Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 12:21

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I recently heard that Xi Jingping is going to release a book of quotes the same way Mao did. It's going to be called That's what Xi said. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at China's War 1937 1941 from GMT Games.

Heat. In China's War 1937 to 1941 from GMT Games, up to four players will take on the roles of various factions as they attempt to dominate China during the second SinoJapanese war of this period. One of you will take on the role of the Japanese invaders as they are attempting to dominate China. One of you will take on the role of the nationalist government, the legitimate government of China as it is attempting to push back the Japanese invaders and keep these other factions at bay. One of you will take on the role of the warlords, indep independent forces that are trying to control China for their own ends. And one of you will take on the role of the Chinese communists as they attempt to dominate China and bring it under Mauist thought. All right, ladies and gentlemen. This is a coin game. It's not terribly different in a lot of the basics of how this plays from other coin games. So, I'm just going to tell you a basic overview of the game and then I will tell you my thoughts. So here you actually have a 1937 scenario, which is a longer scenario, or a 1938 scenario.

And depending on that, you you're going to prepare decks uh your deck of cards. You're going to use kind of three uh layers of decks for the 38 scenario and four layers for the 48 scenario. You're going to be mixing in propaganda cards into the different levels of these scenarios. And of course, the propaganda cards are your uh the period in which you'll do your scoring. Now, there are a few differences from this coin game and others. For instance, you will have places for uh only two bases in each uh location. You will have them on the board printed there. Uh of course, you have things like support and uh you know oppose which is either for the nationalists or for the uh communists. You have of course control which which really affects the nationalists or the wild. The Japanese don't care so much about control and pacifying the countryside so much as they care about the transportation system because on the board you have railway lines and you have rivers. And the Japanese are trying to dominate these rail lines and rivers and that's going to be part of their victory conditions. Now there are a few other things. The Japanese can do a large offensive. They have a large offensive token which allows them to be able to kind of move a lot of their fellows uh quite quickly and engage with their enemies quite quickly. Some cards that come out will also give capabilities to various factions. You can place a capabilities token in the capabilities box to show that that is in play. Some of the cards will have momentum, kind of ongoing persistent abilities. So, you leave those cards out as you watch them. Now, throughout the game, of course, you're trying to accomplish different things. There are different uh victory conditions for the different factions. But there's other mitigating ideas here as well. The nationalists have foreign aid. They're

trying to impress foreigners, so they want to keep that uh foreign aid flowing in, and they can at times convert that to resources or not. um uh their patronage is very important to them because they want that uh you know as part of their victory conditions. Uh the Japanese actually they're worried about their commitment and this is of course is because the Japanese that are committed to fighting in China are also having to deal with the Japanese back home who are looking at maybe a naval solution to their problems or invading going to war with the with the Dutch or the British or what have you. And so the level of commitment to what's going on in China can ever flow. Again, that's very important to the Japanese. Now, the communists are just trying to stir up trouble. They want opposition out there, as much opposition as they can get. Of course, they also want their bases out there. The warlords, they want wild control of population. They also want to put out their bases there. So, of course, they all have their objectives they're working toward. They're trying to do things. And there's all sorts of different kinds of uh actions you can take. And again, I'm not going to go through all the actions here, but for instance, uh the, you know, communists, they can sabotage rail lines. They can try to take those out. The uh nationalists have their own gorillas that they can bring out to try to battle them to try to fight with them as well.

But of course, all sides can kind of recruit and deploy. And there is combat here. You actually do have a combat table. You're rolling the dice depending on your forces. You're seeing what your uh uh forces amount to. any casualties go into the casualty box which can have larger repercussions um on the board may affect uh you know victory conditions long term. So there's a lot of different moving parts to this game but it's actually uh fairly relatable accessible if you've already played a coin game. Uh it'll be very familiar to you. Just like in coin games you of course have the eligibility box. Uh whoever goes first is going to determine what the next person can do. Uh you can play an event card. You can take an action with a limited ability or just the special action. Uh and then as I say, it's going to put you on a track that will kind of limit the option for the next person.

