Skip to main content
Loading video...

"Hallertau" Review After 10 Plays | RosenBlog April 2024

Transcript 19:15

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this Rosen blog for April 2024 we will go over holler tole in my review of it after 10 plays for news there hasn't been much announced there has been one additional picture published officially for Black Forest the new Rosenberg gam slated for Asen Spiel 20124 later this year and so we have another picture of that that more or less shows the same of what we saw before in Prototype version and so hopefully more details to come but nothing at the moment so let's get into the review so holler toow is Uber rosenberg's big box release back 4 years ago in 2020 and in this game it is set in the largest hot producing region in the world where players take on the role of Village Chiefs aiming to enhance their Villages wealth and Prestige by supplying goods from Agriculture and sheep breing to local Crafts People players strategically place workers and utilize card combos to maximize efficiency and prosperity the game features Progressive worker placement a two field rotation system and strategic card play challenging players to make optimal decisions to make their Village shine and that is a summary of the overview provided on Board Game Geek but now to highlight some of the mechanisms that makes this game shine and perhaps unique from among other Rosenberg games or games in general so first let's talk about the cards this game features 10 different decks that you draw from four

of the farm yard and Gateway decks are provided in the game each of these decks differ in complexity and the focus that they provide in the game based off of certain resource types and whatnot and in addition to these eight decks you have a bonus and a point deck the bonus deck gives you opportunities to uh gain bonus scoring opportunities and and resources and such and the point deck kind of offers some endgame Victory point points opportunities for uh resource collection as well you pick and choose which farmyard and Gateway deck to use when you play the game you randomize amongst the four of each type of deck and choose one and that creates a variable experience which again focuses on different aspects of the game in addition you get to play these cards virtually at any time on your turn or even on other players turns potentially leading to cascading combos of resource conversion and point scoring second the farming there is a balance you create first by managing the two field rotation type of crop Dynamic uh crop management and field planting they move up and down according to whether they are planted or not during the round offering different yields of crop as you plant them from round to round also the Sheep are handled in a unique way compared compared to other Rosenberg games they're not necessarily uh you're not necessarily breeding them but you must continue L Advance them up from round to round in the stable board

and the spaces that they occupy so they don't die of old age and get removed from your supply if you reach a round and you still have sheep on that particular round card that you draw from the work rep placement is next so the worker placement board is handled as a quadrant system you have four different areas where you can put cubes and in each of these areas there are four different worker placement spots and in each worker placement spot you have places to play the your worker placement cubes which for everyone they are the same color and you start from the bottom to the top and they have spaces for one to two and then three workers so all of that to say is that you play a worker to a spot that has not been occupied by anyone you play it with one worker take that action great the next player who wants to take that spot needs to play two workers in order to perform that same action from round to round the board is wiped of these cubes that are played whether they are the top row for lesser player counts or an entire quadrant for higher player counts and so you can see that soon the board gets pretty tight and more workers are needed to typically perform actions that are either very popular or desired based off of your strategy then finally the resource conversion aspect of this game the cor of this game is moving your community center across the point scoring board by creating space with the craft buildings at the at the end of each round you turn in Goods to move each of these buildings over at least one space tools acquired

by spending worker placement cubes allow for further advancement of buildings during the round with ever increasing demands to move the buildings from round to round the game scales in the amount of resources you need to score well but in addition to moving over your community board you start to acquire more workers hence being able to take this same actions as described before with those additional workers if need be so so let's compare holler toown to some other games the first game that I that popped up for me and this was found by looking at the section on Board Game Geek where you look at a particular game and you go down to the fans also like section which usually offers some games that are similar in weight and me mechanisms and and rating and ano 1800 was one of those games that popped up that I agree with and for H ano 1800 is such a game that for me finds a lot of similarities due the fact that both games revolve around cards that contain little mini objectives for you to fulfill with resources Ono 1800 is more deterministic on these cards I think the game revolves more around the cards and in a holler to it may enhance the game play which is more focused on turning in resources to move your community building but there is a constant feeling of progressing through the game like it's a step by- step like a staircase you fulfill a small objective you take a couple of turns to fulfill that whether it be the cards in ano 1800 or in holler toow and you draw some more cards and

