A Feast for Odin Review - Viking Feng Shui
Transcript
a couple of months ago we reviewed a little game called Cottage Garden a small gentle Affair about creating flower beds by adding odd-shaped tiles together also known as poly aminos in that video we remarked on the game designers Uber rosenberg's pension for creating games of progressively elaborate size and scope that little game grew out of the development process of this cardboard gantu and its Central mechanism of adding tiles together being pretty much the Christmas dinner of board game mechanisms A Feast for Oden huge perhaps even too huge and different but it's still rooted in UV rosenberg's tropes of worker placement and of vast variety of paths you can take welcome to fist for Odin's player board this is your thing Square now stop sniggering I can hear you thing square is where your Vikings gather before going out to kill and murder stuff after they killed and murdered stuff like animals or innocent lithuanians they'll bring loot they have found and neatly arrang it on display It Is by their interior decco design skills that Vikings were judged following the Fue style of stuff placement they could truly achieve the pleasure of the nose Gods like many other Euro games A Feast for Odin has you vying for victory points have the most at the end of seven rounds and you are the winner however this player board has you at a disadvantage straight from the get-go as you have 80 negative points printed on it not a problem grab some loot cover it up by sticking it pretty much anywhere
and you'll be fine except there's also this engine building element INB built into your hall you see this track of coins going diagonally right here well at the end of every round you'll have an income phase and the lowest uncovered number of coins that you have will be the number of coins that you get and coins are very desirable because they're very very tiny and versatile they can be used as any other tile to cover up your hall or also as victory points meaning you really want to get them but it's not as easy to cover these coins up because to cover one up you have to have everything below it and everything to the left of it covered up as well so get some coins pick up some tiles murder a Lithuanian sounds easy right that is Until you realize that you acquire tiles by placing Vikings onto this action board that has 61 different action spots let me reiterate that 61 different things you can do anytime your turn comes up the first time I played this game I tried to figure out like the best pathway of taking tiles or spending resources to get different tiles or spending Tes to get different tiles and I eventually just gave up and did the first thing that gave me anything at all hopefully figuring out something sensible to do later down the line it is a little bit like going to Tesco extra with a list that says eggs milk and sugar getting to the dairy section realizing it's 300 ft long and then just somehow ended up at home with a bottle of vodka tub of ice cream and some venison steaks without the eggs milk or
Sugar by now you've probably pecked that a fe Forin is on the heavier side of games every turn you'll be navigating a complex Maze of action every moment wishing that somewhere down the line you became a data analyst or a programmer or some sort of private investigator any profession that would give you the skills to be better at this D game each round you will ache over the possibilities missed as the tiles you picked up are never quite good enough they're too small two square or there's just not enough of them further complicating matters is the fact that not all tiles can be used everywhere these orange vegan tiles and red meat tiles can't be used to fill your hole but are necessary to arrange a feast at the end of each round if your Feast doesn't have enough different foods then you'll have to take thing penalties which are negative points some rounds you will have a harvest that will supply you with these but of course the action board offers you options of converting them into Tils you can actually put into your hall but even if you do convert them tiles can't just go anywhere green tiles are inferior loot meaning you can't place them orthogonally adjacent to each other lest you fill your hall with suboptimal poundland style tat you have to space them out with blue tiles or what even more painful with coins now I won't deny that it's fun to ache over this puzzle of Viking placement especially because different actions cost a different number of Vikings to place depending on how good they are so you could place a single Viking and get this horrible sardine or or you could place free and get a whole ton of blubber just imagine how much you could
cook with that but whilst it is engaging it is not really the most elegant of things it's less like your Mansion garden and more like getting slapped by a wet trout just leaves you standing there and looking a little bit flx it that's because the game throws you right into the deep end of this action board and gives you the shoddiest paddle in the world this single unassuming occupation card these occupation cards are the weakest part of feast for Odin there's two types of them one is a starting occupation card that you draw from about 15 at the start of the game and that's your starting occupation and then there are these Browner ones although not necessarily more poo poo and they come in the deck of their own and they're acquired through the course of the game actually not just one deck three decks you see at the start of feast for RO and you meant to choose whether you want to play with either deck a or deck b or deck C or combine two of them or all three of them or throw some out if you want to or burn one of them if I was to eliminate one card from existence there's so many of them and they're so unreliable that I don't think I would ever even miss it don't worry I didn't actually burn a real card this is just a fake spacer I did it to annoy you a little bit the idea of these occupation cards is that they're meant to drive your game in a particular direction although I would argue that it doesn't always work because they are so nebulous sure sometimes it does work and you'll get an amazing set of cards cards that complement each other really well but more often than not you'll just get a random stack of crap that you don't want
