The Red Cathedral PLUS Contractors Expansion - With or Without? A Board Game Review
Transcript
me I have a love-hate relationship with this game hi it's Tyrant and Stella from people University today we're very excited to do a review for not just one well it's one game with expansion red the red Cathedral and the first expansion contractors I just assume there's going to be more than one expansions well hopefully so we're gonna go through the overview of the base game first and then we're gonna give you an overview of the well the expansion and then I'm gonna tell you what we think of Base game expansion with without and so on so red Cathedral it is uh there's dice involved it's a resource management sort of game and we are building these towers here in 16th century Russia and we're racing to complete these towers and get as many points as possible uh the game interestingly has two paces of points uh it's got what I call small points or reputation which is represented by this icon here and then it's got big points or Prestige represented by these Gold Eagle icons here and as you gain more and more reputation those things come together and it lends an interesting Pace into the game uh on your turn you'll take three one of three possible actions the main one is going to be to use the wheel so you can pick up any one
of the dice move it as many spaces forward around the track as it has Pips and then gain the resources at your destination once for each die that's there so moving that around there will give me this two wood twice so I would take forward and I would add that to my player board you also get the opportunity to do an action from The Guild card that is in that location so here I could get a coin for example and sometimes you get some bonuses for dice as well so that's the main thing you do at the end of your turn when you do that you re-roll the dice in that location so they're going to be different for the next player and that keeps things fresh your second option is you can claim one of the tower pieces going from bottom to top simply put your banner on it and you get the workshop tile that comes off it and this is a bonus so you either pay the money that's shown on one of these spaces to place that bonus there or if you can't afford it or don't want to you just flip it face over and block up one of these spots and from this point forward whenever you move that die you'll get that bonus so I could move green on a subsequent term one two three four five get this two Stone and get a goal in any orders you want yes and do that stuff yes the third action is you can deliver
resources to the towers and you can deliver up to three resources on a turn and they have to go either on your banners where you've done it so I could deliver a wood here and if I had two Stone I could deliver two Stone there as well three or you can deliver them to decorate the the tower which I don't have well set up at the moment but if this has previously been built um I could deliver a wood and some gems to make a door on that and I can do it on my own or on anyone else's and the colored door the green one yep and uh doing these decorations is going to give you some immediate Peak points Prestige points again points that's all big words yes you keep going round around the table like that resolving these actions and building these pieces and getting the points and coins and things on them until someone has built six pieces and that will trigger the end of the game uh you finish off you score majority points for having the most banners and decorations in these towers and the bigger towers that have been more built are worth more points so drives drives area control to the bigger places yeah um and whoever has the most big points at the end of all of that wins that's basically the base game yes now what
does the contractors bring to the game so the contractor's expansion it really does two things the first is that it just gives you a whole lot of new Guild cards and you would swap out you would swap out the cleric which is the one that focuses on giving you little points for one of the new ones from the game and that just gives you a new focus a new sort of thing to do lots of replayability there but the other thing and the major thing that contractors brings is the new mechanism with this board here the contractors specialist board and you've got a new player board overlay as well that works with this so there's six uh different cities here each either corresponds to one of the towers or is blocked out yep there is a new resource that replaces little points called permits and there's a new yep that will be replaced as well I don't have one with me but would be replaced uh and there's also a new die which is the Black die you've got a fourth option for your turn which is you can send one of your contractors out to find a specialist so you will pay permits equal to the number of contractors in your destination including yourself so it will cost one permit for my first one in a location if I wanted to send a second one there
it'll cost me two permits I'll go somewhere else four one yep so I popped myself out there that's fair player though not per other player uh including other players including other players the if you went there next you would pay two phones yes yes and then you would take one of the specialist tiles that is one of these Stars adjacent to that City moscow's adjacent to them all and pay two coins and place it on here and this kind of works like a workshop except it's once off so when you move the Black die you can use this and then it comes off your board and flips over and shows you a tool icon the tools you're doing a set collection of dissimilar tools and that will give you big points at the end of the game uh there's a little bit of area control out here so when the tower that corresponds to that is filled like is complete so all of its portions are built then you will gain big points equal to your contractors in that City multiplied by your banners on that Tower to give you more points away multiplayer yes um these replace these replenish every every time and then once the tower is is done that city is closed so that's really the three things it brings it brings all these extra bonuses it brings