move on to the next small little objective moving from place to place until you finally accomplish something great by the end of the game the second game that I want to compare to holler mechanically is world wonders these two games aren't very similar in terms of complexity and theme but in how each turn feels like with the worker placement in holler Tow and the spending of your money in world wonders I feel there are some similarities how much money or workers you're willing to spend on something expensive like a Wonder in world wonders or to take a worker placement spot in holler tow with two or three of your workers is where a lot of the tough decisions come do you overspend and take actions that kind of progress your strategy to a point or do you take something a little bit more efficient world wonders you know do you take an action do you spend a lot of your money at first to take something big like a Wonder or a really big building or do you start small and wait for other players to play out their actions in order to take bigger ones later that's where a lot of the decisions come and it's kind of like you have more flexibility in what you can do and how much you can afford to spend from turn to turn versus other games where you're just playing one worker out and taking an action and so on and then finally uh well the first of the two Rosenberg games that I want to talk about is Agricola my first Rosenberg pick has to be gria for many reasons the theme of course the worker placement mechanisms as well the farming mechanisms for that matter are very

similar and yet different at the same time right like the way that you handle animals in both games are different the way that you handle crops are a little bit more similar but in both games you have card play that enhances the game playay agricola's card play is more determined at the beginning of the game usually with a draft where you contain cards in your hand that you can play throughout the game if you choose to do so and in holler to is more tactical and Progressive during the game where these cards are drawn throughout the game and you can play them at any time the huge amount of decks of different cards that are provided in each game create the sense of endless variability that has always drawn me into these games and once helps me want to play these games repetitively in that sense news fured and orani burger Canal also fit the bill with having lots of different cards that you play through and that you don't see the entire you know deck or couple of decks that you play with but I think Agricola theme wise as well as with the card play kind of reminds me most of holler toown and then the other game that does have some card play as well is at the gates of ly yang this is a game that other people have made connections to as well also in terms of crop management building up a sort of engine to plant your crops have them produce more crops for you during the game and turning those in for customers and and whatnot and so that is reminiscent in holler toown where that kind of crop multiplication mechanism that you see in a lot of his games are is really the focus here in in holler toow as well as a lot of The Craft buildings require you

to plant crops to advance their places it's a little bit less interactive than at the gates of ly Yang a lot of those cards allow you to interact with the boards and Tableau of other players holler toow is very much more multiplayer solitire but the amount of cards that offer some variety of what you can do and helps the things that help you to do a little bit of resource conversion are there as well and that is a similarity that I agree with so let's go to the peer review so let's talk about what people particularly on Board Game Geek had said about holler tile that is praiseworthy so people who love Rosenberg games really enjoy this game for the theme the mechanisms and the variations with card play that this game offers very similar to other games as well the Thematic integration of Concepts such as the field system and the Sheep getting old and having to progress them from round to round make the game intuitive to learn because those thematic tie-ins make it easier to Inuit it the rules which helps it become more not only easy to learn but also to relearn and come back to if you haven't played it in a while the pacing is really well done for a heavy Euro Style game and the worker placement is tight and interactive with lots of opportunities for blocking or at least making it more expensive for someone else to take a certain spot the combo potential for playing cards at any time is really fun as well and people like that experience as well as the solo experience some concerns are there and

starting with the cards the large variety of cards comes with the luck of the draw aspect of not having the right cards in front of you each game and that can be hard when when someone else is having virtually better luck than you and watching them play card after card you know on top of their Tableau while your strategies kind of don't come together when it comes to the cards and so it's it's hard to live through sometimes in addition to some the strategy of the game regardless of the cards can feel kind of Route with the main goal of moving over your community center by spending the same amount of goods each round feel scripted there are minor complaints about the storage of your goods in your supply more of a component complaint uh where the tracker for your goods is kind of a vertical uh 1 2 3 4 5 type of arrangement and those especially later on in the game and especially if you're doing well in the game can become really compacted because there are so many different resources in this game and if you have multiple of the same resources then that area can kind of feel tight and it's hard to keep everything together so for me my review after 10 plays and for me I've the majority of my plays have been solo with a few multiplayer games here and there if I could describe this game in one way I would say that this game feels cozy or familiar like greeting an old friend after pull it out of the box I agree that the rules are intuitive and the math puzzle is pretty much the same from round to round especially with solo play uh sometimes you can uh flip over your

round uh you know exactly how many Goods you need to provide in each round and so you can calculate exactly how many resources you need to move each building once or twice or even more and so the fact of the matter comes to you're coming back to the same strategy you're trying to beat your own score if you're playing solo and and sometimes the decisions are laid out in front of you you know exactly what you're going to do at the beginning of the turn you can take turn after turn in the solo mode pretty easily with a little bit of variety that is offered with the cards that may offer a slightly alternative way to getting to that that same goal that you have from round to round and after a few plays I felt like I was returning to the same puzzle each time and personally my scores weren't getting any better they you know were growing after a couple of plays and they plateaued at a certain level and I know a lot of people were tracking different scores that people were getting using different combinations of decks and I think you know obviously I'm not an expert at this game by any means I think there are people who are smarter than me out there uh collecting better scores it's been a while since I've seen those compilations of scores that are listed in Board Game Geek but I I assume that they are higher than the scores that I've been getting and a lot of that is dependent on the cards that you draw which is once again down to luck of the draw and despite also in in addition to that despite me having similar scores I found I was having similar scores and and it wasn't with the same decks you know same combinations of decks it was with different combinations

