Skip to main content
Loading video...

Realm of Reckoning Review: What Do You Reckon?

Transcript 18:48

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel.

I'm Chris Ye.

I'm Mike Delisio.

Today we're taking a look at one of the newest games from IV Studio called Realm of Reckoning. And it's about stuff. People are fighting the

king, right? The king. The king is dying or sickly [snorts] or something.

He's getting reckoned together.

It's the queen. Oh,

yes.

The queen is dead, boys.

It's an oddity because it's not necessarily not thematic and it's a it's a game where you're going to be fighting over different areas and well having reckonings of these realms. Um, but at the end of the day, yeah, I don't really know what it's about exactly, but I do know how to play it and I'm about to show you. Okay, the first thing I want to talk about here is scoring. So, during this game, in each of the different eras, you're going to be scoring or you're going to be having three rewards cards. And players are going to be picking these rewards based off of area control on these spots on the board. And when the players win, whoever wins picks one of these rewards. There's a negative one. This is for four players. These will change based on number of players. So, someone's going to get something bad. But one of the things that you will get is putting out a scoring marker. And you're going to pick something on the board to score. And these will score at the end of each of the errors. And they also will So, if the first ones that are put out one are going to score three times. So, there's only going to be nine of them placed down here. And you'll notice there's a lot more spaces than nine. And some of these are going to get points based on how far people are on these tracks. Some of them are going to get points based on icons that people have in front of them on cards. So, these cards will have different icons.

I'll talk about that in a little bit more. Some will give points if you have neighbors with fewer symbols. Some will get points if you have majority here. But basically, players are going to decide what scores over the course of a game. The game is a drafting game. Each round of the game, players are going to be looking through a handful of cards, picking one of these cards to play and then passing it around the table. In each era, there's a couple of scoring cards that will be shuffled into the deck. You're not sure what colors, but when they come up, if you play this card, there will be what is called a reckoning or you will score to put out those markers I just mentioned. But whenever you get a card, you will get whatever it play a card, you'll get whatever it shows on it. So, for example, this one gives three coins. This lets you draw two cards and so on and so forth. When you play it though, you're going to decide which part you're going to tuck under. I can tuck it underneath here on the top under blue or I can tuck it underneath the bottom here at yellow. And cards have two things on them. If it shows arrows, you're going to move on the track that many spaces.

If it shows these symbols, they will possibly count for scoring at the end of the game if that scoring is triggered. For example, the red one. But if that one's triggered, you're going to get points for the number of different symbols that you have on this red one. At the same time, I might want to move up the track on red or I might So, you're going to have to make that choice when you play the card. You always get the middle and then you'll get a choice on where to put that card. Each player's board tells you what you start with. Like this one says you start with one on the blue track, two on the pink track, and you also start with one of these big guys here. And players are going to be collecting these. These are called warden tokens. And this is going to matter when we score. So when an area is scored, there's a couple things that are going to happen. The person who scores it gets to pick one of these pillars and move it to that area. That matters because that's those are the colors that matter for that area. That means you're going to count you have stuff on the tracks and you're going to have these mercenary cards that you'll be able to play in that area. Now, there's going to be people in the area and you're going to whenever there's an area that you are basically fighting over, players are going to be secretly picking a power and whoever has the most power is going to get the first choice of rewards in this card, etc., etc. Remember, one person will get a negative reward. So, everyone's going to pick power. But where does that power come from? Well, by removing these guys in the area will give you one power for each one that you remove. Wardens that match the color of

the pyramids that are in the area will give you three if you discard that warden or if you don't it just gives you one power. There are mercenary cards that will give you power. So if I play this mercenary card for example, it gives me one cuz there's a blue pyramid there. If I play this one, it gives me two because there's a blue and a yellow there. So you can spend mercenary cards. You can also move down tracks to get power in these areas. And you can spend coins, although you have a limited amount of coins you can spend. One coin gives you one power. Another two coins gives you another power. Another three coins gives you a third power. So, you have to be able to pay all the power that you bid. Players will see Terminus, reveal it, and then we'll resolve it. Each person paying the stuff for their power and then getting the rewards. At the end of an era, after all the cards been drafted and played, we'll score for whatever statues are on the board. So like this one here is eight points for eight points for every southern region where you have majority. This one here will give you points depending on where you are on the yellow track etc. After three eras, whoever has the most points is the winner of the game.

Realm of Reckoning is a very interesting game in many ways because like many IV Studio games, it feels like it's outside the box of general game design.

They have a they they have a style right at at IV Studio. They've had a lot of different types of games, but they all seem to have some certain hallmarks. And one of them is slightly skewed from center, right? They they feel slightly different. Very interactive usually. And this is certainly no uh you know variance from that.

