Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 25:08

Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the discriminating gamer. Say, what's the difference between a good lawyer and a great lawyer? A good lawyer knows the law. A great lawyer knows the judge. Today, ladies and gentlemen, we're going to go ahead and take a look at First Monday in October from Fort Circle Games.

In the First Monday in October from Fort Circle Games, one to four players take on the roles of various institutions or schools of thought as they attempt to guide the court over its long history to arrive at their own particular ideas of how legality should be interpreted in the United States. Now, the game board is three game boards. Essentially, you have the main game board in which you have the space for the nine Supreme Court justices. Yes, yes, yes. I know over time that number goes up and down, but for our purposes through the whole game, we've got nine Supreme Court justices. I mean, be times there'll be less, but basically there's space for the nine Supreme Court justices. And you also have a space for the four different judicial philosophy tracks. I'll talk more about them in just a minute. And then of course, you've got the last section of board and you're going to have some different information here. You're going to have, of course, a breakdown of kind of some of the sections of the game, but you're going to have the robing room and more on that in a minute. And you're also going to have candidates. These are people who aspire to be on the Supreme Court and you're going to try to help them.

Now each player is going to kind of have their action board which contains all of the various actions they can do in a turn. They're going to take two kind of regular action tokens and then a Supreme action token. Uh you're also going to take a number of influence cubes and a number of clerks that will be available to you during the game. Now also too at the very beginning, each player is going to take three kind of judicial philosophy cards and these represent exactly where they want these philosophy tracks to be at the end of the game for scoring purposes. But they're going to draw three of them and over the course of the game, because the game plays out in three eras, at the end of each era, you're actually going to discard one until you've got one left that's going to be kind of basically how you want the court to look. Now as I say, you've got these judicial philosophy tracks. There are four tracks. You have commerce, you have executive power, you have freedom of speech, and you have equality and liberty. Now all of these things are in a tug of war, essentially. Do you want kind of greater freedom for the people?

Do you want more government control? What's the balance there? So essentially, when you select these philosophy cards, you're trying to get these you want to have these different philosophies on one side of that debate or the other. And if they're on the extreme part of that debate, meaning they're in the last three spaces, you may get even more points for that. Now also too at the beginning of the game, you're going to have starting justices. So you're going to place these starting justices out. Uh I think believe there's more than nine. You're going to place nine out and I think the others go back in the box. And then you're going to create a deck of other justices that will come out. So you shuffle all the ones together, all the twos together, and all the threes, threes together, representing the different eras. Threes on the bottom, twos in the middle, ones on top. And they're going to be the next ones to come out. In fact, you're going to put the first three on the deck in the candidate spot on the board there.

But you're also going to have the cases. And the cases themselves likewise are in three different eras, the first, second, and third era. You're going to shuffle them each individually and build third on the bottom, second in the middle, first on top. [clears throat] Now, what you're going to do during the course of the game is you're going to put out three initial cases. And there's different areas on the board as they're and they're going to be kind of pushing, moving to the right. Now, once they get to the last spot on the right, this is decisions. And you're going to want to influence the cases before they get to decisions in order to score them. Now, each of the decisions reflect one of the judicial philosophies. So, when the card comes out, you're actually going to put a marker showing whether it is toward more government control or more freedom on that particular issue.

And that's going to kind of determine some of the aspects of how you can try to get influence on those cards, get clerks on those cards. Now, play is going to go around and around. Each player takes an action, then the players the clockwise until you've all taken the three actions, the two regular actions and the supreme action. Now, all things being equal, there are six different actions you can take in the game, both with the regular version and a supreme version. The first thing you can do is gather influence. You'll be spending influence in this game. It's a resource, it's a currency. So, you can take your colored resource kind of from the general pool and put it kind of into your specific personal pool that you can use. Ordinarily, you can just use four, but if you do the gather if you do the supreme action for gather in influence, you can gain seven influence cubes. You're trying to put your clerks on the different case cards.

And how you do that is essentially you play do an advocate action. Now, with the regular advocate action, what you are doing is you have to spend influence in order to to put a clerk on of those cubes. The number of influence points you spend must be equal to its location on the docket. It could be zero, could be much more. Further to the right it is. You also have to play two more influence if that case is already on the side that it is indicated. So it's already a winning case. It's going to cost you more to get on it. And then it will cost you one more if there is another co-counsel on there. For every other player on there, it's going to cost you another influence cube to get onto that one as well. Now if you take the supreme action, you have to spend two more cubes and a renown point, that's a victory point, in order to put an additional clerk on there. So you can put two clerks on there instead of just one. Now you can attempt to retire a judge. Now if there are already four vacancies on the on the Supreme Court, you can't do this. But otherwise, what you can do is add a age cube to that judge, meaning you try to want to get them out of the way.

