Shelf Life - October 2026 (games covered in March 2026)
Transcript
Welcome to ShelfLife, the monthly series where I look at games I covered six or seven months ago and let you know whether they're still in my collection. And this time I'm looking at games I covered back in March. Let's see which of them had shelf life. First in the crowdfunding corner is Dusk Runners. This is a narrative campaign game with a hand management and like kind of some deck building and stuff. This one didn't work too well for me. The basic mechanics seemed okay, but at least from the little bit I saw in the prototype, I didn't have full confidence in kind of how the campaign would work. Now that being said, I did like the core skill resolution mechanic. It reminded me a bit of Seventh Continent or Seven Citadel. So maybe the final game will be great, but I was not fully confident in Dusk Runners yet.
And then the only other game for me to talk about is the upcoming Shattered Peak expansion for Leviathan Wilds. Uh cuz I did cover a hell of a deal in this month crowdfunding wise, but it delivered very quickly and that's going to be on a later ShelfLife with the final game. But yeah, Shattered Peak, great. I mean, I love Leviathan Wilds, so this was an easy sell for me. But unlike the first expansion, this one adds uh several more characters, uh climbers in and not just a ton of Leviathans. So it ups the uh variety and the combinations you can play on both sides of the aisle. And all the new Leviathans I played are really cool. This is also the first expansion that really got my 14-year-old really into the game and he was playing it a lot with me at whatever convention we were playing this uh in. So yeah, I'm very excited for this one. Can't wait for it to deliver. That's the Shattered Peak expansion for Leviathan Wilds.
And that takes us into the release games. First one is Adamastor, which is a solo adventure game with kind of these card row management and some leveling up opportunities. Uh this one was almost a complete miss for me. I found the game tuned incredibly tough unless uh I was just playing things drastically wrong, which I've not heard anybody say I was. Uh I also found it pretty repetitive in the gameplay. They had a campaign mode, but it required you to win multiple games in a row, so that was silly with my difficulty with even doing somewhat well in the game. So, yeah, this was uh not good for me at all. But, if you love super challenging solo card games, it might be worth giving Adam Astra a try. Uh total call for me. And then I have Baseball Highlights 2045. This was a review I did of the game even though it's a pretty old. And this one is awesome. This one is definitely a keeper for me. I had called it back in the day, but getting it back I remembered how much I love it. Uh my sons enjoy it as well, especially my uh 14-year-old cuz he's playing softball now. Uh so, yeah, it's it's just a really good game. I love uh deck builders like this one that every time you add a card, you replace another card, so your deck is getting lean and mean. The solo mode is pretty random. I mean, heck, the competitive play can be pretty random, too, cuz sometimes you just have to guess if they're going to have the exact counter for your card or not. But, it doesn't change the fact that Baseball Highlights 2045 is a super fun, uh competitive, and solo deck builder. Definitely a keeper.
Next up is the new core set for Arkham Horror: The Card Game, one of my favorite games of all time. Uh the new core not one of my favorite things of all time. I think it's fine. Uh it is a nice jumping-in point if you don't want to try to track down all the old sets. Uh the new campaign I found pretty derivative of the original Night of the Zealot campaign, but if it's your first experience, there's nothing wrong with that. But, yeah, for a returning player like me, I didn't find a lot to recommend this new set, but again, good for new players. I also have not loved the new things that have come since then. So, uh I do have to think I have the next side scenario delivering soon. Maybe that one will be good. But, this has been a bit of a mixed bag for me. Uh if I was not getting review copies of Arkham stuff, I think I would probably stop with what I already have. But, yeah, that is the new core, and it's a keep just cuz I'm keeping all my Arkham stuff.
Next up is the Cantaloupe series. Uh this is a sort of uh point-and-click adventure game in book form. Uh kind of has vibes of like Leisure Suit Larry and other games in those series. And I thought this was quite good. Uh sort of. I think I talked about this on the podcast, but yes, uh episode 1 of Cantaloupe is great. Really enjoyed that one. Episode 2 I found personally to be nearly a complete train wreck. It had this hacking mini game that I thought was just a terrible choice. And also I found uh the storyline was just kind of spinning its wheels and almost nothing of consequence happened. But then Cantaloupe 3 is awesome as well. So, I think I might have said yes when I talked about it on the podcast or wherever that I fully recommend getting Cantaloupe 1 and 3. And I kind of think you should just, you know, uh skip two completely cuz everything that happens in two is kind of rehashed in three anyway. So, I don't think you even really miss anything. But still, Cantaloupe, if you're a fan of point-and-click adventure games, uh pretty big recommend for the series overall. It's a lot of fun.
