this from a players point of view there's always is the chance that A Game's legitimacy the legitimacy of its indeterminate outcomes will be undermined by because of its institutional control that always raises the question of whether the fix is in right whether that institution is uh cheating behind the scenes whereas our local games are governed they also need to be legitimate with the questions of whether they are whether there's cheating or monitored in much more direct ways typically interesting so kind speaking of sports betting you know one of the the most striking amusing maybe a little concerning things I read in in your book um was you discussing two guys just kind of sitting around having a drink and watching flies and like making bets on whether they would land on particular pieces of fruit yeah and I mean good Lord uh but what do you what do you I guess do you have any opinions about or have you been considering um um things like DraftKings now where people can really bet on not only the outcome of sports games but of many many sort of micro things within a game and you know what does that say about us based on what you know about

gambling and how should we approach that I think it's an area of really really great concern to me there's a book called selling hope about state lotteries uh from this book from the 80s and it's one of many critical works on state sponsor gambling that makes the point that when people are caught up in an economically disadvantageous situation and often with respect to dire circumstances a medical bill comes in often their only hope will be to try and win the L and there's something terribly tragic about that right when and and especially when you think about the fact that that Lottery is offered by the state right so someone in a in a vulnerable position um and we don't have political institutions uh except for at least some level of responsibility for protecting us from vulnerabilities whether they be natural disasters or house fires or any a number of other things that that are supposed to be provisioned Services provisioned counteract those things so when people are in Des desperate circumstances they will turn to these kinds of mechanisms but the development of sports gambling has taken that to a different level and I think the element

of It's a combination let me say say that again let me restate that the development of sports scandling has taken all of that to a different level and I see it as a combination of the rise of technologies that can command our attention as I was mentioning before uh the scrollable media driven by algorithms that resemble video poker and video slot machines it's almost endless how an interface for any given app can be improved to make it reach out to that deeply human aspect of our experience that makes us want to uh pay attention when there's unpredictability and pay attention when there's pattern especially if the balance between those is just right just enough to be fascinating right and for us to think about maybe if I do this action I'll see a change like this in the pattern if I do that action at the same time these kinds of sports betting systems including proo in Greece were always in part about gender identity about the demonstration of Mastery and in many countries in the western tradition cultures of of the West shall we say and others too

masculinity very frequently gets bound up with ideas of demonstrating Mastery of especially of complex systems I know Sakura so I'm going to fill this out and you're going to fill yours out and we're going to debate but we're going to see who knows this game better and if I win then I know soccer better than any other player in this country kind of idea DraftKings these kinds of Technologies are very much tied to ideas of the demonstration of Mastery and that's been a big part of gaming history uh there's a Incredible Book by uh Carly Kirk called coin operated Americans and Carly is an historian and it's about the video game arcade of the 70s which is when I was a kid and going to video game arcade loving and her argument is uh the subtitle reboot rebooting Boyhood at the American arcade and in that era this post-war United States era masculinity is increasingly defined not by Mastery over uh large machines gross motor skill related stuff agricultural Factory heavy stuff and increasingly defined by still Mastery but over fine

motor skills uh command of complex systems think of the NASA engineers and the celebration of them as a kind of masculinity the the engineer working for a a big Corporation GE IBM and the way in which they are someone who is uh demonstrating their masculinity by knowing how to manipulate and innovate in a complex environment Carly kerk shows that the video game arcades of the 70s are about a very similar set of projects for these players and they as you would predict get celebrated they get celebrated nationally they're on the cover the high scores for all of these different games are being recorded at an Iowa video game arcade people are calling in and telling the high score someone got on Galaga or whatever it was and those people gather they're gathered in Iowa and Life Magazine takes a photo of all of them and it's all boys and they shoot it like a varsity team they even get cheerleaders from the local high school to dress up as cheerleaders and pose around these video game players right so the the gender angle on this is so obvious and important right so getting back to the question of these sports betting

concerns I think they are profiting massively on both the Innovations of technology to command our attention that all of us are experiencing along with the the game of being masculine that's been in place in the West for a long time and then layered onto that a lot of loneliness and economic disadvantage that uh that are reported when people study men right lack of close relationships uh lack of social connection and I think those companies have stepped into that breach interesting concerning it'll be really interesting to see how it all kind of plays out in the future all right I have one more kind of hard question before I ask you a couple softies uh and by heart I mean like I guess rude but I don't mean it that way so like just for context I wrote my dissertation about Coptic monks I am no stranger to the ostensibly impractical but I feel like in our current culture uh especially as we talk about grants and you know not wasting money etc etc you know I know there are people who say oh a full bright to go gamble in Greece like oh you know um a n was it National Science Foundation science you know Grant to go hang out at a company and watch a video game get developed why is this work important

