Frosthaven: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Zach and I are doing a discussion or review over Frost Haven um this is normally something I don't do because I obviously very much want to do this as a series on the channel however I have a bunch going on I have a bunch of Series going on on the channel already I think if I'd added this one I would never be able to find an upload for regular games because it's like I have what campaigns do I have I have a on trespass both sworn Madara uh uh Artisans of Slender Veil and familiar Tales so I have five campaigns going on on my channel and since I record them in bulk I have enough that I basically can upload weekly before I record again it's like I gotta find some time for other games um so so Zach has a copy and that's how we've been playing it like I've just been actually just playing it instead of recording So eventually this will be on the channel as a series whenever my schedule opens up probably when I finish one more campaign I think I'll I'll start doing this um but yeah here we are here it is actually uh Zach when you go and talk about what do you think of frost Haven well like Blue Haven box and show you sure um so it's definitely a Improvement on uh gloomhaven
um clearly Isaac took a lot of the things that he learned from making gloomhaven then making jokes a little lion and then making another Improvement upon the series um probably my biggest thing is still is going to be it is because I mean you can see just box size is significantly larger content-wise it's much more massive it is rules wise more complicated than even gloomhaven was like it doesn't feel that way because I played bloomhaven a ton and draws a line a ton but when you really look at side by side you have an entire new phase with a whole new set of rules with everything that was all the rules for gloomhaven in addition now all that being said the new sequence the um was it the selmet phase is [ __ ] fantastic yeah um you're literally building up your civilization so I think it's both of your ours as favorite part of Kingdom Death where it's a settlement building stuff up making armor right um getting new equipment put into this better your resources I mean we've had the comment glue made then they always felt like you had to collect coins for yourself to upgrade yeah now they have a system where it's much more um Universal the group is gathering resources for the group you can buy stuff you can use your resource to buy a weapon for someone else right in gloomhaven it felt it felt like he wanted semi-cooperative but it's like well your theme doesn't allow for that
so I just felt like you were being a dick to just rush and grab the money it's like right I guess I'll never get items and some characters were so much better at going and collecting loot that it it hurts basically everyone else in the group now like my character is fairly good at collecting loot it doesn't hurt the group if I have all the loot because I can share and spread that well my character I don't even have a way to loot right I could have put it in but I'm like well I don't really feel the need for it right um so basically earlier today I recorded the final top 10 segment of my the top 100 which should be out probably before this but if it's not uh shocker gloomhaven was still in our top ten um at like four and five I think for me and him and he was not counting Frost Haven I kind of maybe by the time I did my top 100 I hadn't played Frost Haven yet but I would just lump up together right and he was like well I hear that Frost Haven is everything gloomhaven just better and I'm like that is 100 correct Frost Haven to me is like it would be hard to go back to gloomhaven I think because Frost Haven just is Superior in every way and if you watched my final final discussion for gloomhaven uh there were a bunch of another Bunch but there were negatives that I had for it uh one of which is like you have certain weapon cards that are like exhaust right one-time use one time using them like that doesn't even make any sense right Frost Haven we've haven't come across any of that I think
one item so far and but it's like a crude it's no shield and that's it and it's like okay well that makes sense it broke right uh but everything else is a tap and I'm like I'll take a tap to where it's like a special ability and you just have to refresh it sure right but all the little weird things that he put in gloomhaven that were kind of like based off of mechanisms instead of theme have since been removed or updated in Frost Haven right uh it's such a massive game I'm trying to figure out kind of a way to um like of like a certain point to start like it's clearly if you don't like gloomhaven you're not gonna like frost Haven right if you but if you're new to the Hobby and you've obviously heard the the stuff about these games um one we would probably say start with jaws a lot exactly like get that go to Target I think it's like 40 50 bucks uh so you can easily find for 30. that's true and it's not like what amazes me about Jaws of line which I've done a series and discussion for on that it's uh it's not like hey here you go you [ __ ] idiots like here's gloomhaven it's like no it's just like the best tutorial system right and then the rest of it is gluehaven right and then after you're done with that you're just like great we don't need this blue Maven rule book right we could just play it now um and I haven't personally read the rule book for frost Haven but what I've heard is that it's kind of like he tries to do like what's new yes in it he has
blue boxes for any section that's new um it basically becomes all new stuff well so it switches to basically um like upgrading your city and all the settlement phase well of course that's all brand new because glenhavior doesn't have that so yes and that is a big chunk of the rule book it's that settlement phase uh there's five pieces of it and they're fairly in depth um so yes it's all new but it's not like the in-game mechanics tend to be new it's that face is now new so I guess as with like kind of a lot of games if we have more positives to say than negative right soon we do let's start with negatives uh on Frost Haven uh it's massive it's yeah it's so massive it's huge it took me forever to do the insert but um not because I usually don't consider negatives of like production or like shipping obviously this was delayed significantly right um I usually don't consider that because that's kind of you know par for the course with a Kickstarter um the the one of the negatives that I actually have is the app yeah like that's it's done by Lucky Duck and there was a whole you know thing with like the guy who made the Blue Haven helper app um Isaac's one that just like he wanted to start charging or get royalties from him and the guy was like dude I made it as for fun right I'm not dealing with
that and then luckily you know Isaac and cephal Affair said well we'll we'll hire some hire someone to develop an app so at least it's there but it seems to have like a bunch of like weird quality of life issues it definitely is less in my opinion clean than the original one was um it definitely seems to have a lot of issues with syncing with everybody else's phone um which again when you're charging people for an app yeah how much is it like 15 bucks or something like that then I kind of really want to work well yeah yeah 15 bucks for a nap when the other one was free or was it no uh on Apple it was like four or five or five bucks okay yep um that's right because it costs and that's why Isaac went started wanting money right um which I mean I don't really blame him like if you're gonna make money off of an IP because that's where like all the the free stuff because he basically was like Hey use all my Gloom here and stuff make your own campaigns but if you're selling it then it's like well all right now you cross the line yeah the sinking one is one of the major bugs there's other times when you're including the scenario like in in the previous app it would just Auto put all those people in but then for some reason it doesn't do that every time it doesn't do it every time which is a little Annoying yeah so we kind of have come to we try the sync it doesn't and then it's like okay well we'll just go to the the dial we do the Dallas for every character and then play the monsters on the app on my tablet