Next up is Dixit Kids, which is I believe the first cooperative take on the Dixit formula where you have these really odd uh art cards and you try to like figure out which card was picked by a person. And I think the cooperation works great here. You basically have two emotions of bunnies and you're trying to figure out which card matches which. And they balance it pretty well at different player counts because there are more cards even though uh the same number of people have to get it right. Uh it can be very tough sometimes or very easy just based on the random luck of the cards. But I have found this one very good with adults as well. I think it might be my preferred way to play Dixit at this point uh regardless of the kids moniker it's been attached to it. So, Dixit Kids, that's a keep. Whereas Miskatonic Tales was very much a call. I did not like this one uh very much at all. I didn't like the skill system and the action system. I didn't like uh how it was so focused on just kind of innate investigation and going through drawers and stuff. I didn't think the replayability was strong. Now, I am very excited to play Horror on the Orient Express. I finally got my review copy of the final game of that one and I definitely enjoyed my preview plays. Uh but yeah, this one from the same company, Chaosium, was not for me. Hope others enjoy it. Uh but that is Miskatonic Tales, definitely a call.
All right, just a couple games left. One of the last ones is Dice Mansey, the tower defense game from uh the Gabe Barrett solo game of the month series. This one is really fun. It has great Studio Ghibli-esque art. Uh it has these really interesting spell chains and these ways that you're fighting enemies. All that being said, it did end up being a cull for me. I'm not going to say that I didn't enjoy it, but just uh if I want to play a game where I'm defending against like enemies incoming, I'll probably play, I don't know, Skytear Horde or uh Battle for Greyport or uh something else that's a little bit more deck-buildy in the same genre. But, this game is still great. Uh no real big uh complaints about it. I like the systems quite a lot, the dice placement, the art is good. I think some people will struggle with the spell chaining. That part can be a little bit obtuse in the mechanics. But, uh Dice Mansey is a great game, but it was still a cull for me.
And last game for this month is the Rocky Roads expansion for Heat: Pedal to the Metal. And uh I'm this is a broken record if you've watched any of the other Shelf Lives on these or the reviews of them in general. I would never buy this if it was not given to me as a review copy. I would never buy any of these track expansions cuz I'm not one who's playing Heat often enough that I like am getting bored with the base game uh garage modules and cards, getting bored with the tracks. I guess if you play it all the time and you really like need uh some fresh meat in your rotation, then sure. But, yes, I find all of these a little bit unnecessary. Uh like uh all the other ones, Rocky Roads has an interesting track mechanic that is only used on one of the tracks and is, from what I can tell, never going to be ported anywhere else. Uh it does have I think this was the super cool cards, if I remember right, where you can like uh remove heat cards that are in your discard pile. That's That's a decent mechanic. But, yes, uh this totally unnecessary. Uh this will be in a future episode of Shelf Life, but yeah, the only uh expansion I kind of recommend for Heat is the Legends expansion if you play a lot of solo cuz it makes the solo mode a bit more dynamic. But, honestly, I think Heat is also a great game just with the base box and nothing else. And then you don't have uh little lift and difficulty fitting all this stuff in the one box cuz right now I have all of it split among like two or three boxes. So, yeah, not not a huge ringing endorsement. Rocky Road is fine, but it's not something that I would recommend. I think Heat is good just with the base game. So, there you go.
Four games kept out of eight, which sounds pretty good, but all of them are either old games I rebought, new versions of old games I bought, or expansions. So, there was nothing in March that was fully new to me that I felt like I had to keep. But, let's get to the contest and see which of you were able to guess my choices. So, starting out with the first pair, 64% of you got it correct and said I'd the Baseball Highlights. 26% thought I would keep Adam Master, and 10% thought I would keep both. Moving on to group two, 92% Yeah, not too surprising. Thought I would keep one of my favorite games of all time, Arkham Horror: The Card Game. Uh 6% said both, and only 2% thought I would keep Can't a Loop. Group three, 63% got it right and picked Dixit Kids. Only 28% said Miskatonic Tales, and only 9% said both. And group four was the biggest spoiler because 53% of you said I would keep both incorrect. Uh 33% correctly said I would keep the Rocky Roads expansion for Heat, and only 14% said I would keep Dice Man C. And that leaves us with these potentials. We've got a lot of people who got it right this time. Uh Thilo, up there in red, said they didn't want to be in the contest, and the yellow names are our Patreon supporters who get double entries. So, I'm going to roll a D6 for the row, and then a D6 for the column.
And here we go. We've got a two for the row, and a two for the column. Which means Carlos Arce is our big winner. I'll be in touch about your free game. Everybody else, check the video description, and you can enter next month's contest. Good gaming, everyone, and we'll see you at the next stop.