and what can we do to engage with it more and kind of help appreciate it right I think it's a great question I think we should always be ready to answer those kinds of questions I view the academy and its long Tradition at its best as the place where we rigorously try to answer the questions that we have about the world about Society about ourselves and of course one can always find some odd examples of research projects which make one scratch one head but I think any research on games is relatively easy to communicate the importance of its relationship to the things we're curious about to people out there in in the world and that's simply be because games increasingly saturate our experience and you can make the argument in strictly economic terms very easily just by pointing to how much money is in the game industry uh if you consider both computer and analog games we're talking about something that is much larger than the film industry for example that's a lot of money and where the money is is where people's uh meaningful experiences often are so what's going on there uh and why has it grown the way it has those I think are really good questions

for the Greece work I think as well it comes back to what's meaningful for Greeks what happens in the gaming table is culturally meaningful it's something they talk about it's something that is part of the currency of their social relations so if we were to ignore that we would be ignoring a big part of what makes their lives meaningful to them uh more to the point when we look at how in any given cultural context people confront the contingencies of their experience may be things like uh terrible diagnosis and in medicine or accidents or natural disasters any of these dramatic contingencies which call for social support and create real challenges for for meaning people ask questions like why me right uh we need to do a good job of being in a position to understand where their language for those things come from where else do they use that language how does their attitude toward this thing that they face Maybe reflect something we could see when the is not going down when someone is not facing a terrible tragedy but they are facing the contingencies of a game they will because we're cultural

people cultural beings they will display the same kind of habits and uh talk about things in similar terms so that would be how I would talk about how this research can help us then on top of that I think it's pretty easy to point out and we're all pretty aware of I think you even referenced it before increasing concern about how social media and mobile devices digital Network Technologies are commanding our attention and shaping attitudes and and habits and perhaps getting in the way of meaningful social connections and I think games are a big part of that game design is a big part of that excellent all right so now you get a couple softy questions at the end uh so you mentioned you love to play games uh have you played anything recently that you really enjoyed boy well uh I've just started dming a new campaign in Dungeons and Dragons set in the uh dungeons of drenim campaign setting from the dungeon dudes Monty Martin Dr Monty Martin also recently got his PhD and Kelly mlin uh which I just am super excited about um I think it's a wonderful setting I what I really like about it is that it's a world without the clear hero answer where everyone's going to solve every problem so it's a cosmic horror setting so that's really fun uh I play uh console games quite regularly um

sometimes almost meditatively right just to you know take a break from things during the day so Hades is wonderful for that I think it's it's a beautifully designed game and rich in content but also incredibly replayable so I like that one very much uh we will try out new board games from time to time I'm not going to remember the name of it but my son and his fiance brought this game which is very very distinctive board it's like a a color palette it's like it's like paint swatches a whole bunch of boxes of different tones of color and then you uh you get a card and you you basically can use a word to describe the color you see on the card without using the name of the color and then people try to like an object that has that color and people put their tokens guessing where on the board your color must be and that was just wonderful I love games that invite us to be social in that way it's the reason games like fictionary or uh charade type games I think are so popular right they get us performing for each other in this gentle uh and open-ended way awesome are you talking perhaps about Hughes and q's Hughes and qes I used Google to try it's got to be it's got to be it uh it was really really fun uh my my children are often bringing uh games to me that I don't know about uh it's how I played exploding kittens for the first time and

uh um what's the Tokyo one with all the mo all King of Tokyo King of Tokyo you know a lot of that stuff uh we played over the years and just had a great deal of fun with but usually they ask me for the holidays to DM for them so I've been dming one shots actually it's no longer a one shot but once a year we get together and they each are playing a different character from the movie Rise of the Guardians uh which is got like a Santa type character and an Easter Bunny type character and all these things they love that movie so I've been kind of depowering those Heroes and putting them in the Middle Ages and they're slowly trying to work up to fight the the big batty pitch at the end so that should be oh that's so fun uh and if people want to follow your work online where do you like to be found yeah so I have a web page uh Thomas m.net um it's set up as a Blog uh again while I'm chair things are very difficult uh to find time for that kind of thing we also have our collaboratory the um digital cultures collaboratory uh you can find that with a quick Google search at wwm in addition most of my published work that can be freely available is on my academia.edu page so that's a place where you can find a lot of my work I was felt very fortunate to be able to open publish um make available my chapter called the digitally natural which is from the r companion to media media anthropology that just came out

either last year or the year before and that's one where I talk about a number of these ideas about how we take our digital environment to be Beyond question excellent Thomas thank you so much for coming on the show I very much enjoyed this conversation and I'm really grateful for your time it's a lot of fun Liz uh thanks for the opportunity and you can find me online absolutely all right everybody out there you know what to do please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming you

Progress saved