basically yeah facing the group so that way everybody has a general idea of health and where they stand um so the app is definitely a negative for me um that's all I got I think I'm trying to think of other other negatives that Frost Haven has because it can be a negative for me is still going to be like it's a little discouraging it's it's both a negative and positive um we calculated doing like three scenarios once a week would still take us like eight months to complete this game yeah and I'm like that is a lot and we're talking two hours of scenario pretty much yeah so you're talking six hours plus an hour of setup and clean up on top of that yeah um and we're like veterans like yeah all beaten like it's me you and your wife and the jaws of the lion so it's not like we're like how do we play right yeah we're like trudging through and like that's including like you already have it set up for one snare that's including playing the scenario and then the settlement phase and then cleaning up and saying for the next one so when you really get down to it there's a lot of time involved and again you don't have to you can play this you know and complete 30 missions and be good it looks like you can pop out the main story arc and do none of the side stuff I mean that's kind of sad you're wasting a lot of it but missing a lot yeah but again if that's the way you want to play it it's there it it's great with that um but again it is a little like man
it's a lot of time it is uh it's it's an immense amount of time uh it's a fantastic DND replacement if you don't you want to do the envy you want an epic story right uh Frost David definitely brings that uh just like blue Maven did uh gloomhaven I think was even shorter probably for the main story now obviously I get [ __ ] off since I cut it we're not done with frost David right this is after about 20 hours yeah of gameplay probably roughly we've done eight scenarios or somewhere in that neighborhood yeah yeah if we're about two to three hours each you're close to at least on average 20. um and it's like after like like pretty much a full day's worth of hours we're like I feel like we're like we're still right at the beginning in our settlement um our characters are like level
uh but yeah it's it's a lot now I live for these these games are like always give me my favorite like my top ten of oh yeah is like all story driven campaigns all right so the length is not a negative for me personally but that's just because I can set aside the time for it right clearly from the box size you're not going to get a light experience right um so let's go ahead and uh I guess the the oh no I do have one negative I it's uh so this could open up later on we're still like I said at the very beginning but you how you get potions so the market is is like is tweaked a little bit it's not just like here's your stack of items right um they did it in a way where you now collect like herbs right and you can combine those to make uh potions and I'm like oh cool that's that's really neat I like that crafting system you like you do this and this and you don't know what it makes oh it's a healing potion but then it's like oh so now we can just make those no nope you just made one but we know how to make them now we should just be able to make it no no I find that very very odd right it would make sense if it's like you don't know what it does you figure it out and from there that point forward you could start making like healing potions or whatever but I obviously that seems like it's something again more mechanical than it is thematic right uh and as someone who
never loots like I never get those herbs so I guess I'll never get a potion right um and he still doesn't really allow for like trading or anything like that so it's kind of like like if you have a potion that's your potion right like well I'll tell you when you first character you can hand it to someone that's true but that's it right so that one's just kind of weird for me it's not like a big negative but it is just thematically weird and uh but other than that I like the idea of like that chart of like making something that's really neat I but other than that like so huh with uh let's talk about because one of my favorite thing about gloomhaven and Joseline are the characters yeah so let's talk about the characters in Frost Haven the ones that we have personally experienced are awesome they're so cool and and he did something amazing and gave them complexity yes like rainy rankings and kind of like uh like at the very beginning of the book it's like here's your characters this is what this is their play style right it's so nice oh great and not just on that so every character like in all the rest they're still asymmetrical they're all different but to the point that your player boards now explain some of the differences for your own character so where you can break like basically every character is kind of breaking some rules somewhere or adding a rule to something yeah it's not
only a player board and somewhere deep into a rulebook or a card it's one piece you have your awesome art yeah and then you have your rules explanation for the character and their backstory on the back right um yeah so we are playing the I'm playing the Gemini yeah or the the not the Gemini that's its race um horror no the horror is the race Gemini's it's class okay you're playing the blink blade right and then your wife is playing the um bone bone bone eater Shredder bone slice slice bone shifter bone shifter yeah um so we're missing uh we're missing three others because they start with six again right um but out of the characters that we've played so at this point I have I it for glue Maven the only characterize the V6 that I haven't actually played myself as the Mind Thief it's pretty funny I've seen the mind he played multiple times so it's like well I kind of have but yeah so all these characters were fantastic right um but because Frost Haven is still relatively new and you're not I don't play it where you can freely swap in and out I don't think you're technically supposed to uh until they officially retired right so uh we can talk about the characters that we're personally playing and that we've seen Ashley play right um I think they're better I think they're better at least the opening three are