the set collection and it brings this extra sort of points by uh focusing your contractors into the same Tower as your as a tower that's going to be complete you made it like really easy but this is quite a brand branding game and despite of the size of the box my perception of it before I played it a while back ago it was uh kind of like medium till light is I mean the rules is not that heavy but when you start counting the points it's like it's not as heavy as kanban but when you set the points that's a big thing I know it's a big comparison but you know what I mean there's like the the gaps between the the actions in kanban is not too difficult and here the action is not too difficult it's basically three different actions with the contractors the fourth action this this board is really neat because sorry oops so this is like double kind of like double bottom and you can see it double there and then it just Clips perfectly in there sorry Karen like that so like oh that that fits very well so uh yeah that's just neat like it's thoughtful thing I think uh what do you think there well I don't think it's as brain burning as Care Bear saying that it's
one point that you can potentially get old combo your actions so I'll focus on the base game first I thought it was really quite nice and I thought it was a really nice um you know gateway gateway plus sort of um game because it's not a Gateway game I think well this area is more complex than I think it is because I I think it is I think the actions are very simple I think it involves you know it brought me back to Qatar because it involves a dice roll it can sort of change things on you really quickly and you know it's simple you go around and get resources you put resources out there and you're trying to area control in three like in um five towers and you can do your area control uh by completing the sections and getting banners and they're worth a lot of points and area control points or you can zip in on other people's towers with these decorations and get a lot of you know get big points but spend your whole action doing that and I just liked all the different options the fact that they're even in the base game there was about I think there was 12 of these cards and you use one from each of three sets and where they uh where they end up gives you all these different sorts of it gives you a lot of a surprising amount of replayability and like the first the first time we played we had this guy who was worth um little points
quadrant as the little points marker and I got a little points workshop on my white die and the White die has a nice bonus where you can pay coins to move it further which the other dice don't have to get coins keep Landing there I just kept doing that I I there was like a couple of them on there and I just kept doing laps and getting like three points every time and because it was near the end of the game even more like every little point was a big Point as well so yeah I just I really it really stood out to me that that extra option was sitting there it's true and it means you know there's going to be heaps of those sorts of combos not every game is going to be the same there's always going to be these little extra ways you can go about it and that has that guitar and feel as well because sometimes you've got a map that gives you like three forests because they're all next to each other and you've got to play you've got to play it as it lies and I think this in a very simple way gives you a lot of flexibility on playing it as it lies so me I have a love-hate relationship with this game I love it because of what you just said but then I hate it at the same time not hate is probably a strong word I hardly use that it's sub frustrating at the same time I plan my turn Okay I want to do this this is a dice one two three I'm gonna land there and then somebody do that and then roll all the dice and I can't do that anymore so that's like ah it was like a bit like five tribes I think in that way the game has the five tribes issue yeah
um it's not not quite I mean it's not exactly like fire tribes because the biggest issue with five tribes and then yamatai which came after it was that kind of the perfect action for everybody is usually a variation on the same thing and I guess that's sort of the case here as well because you everyone would always be able to play the same set of dice for the biggest action but then it all changes and if you're not thinking ahead there can be a lot of downtime trying to reap recalculate what is optimal so yeah maybe it is quite long like five tribes yeah yeah um trying to you don't want that thing where you recalculate every time because that will slow things down it's not always hap doesn't always happen but when that happens that could be the case I mean I you know if I if you have coins that handy you can just move other dice but sometimes like I just really need that one the Green Gem and you just couldn't get any of the dyes to get there to complete your thing and then other people would come I just compacted this because so that you can see everything it's not like meant to go like that but then other people that just finished there it's my fault as well I didn't really like race to complete my bottom Tower and then I lose some points because I couldn't get that one and then I was like oh I'm gonna complete that but I want to wait until I have this gem so I can get the decorations happening as well like that's also my fault there's a
nice timing piece to that yeah yeah yeah that it's like that's a good puzzle which is really good it's really puzzly but at the same time could be frustrating this is what I say love and hate relationship with this game I love it but it can be frustrating yeah I think for me I really do like it and I think like five tribes you need if people aren't on the ball and thinking about it it's going to it's going to stretch out there's loads of loads of replayability for this for this one it's like how you built the Tower this is like one of the random Cuts you draw how you brought your Tower these get placed randomly we're talking about the base game we're still on the base game yeah okay let's just like keep my point um opinion for the expansion a bit later on the expansion so this this board um I know that I can reroll my dies in the best game as well but it will give you contractors which hand in handy like some of the bonuses here you can focus on other things you can get you know whatever you want to say oh yeah that's the thing that I need so you just grab it by sending contractors but then you have to get these resources as well sometimes it's hard to get it's sometimes you just want to set your contracts at one place to get resource or get the set collection thing or actually endgame's scoring I think those three I think I'm lacking I'm like I want instant gratification so I kind of like I tend to just get it right now but this contractor is adds a little bit
