A Message From The Stars - TCbH Review
Transcript
sir the aliens have sent a message they have what does it say so it was just the word spelunking and it's worth yeah it's worth4 points um so I'm just spitballing here but maybe we send back the word spitball and see how that does sir yes sir a message from the star is a Cooperative social deduction game where you play as either an alien sending Transmissions To Earth or as a team of scientists trying to decipher what that message means each round of the game the alien will pass a word of their choice to the scientists along with a score that aligns with their Cipher which includes letters that add to the score letters that double the score and a letter that makes the score negative no matter what after receiving their word And discussing it the scientists send a word back of their own that the alien scores on their Cipher and hands back play goes on until the end of four or three rounds if you're playing the harder difficulty which I'd suggest after all four rounds scientists collectively take their best guess as to what the alien Cipher is using all of the information they've gathered so far but there's a catch before the game begins both the scientist and the alien get a Mad Lib style message that they have to attempt to communicate to the other side through the words they send this adds just enough a wrinkle to keep the game from being too easy all players have to figure out what words will help solve the cipher while also getting their message message across after the
final guess you tally up your score getting one point for everything you've gotten correct that being letters in the cipher and words in both messages that's kind of it there isn't a winning or losing mechanic in a message from the Stars you just are playing for a high score which feels a bit anticlimactic everybody that I've played with has wanted something a little bit more from the finale I kind of wish in the rule book there was something to incentivize getting a perfect score or like just like a table that says when you get a perfect score you've reached the rank of pan galactic messenger but that's just not there when the game ends it is either a perfect score or it's not and everybody around the table just solemnly goes oh yeah cool which isn't great considering how much fun it is to play a message from the stars with that said the cipher mechanic is great adding just enough limitations to create a fun puzzle where you're trying to communicate the cipher but you also have to communicate the message and you're searching your brain for that perfect word and oh when you find that word it feels so great as alien and as the scientist there's definitely enough there to solve the puzzle almost always we were able to solve the puzzle within the four rounds which is why sometimes I think it's better to do the three- round version one it makes the game go a little bit faster F and it gives the scientists less leeway in their Transmissions that
they sent they have to be perfect or else it's going to be really tough to solve that Cipher the rule book mainly focuses on the Cooperative side but it does include a competitive variant on the last page of the rule book where two aliens send messages to two rival factions of scientists publicly but then receive private Transmissions back from those scientists secretly scoring them still trying to get their message across it seems like a footnote in the rule book but I think it fixes most of the problems I have with this game with everything being public in The Cooperative game it's really easy to deduce things out just by talking it through whereas in the competitive side you have to really think about what you're saying so you don't give up too much information while still helping your team solve the cyer it also makes the points matter more where making sure you get your message across and getting that perfect score can be the difference between winning and losing a message from the stars is great I think it has a niche as a light social deduction game that has maybe a bit more going on than say something like code names it might not have enough to sustain itself for an entire night of gaming but it definitely has a place at the start of an evening while you're working your way up to maybe a bigger deduction game that is my review but let me know your thoughts down below what is your favorite deduction game would would you respond to aliens if they sent you the word spelunking with zero context other than that it's worth negative4
points let me know thanks for watching thanks for tuning in and thank you for being such an awesome Community I am Eric with the cardboard Herold