better than the factions I played here so I'll put it this way again like we bring in Jones the lion on top of it I think just the lion are better characters um starting characters than the starting six in Gloom paperwork okay um so I think again every time he's made a game he's improved upon his initial six to make them feel good yeah because the initial six are good in gloomhaven but then almost every single time we would find one of new characters like man this guy just does this better right and like and that's it's fun that's fine buy one at the end of the game where I have all the options to say they're all equally great they're just what do they do special compared to someone else yeah I mean these are still a lot of fun but they're whereas the gloomhaven world is luckily not your generic fantasy Trope right um you still kind of have you have your brood you have your your Rogue or your robe is a scoundrel you have your I mean that's tinkerer wizard um I guess another brood basically another yeah um they still have their stereotypes but I mean it's a cleaner stereo yeah it's my brood actually in my entire run through was the only one that I never retired like I saw like two characters in blue Maven I just never unlocked them and then Frost Haven they don't they don't uh bring in new characters by unlocking by retiring these it's story driven right and that is super cool too it is because like we and one of the
opening like the second or third scenario we did it was just like hey here's the characters it's like we're like kind of looking at us like huh is he playable like is that a playable thing and we'll try not to do spoilers but yeah it was like uh I kind of want to play that now right even though the character I'm playing is so it's just so unique right um so you and I played the highest complexity ones the blip blade and the and the Gemini um actually this was the intermediate still okay so I won't say these two were the low complexity and then the person who basically poisoned slash damages themselves to support other players and the Summoner or the intermediates gotcha um which I was talking to so like again not really I was gonna grab the rule book and look at their names so we did the um opposite so the path we went on I have another friend playing the campaign and they went the other path and you selected the other person gotcha yeah it was and their reasoning was the same as ours like because we met them first oh yeah it's funny they'd be weird you're like hey man yeah we're starting with them you suck uh yeah so let's talk about let's talk about the neutral one the one that we haven't played but we're watching Ashley play uh this is she's like your Summoner yeah uh and she summons a bunch of like skeletons and wraiths and demons and stuff yep and she has like six Health overall but her entire dick is just you just have minions to
absorb all the damage from you right you make walls of people and you sacrifice your health to boost their power yep let them activate multiple times right um it seems I feel like that she's more complex than us in terms of like making her useful right uh because it's like well yeah you're never taking damage but your summons die super quick right uh so it's like maybe like late game she's bringing in like massive like demons and it's like oh that's cool and one of the cool things about it is they did change um at least I don't and she doesn't have as many lost cards like an old Summoner from gloomhaven and tons of cards that would get lost like every time somebody got lost she has summons that literally you can play if it dies it goes to your discard problem like a lost file so when she reshuffles she has it again yeah you play it another time yeah um and so to me it helps balance like you're not so worried about throwing tons of summons out that you're going to be like oh in fact if he dies I don't have him anymore my two Health skeleton dies versus throw them out let him charge some enemies hit something dive let's go again yeah right you'll get him this time right all right and then but she also is kind of a slight support because she has ways to heal and it's like and then I'm over there yeah I'm over there getting my ass beat and I'm just like where are you heal me she's like okay
has wall of skeletons to protect herself so she can heal me um she's that classic Necromancer and D that just does nothing but just walks around with a horde of zombies skeletons just feeding her grapes and wine and she just walks past yeah has him carrier right it's uh I think she's great um I do kind of feel like she's she's a little bit on the slower side starting out but I think that she will quickly as she I mean depending on how if she levels up before she retires right I think she'd be really good uh let's talk about your character the blink blade so very interesting uh his mechanic is at the beginning of your turn you have time tokens that you choose to either go fast or slow so again breaking rule gloomhaven there's two initiatives on each card and there's basically each card now in force Parts um depending if you go fast and spend a token yep you have faster initiative and normally you do more damage or move faster or more things yeah where slow there are cards that actually benefit you like I have one that heals everybody to help within range of three if you go slow yeah um or gives you ward and those type of things but and you gain back in time token but you only have so many time tokens yeah so you can't just constantly go fast even though you really kind of want to because you have high initiative you have lots of movements right um he has a lot of what I call the quick he does damage then can walk then does
damage and then you do the bomb side of your card it might be then run seven spaces yeah um that's pretty cool honestly like kind of your gorilla tactic right spider um yeah there's something more teleportation yeah that's kind of what I thought it was like portals and stuff but it seems It's almost like he like there's there's a video game that came out I think called Quantum break and it was kind of like he like it's like almost like when you're going fast you're like freezing time right to like rush and do a bunch of stuff and then when you're going slow it's like you're going normal right uh to like recharge up your your time manipulation that's kind of how I Envision it that's how I mean maybe you do get a teleporter in one of your levels right who knows because I don't I don't look at levels ahead I know either I think it kind of ruins some of the fun but right but he's really cool uh unfortunately we picked characters that were all very squishy yep we're all very squishy she has the lowest Health out of us three and then you and I have the same thing yeah uh so he's no drinks we have no tanks not not even a little we have very like I would probably call them this piss poor healing um I have no way to heal myself and sorry if you only like do dot healing yeah and she has like kind of one I think one burn card that's a heel yeah and then we go to mine which is the Gemini which is the one that would intrigued me the most where it's two decks of cards seven cards each at uh
and you have to so you swap forms and it's a melee form in the range form uh and you have a model for both on how you want to deal with it and the melee form is obviously you have to be adjacent and the range form is very restrictive it's not like oh your range form you can hit up to Range four it's like nope you have to hit exactly at this you know specific range right and there are cards that you play that have it forces you to change form so whenever I'm playing them I'm very you know aware of like well I just spent all my cards in melee form they're all in my discard pile I don't want to have to pop back and then start losing cards right but if you can balance that if you can go back and forth and he has a lot of I mean that's 14 cards really he has a long potential he has a lot of choices that you can start making yeah um because I can just when the scenario starts it's like oh okay they're all away from me range mode right uh his range is kind of like a lot of AOE uh damage it doesn't do a whole lot but like I I think the versatility of him is really cool right uh for doing that and I think like the last scenario we did you were trying to complete one of your masteries right and it's like I was basically in melee form the entire time and I'm just like at the front lines I'm like I'm not really meant to be doing this right heal me like it's it's just so unique are so great uh and then they went a