more complexity in this area especially I'm saying brand burning like could be brain burning sometimes throwing to matters out and then change it straight away that's probably what I meant it's not that difficult and I definitely I will clarify it's not like Ken Ben but what I'm trying to say is kanban actually is like action and then scoring the scoring yeah the scoring is more complex something yes that's that's what I'm trying to say thank you very much I do like the uh the dice building well this is also on the best game I just haven't mentioned it before I do like getting this I think this is what happened I love it so much that I keep putting my banner without completing and then somebody else completed before me and then again all those coins yeah we did well we could bring that I'm just like I just want this I want that I want a lot of these that's a sign of good games right yes I'll tell you the the story of the first time uh we played with contract you I always remember your first time right first time we played with contractors there was a tower that was six you claimed the bottom one I claimed all the rest and ended up with two contractors on that um city so it was kind of a gamble because I had to I had to make sure the biggest tower got finished in order to score the points on here yeah and because I was going to get so many points out of it I wasn't going to get any help from anyone what was you had because you had the bottom Banner
um you could have stopped me from getting points off the top Banner by because you would you could have just waited there and never finished it but then you would have lost like 15 little points I know as I went finishing it so you had this incentive to finish it as well um so I think that was a very extreme example that's very clever mechanic though they you know surely thought of it I think that was a very extreme example of using this yeah but it's kind of got that same Pace as well so you've got the risk on the big towers that it doesn't get completed and never gets scored the small Towers you're not going to get anywhere near as many points but they will finish early in the game you can complete yourself easily yep and the big points that you get from doing it because you score them immediately they're the more valuable big points that you get earlier in the game so it's kind of got a clever pacing to it yeah I guess this automatically the taller Tower once somebody's starting to put banners other people would also want to race to put banners for their points especially then they look at the contractors oh they've got a lot of contractors I want a piece of that because you know this majority point but second players also get something and third player gets something so there's a incentive all of just putting one Banner in it or decoration really um overall I don't know if this new mechanism it's definitely well balanced and it gives if you've completely worn out your old red Cathedral this gives you some new new options and Pathways but it's
one of those expansions for me that detracts from the Elegance of the base um anything to work to you but I think I would prefer to play with just the bass and maybe the extra guilds give that extra options and the other thing that made me you know I described before my excitement with just doing laps and scoring this this takes this one away and I was like where's where's my oh come on that's not fair where's my other fun way of scoring that I enjoyed so much last time so I'm sure there are other ways of scoring you know otherwise but yeah when that came up I was just like oh that's not fair Terence anyways that's a fair fair comments Fair opinion this you know I would think that this would suit the same group of people familiar with it and play multiple times because so as I say again lots and lots of replayability these cards that comes with the contractors for example there's one card it's actually several cards that bring a bunch of other stuff in it yes I've lost track of which ones of these are base game versus others but yeah there's ones that that have gems so there's new gems that come with yeah it's like it's full on like it's like a game on its this one here this guy has come with like brick tiles which give you some extra bonuses bonuses this guy okay here there you go to cash bricks into uh into points so if he's on a spot where the bricks are yeah uh laps now Terence
we're happy Taryn will be happy because of that yeah uh there's one that's got a whole extra deck of contract cards that let you like gather resources and complete contracts this guy's got his own meeple um so yeah lots and lots of and lots of icons all you have to do is bring one or two of well you're only meant to bring one of these cards in but it just changes it's like a Maracaibo like between scenarios in Maracaibo there's only one or two changes to the board but because of how intricately that board is laid out and it can feel like a whole different uh game a whole different game just with this one just with this one tiny difference it can change everything again I okay okay the extra board because it gives me other things that I can distract myself maybe that's not a good thing and then I abandoned a tower but um I think I'm gonna you know I like that maybe we can compensate Tara and you'll one game we play the base game the next one with the contractors and I get to I let you take this one your favorite little card no I don't there's some good stuff in here and if you really focus on this and if if everyone else is avoiding it and you spread out you can get like six yeah 16 big points if you get a set of all that's that's actually really good but uh towards the end if you are right there just like basically just one point unless if you like doing a doing laps then that's okay but then other people
would do laps as well now have you played the red Cathedral did you pick it up at Essen this is also one of the game or expansion in this case that I mentioned in our most anticipated SM 2022 games which is the expansion now I got it earlier I just hadn't had a chance to play it earlier oh well I did but I haven't we haven't had a chance to do the video earlier before Essen and um this is this is it so I think if you play it if you love it you play a lot in your groove then I would recommend getting the expansion but otherwise the base game would be fun too is that fair to say I think so I think you would you would want to be very well acquainted with the base game before going to this expansion it doesn't um it it doesn't click on easily yeah but um
hopefully you enjoy that if you want us to make more of these type of videos or suggest us what sort of games you like us to review even please do write in the comments that will really help us hit the like button subscribe if you haven't already done that the Bell thing you know ding ding ding if you want to get notification I'm also on Instagram so find me there as well and hopefully we'll see you next time thanks for watching bye