to even utilize and that is a problem this is the epitome of excess in board games and I suppose the ludicrous amounts of these cards is meant to say hey every time you play this game it's going to feel a little bit different but because 75% of these I don't ever want to see I don't think that works and that's what makes a feast for odent the Christmas dinner of all board games it's got every type of food your mom ever knew how to cook on one table and even if you really don't like the brussel sprouts then well you'll still be left reeling after all the roasts and vegetables leave you in meat sweats sure it's no dinner at a Michelin star hotel but it's never meant to be it's simply meant to be satisfying but if it was just brussels sprouts then it would be fine however someone sneaked these onto the table yep there dice yes a face Roden has dice which is weird for a Euro game because they're mostly games that require you to navigate a complex puzzle without luck getting in the way so here's how it works some action spots give you more tiles per Viking spend however to get those tiles you need to roll a die and depending on what type of action it is whether it's raiding or pillaging or wailing you have to either roll a high number or a low number if you haven't got the number that you needed to roll you can roll that same D two more times each time keeping the latest result if you still haven't got there you can always spend resources
like wood or weapon cards to bump up that result if you're still not there you will get some resources and weapons as a constellation price and if you got there well you got the thing the designer acknowledges in the rule book that it's odd to have dice in a euro game but overall necessary because it makes the game more fun I would argue that it doesn't however in a The Twist of events that surprised even me I don't actually mind the element of luck in the game it's just the fact that the dice mechanism isn't very interesting at the end of the day it's just roll a die and see if you got the number and that doesn't excite me but I guess if it was a little bit more intricate then the Christmas dinner analogy would fall apart so at least there's that let's take a moment to take some stock this is a meaty game targeted at players who enjoy little to no like elements yeah it has not one but two major luck elements free if you count the incredibly unhelpful random drawing of weapon cards that means that heavy Euro gamer crowd won't necessarily appreciate it as much well who is this game for then is it maybe for the Casual crowd I decided to go out onto the Streets of London and just ask people if they would play this game with me let's uh let's see how that went excuse me sir would you like to play a board game no it's about Vikings excuse me sir would you like to play a board game no it's very cool about Vikings it only takes 3 hours would you like to play a board game only 3 hours long Vikings it's only 3 hours long
Vikings excuse me would you like to play a board game 61 action spot every turn no one wants to play a board game okay definitely not for the Casual crowd well who's this game for then the boring answer is one for people who don't mind just the sprinkling of luck in their board games and be for people who enjoy a mediumweight game even though it has a truckload of different ideas that certainly ramps up the complexity it never feels impenetrable due to its elegant design instead it feels intuitive and will sit right at home with people who are ready to graduate from a lighter game or have already done so it's people who want a big Feast out of their board game but one that's not too over stylized it will leave you sated it will leave you full and it certainly won't leave you wanting there's something to be said about U rosenberg's understanding of game design and how to make each round feel a little bit different it would be so easy to find the most optimal route amongst these 61 action spots and keep doing the same thing over and over again for seven rounds but that would be boring instead each round feels just a little bit different and throws a peg into your bicycle wheel of a plan forcing you to find new solutions to new problems sure A Feast for Odin can be daunting on your first play so instead you'll just find yourself licking the gravy off this spoon or enjoying the pigs on the blanket before you learn how to properly dig into this feast and sure sometimes someone might have one more roast Spud than you but you'll still enjoy the
experience and I found that I also enjoy the experience I don't so much mind anymore the very random occupation cards or the somewhat wonky push your luck dice element in the game I just don't mind that they're there because I don't have to eat them I can enjoy the rest and it's fine and you know what I think you'll enjoy this game too thank you so much for watching this video if you have enjoyed click the Subscribe thing over there and be part of a cool board game gang if you've played ps4in or you have some thoughts on it please make sure to leave a comment in the section below and if you haven't done so yet subscribe to our friend John's Channel who's at least as funny as we are and he really helped us with this video without him it would not have been so much possible