whether they were labeled and I believe it's the farmyard cards as like beginner then expert Master Advanced like I do see that some of the uh wording and requirements are a little bit more complex the farther you go up in in complexity with those decks however my scores didn't seem to vary differently I I did it didn't feel like it was harder for me to get a good score with those cards that were more complex and I believe some of that it has to do with the the core gameplay that this game provides you with moving that Community Center and turning in the same amount of goods each round from round to round and so so that core gameplay is not changed at all it's just that the cards are a little bit different and perhaps give you a more efficient boost at sometimes and less so during other times now despite me saying that it does feel a little bit rote from game to game don't get me wrong because I really enjoy the concept and the flow of this game once again I like returning to a cozy experience which I feel like this game is embodies a cozy experience where I know what to expect when I revisit this game I can kind of sit there and plan out each round having a little bit of a you know farming music background you know a cup of hot chocolate or something like that it that that's the kind of setting that always comes to mind and that I find myself in when playing this game and it really doesn't need this need the same variety and tight gameplay that's sometimes punishing as Agricola

has I think agria is fun in a different way where it is very competitive and you know you can lose after you know the first couple of turns in the game and it's hard to catch up on whereas in holler to your luck may may vary sometimes it may start bad and become good uh but you always have that core gameplay to draw back on to progress and I think everyone can if if they're familiar enough with the rules and everything can perform well enough uh and that seems to be pretty steady and constant uh from game to game the cards in agrica as well seem to bend the rules a little bit more drastically than in holler toow where it kind of is simplified to more hey if you have enough of these resources either if you've reached these amount of resources or if if you turn in these this amount of resources you get a bona fit and perhaps a card draw so so yeah they're a little bit more simplistic I think or at least more straightforward than cards in agrica even in Newt I think the cards are a little bit more straightforward they're I feel like it's a little bit more on line in par with uh at the gates of L Yang yeah on that note as well I do have the promo deck a couple years ago I think it was 2021 or 22 a promo deck was released and I I bought it through lookout so it made may still be on the lookout games website and so I played around with those cards I believe it's a farmyard card or a farmyard deck and the cards didn't feel very difficult actually it kind of reminded me of a

good intro version of of the farmyard deck to try it with players who are new to the game where there weren't any conversions or turning in of goods and resources it was basically if you meet these resources gain a bonus and so on that side note I I think the promo deck is a great way to maybe add a little bit of variety to your game but I think it was really good to have as a intro type of deck for newer players the multiplayer experience is good and bad for me I do feel the rush and the joy of playing cards one after the other creating Combos and the sadness as well as I look on my competitors doing the same on their turn when the cards don't line up for me and so yes I do agree that this game is very much luck driven when it comes to the cards but I don't mind that because the variability between the decks isn't as robust as I thought it would be and even if someone is having really good luck I can still fall back on what I know to be a good core strategy which is just moving up those those buildings because I think the majority of the scoring that you have in this game is dependent on how far you get that Community Center to the right and so in some I think what this game is trying to do for me and why I enjoy this game despite the repetitiveness of strategies the luck based card play as well is that I am drawn in by its cozy and familiar themes and mechanisms over and over again it wouldn't be a game and I don't think that the point of this game is to be really competitive at it like AG gria but I think it captures the feeling of

working the farm the best that you can and and coming back to a very familiar puzzle just to be in that space which is very much akin to Lifestyle farming games like Harvest Moon and stardy Valley which I really enjoyed playing growing up and I've mentioned that before on the podcast many times I really enjoy that feeling and returning to this game over and over again has really satisfied that need sometimes to just play a game to to have fun and to just solve a puzzle and kind of sit there in your own cozy Tableau and farm without having to be too involved in the competitiveness and mechanisms that are and tightness that are seen in other games and so I still enjoy having this game in my collection and I still rate it high and I know that I can always return to this game and have a great time with it so those are my thoughts and review of holler toow after 10 plays thank you for Consulting with me today and hope that you schedule an appointment with me real soon take care

Progress saved