If you take the supreme action, you can go ahead and actually add three retirement cubes to that judge. Now when you take this particular action, you're going to actually roll to see if these judges actually do retire, if they've been on the court long enough. Now they have different die on them. Each each Supreme Court justice has a die. And these die, they're different sided die, so they can be more or less likely to leave the bench. So essentially what happens is you roll a die. Now if the die roll is equal to or lower than the number on cubes on that justice, that justice retires. Now here's what's interesting. The justices have kind of their judicial philosophy in the top part, but then their retirement, what happens to them when they go into retirement, which kind of works in the opposite direction. So when a judge retires, it's going to manipulate the philosophies. They may go up or down any number of spaces when a judge retires.

Now you can also support a candidate. As as say, there's going to be three justices that are candidates that potentially can come on the Supreme Court. You can add a clerk to one of them, or if you take the supreme action, you can add two clerks to one of them. Now, you can potentially do a law review article. If you do a law review article, you can move any one of the tracks up or down one space. But if you have influence with any of the justices, and I'll explain more on that in a minute, you can actually look at what their judicial philosophies are, and you can manipulate up to three spaces one of their judicial philosophies. Finally, you can do the rest action. Now, the rest action is the judges in the robing room and the robing room track. If you do the regular action, you can just move up one space. If you do the supreme action, you can move up two spaces. But each space has uh kind of an action that you can resolve, and if you move two, you can resolve them both. I'm not going to go through all the actions here, but they let you do fun and interesting things, gain advantages, gain certain tiles that let you do fun and interesting things, maybe swap around cases on the docket. There's all sorts of things you can do as you advance along the robing room.

Now, once all the players have gone, you go to the adjudication phase. The first thing you do is elevate. You look and see if there are any uh open spaces, if there's any vacancies on the Supreme Court, and whoever's ever got the most candidates on the Supreme Court, uh who's got the most support, they will advance. And those uh clerks, whoever put them there, will now have influence with that specific judge. As soon as that judge gets up there, you adjust the judicial philosophies by by the philosophies they support. So you're going to go ahead and manipulate the philosophies track. And you can do this twice. So after you do the first one, you can then place a second one assuming there's a second vacancy. If the remaining justices don't have any uh clerks on them, you simply take the top clerk and elevate them.

But critically, you can only elevate two clerks at this You can only elevate two justices, rather, at this time. Next, you have appeal. Essentially, this is where you slide all of the cases on the docket one space to the right, and you place a new uh case on the docket. Next, you're going to score cases in decision. So, every player that has a clerk on the space or on the side, rather, of that decision that matches where the judicial philosophy is at that time, they will score. If it's tied, they'll each score kind of the secondary level. Places that are kind of or clerks that are tied for second place won't score at all. But you'll go ahead, you'll score them. And then there's certain uh events that may trigger as a result of that case being played out. Now, critically as well, if you are on the uh winning side, you can write an opinion. If you have a justice who has a philosophy that matches the philosophy that just won, you can remove the clerk in order to score one more renown point.

Conversely, uh and actually you can do that multiple times if you have multiple clerks on justices with that philosophy. But if you are on the losing side of that particular case, you can remove one of your uh clerks from a justice uh any justice, as I understand. I think that's correct. Uh you can remove them from the justice to do a descent, and that will gain you one renown point. Next, you age. You have three aging uh die. You go ahead and you roll them. These are 10-sided die. If you get the zero, nothing happens. But otherwise, one through nine, you're going to be placing the aging cubes on the various justices. This is the natural aging of these uh fellows as they get closer and closer to retirement. Now, through natural aging, if a justice receives enough cubes that their die roll would automatically remove them, they then retire from the bench, leaving a vacancy.

Next, you moderate. If any of the judicial philosophies are all the way to the end of one track, you move them one space toward the center, regardless of uh which side they're on. Next, you're going to pass the gavel to the next first player, and then you are going to check the eras. If either the case deck or the justice's deck has moved to the next era, you're going to remove all of the other cards from that era from the other deck as well. Some other events may trigger if the era is passing. And critically, you're going to get rid of one of your judicial philosophy cards, narrowing down the scope of what your philosophy will be for the end game. Now, as soon as the last card is drawn from either the case or the uh justices deck, the candidates deck, you are now finished with the game. You can The round should be completed. You are at the end and you move to final scoring.

