Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 10:07

give me your hand quickly what are you doing Earth we want to review earth right this Earth this is the review for the board game Earth the good and bad about it by the end of this video you will know if you want to dig into this we have six growing questions that we will answer in this video but before we do that be honest what is this game Earth all about it's about ton of cards essentially you are building an island and you're playing cards into your Island and creating opportunities score points in one million ways during the game you will plant Flora in your Tableau whenever somebody places their 16 cards then the game and triggers and then whoever at the end of the game has the most points these green leaves wins the game each turn one player is the active player who has this token he will select one of the actions he wants to do he selects the action he does the top part of the action and everybody else at the same time can do the lower part of that action and those elections let you do multiple things for example plant new Flora or get resources to play these plants like soil another thing you can do is create sprouts and last thing you can do Growth Action which basically places these wooden thingies on top of your cards and they all score points inactive players do the same actions only they are a bit toned down one more thing you do on your turn is when somebody activates an action is you also get to activate your Tableau most of the cards will have an action that is

associated with one of these big actions for example if I pick the red action I can activate my red cards and do extra actions just a lot of things you can do on your turn or on somebody else's turn there's tons of choices you need to make just for actions though and it's quite quick fluent but how good it is we're gonna talk about in this video so we should jump to the first question which is who would you get this for three two one smooth engine builders that non-gamer gamer that I call wife person so my wife person saw this cover and were like um that looks pretty then you show some of the plants that looks pretty and every time we play she goes like oh look at this plant or oh this plant's creepy the visuals of this game will make it easier for me to get this on the table to play with my wife then for example any fantasy sci-fi or anything else it's just such a welcoming visual appeal to this game she wouldn't call herself a gamer even though she is a gamer so that's why a non-gamer gamer because she really enjoyed this did I hmm we'll see this is an engine builder meaning that this is one of those satisfying games where you played bunch of cards and slowly progress each of your turns you get better better and your system start to flow and whoever builds like the better system with their cards wins usually a lot of these engine builders have a lot of downtime this one is smooth because you play all at the same time means it's quicker and there is a lot of other life improvements in this one if you like pension Builder playing cards these Euro style games where you

get better each time I think this is for you so what are the three best things about this game my third best thing about this game is going to be photos they just look great you mentioned the design of the cards complements the photos a lot of times when you see photos on board games you already feel like I don't know if that's a good idea but this one does two things one the card design and the other thing all of these pictures feels like in the same theme they all look similar have the same Instagram filter they just feel like a nature album would look like it's all cohesive I love when the games put down like this little flavor text at the bottom like a scientific fact and there's a ton of these here my number three thing is decisions versus rules it's mid to high level of difficulty but overall the rules are quite simple to explain because they use very clear icons and even though it's a competitive game all the rules you can say I'll explain it when it matters for example planting the card quite easy to teach even though it's quite a difficult game we are all playing when somebody selects an action they do the top half everybody else does the bottom half and then everybody does their actions on their cards sure sometimes somebody will take longer to figure out what to do but most of the time you have always something to do my number one actually wow is the smoothness I think this game is really original with that feels just as rewarding as like interpreting Mars or the big ones but they have implemented

some is just improve upon it and make it really really smooth yes we do all the actions at the same time but also the iconography that I mentioned before Oh here so it's easy to always do these actions and there is not a lot of them but they feel like when you play them that there are a lot of options and things to do from the get-go felt like crazy let's go this this nobody ever almost had any questions okay my first is gonna be all cards good cards it just has been my experience that I always have problem deciding what to discard some cards just give you upright a lot of points some cards give you points because they interact with the scoring cards some cards have huge one-time effects some cards you can afford now some cards you can afford later so maybe I should save it for later I always feel like any of the cards I pick could be good and maybe is good I will complement that with your Island your Tableau that you play is called your Island and all the mechanisms there are very rewarding playing those cards makes you feel good and there's also the system where it really matters which card you play next to what card each of those cards will give you bonuses for each of those actions you can get points for almost any card in rare cases you will get maybe one card that you don't like you can always compost it and just get points from it but yeah I talked a lot about the good things about this earthy game are there any bad ones well let's see why this game might not be for you AP or analysis paralysis people who take

a long time to decide what you want to do if a lot of decisions paralyzes you oh boy this is like your worst nightmare this game might not be for you if you take a lot of time deciding what to do and your friends always go quicker then that's not for him there are always six scoring cards that you all share and you have to consider all of them just so many things that even people who don't have AP yes still struggle with this one daunting is what I wrote down it's daunting even for me the first time well I gotta follow so many things but it gets easier the more you play like by the second time actually you already know okay okay I'm already comfortable with this smaller one but it's text with these cards all of them are unique especially the objective card sometimes will have a lot of text and uh you need to make sure that everybody understands how it works and sometimes you're not quite sure it's not a big deal but it's just six of these does this if it's there like this which can get complicated with these cards uh I have a very very small one do you have any bad things to say about it about text I see what she's there anyway the insert it's bad it's non-existent yeah I mean there's a ton of cards and it didn't have plastic baggies for them and without plastic baggies they're just kind of sliding all over the place and there's a ton of cards I mention there's a ton of cards there's a ton of cards three two one there's enough to explore on Earth just like in real life there's so many places

we haven't visited and probably will never In Our Lifetime and there's so many cards here that you won't explore there's so many strategies that you can replay it multiple times in one evening and still will feel like there's some replayability my wife when we played the second time she was like I give this my stamp of approval always increases the amount of chances I will get to play this game I think replayability is not an issue in this game but what is the best alternative for this game three two one everdale I knew you're gonna pick Turf in Mars or at least write it down I'm just presenting a diagram here when on one end we have wingspan on the other end we have turf ring Mars and the Earth is right here in the middle of this spectrum it does have the same feel same like Tableau building uh looks many actions you can do but it's somewhere in the middle in the level of difficulty for me it's everdale because of the Tableau building also about the color scheme and the creatures all four are really good games that you could put on a table okay well what's the final rating then three two one must have wait that this doesn't happen often I would have gone with fantastic but since my wife likes it and I know I I could get it to the table I must have it this is not our copy we borrowed this and played this and now we'll I guess we'll have to get it well I want a must have all most of the games I play but let's be realistic here but if my wife likes a game or my kids really like the game I mean more inclined to get it and

I guess I'll have to I'll have to get it now to play with my wife and maybe try solo like you said does sound like good fantastic game we didn't mention it but it doesn't take long to play with like four players including the rules it's a bit less than two hours and I think I can see it going down way way more I liked airplane Marsh not as much as you but I liked but it's a long game and wingspan is really nice but it's not as crunchy as this one I want it to be crunchy they basically took one of my favorite games of all time turfing Mars and just made it like smoother I'm not saying it will replace terrific Mars because there are different games but just for certain situations for sure I will put this more on the table just to give good good you know who else is good it's good they are good because they're gonna like this video right and even better than good are our supporters they're really awesome at patreon and baby join the board game hangover family and be awesome and we do extra content for our supporters there's a new video every month

Progress saved