Skip to main content
Loading video...

Night Soil Review: Quick Take with Tom Vasel

Transcript 3:40

That is Night Soil. Night Soil is a It says on the back a very mature game about sanitation in Tudor England. Designed by John Moffit from Grail Games. This is a game about poop. That's all it is about. You are modern plumbing isn't there, so you have a bunch of guys whose job it is to come through. You have night soil, that's what it's called. You have these competing night soils. You're going to come, pick up the stuff, and get it out of the city with waste cubes. So, this is a This is a game that is a four out of 10 for me, and there's several reasons for that. One is not on the design of the game, but on the company here, Grail Games, decided to do this one in ye old timey methodology, which I don't hate the old time artwork. Some of it you look at you're like, "That's pretty gross." But, I don't mind that. But, the graphic design is not particularly good. The game comes with a cloth mat, which is completely unnecessary. I mean, look at the size of the box. They could have fit a board in here. And the cloth mat with the printing on is pretty hard to read what all the symbols do. And that I find that to be a detraction to the gameplay.

And and the graphics themselves aren't great. I'm not talking about the art. The art is fine, but the graphics themselves aren't particularly good. This is a game that kind of beats you down. Now, you might think that's part of the thematic here, but it is both simultaneously a card game in which you're playing these cards that give you benefits, and worker placement, and then sort of area control. You essentially trying to expel these cubes out of the city, these poop cubes out of the city, but you don't want any in your area at the end. And because of that, it has a pretty big problem in that this game can you can have really horrible turns. At the end of a round, there's workers out on the board, and you can get these workers back. You don't have workers that are set for you, workers that you can place out. You get them back if your areas are clean to poop, but if someone just throws a poop cube into your areas at the very end on their turn, then you can end up with a turn where you have no workers to put out. And I've definitely seen this happen, and that's a big chunk of the game that you're not playing, and just watching other people play. And right there, I think that's just bad game design.

Uh and this game forces you to be mean to other players. And I don't mind necessarily games that are mean to other players, but you're just mean for the game kind of forces you to be mean. I don't want the poop cubes in my area. It's my turn. Uh I'll get them out. I'll move them into your area. Uh whose area? Uh you. And all I'm doing is hurting you because the game is really kind of requiring me to do that. And it almost has a rich get richer. If you get some really good cards and some good things, and then you manage to clear the the poop cubes out of your area, you then can do better for the next round, so it's hard for other people to catch up. There's some weird area control for different guilds that give you special ability. And once you have them, it's hard for other people to necessarily take them away from you. And even though the theme, I think, is a fun theme, I don't think the game itself is particularly engaging. So, that is Night Soil. I wanted to like it, but uh it's bad.

Progress saved