Yeah. It's kind of like when you watch a movie director that you know like oh this is going to be another one of the you know the guy who did Grand Buda Pest Hotel.

Well Anderson and designed Realm of Reckoning.

That's exactly what we're saying.

But yeah, but there's definitely a style to it. But I say that because again it has that same look where everything is dark and there's, you know, bright color inks on a dark background, which I like. Fine. This one is so dark. Let's just get that out of the way. This board is almost to the point of bland. Like I I would believe that Ivy Studio had stock in a black ink manufacturer.

It is. It is very sty. All their games are stylized. This is maybe the most. And I think that this one, you know, strays into the into the realm, pun intended, of slightly affecting the usability. I think there are some production issues with this one that I wish had been addressed.

Uh, but that's, you know, specific from the gameplay.

Well, no, but I think I do think it is a minor complaint that I have also. And that's that, you know, I'd made a joke at the beginning about I don't know what the theme is, but it doesn't help. Everything is black. Yeah. and the scoring, which is so critical.

Every time I play it, I put a token, I'm like, what's that scoring again?

And I kind of wish it was just a little easier to see what was going on.

Yeah. And that things were a little more delineated as far as like what. Yeah. Things along those lines I think could have been handled better. Um, and that is probably most of what my negatives would be would be about the production and some of the usability concerns I have with it. I also think and this not a negative but I mean we mentioned how the stuff skews a little bit. This whole idea of how the reckonings work

is not a common thing done in games. In fact the game that does this

very similarly is Twilight Struggle

where you have those scoring cards that you will draw and play them and then you're like oh Europe scoring. Oh, you know I need to prepare for that. And that's kind of how this is too. They do a good job at, you know, making sure probably every color realm will score, although maybe not.

Um, but they also do a good job at kind of the way things maneuver, but that's a little bit oddities because it's all about area control. But that area control only matters really,

not not only matters, but mostly matters to place those scoring things. And that's the thing, that's the element of the game that I think is particularly interesting is that you can set up, you know, the game theoretically so that the area control or area majority is not really affecting the scoring all that much. But to be able to do that, to be able to choose the things that don't prioritize area control, you have to have area control and take that scoring marker. Right? So there's this little kind of an odd pushpull thing where you cannot you cannot ignore area majority or at least

if you are you have to be in a position where you can pivot to what other people are picking to score

variable selected endgame scoring is one of my favorite mechanisms. Actually, this is end of round scoring because the the the special conditions that you trigger in round one are going to score at the end of round one and two and three,

which makes the one round the most important essentially.

Yeah, it's one of my favorite mechanisms and I think that it is done well in this game. We have a few little complaints about like when it's your turn to choose, you're like, "Oh gosh, okay. Oh, what's that one do again?"

Mhm. But that kind of speaks to the fact that there's a lot of options for what can score set collection of different cards that you've tucked or symbols or icons on those cards or uh you know the map now matters the northern regions and the southern region majorities that scoring is turned on and that's not going to be necessarily every other game. Uh, so it's it's very fun and I love that it is player driven and sometimes you're in the space where you've won an area majority battle and then you say, "Okay, but what what do I want to activate?" Scoring is I'm going to help somebody else. So, how do I kind of ooh, what's going to help me the most, but I know I'm going to have to also lift up some other players in the process. There good good chunky decisions in this. Yeah, and it is definitely a game that rewards multiple plays because as Mike said, that first that first round is so important because those things score three times.

Yeah.

And you're like, I guess this thing don't you can't do that. Now, in your first game, you can, but when you come back around and then also knowing like one of my favorite things in this game are the um wardens.

Yeah,

because they give you that plus one. They're great. I should get as many wardens as I can, but they give you three if you discard them. Ah, I really need to discard demon, but I'll wait till the final turn and I'm not sure. And then I don't know if I mentioned this in the overview, but let me mention it now. If you are the farthest on different tracks, you get these extra boards that give you special abilities.

Yeah.

And whoever's the farthest on the board, you can take a board from someone else if that if you go farther on the track than they do.

And that's a really big deal having that free one gives you free money. one gives you uh they they give you different cards

boost things that you normally would do.

They boost things and having those boosts is a good feeling to have, but also um the game tempts you all the time to pull back on that track so that you can win the area majority. Everything about this game is use your resources. Use them, use them, use them, use them. But also if you don't, you're okay. And I'm like, ah. And the game and the other players force a lot of tough decisions.

Yeah. The two things that have kind of been mentioned are my favorite aspects of the games. Uh playerdriven scoring I've mentioned many times is one of my favorite mechanisms ever. This does that uh in a very interesting way uh very impactful way as well. And I this isn't the right terminology exactly but it almost feels sandboxy in the sense that it's sandboxy in its economy. So basically you're getting all of these resources, right? And those resources all have some type of inherent use or value. Okay? But they are also all used to drive auctions, which is another one of my favorite mechanisms as a game is an auction game. And this has some of the most interesting use of auctions I've ever seen in that basically everything you have can be used as currency to boost your area of majority.

