Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Hungry Gamer's Iliad Mini Review

Transcript 6:32

Ooh, that looks tasty. Welcome, folks. Today the Hungry Gamer is back with another mini review, and today we're talking about Iliad from Bitewing Games, designed by Reiner Knizia. Now, this is a two-player game that is a tile-laying game, and ostensibly each player is one side of the Trojan War, and you're kind of trying to gain the favor of the gods. Whatever. It's a tile-laying game. And really what's going on here is in this tile-laying game, you are placing tiles out on the map, and as you're placing them out on the map, some of them will do things, and they may cause tiles flip, it may allow you to move tiles around, but once a row or a column fills up, you're going to add up the values that each player has, and whoever has the highest value will get to pick which of the rewards on the side of the board that they want. The other player gets the other. And some of them are good, some of them are bad, and there is a way that you can go through as you're playing to make sure that you can automatically win the game. If you get one of each suit or each of the gods and a ring, I believe it is, then you will automatically win, points be damned.

And that's it. You're going to have two tiles in front of you, you're going to pick one, and you're going to put it down and do what it says. And that's it. You're just literally trying to manipulate the board, manipulate the tiles to where you win the rows and columns that are most meaningful, the ones that have the big negative or something good. And then you set up to where you're going to lose the rows or columns that are less important to you. And like I said, that's it. It's a very, very simple game, very fast, very easy to play. So, with that being said, what do I like about this game? I like the idea around it. I like the idea of the both sides of the Trojan War and I like that the different rewards around the board are ostensibly the different gods and as someone who has read the Iliad, it really does matter when the gods are helping you. So, that does make sense and I like that idea. I also particularly like that every game the the surrounding of the play area is different. So, that does make every game different when you sit down to play and that I really like. I think that is actually a very clever and I also really like the way that some of the tiles are going to do things. Maybe it's going to flip a tile over, take away a number, it's going to move a tile. So, suddenly you're going to change the number that's going to activate somewhere.

And I particularly like the tiles that the value of them are equal to the two tiles next to it. Very clever stuff cuz the tiles next to you are going to be the other players' tiles. So, there's a lot of cleverness here and I also like the limitations that you get when you are only getting a few tiles to pick from. One, it keeps the game moving, but two, it means you're constantly having to react to what is happening on the board. Now, I like all of that. I think it's all very, very clever. So, what are my quibbles with the game? Well, the first one is thematically it does not land. In theory, but it's one of those things, it's like if you are of my generation, you remember Magic Eye and you kind of had to squint and kind of pull your head back from the thing and turn your head and then you could kind of see it.

This is like that. The theme's there, but you got to look real hard for it. This is a This is a theme-less game, really. And as someone that is really into theme, it's a little bit of a miss for me. I'll also say the game board is a cloth game board. In fact, I got it right here. And it's kind of cool. It's canvas. I love the idea, but you can't really see it here, but it's got creases in it. And those creases don't go away. And those creases mean the tiles kind of don't lay flat. And I just I guess it's a theme thing. I don't know. I don't get it. Like why not just have a foldy board of cardboard this size? Because as much as I like the cloth board, it slides around, it doesn't lay flat, things don't sit on it right.

I don't know. Maybe I should just iron it or something. But then I'm ironing my board game. So, I don't know. To me, that is also kind of a big miss. But then talking mechanically, my only real quibbles with it are simply that there's just not a lot here. This is on the light end of a filler game, I think. And yes, it does have very cool stuff. As I said at the beginning, it doesn't take away from that. There's some neat things going on here. But to me, this is just a filler game. And it's a filler game that feels a little bit more complicated. And the only thing I'm going to say about it is it's basically just a filler game. There's nothing deep about this game. You're going to play through it and okay, you're going to change the border and you're going to different things there.

But really game to game you're not going to have that much of a different experience. And while it's pleasant and fun, it's not one that personally I think is standing out from all the other filler games in the crowd, especially with a pedigree like Reiner Knizia has. And that's probably not fair for me to say that. But for a guy that is the guy, it feels a little bit lackluster. So, there you have it, folks. That is Iliad. I know I came off pretty negative there at the end. Actually very negative sounding there at the end. And I it's not initially my intention. I had fun playing it. And if someone wanted to play it, I would play it again. But this is one of those games that I'm just not convinced that I would go to the shelf and pick this for a two-player game over the myriad of others that I already have.

Now that said, if you're a big fan of tile laying, if you're a big fan of that idea of the the rows and columns, then your mileage will probably will vary from mine. You'll probably enjoy it far more than than I did. I don't think there's anything wrong with this game. I just don't think that this is a particularly special game. So there you have it, folks. As always, if you found this video useful, please like, subscribe, share, maybe become a channel member. As always, thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful, wonderful day.

Progress saved