You're going to score the card on the decision. Uh you're going to score the next two spaces on the track as well, although you won't be able to do um dissents or opinions as a result of the scoring those cards. Now, there's something called case breadth. For every player who has a complete set of the four different judicial philosophies who has won four of those cards, they immediately gain five points. Now, you also have case depth. For every player that has the most uh cards in a specific uh philosophy, they're going to gain two points. Uh the second most player would gain one point. You're going to score for bench influence. The player with the most clerks on the bench will score five. The second most will score three. Now, throughout the game, as you are writing dissents, you're gaining a point or a renown point for that, but you are also gaining a dissent token. Now, at the end of the game for final scoring, whoever has the most dissent tokens, they are going to win four renown points. The second most player will with renown uh dissent tokens will win two renown points.

Finally, players are going to check their judicial philosophies. They're going to look on the board to see exactly how they score. Again, they're going to score more points if their philosophies are in the extreme last three spaces of either of those track. Players are going to go ahead. They are going to add together all of their renown points and whoever has the most wins first Monday in October. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now, back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen, first Monday in October. Before I say anything else, one thing I do want to let you know, and that is I am currently in talks with Fort Circle Games to publish a game I have designed.

Now, we're still in the early stages. May happen, it may not happen, but I just wanted to be up front. And that relationship with Fort Circle Games in no way colors my feelings about this particular game. [clears throat] So, last year in March of 2025 I attended Circle DC, which is Fort Circle Games convention. And and I don't do a lot of conventions, but I was really excited. One of the reasons why I went there was to discuss the possibility of my game being published through Fort Circle. But I was really excited to go to this convention. It was a great opportunity to go back to DC and I did some work in the National Archives while I was there. And it was just it was just a great experience. The convention itself was a lot of fun, but easily the highlight of the convention for myself and for my wife was they through the convention they offered a tour of the United States Supreme Court building. And so we went to the United States Supreme Court and we were able to go into the actual chamber there, the actual courtroom.

We went and saw the library and all sorts of other fun and interesting places within the Supreme Court building. We had a guided tour. It it was awesome. I'd never been there before. I mean, walked past it before, but I'd never been inside the building. And it was just so cool to actually feel the history of of that building. And it's interesting to know the building's not that old, right? Supreme Court met in all sorts of places. I think that building was made like in the 30s, I think. But it's it's history and you think of all the history that that has been made in that building and and and with that court. So that was pretty cool. Now, immediately after our tour, we went just across the street to the Supreme Court Historical Society which they actually hosted a play through of this game. We were able to play this game. Talia, the designer, was there and taught us this game.

And so my wife and I, two other people, we played through our game of First Monday in October. And I won. [sighs] So that game, I had a really good experience with that game. I really enjoyed it quite a bit. And in the last year or so, the more I thought about it, I was wondering, now did I really like that game? Did I really enjoy that game? Or was it just the experience and kind of being caught up at having just gone to the Supreme Court, was that what I really liked? And so I've been looking forward to getting a copy of this game to do a full review. I received this copy not too long ago, and my friends and I jumped on it. This is one I wanted to get played again. I've been eager to play this game again. It had been long enough I couldn't remember the rules, so of course I read through the the the the rule book again, and my friends read through the rule book. And so we sat down to play it. And one of the first things I will say is I think this is actually a very intuitive game. I think the rule book is is well [snorts] written. I think it's easy to understand concepts and ideas in this game, which is something I really really really appreciate.

There's nothing worse than a otherwise fun game that's got kind of a screwy rule book. And this is I think a really really well done rule book. So we sat down and we played the game, and very quickly we pick it up. And this is a game that moves very quickly when you know what you're doing and you know all the phases, you know all the actions, and you pick all these things up as I say again, very very quickly, very easy to learn. And we're playing through the game, and I instantly remembered why I really like this game. This is a very fun game on a lot of levels. First of all, the theme here is not something you would necessarily think would be that engaging, and yet it absolutely is.

The way the different mechanisms here all come together and all work with that theme and through that theme is really a lot of fun. Now each of the justices' cards come out, they are actual justices. There's a little flavor text that talks about them there. Uh, that is really cool and interesting just to see them come out from the different eras. I really liked that, but the idea of the cases themselves that come out, that is very cool and that, you know, the different cases about all sorts of things that have shaped American history. So you're really you are really learning a lot of history as these cases come out and and play across the board here. Uh, so the history element here is great. Of course, as many of you know, I'm a historian, so I love love love games that really engage with history in new and fun and unique ways. I've never seen a game that engaged with history quite like this one. So I really appreciated it on that thematic level.

