Skip to main content
Loading video...

Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest - Discussion

Transcript 22:33

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for libertalia the winds of gale crest the ever exciting remake of a cult classic of the original libertalia that i don't care about anymore because it's not on so um obviously this game has been gaining a ton of flack just for even existing um and i gotta say from from my point of view i do like this better um but it is the same game like uh with a few minor tweaks so if you i i mean zack will probably he might differ but i would i would say if you like libertalia you're gonna like this um the biggest discrepancy between the two is the art so let's get that out of the way this art by itself is fine it is it's not amazing it's not like it's not like no one's comparing this to like i mean people might with everdel but everedell has like the charm and the whimsy you know i actually like the i wouldn't compare it to everything well because it's animals that's the only thing that i would kind of bring it up as this is like weird indie low polygon type of art right very very uh cartoonish yeah very bright vibrant it is fine it's i don't know why they changed it i think they easily could have just done the same kind of cartoony art style with

humans and with this the characters from the original but whatever because that's that seems to be the biggest thing that everyone is [ __ ] on this and the furry the furry jokes that i made the entire run through i mean justified whatever it's fine but it doesn't affect the game but the art's not bad it's not in fact i would even argue the original is dated in some way sure but an art subjective so that's what people can grasp uh and rate this a one for without ever actually playing it but with that being said um i actually do like this better um mainly because it is it's more modern it is streamlined there's no confusion on cards like we were talking about with the original uh that there are clarifying um like it clarifies what those very specific cards do uh even like the small thing we mentioned about the exile versus the discard that's very clear in this one so apparently so obviously those were issues with the original uh that that i guess they were like oh we need to fix that with that being said what do you guys think of libertalia winds of gale crest i'm um i did feel like it was different player interaction so in the original one there's a lot more tokens that affect other players when you take them here there's only one really now uh yeah the saber right the the abilities yeah the tokens if you flip the board are more aggressive yes and also i'll bring

them out uh while you keep talking there are uh tokens you can swap them okay so at least for the way we played it was a long side okay so it was a lot less i call it aggressive versus the other game was on yes choice of token like realistically you made the best choice every time you could with these tokens yeah where like when we played the original libertarian um sometimes you chose the token that helps you more than what it was going to do if it fell into someone else's hand yeah yeah those are those are auto so um so yeah like uh the night sight for the amulet would be gain one for each reputation token to the right of yours the relic is at the night you lose a coin instead of at the end you lose three right the barrel is you may discard this token to gain two reputation and at the end you gain two money the chest is you gain four coins plus one for each of your map tokens the hook discard the character that gained this token the saber discard the character of your choice from an adjacent player ship there you go there's the the original and then the map if you have more map tokens than any opponent gain eight money and discard your maps otherwise keep your map tokens for the next voyage oh that's better yeah yeah i like this because it's not so much hinged on luck of the draw like you at least can gain something if you gain two um but i do like the fact that

these are versatile and you can just shuffle them and be like oh which one do we want to do okay let's do the barrel knight you know or flip the board and have all night tokens right right so i i like that these exist yeah it does seem the tokens the loot themselves are not as cutthroat but the cards ended up being right like a lot more cars killing everyone and definitely just again clarifying the cards are fairly cut and dry versus the other one could be subjective and like reading this all like the preacher was one of the more classic ones because the old preacher basically says discard all but one of your loot and you know one loot yeah is it talking about the day or is it talking from what you have this one's very clear your loot yeah so you only have one yes that's cool that's kind of nice it is nice and that i mean once again i didn't really flack the original for that it came out in 2012 sure um so i would have i would have [ __ ] on this one if they didn't fix it because it's like okay you had 10 years to add your yes uh brett what do you think of this one um largely the same i agree with all the pluses and minuses that have been discussed and all that pans out for me the one thing that just bugs me but you know but on the night time or the the other powers i can see is just the whole concept of uh reputation um seems to be so important on the cards but it ends up having very little to do with the actual game mechanic right um that bugged me but i can see on those powers they suddenly become a lot more strategic right because you're

constantly moving up and down yeah the order of the cards kind of threw me for a loop because there were a time where it's like wait does reputation mean i pick first or my ability goes first because honestly i'd rather have my ability to go first right but i guess it depends on the card it depends on the card and when you play it right so and we were doing it of course where you you pick first because ultimately that's kind of what you want to go but there's a lot of cards here that are like i really need to go before everyone else like my brute it's like or whatever it's like man i'd really like to play my card first right but i also feel like the overall feel for me playing was more strategic not a lot yeah but then the original the original one more of a party silly let's throw our cards and see what happens you can almost play it random blind draws true just to see what happens right yeah this one i really felt like okay i want to do this now and oh if i do this if i do this i can do that and not lose there's a lot more combo capability that would seem like it really didn't matter what cards you drew you could find some combos to walk through and i think having the 10 cards the 10 extra cards adds more versatile my favorite part of the original was the fact you draw six and you're like ooh and then this one because you still draw six but you start playing more that opens up the possibilities for way more combos because there were multiple times you thought i was playing certain cards and i was like am i missing something but then like your how you saw cards to use was different than how i saw him and i like that yeah uh all right zach um this game is is

technically better than the original i think yeah i think it's um i have gripes about it which would probably make them about even in my mind yeah the board is is a little messy i i would agree these need to you're talking about like these specifically just organizationally yes it could be streamlined sure it's weird that these are on the top and i i don't know yeah it's not a big grape i like that these are here um but i don't like the fact that they're see-through like the because there's a lot of space where they don't you know most of them don't need to right like replacement for me so you have chest then barrel and the ambulance all by itself right those should all be like you know like the benefit one should be at the top no i would agree with them because they didn't want to cover the art and they certain games do this they they uh they take like what is it style over substance it's like your text that that needs to be just pure white right or this white so like it needs to be darker but then like the the stuff above it that could show the art that's fine but it's like that from a distance like i wouldn't be able to read that like what the [ __ ] you said and i know that you're getting into all of it right and i know the amulet it's the same whatever and then you have these like with no player aid this is all you've got to go on exactly so it's i i would agree with that the board while really colorful is not in like super helpful another small gripe compared to the first one these tokens are neat but having i mean that's going to be public information we're playing on a very big table so if you're playing at home it's potentially you're going to be able to see your partner's um

score but like you're you're ultimately if it's laying flat you're going to be out what's your score between turns yeah like halfway through it's just easier i mean they could have easily done a score track around like i mean that's generic but it's accessible and everyone can see it no i i agree i think like because the game is obviously about having the most loot i get why they chose this to be like oh my treasure chest of money i like that in terms of theme but in practicality these are just so annoying like i don't want to ask what everyone scores whenever in the first one you could easily just look and see the idea of like health and mana markers from like an uh game and they're like let's just do that with score that's not necessary for for victory yeah exactly uh well because in in in this one where a lot of the cards are affecting other players and the first one as well with tokens it's like who i choose to affect is going to be dependent on where they're at on the track or potentially what um what our characters are in their ship but because i have to now stop and just be like hey what's your score what's 60 what's yours 50.

oh it's just stupid when i can just then immediately look and then pick right another thing to kind of go off of how these things aren't really practical i like the fact that they have the ship and the graveyard i like that what i don't like is the fact that you have to stack them so if you have nighttime effects or and the voyage i now have to be like can i see your ship cards to know if i'm killing anyone's people who know which ones do you have versus the other ones where they're all laid out and i could be like oh okay i know who that is yeah but the word they're very mean that could affect anybody's ship because they're the swords only affected the island oh maybe that's why i don't know that there was very many you know that's a good point actually i think you're correct i don't think i think it was something the only one that i remember the brawler was yeah you're right was it the wrong no the um uh not the brawler it was the yeah the number 22 the bro not the not the brute well that's only if you're yes you're right okay no you're right yeah the brood was the one who removed the eye right no the brawler is the only one that effectively killed someone else from another ship yes not the island which again terminology is a little important in this game so like and again one thing that is nice they put island here so there's no depth no no this is the island yes clearly i will say just aesthetically i do like the fact that everyone's ships are different right that that's cool uh they had no reason to make this a lore game like it's like okay what is this

it's a lineup game it didn't need thor but they did it anyway yeah it's like okay um but the the additional cards i will say actually because like in the first one there were we whenever we did the run through like there were multiple times where it's like these the same kind of sucks i can't really get a synergy in this one every voyage i'm like oh oh okay oh okay i can do this yeah yeah i always felt like we had some energy and i also like i mean yeah they definitely look like starbursts but i will give them credit that at least you can very clearly tell like what they are um and immediately tell what you know what they do yeah uh and maybe that's why they just kind of had the ship thing and they then do a player aid because these are no longer hidden right who i'm gonna affect i can look up and be like oh okay you clearly have two maps versus them being face down right as tokens and it's like i don't remember what you have okay yeah i'll just pick you you know um zach what else you got um the only other gripe that i have i mean the the art is like you know a point below the original um yeah it's it's not my thing right it's not that bad once i look through it i was one of the people who like somewhat agreed to some people's critiques of like this arts kind of yeah and i do think it's kind of it but like that's the worst part of the game for me and that's really like not a big deal sure um outside of this it's a great game and this is doing nothing but this is basically like it feels like a um

partially an upgrade also a a uh expansion to the original game yeah um what it does is because the original libertalia was out of print and if you i mean some people sell it for like 50 bucks but most of the time i remember i think now people are knowing this is coming out so they're trying to get rid of their copies but originally i think it was selling for like 100 bucks like people were scalping and that's what this that's what this did well it's like hey here's a beloved game everyone loves it here you go and they they made very minor tweaks they didn't give it libertalia just to sell it and it's a whole new game so the tweaks are improvements for the most part i i would agree i actually like the fact that you get the same amount of cards but you play more right um each round but what's interesting about that is our run-throughs for both games was the same right so about 50 minutes but maybe maybe a little bit longer for this one and that's that's actually a huge plus because normally it's like great this game was three rounds oh they added two more now it's five rounds or something stupid now it's an hour and a half game and it's like this game wouldn't be great if it was an hour and a half one of my biggest concerns because i knew the round structure the day structure at the beginning it was gonna go one through four then one through five then one through six at the end yeah right um my concern was instead of getting nine cards at the beginning you're gonna have those early cards that everybody forgets about and by the end of the game you play a card that everyone forgot about

and they're like oh [ __ ] i didn't know you had that yeah um there are more cards in here that allow you to pull cards out of your graveyard and your den yeah back in your hand i saw i think we saw four of them he had a full hand yeah especially by the end of the game like i had like four cards left and he had nine so we had the um the necromancer the surgeon the innkeeper and the other one that allowed you bounce again another card so like the uh guy where is she yeah yeah oh you said the innkeeper yeah yep so i mean there are so many cars to bounce stuff around but and then hooks allow you to keep stuff in your boat which is interesting yeah the hook being like okay like i get to keep which i didn't think it through that was in your boat and not it back into your hand correct originally stay in your ship but that means like you know but then you can play the innkeeper and bounce someone back or what i did like i got the hook and i'm like oh well it's the last round okay that's two coins right like okay um but i definitely see where you're coming from i think in the first one maybe i just don't pay attention enough but even by the third round and the original i was like oh i didn't even remember you had that this one does accentuate that even more though if you are keeping and you're like i think i got it okay that's probably what he has left and this one yeah you really have no hope you know what they got and the old one i did like blackjack so i just did plus minuses for everybody to figure out odds of what cards you can you also have like a little leg tapper when you have like a body exactly

this one i was more like i think i'm ahead yeah i i didn't strategize as much with card counting as in as i did in the first one this one i was like oh here's the card like the synergy the combo that i can i can do i'm gonna try and go that route and it's let's just hope it works out right um but yeah i i think this game only enhances the original you now no longer have to pay someone a hundred bucks to get the same game you can pay stone meyer 80 bucks no i have no idea how much how much this game is um but because they were nice enough to send me a review copy but but yeah i think they kept they kept the game pretty much the reputation track once again it's there i think it i take it or leave it on the reputation track i like the fact that if you until we play those that's going to be yes yeah like that's going to make the reputation a little more make it huge and also this is probably that's where we get cutthroat so you start knocking people back so they start losing money um which is i mean that's fine if that becomes and like i said the reverse side of the board if depending on who you're playing with it's like okay this is for families right and and then you do the night side which actually looks pretty dope kind of like this actually it you know what this reminds me of this is sea of thieves that is exactly what this art is yeah i'm like man i feel like i've played a game like this uh yes sea of thieves

so which i still to this day has the best water i've ever seen in any game um but it has too concerning like 90 percent of the game is water yes but also there's nothing to do with it that's why it was free like two days later right no but yeah then then it already has those abilities but you can be like ah this one's a little too mean let's do the whatever though you can tone it back a little bit yeah and i like that right so and because it's stone meyer they're probably releasing expansion did the original have an expansion i don't think so no okay so which is always uh a good thing yeah all right so you guys got anything else one quick question yes go ahead just quick round to the table if you have the original is there a compelling reason to get this i would say no yeah i wouldn't do it okay well actually no i would say yes only because this will be supported like if you chances are stone meyer is not like they're not fantasy flight they're not releasing 4d expansions for a game but chances are they will probably at least release one and then you can have more content so you would sell the first original and buy this that is what you're saying i would or wait for the expansion just because see if you like it just because i like having those kind of games that are modern and they'll be up to date and supported um but then again galaxy trucker got a new addition and i didn't sell my stuff and got that and get that um the other one was better right so but i don't know in the

original so and but so if you don't own either then definitely just grab this one don't get the other one but that is a good question i would buy this if it was discounted i'm not paying full face value for sure because i can get kind of the same experience but yeah without a doubt but if you didn't have the original and you had to pick between the original one and this one same price which one do you buy because you find out on mo can right so you know for the same price weber stonemaier which one do you buy right i would probably get this one not because i i like again i like the original one and i like having that older component it's something that less people have so that's yeah that's cool yeah but uh i think because the art in this is more accessible which was the whole point of making this art it's going to be accessible to families if i introduce this into friends this old tattered box of libertalia that's been played 50 times or this copy people are going to be more apt to play this copy true and i want to get it to the table sure though and uh and this does have a solo variant which i haven't tried but i will do a run through for it so that's also and stone meyer is probably one of the top companies that make solo games right yeah um or solar variants but i i mean to each their own like i think that's the dividing point is the art like if it's the same game and someone's like i don't like the r i guess i'll keep the first one but people will probably start selling there's more if this gets supported it's like oh hey libertarian expansion right the sales of gale crest or something that's what they should the sales of gale crest i mean if i have either one i buy this

one because the the language on the cards are clear yes it's for me yep and this has variety and the other one yeah you have the 30 cards and they'll come out differently this you have more cards and more abilities yeah yep so uh all right so with that being said on the scale of one to ten what would you give libertalia the winds of gale crest uh we'll do the same order uh i give this a nine also nine awesome yeah awesome there's certain things that pull it back from being because it isn't i do think it's a it's a more refined game um there are certain things they don't like so sure even so kind of evens out yeah i'd say it's an eight yeah just bump it up two and a half it's an improvement yeah me too slight improvement to eight cool yeah uh i think i'm actually going to what was that an eight for the first one i believe so um yeah i'll actually give this a nine like i'll match i'll match his i think it goes up one more point because it only enhances the first one right all right so that's our thoughts on libertalia the winds of gale crest let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share subscribe hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever

time of day it is for you

Progress saved