Absolutely.

It's so brilliant. It's like these coins I can use as influence essentially in a region in a realm and I may not even need these coins unless coin scoring is activated. And so it's like you have this constant evaluation and re-evaluation of what are your resources worth, right? Those mercenary cards are inherently powerful because they will just directly give you influence in a region, but they might be better spent just as an auction as grist for the mill, the the economy mill. It It's so smart. It's just like everything you have has some kind of value, but it might be more valuable somewhere else. Wardens are great, but do I sacrifice it because I really need this one? Those make really, really compelling decisions. And then someone turns on the endame scoring that says if you have a set of these three color wardens five 10 you know bonus points is sitting there going now I have lots of reasons why I'm debating spending them or not. I and I think it's

it's an interesting set of modular rules so to speak where like in a game of of Dominion or a game with variable setup at the beginning of the game you put out a couple of different things. You're like this is what we're playing with. This is kind of that except it's all out there from the beginning and over the course of play you choose what is activated and that's really neat. It comes with the downside of you got to teach everything up front and you're going to be teaching of those uh I think it's 17 scoring locations. You have to teach all of them.

Only nine will actually be relevant in the game right by the end of the game.

And so it's it's a bit of a bear for that first play. Yeah.

And honestly, even for the second, oh, what does that one do again? You can only choose one between these two. Like those little rules in there. But it is very fun and I think it's very like worth that kind of upfront uh investment. Yeah, I like it a lot. I think it's a very interesting like the decision space is very interesting. I'm giving it an eight out of 10. The thing that keeps me from giving it an excellent is uh just minor things. One is when I'm done playing it, I'm always like, "Okay,

I'll play that again in a few weeks." Because there is that much going on. And I also I also want to be clear, I like this game. I very much enjoy it. But I definitely don't think it's for everyone. There's a lot of people who shouldn't play this game. There's it's easy for you in the third age or era, whatever they're called, to go, "Oh, you know what? It really doesn't matter what you know what happens here. I'm out." You can discover that. And you can also bid really high in an auction just to be edged out on one thing by someone else, which is a legit thing in the game. But some people will dislike that because you still got to spend all that stuff and you're getting maybe a much lesser reward at that point in time. But I still think all these things come together to make a really cool game.

I'm go I'm also at an eight out of 10. I think that this is such a fun game and and Mike kind of nailed it. It's this it's an auction game at its core that has the dressing of an area control dudes on a map kind of a game, right? Uh and and there's so many different resources that can be spent in clever fun ways and then all of a sudden this endgame scoring turns on. You go, "Oh, I was going to use these battle cards, but now I want to hold on to them, you know, and and I love that that tension throughout." Kind of like you, Tom. I would I like this game is almost at that excellent threshold. I wish that it was just a little bit smoother because drafting cards, playing a card, so smooth. And then someone triggers a reckoning and that smoothness just stops and you go through this very intricate sequence of of doing a reckoning. You go, "Okay, now where were we? Oh, Mike, it's your turn to flip a card and do a very simple thing. We're back to doing the simple."

I think

the reckonings are like half the game.

They are. And so it's it's if it Yeah. So it's there's like a few of those little things that hold it back. But an eight out of 10, I'm still saying that this is

super fun. and I look forward to playing more.

And you know, I think we've talked about my negatives. One being some of the usability concerns and two would have been what you were saying is that the reckonings can slow down what is normally a pretty fast, you know, you're playing a car doing a couple little things. And so there is a little bit of herkyjerkiness in there, but what uh Oh, and the fact that you mentioned this isn't for everyone. I 100% agree. I think you can say that about almost every IV studio game.

Yeah, that's true. you know, because they're, you know, offc center. Uh, I am going to kick it to the 8.5 because I it has two of my favorite elements in games and they're both done in a very unique way. The playerdriven scoring, which I've already talked about, I don't need to blabber that. And and the auctions, I don't need to blabber that. Those two things are some of my favorite things in games, and they're done not only well here, but they're done differently. So, this is an auction game that doesn't play like any other auction game that I can think of. Um, and it's got that playerdriven scoring which is also different than I've seen anywhere else. So, an 8.5 I do kick it up to that excellence notch. Um, even agreeing with you in that this is not something I'm going to be playing every week because this is an experiential game and it does reward more plays. There you go folks.

That's Realm of Reckoning. I'm Tom.

I'm Chris.

I'm Mike.

See you next time at the final reckoning. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved