Skip to main content
Loading video...

Crash Octopus: Dice Dropping, Flag Flicking Fun from Japan.

Transcript 9:44

usually I start my reviews with a pithy phrase a theme or mechanism condensed into a single sentence that summarizes everything a game has to offer the hook of the product but with crash octopus I'm gonna have to take a different approach a description of the game won't do it justice this is a game sold on visual appeal that there what you're looking at that's the hook I'm not importer I design games and I review them on this channel with a focus on product design if you like what I do please subscribe comment and hit like crash octopus is a 2021 release from itton the Japanese publisher responsible for 2016's gorgeous Lolly stick stacking game Tokyo Highway crash octopus is another dexterity game this time for two to four players age 7 and up and Lasting around 20 minutes the goal in Crash octopus is to load five different types of treasure onto your ship or if the crab reaches the end of the colored beads before that happens the player with the most valuable Treasures wins on your turn you can either flick a treasure or navigate your ship if you choose to navigate you use your flag to flick an anchor and move your ship to any location adjacent to its new position and if you choose to flicker treasure the aim is to make it bump into your ship but crucially you can never flick the closest treasure to your ship and you can't load the same treasure twice if other treasure falls off your ship well that's tough luck you'll have to collect it again on a later turn after any player loads a treasure the crab is moved if it steps over a black

bead the octopus attacks each player takes turns to drop a die onto the octopus head and if the die bounces off and hits a ship any treasure which falls off is left in the ocean if the dye misses the ships and lands with a blank Result One tentacle is moved adjacent to the die if the die misses the ships and shows the pink result the octopus head is moved adjacent the game ends when a player loads their Fifth Treasure or when the crab crosses the final bead there are additional optional rules for a desert island which always has treasure on it you can collect the Treasure by bouncing your anchor off the island but you can't do this if your anchor is currently the closest my copy of the game also included the pink pirate mini expansion which allows a fifth player to join in controlling the special pirate ship the pirate ship moves like the other ships but it collects Treasures in a different way the pirate ship can shoot a cannonball at the octopus head a successful hit allows the pirate player to drop the dice onto the octopus head and resolve the the results as usual except that any treasure toppled off the opponent's ships will be stolen by the pirate finally there's a second octopus head in the Box to use in a more strategic variant where you have a choice over which head to drop the die onto and there are also a couple of insubstantial mini-games described in the rules now I'm a huge fan of dexterity games and flicking games in particular I love pitch out and flick of Faith catacombs and flick em up plus many more so crash

octopus was an inevitable purchase when I came across it in a Spanish game store the box cover is striking and intriguing and I had no trouble downloading an English copy of the main rules online although the pink pirate rules took a little bit more hunting down the onboarding process was great the rules are easy to follow they're well laid out and we were up and playing in no time this is a game which is all about table presence but that doesn't count for much if it isn't engaging to play it and earlier Tokyo Highway had a similar aesthetic appeal and managed to couple out with some really fun gameplay so I had high hopes for crash octopus I rank games using my engagement ladder system each game is scored between zero and three points in five categories and each point climbs the game one run up the ladder and a score of 10 or above tops the ladder and indicates a real favorite with me crash octopus has a silly theme and it doesn't make much sense there are Treasures flicking all over the place dice bouncing around and players are targeting their opponents with octopus attacks but looking from a wide lens it seems that we're treasure Hunters collecting items which wash up and alongside our vessels while avoiding a giant octopus and a pink pirate ship there's a slightly surreal narrative here but it is a narrative nonetheless so I'm giving the game A two the next category is Meaningful interaction and the game is certainly interactive players are knocking Treasures off their opponent's ships all over the place but I'm not sure how meaningful the interaction is it's pretty hard to control where the dye

lands when you bounce it off the octopus head so the outcome of an attack feels rather arbitrary I'm scoring at a two for interaction for stress and challenge it's a one the main stress in the game is hoping that the die doesn't bounce in your direction that's out of your control so it isn't something that you can do much about and that does make it all feel a bit unfair when it happens it's not really an example of the positive tension that I look for in a game feedback refers to the way in which a Game responds to the player's input that could mean rewards for skillful play and this game has a bit of that though with a maximum of five items of treasure to collect it's hardly generous but dexterity games often feature a more immediate form of physical feedback the tactile sensation of propelling a disc across the table with your finger and surprisingly this is one of the most disappointing elements of the product the flags are the flimsiest items in a gorgeous set of thick wooden components flicking a disc with these flags just doesn't feel good and it's far harder to aim accurately than it would be with a finger flick likewise with the dice bouncing mechanism propelling a die across the table accurately hitting your target is hugely rewarding in games like Cube Quest or Mondrian the dice game but bouncing a die by a vertical drop removes any real skill and all physical feedback again it just doesn't feel good so for feedback I'm scoring the game on one category is Meaningful choices it's

often said that a game is only as good as the decisions a player gets to make on their turn and while I don't subscribe to that view wholeheartedly very random games like ravensberger's strike can be tremendously engaging crash octopus does feel like it would benefit from a few more choices some strategic decisions to give the players agency to make them feel clever you do get to select which Treasures to flick and when and where to navigate your ship so it's not entirely devoid of choices so I'll score in a one so the overall score is a seven and while it's short of the top run it's not quite as negative as my analysis might have come across and to be honest that's about right it does feel like a seven the table presence the bright colors the silly story do a lot of the work here it is a joyful product moving on to my product design checklist is the product Innovative well I do think the presentation is innovative even if the gameplay is not the Twilight components are beautiful the octopus head and tentacles moving as separate entities works well the bright colors and the Striking box art all make the game Stand Out does the product deliver on its promises yeah it looks great on the back of the box and it looks great on the table top this is exactly what the publisher is selling table presents and it delivers in Spades is there a need for a product like this well there are still relatively few 3D wooden games like this one flick Em Up was a good example a few years ago there's something delightfully wholesome

about a box full of wooden toys as opposed to plastic warmongering minis I do think there's a market for products like this will the Game grow with its user no the game serves up everything that it has to offer in the first couple of plays the game makers have tried to dress the product up with mini games and variants But ultimately it's the main event that players are here for and that's pretty insubstantial so we'll finish as always by plotting crash octopus onto my idea execution Matrix High selling commercial products combine great ideas with stunning execution reaching the red or orange parts of the grid crash octopus is a really good idea I love the box of wooden toys the silly narrative the octopus with its Wayward tentacles there are some nice ideas in the mechanisms too it's clever that players are never allowed to flick the closest treasure even if they really want it but ultimately the execution lets the product down the box in the rule book are excellent so onboarding is a breeze but the gameplay itself is lacking the game is chaotic and it's often frustrating it's not unfun but the pace things off the game is often over extremely quickly and the wind can be stolen at any point swinging from one player to another throughout the game with a single dice impact a player can lose all of their treasure but there's no sense of control because the flag flicking and the dice dropping just aren't precise enough to use skillfully I've mentioned a lot of other flicking games already in this review and crash

octopus just doesn't reach the tense highs and lows of other games in the genre crass octopus is certainly not a shipwreck of a game it's bright and colorful it's unusual enough to draw players in and enjoyable for a handful of plays it sits in the green section of the grid which indicates a solid release for itton and I really can't speak for the Japanese Market maybe this one is a mega hit who knows click on the link to find out about more fantastic flicking games and don't forget to keep an eye out for my new family game zingazam coming soon from brain games until next time all the best

Progress saved