You can always pass and gain resources. And then if you're ineligible, you can't go that turn. So you got to wait till the next turn before you become eligible each round. Only about two people are actually going to be able to do things each round. So players are going around and around. They are taking various actions. They are playing the event cards. They are engaging in combat and taking casualties. Critically, they are working toward their victory conditions. Now, whoever can score their victory conditions first during a propaganda round wins. China's War 1937 1941. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now back to the review. All right, China's War 1937 1941. Uh, this is a very interesting coin game. Now, I do just want to comment on something right off the bat. It was a for me, somebody who studied history, and when you study history, particularly military history, you have to know geography. I found the map a little jarring in the way that kind of north is, you know, if you're facing the map, north is to your left, south is to your right. Uh I don't know, you just kind of expect, you kind of expect uh something to kind of maybe more align with traditional ways we look at maps. And this doesn't.

That's fine. It's not a huge deal, but it's just something that kind of threw me off a little bit in my own kind of way I look at at at the geography of a place. So that was a little weird, but not a huge deal at all. The game itself, as I say, is in a lot of ways a very standard coin game. So I played at this point, you know, maybe a half dozen or so coin games, and this one I felt was very easy to get into. It was very accessible. There are a few little things here or there like the of course the transportation systems, the railways and the rivers. They work a little bit different, right? There is combat here. I know we saw that like in Liberty and Death. uh we had combat and casualties that kind of kind of affect other things on the board, but basically the game is interesting. Now, one of the dynamics of the game is the Japanese come into the game pretty powerful right off the bat. And so the Japanese are just going to kind of try to run roughshod over those transportation systems and gain as much of them as they can in order to win the game. And so the other factions kind of have to be proactive in trying to put them down.

They can't just be chasing victory themselves. they have to say, "How can we stop the Japanese?" So, you kind of have a very interesting dynamic where it's almost from the beginning of the game, at least in the early part of the game, it's threeon-one, right? Three of you are kind of teaming up against the Japanese. Now, in every coin game, one of the things I love about coin games is you see these kind of natural alliances occur, meaning yes, we're all in it for ourselves, but you and I have to work together and him and him have to work together. And so, you kind of have these alliances even as you're still looking out for your own interests. and they kind of come through in most coin games as, you know, two sets of two, at least the ones I played. In this one, it's a little bit different. In this one, like I say, it starts out where you're kind of threeon one because the Japanese are just a juggernaut at the beginning of the game. I found that the actions uh you could do in this game were again very intuitive. They made sense historically and thematically. To me, sometimes when I played coin games, I kind of scratch my head. I'm saying, "Well, now how does that work? Why is why is that happening here? And uh I think it's one of the good things that like GMT provides like a lot of the notes about the game of designers on why they they did things. That's always very helpful. And here I just I I felt like I didn't even need that stuff. I felt it was it was pretty intuitive what was going on for for all of the factions. So I thought that was that was pretty cool.

Really had fun with China's War. Another great coin game. Another fun coin experience. Really enjoying coin. Like I say, at this point, I've played, as I say, maybe half a dozen of coin and coin adjacent games, and I'm just loving it. I'm I'm I'm really enjoying it. I'm always looking forward to playing uh more coin games. There's still plenty that I haven't played. Some of the heavier ones I haven't gotten into that that I'll have to at some point, but I'm really looking forward to this. And I should say, too, I was also kind of cool because while we're playing this, Al, who is one of our regulars, he went to the GMT convention here, oh, several months back, and I guess he played China's War there. he learned from the designers there. He bought it. He's been playing it solo. So, he he kind of could help us out because he kind of understood a lot of the dynamics of the game. Um, and that was very helpful, too. But the rules themselves, I think, are pretty I think it's a pretty good rule book. I think everything's well explained, and it's, like I say, very, very intuitive. If you've played a coin game before, I think you'll pick this up pretty quick. This, in fact, if you're if you're new to co coin, this may be a good place to start. Although I'd probably still recommend uh either one of the two-player ones like British way or the coin adjacent guest of Robin Hood or uh even Cuba Libre, which I I think is maybe the most accessible one. Uh that one's a heck of a lot of fun as well. So, I really like China's War. I'm going to go ahead on the Cody scale. I'm going to go ahead and give this one an 8.5. Yeah, I think it's just fantastic.

Um with more play, it it it could go up on that scale for me. Thank you once again for joining us today on The Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on Board GameGeeek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear what you have to say. And please like and subscribe to this video and our YouTube channel. It would mean the world to us. Now, if you do really like what we do here, I'd urge you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history. I even post some of my lectures on that channel. It would mean the world to me if you'd subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what we do here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave the tip. You know, I think my cat is a communist. He won't shut up about Mauve.

on the solid ground. IT'S A LONG TIME THAT I'LL BE dying once a year. I wind up in the

And your life's work will have been meaningless.

No.

Progress saved