Mechanically, this is really kind of an area majority game. You're trying ultimately to get the most clerks on the different cases and try to to to figure out when they are going to uh you know, at what point they're going to get there and when they actually get there to the decision are the judicial philosophies going to be there to support it or the judicial philosophy going to be there to support it because the game can change a lot. There are a lot of different actions people can do. One of the big things is uh you know, if you see a you see a case coming up and you don't want that particular side to win, one of the things you can do is you can try to retire a judge that a justice that is when he leaves, it's going to alter the constitution of the judicial philosophies. So you make that your play.

You can also again just try to manipulate the the the the philosophies directly. I should point out too, the Chief Justice, when the Chief Justice is appointed, uh everything is double and when he retires, everything is double. So you can really swing the philosophies by targeting the Chief Justice, but you don't just have to target the Chief Justice. You can target the others to in order to get those swings and to get the philosophies on the side you want them on. And then there's also that decision of well, I can go for that case, but they've already got somebody on there. So it's going to cost me more on there. And then even if I get on there, I'm probably going to end up having to share the points. So that is that's unless I can get a lot on there. So that's a very fun part of the game too. Now also when you win or lose cases, you can write the opinions or the dissents. The dissents and the opinions just give you a point immediately.

Uh the dissents will also give you these those tokens so you can potentially score points at the end of the game. But critically in order to do that, you have to remove influence from a justice. And it's hard to get the the influence on the justices. Really the only way is to support the candidates uh as they move up. There may be something on the roving room. I can't remember. But you're supporting the candidates. And that's another great thing is you want to support certain candidates that match you the judicial philosophies you want either for those cases or for your long-term philosophy. So you want to support those candidates. But if you go ahead and you put clerks on there, somebody else can turn around and put clerks on somebody else and you can find yourself outvoted and there's not enough room for you. And if like I said, the two others go on, that one is just eliminated, you lose you lose the influence you just spent there. You lose the actions for it. Uh so there's a lot of really really really great decisions here.

And more than that, more than the decisions you make in this game too, just the basic mechanisms like the the retiring the judges and how you're you know, you're randomly adding the aging cubes to them with the die rolls. But then critically on your turn, one of the actions you can take is to try to retire a justice. Uh that is really cool. I really really like First Monday in October. In fact, I've liked every game I played from Fort Circle Games, Votes for Women, Shores of Tripoli, uh Blackbeard. I've I've really liked all the games this company has put out. But I have to say hands down, this is my favorite. This is my favorite Fort Circle game that I have played. It is really a lot of fun. Great competition. And and and and in that competition, I think maybe more than anything that I love about this game is there is a lot of take that. There's a lot of you've got these plans and somebody can go ahead and they can play cards, they can manipulate the justices, and it could just screw over what you're trying to do. It happens every game.

Uh so the best you can do is try to make those plays to optimize the points you can get, but but there's there's I don't want to say chaos, but there's a lot of you never know what anybody else is going to do. And so you're, you know, like Von Moltke, no plan survives contact with the enemy. Well, no plan you come up with is going to survive contact with this court as all these other players are manipulating what you're doing. This is a fantastic game. Um I really like it. I actually am You know, I do for my Western Civ classes, I actually have board game night, but most of those deal with kind of European topics. Um one of my colleagues uh I'm trying to get her to do American history uh games uh for a game night. And I think this is one I would definitely bring to that cuz this is this is such a fun and clever and fairly easy to learn and easy to teach game. Really really like it. I'm babbling now, but I am a big fan of First Monday in October.

This is one I can't recommend enough. Uh I've really thought about the score, and I was initially thinking an eight or an 8.5, but the more I've thought about it, the more I enjoy this game. And after the times I've played it, I'm I'm going to say it's a nine. I'm going to give this game a nine out of 10. Thoroughly thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank you once again for joining us today on The Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. Tell us your thoughts. Please please please like this video and subscribe to our channel if you haven't done so already. That means a lot. You can also check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, books on history, fun things like that, and I even put up some of my lectures there. Again, it would mean the world to me if you would subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what you see here on TDG, I would humbly ask you to click on the Super Thanks button and leave a tip.

You know, my grandfather knew the exact date, year, and time of day he was going to die. He wasn't psychic. The judge told him.

[screaming]

I'm not the first player of this round. You are the first player.

No, you you were the first player of this round.

No.

No, you were the worst player of this round.

I?

Yes.

Oh.

Yeah, then Mike got the last round.

I want to trade.

Progress saved