little bit more in depth with the characters on like the fact that they have now masteries that they try to do right um and these masteries in the game so you have your character sheet looks pretty much similar to your other one right from gloomhaven but now it's kind of like special like things you can try and do special challenges skills that you're trying to accomplish uh and if you happen to do it in a scenario then you check box it and it gives you a free perk right uh and I think that that's that's something cool yes nothing major but one is like one you're gonna kind of do maybe early on and then another is like late game maybe you're going to work if you like Yeah The Stars online like what yours one that we just got for you was you can't be targeted by an attack right we thought that was the easy one and it's it technically is if you just never did anything the whole time right you waited for but it's like that probably would have been easier had we had a tank that'd be easier if we had a tank it probably would have been easier if we weren't doing a um Escape mission for the one we chose to do it on that was also true um because there were definitely missions like if we had to just kill everybody that my ability to zip in and out of fights um but considering that our goal was basically continuously move forward zipping forward and backwards too often well it's going to be detrimental and then your wife [ __ ] picks the one thing never moves more than two spaces on an escape Mission because I thought I thought her character was just that slow
yeah and then she's like nope I had this I'm like uh and we almost lost because of that like yeah she's getting Slaughter because we both left because we were done like you could be targeted I'm like sure you were gonna book it like she'll get there and then like and then nothing for a while I chose to go slow I'm like I'm gonna go home yeah uh yeah and then one of mine which was to uh I think it was to lose a car in every round right uh which was like all right I'm exhausted guys right but my other one is I have to change forms every round right and that's just rough that is rough yep because either you're gonna get in a situation where you're only doing stuff maybe half the time because he was on time for it which again if we had a tank that probably won't be as bad true true um but they also instead of your regular perks that just like kind of change your modifier deck right now they have like three things that are special cards or special abilities yeah strip abilities I think that that's really neat um because I think our very first narrow we played like we had like them already out and I was reading and I'm like
it's like I'm a guy who just wants to move [ __ ] everywhere yeah that's like perfect yeah I'm like God yeah that's just so good uh and then the one I have currently allows me to ignore conditions if I inflict a condition for myself I can ignore it which you have a lot of cars that do that yeah one curses my I can curse myself to do a wider attack but the one that's even greater is one of my perk cards is another times two right it gives me break right and uh which is horrible because break is a new condition work your double brittle you're dealt double damage yeah and uh so I'm just like ooh times two ignore that right most attacks and then just instant kill you exactly so it's just so cool like the characters are still amazing to play as and then it's just a little bit of extra stuff throwing that not not making it too complex but they're still there it's still there one thing I do like about character wise is instead of having road events in City events that affect a specific character it now has three different characteristics of a character yes and so we don't need like again in gloomhaven it was you need the Inox brute yeah if you didn't have him you couldn't complete a now it's it's longer character you know has Nimble then you pass and so because everybody has three the chances of you actually having the one that you need right is there we hit one that didn't we didn't have anybody I
think was like barge or something like that yeah um so we couldn't complete it that way but again I like the fact that it's not a class specific because right if you don't like that class then you're just never going to hit that exactly yeah you just have instead of it being in a four player game you have four chances now in Frost Haven you have in a four player game uh 12 chances 12 chances yeah um 15. no wait it's three times three three each yep yep that is how math works that is 12. um yeah and this is so much better and then also the events have like are kind of a little bit more they still are do have very class like the one we had where was like hey do you have a a borrower in your group yeah we do okay well you can choose this option right uh it's like oh yeah I want to do that that sounds neat right uh so they do pop up still but yeah it's not just some generic Road event or City Event exactly that you need a specific class for um so I like that quite a bit better for character wise um I'll say again um the road events to see events in gloomhaven to me were weak they were very good or bad like they sometimes they were bad or bad right like in here they seem way grayer they seem more like this is just an event we've got a couple for whatever reason of male deliveries that's it and the question is do you open it or do you go give it to the person yeah and we've given it so far to the people every single time yeah but theoretically
and then they're like oh the legendary acts of God and you're like man we should have kept that right like damn it but then they're like Anyway here's 20 XP or whatever it is right all right it's never like we got something in return not being as good as the item that we've lost from that but it was good it was fine yeah but to me the choices feel better um I feel more involved if you don't feel like I just don't care yeah sometimes the road events in bloomhave I just didn't care man there were so many in Gloom Haven because I'm playing it on Steam again and I'm reading them out and it's always like oh you see a band of uh of gypsies on the do you help them or not and then it's like yeah we'll help them they rob you you start wounded right or and then it's like okay and then you get it again and you're like no we'll leave them alone they curse you why even deal with that if it's just gonna always make like the one that always gets me is like oh you see like you hear or smell smoke in the distance and you're like okay we'll avoid it and it's like well you took went the long way around you start with two discarded cards right oh we'll pull out the fire you start wounded right okay so these they just always felt like they were gonna dick you right and frost Haven hasn't really had that now the thing of frosted when we haven't hit is we are they do it by different kinds of Seasons so you're getting summer and winter yeah we haven't got to Winter yet yeah that's probably where all the Gloom Haven events come in right and that's what everybody has said like
on forums like yeah summer is like gloomhaven normal okay and then winter is where you get just demolished we're like oh man it's kind of cold up here but it's nice yeah winter oh we can't see anything we're gonna die right all our soldiers are dead our walls are in tatters bring up the spears is that an army of like right algox yay right are they bring snow demons right is that Lucifer but Frost version hmm guys uh what level are we yeah you lose 10 levels oh right uh what I was gonna bring up was so for this and this and draws the lion I will never play these if I were to go to someone's house and they're like and they started reading out loud I believe I do not have four teller no I don't like apps and games okay well you can do this by yourself yeah foreteller is it is a godsend and it is if you thought it was good in gloomhaven Frost Haven just kicks it up a notch like all the road events City events all scenario book events yep everything that has any part of the words that you would need to read out in a story is there all the options for the scenario um like Road events and City events are in there like you literally it comes pops up you choose a or b you click it it reads out that the the voice acting is way better
every character is like has their own voice the sound effects the the soundtrack is just fantastic it's just brought up to another level yep uh and what's even great about that because glue Maven was still very good the riding in Frost Haven it's like I think at one point Isaac hired someone with a sense of humor because because these are very hot topic edgelord like writing like your uh your creative writing in eighth grade English whenever you're going through puberty this is like oh you grew up so I think because that was made comment when it first came out or went versus being pledge the same person who did Charles and the lion rode in City events okay for this as well because again Gloom Haven is great for I call it first edition yeah and then you realize all the problems with it and you fixed a lot of them with Joshua line and then he said okay let's take it up another notch let's try and improve again what you did in my opinion with frost Haven taking everything they've learned so far and just said let's do it better yeah yep so the writing is funny um we'll also still having moments that are emotional but it's not like you know it's just oh yeah oh God I just want to cut myself because I'm just so depressed it's like Jesus Christ right uh and it's not just more involved even though the world is Bleak and harsh and uh who knows the writing could get very drab
it'll make sense versus like why is everything just weirdly emotional in this yeah so love the riding in Frost Haven so far yep um in terms of the campaign uh what I've always wanted and frost Haven's the only one that I can actually see doing it actually shows you your branching path which is so great it is so great when you're trying to figure out where to go or how far you are it allows the story path you're on exactly because if you finish it and you go back like we finished the main campaign we're like okay we're done we can go back to those sheets and be like oh we didn't go this way like a replay we didn't go this way we didn't go that way we missed 80 scenarios or even just like okay I can see this is the main path of the story but we want to go do a little side quest for a while now I can come back and say okay we need let's reread the ending for this chapter because we're going to go back on the main quest path yeah so because it's been two weeks let's just say yeah let's reread the ending so we kind of remember where we're going down on this path and what the goal and because that was my problem with Gloom Haven I realized it too late that I should have had like a notebook and basically done that myself yeah of kind of explaining each ending for every single section yeah so I would understand okay this is why we're doing this and where we're going with this with the branching path and what the choices were for going down six versus eight yeah yeah because every time somebody go into gloomhab and be like I don't remember why I'm doing right what I'm doing it
almost felt like every scenario was kind of isolated yeah it's independent uh there is an overarching story and I don't know obviously we haven't finished for our savings so I don't know if there's actually going to be an ending but glue maven's main story didn't feel like an ending I mean the final boss I heard the final boss I mean that shouldn't really be a surprise but so it's like okay yeah I beat the big boss don't really remember why I'm here or how he's here but the the final thing was just kind of like a all right well there's three main arching stories in gloomhaven they're all semi-tied together gotcha and so that was my problem too because we completed one not realizing that was one of the story arcs until like I went online after we completely finished gloomhaven and then we completed the main one it's like why is this that much different than that and then it's like okay they feed into each other but it's not well drawn out for you to know that and so again because it is it's not a sandboxes like sleeping Gods but still pretty sandboxing in the sense you have a lot of options at some points like I think third mission in we have like five paths we could choose okay and we're like in Frost Haven or yeah and we're like we're just gonna go this one because we want to fight something not um sure and yeah that's what we did and some of the scenarios actually require specific stuff yes and that so it's like what you're hard capped here until you go out and actually do this right uh and some
will pop up open on time based so there's now like a calendar in the corner if you open up um basically that mission will have popped at some point anyway yeah after just x amount of time yeah kind of like Kingdom Death it's like hey add this event to Lantern 15 it does the same thing here um which I like I do too cool I've always enjoyed that a on trespass does the same thing it's just kind of neat that you're you're given events at very specific moments right uh the I was gonna say something else about the campaign um oh the actual scenarios themselves are just way better yeah it's not I mean we've had obviously some Kill All Enemies right but we've already had to escape and we're not I mean we're eight scenarios in yeah and gloomhaven was it was like you had eight in the entire campaign that were just different the restaurant kill enemies we had now one of like kill specific objectives like we have to kill enemies it was just get to show my objectives um some were literally stand next to a pillar it takes a damage every time so yeah it took eight turns of someone standing there at spawn points like legit spawn points right so you're literally hacking Power Defense yeah right oh [ __ ] so that was cool that's cool and I knew that was coming in I knew Frost Haven was gonna kind of uh uh expand upon expand upon unique events and because some of the events are written and designed by different people right uh which is just better I mean again I'm not taking anything away from
gloomhaven in this review I still think blue Maven is a 10 out of 10 game yep um like I guess in comparison like in comparison I would probably not glimp him into a nine just if I was like one to one comparing them because Frost Haven is there for is this but better in every way right so it's like well okay I see more flaws in this than that so I guess the defrost Haven would be a 10 out of 10 and glue maybe there's a nine however you can take away from what this game brought to the industry as a hundred dollar massive RPG right uh with a brand new mechanic yeah that was light years Beyond most brand new mechanics exactly like you you had I mean there were very few campaign driven games that were good right like they replaced something like DND so if you don't have a DM and want something a little more streamlined like a module for DND fix that problem it did it did and it's like it did well it's the price point it just makes it that much better because it's like the only minis are your characters and then everything else is standees uh yeah I normally do like dollars to hours Like Glue maybe Alone um was so cheap compared to most other board games like the number of hours you're going to get out of loom Haven if you just play through it one time and again board games are supposed to be
played multiple times Blue Haven and frosting might be kind of the exception yeah you are making more money in hours to board game yeah like you're not making that theoretically inside Twilight Imperium right um and if you want to replay it you spend 20 bucks on the sticker and it's like okay now it's reset so get your you know 100 plus hours back right um and to make a different choice or play the steam version if you have a PC then that would probably be if you were done playing the board game and you wanted to play it again at that point I might say get the steam version just for ease of access right uh but I don't know there's just something about physically playing these games that are just I get way more into it than I do on the video I get way more into it on the physical copy all right so because I did the same thing whenever people were bitching about pandemic Legacy when that first came out I was like okay this was like 60 bucks right like you have 12 scenarios that's already five bucks a scenario you play it four but four players that's like a dollar 25 each okay yeah I'm like where's the complaint here well I won't get to replay it and then you can right or you get like I mean if if 12 months you get 24 hours out of it if it's two hours a game I'll put it this way how many people um buy or watch movie multiple times right so you Play Pandemic Legacy or gloomhaven once
the amount of time you know hopefully enjoyment that you're getting out of that game is well worth it yeah and then to me kind of even the bonus of so you play Gloom Haven you loved it but you know you're never playing again buy the 20 stickers sell it yeah and you're out 20 bucks that's true yeah I mean because at the same time it's the people who make that argument are just looking for something to [ __ ] about first world problems where your life is so great you're making [ __ ] up to be upset about uh like because those same people either don't have the game right or if they do it's probably sitting on the [ __ ] shelf of unplayed games it's like how many people are making that complaint and have beaten it right it took me five years to be my solo thing for gluehaven that's so and another thing about myself I I had no one to blame but myself um and that was a because it's like whenever I finished it I was starting to think back and I'm like oh my God five years right A lot has happened in five years right jeez and then Frost Haven comes out and my copy isn't even touched right I put the wooden thing together it's great uh like it it is wonderful um the only thing that sucked was like the map tile pack but then someone did that accordion thing I'm like cool right oh there's a well there's a positive and a negative right there Frost Havens tiles are leagues better than the glue Maven tiles they actually have Art and Design to them that's the positive the
negative they're still tiles yeah and uh and Jaws the lion had to show the books are better yeah they had to ruin it for everyone else and I know people are like I [ __ ] love the tiles like my tiles are soggy because I cream on them I'm like God and they make their own scenarios and play it's like and that's I mean even Isaac has done a post about that pros of the tiles cons of the tiles right I'm like yeah 100 if for the Crimson scales fan made DLC they were able to do all that for the online make the scenario use these tiles that's great have both like and so I for people like me who don't want to make scenarios yeah just give me the book or play that many more scenarios of a game yeah I mean I already looking as like I'm already going to spend massive amounts of time in this game anyway so I'm probably not going to need a ton more yeah and I keep thinking like oh I'm gonna play Haven again and then I think I was like I don't know that I am going to play going Haven again at least not for a long time yeah um unless you're playing it on Steam right that's kind of that's where I'm replaying it the only time I can think of is when my kids are like three four more years older yeah and they could play it with us and then they can experience that story themselves for the first time yeah but that's it probably right and after that it's probably going away a long time yeah I I will say between having the two like I don't like this didn't replace this for me this is just now I
have more of a game I already love and with gloomhaven like I can't it's something you have to do something right because these characters can be played in this right like are they interchangeable interchangeable um the characters from gloomhaven 2 if you play them in Frost Haven Isaac created a new character um sheets for them okay where like your perks are going to be slightly different and those things are gonna be different but like their cards stay the same like you know or you can print them off it's free to print off okay um to exchange them yeah because those sheets I don't really care about if I have to go print them off myself um and that's easy to do I used to print them all off um because someone on Board Game Geek had designed better laid out one so like for um Gloom Haven like I have every single character like three of their sheets um because they were just better full paid sheets cool um because again you don't need the sheets except for the end of every scenario true so um but they had like um a spot for you to name your equipment in on the actual sheet so like your helmet you just put what helmet you have okay um and those type of things that helped you keep track if you're going to throw everything back in the box and clean up well gotcha um so it's things like that yeah uh one thing we haven't talked about is um the settlement phase I know you brought that power at the beginning but we can go a little bit more in depth right on it uh I I think it's awesome I love it I think
it's it's just really really neat because it feels lived in yes like and what kind of ties into that is we're talking about characters and Gloom even when your character is retired which was a mechanic I didn't really like because it almost felt like you never wanted to level them up because you're like oh they're gonna go away I want to see them at max level um and then when they did retire there was just kind of like all right well they're gone here's an event card that may never show up right Haven when they retire they actually like open up shop they join the settlement yeah that's part of the settlement and that's just that's just cool right like that actually it's like oh hey what's up uh weird germ guy yeah you're not getting new characters when you retire on like in gloomhaven you're getting new building options which to me is so good yeah it gives agency of the players on what they want to do it's like well man what building do we want like we do it what building do we level up do you want to start crafting more items do we want to start getting potions do we build into defense right uh and you're not in ever really in an abundance of a loot no I don't think um because everything keeps getting more expensive yeah um you need a certain prestige level or Prosperity Prosperity um to even build certain stuff right um I do like it so the way it progresses is you do time so again kind of like Kingdom depth if there's a story event for that year you start with the story events uh after that you do an actual
settlement event which is the replacement of the City events I might actually even call them City events I can't remember now um and they are either kind of the what we've seen most of the time is mail being delivered but then we had one where we got attacked yeah um and basically you now have a deck that is the city guard and they have basically just like everyone on their deck the actual um um scenario page like where you keep all of your scenario information actually has perks for the city guard so you can modify that deck eventually um because there's one where they just fail yeah and there's some full success and then they have plus some minuses on their attacking defense right um and that's super cool I love the fact that you have soldiers and you can train soldiers you pay to train soldiers soldiers boost up your defense but not only that they give you advantage on the car draws yep um that's super positive but you could be attacked and have five different buildings being attacked and you have four soldiers yeah now you have to make decisions on which ones are you going to defend the hardest and which ones you're potentially going to have problems with right um fortunately we've been in summer so it's been kind of weak attacks I think we've had one one attack we have a hanging buildings damaged or raised yeah um so we haven't had to rebuild anything um and we've been pretty aggressive on building walls where we can that's my
whole thing I know because you're you want you want more shops Ashley got got her ship yeah she's got her ship and then I'm over there like like I just must have kdmpsd right uh walls yeah I'm just like no he's like it's just walls right build the wall I'm over there just build it and I'm like yeah I want hunting lodge there won't be a hunting lodge if we don't build the wall but we I think we only build one wall anyway so I was like okay we've got my wall we got two walls built so far um but I think at this point we got two walls because we hit the next Prosperity that's right so we could get but now it's like Prosperity four for the next month yeah it's going to take a while to get to the car we got our two walls and now we can build some shops right and there's a lot of shops and they level up it's it's pretty cool um so after you do that so basically you run through all the shops that you have and you do there's a top action for what you can do so it can be by x amount of something for gold um craft your potions do any of that kind of stuff after that's done is where you do what your character cleanup so level up make you you know buy gear um do any kind of cleanup on your characters that you need and then lastly it's choosing to build something which I think is kind of cool that your very last section so you can't use the building that you built which makes sense thematically yeah um you can build a new building or upgrade
a building that's cool yeah I love that the market deck isn't just kind of like a merchant that just like a bunch of stuff it's like you're it's pretty limited yeah here's what you got yeah level it up and then you get more um and the goal is fun to bring some more Merchants into town so like we've been working on one to try to bring some Merchants into town yep so um pretty pretty solid yeah because I don't I don't know I'm sure someone's beating Frost Haven by this point that's been out for a little bit that someone could have just really went all in right I'm curious to know like how long Frost Haven is compared to gloomhaven um in terms of scenario numbers because obviously time is subjective based off players and player counts so it's like I think there's what 24 like in the main for gloomhaven I thought it was more about was it more I don't because there's no clean path I haven't really looked up the clean path okay I'll give you really steamroll through it yeah I know on my steam game we like we got to like the reason why I started really rushing because because we caught up to where I was in Steam to where I was in the physical copy I'm like oh [ __ ] like that was quick right uh so then I trudged them through and now as we're playing I'm like okay we have about three more before we're done right at least with this section of the story that I that I did yeah uh because what's weird and I don't know why like because there's there's more scenarios in this right there's I think 114. okay and
there were 94. yeah 94 or 98 something like that in Gloom Haven not counting the expansion I don't know why I went to board game geek um so in foreteller it's um I saw sleeping Gods available I'm like oh so blue Maven has five hours of 20 and 23 minutes of reading right and frost Haven has four hours in 10 minutes of reading and I don't know why like that could just be because maybe there's more like because this is showing like 136 scenarios you don't have the scenario books hold with it you don't have the road in City events all in there gotcha there's a lot of um side stuff that is outside of a scenario okay that frosting is now being read for gotcha it's like just the line is massively more yeah because Joseph lion is uh one hour and 54 minutes right for 24 scenarios total uh 25 25 okay 25. you forgot about the zero zero prologue okay yeah idiot yeah uh and well just for shits and giggles medara is 22 hours yeah it's a book like that all right read it I don't wanna read it yeah uh but yeah I don't know it was just kind of weird to me uh based off the audio but even then it's way better audio Yeah
uh yeah I'm really trying to think of like others so now the question comes becomes uh uh where do we go from here so gloomhaven had the Forgotten circles expansion right do you think let's do predictions do you think he does another expansion like one expansion for frost Haven or do you think there's so much in here do you think Isaac is like I'm done I hate this world I hate everyone here I hate money I always throwing me done do you think he does another another massive one like if he has a world if he has a mass like like you know uh uh what is it called tariel Terrio that Skyrim's in like Skyrim is north and there's uh uh cyrodiil in the middle Elder Scrolls like the Elder Scrolls world where it's like okay well now we can go to this section do you think he has something like that where blue Haven's in the middle then Frost Havens in the north do you think he just starts going I mean so that's what I hope and then clearly this just came out and it's like we're eight scenarios in about two so 16 hours in you know 20 20 something hours in so whether he does it this big or he does smaller ones that are charged with the line size where like because we don't even touch where um the Slavs are like sand Nomads at times like there's trucks you could have a campaignment space there yeah there's 25 scenarios long true because Joseline is like it's it's like a story within
glue Maven right um so I could see those um I could definitely see an expansion of another character with another I mean again kind of depending on the end because gloomhaven kind of through our point of you hit the main bad guy you're like okay so that was the main boss yeah but then instantaneously the expansion plays off of that like the middle oh it does okay yeah so it's you're not supposed to play it until you've completed that big boss fight gotcha then you play against Circle that was a good boss it was challenging but not like stupid it was yeah exactly oh yeah all right I beat I beat you but I kind of had to work for it right versus like oh I just get one shot neat right uh it was cool mechanic for the boss like that boss was if we're talking about the same one I don't know if there's multiple in-game bosses so yeah my thinking here's my prediction is I I kind of agree with you I think well they're going to do their Miniatures one I think that's kind of their subset he can just kind of have off to side because he's a millionaire he's like whatever just go make my Minis and right and then I know they're doing the RPG yep another side project I think their next main big project will be another big box however in the meantime for the next you know three four five years between that he's gonna do another glue like Jaws the line thing right that one wasn't even kick-started right it was just kind of like made so because Jaws aligned was a game within gloomhaven he could probably do another one within Frost Haven right
and then it's like hey here's the next big box and then it'll be another eventually you can make these as stairs uh well they have the fit in a kalex shelf so do they they do unfortunately like it's interesting calyx's are so Universal now in board game that as a designer you actually have to consider a kalex self design the too many bones Trove chest is designed for okay like shelves the old the old world which in the old world is designed around it this was designed around it so um there's only so much you can get at that point you know what you know what he's gonna do it'll fit in okay like shells but it's gonna be two boxes okay you have to put one and then next to the other I mean again I still want to do it oh yeah there's there's nothing that subtle Affair and Isaac will make but that's that's like this that I will not back yeah like I wouldn't look at it because like I know people were bitching about Frost Haven and all that and I was like and I have so many campaigns to play like I I got it and I'm not even playing my own copy right so I never really cared I guess I've just been burned or I just I don't hover over Kickstarter updates because then that just makes you upset it's like okay here when it gets here this is probably my only one that was actually burnt out on the kickstarter being as the late as it was um because it kept getting promised and then not happening yeah that's probably
a learning point it's just shut up keep your mouth shut right hey it's still being worked on what was annoying me is people there were a lot of people getting their copies and I'm like okay it's been like a few months like where's mine right and then I started looking I'm like can I pay for it it was like my game store got it a month before like that all the companies like yeah I should have just gone and pledged it through you guys yeah if I known that and that's honestly probably what I will do next time is instead of pledging myself I'll probably just go to the game store and do a pledge to them yeah that's a lot of game stores do that now that's how I'm getting my Marvel Zombies uh through them and you save on shipping that's um realistically my reason so so yeah uh that's that's I mean can you think of anything else from frosting so do you think it's worth the 240 price point that will be for retail 100 now obviously that's another thing I hardly ever bring up because 240 for me could be you know nothing to send someone or a lot to a lot of people well just I mean gloomhaven was 120 retail when it first came out yeah so you're talking twice the price it is twice the price and the the box size doesn't really show that it's double the content but it pretty much is yeah like you you said it good that gluehaven is like a 1.0 right this is fantastic however if you have any issues with it's most likely fixed in Frost Haven unless it
was glaring actual gameplay I hate the hand management part well that didn't go away right in fact it's more in the game right uh so this is the frost statement is like it's it's if you loved gloomhaven You're Gonna Love Frost Haven yeah uh yeah small annoyances in gloomhaven probably at least half of those annoyances got fixed if you're a brass player uh then you're not gonna like frost David because apparently you hate glue Maven um because you're about a child uh because a friend of mine he was talking about Frosty but he said yeah I wonder when that breaks the top 100 I'm like it it will not yeah like bluehaven just moved down to three for a stupid reason and uh Frost David's sitting at like 405 or five five like the 500 and I'm like more people were actually upset with frost Haven because of the delays and all that Blue Haven came out and it was revolutionary in 2017 so it just jumped to number one right I'm like frost Haven like unless BGG like actually does something about how their ranking system works like I would just say like you combine them yeah gluehaven slash Frost Haven uh I think it's gloomhaven's going to stay in the top 100 Frost Haven should replace in the top 100 that's what I would say yeah um I'm like and I'm copyrights throughout yeah it's just you or or put them both in there because the to both Through the Ages are in there and the Brickle is in there and [ __ ] one and it's so dumb uh but here's the real question yes I so I agree I think 240 you definitely get
your money's worth yeah we just mentioned eight scenarios in at 24 hours uh 20 24 hours is insane yeah uh I agree the real question is is gloomhaven [ __ ] now because it's number three no I mean Bloom even still gonna be my top um role-playing um dungeon girl game it's I mean Frost savings probably gonna replace it in the sense of if someone say which of the two or more play and we'll play for all Stephen because I do think it's better um but I probably rank them basically I think of them as the same they're the same world as to me jaws is the same yeah they'll go in the same aisle for me in my calyxes yeah when they do my top 100 it's both these combined right having two separate things now what's cool still though is kind of like when you're playing like Skyrim or Oblivion or something like that it's like Skyrim is clearly the superior game but sometimes you don't want to be in the Frozen North you want to be in the more uh summary like middle so it's like if you're playing blue mavens because you actually want to be in that atmosphere yeah like if someone's if it just depends on what I'm feeling like don't always want to deal with snow and ice and horrid weather I want to be involved in like like the the art like the art here I want to be involved in this you know higher fantasy Market versus the survival uh element right um they both have their place even though mechanically Frost Haven is just it just it just made improvements on every element right uh
although between the two covers I still think this one's better is just newer for me so I mean I was going to be famous so much that you just had always out yeah you really look at and it's like oh man how many characters are just on the main yeah like it's just it's drawn to like oh who's this you know menacing figure with these two characters and there's a lot of like stuff going on this is your high fantasy Market this is action-packed right um so it's like it's still cool but like this guy's that guy's [ __ ] right there he's just being killed by that that Inox or that out box whatever their names are but it's like this just feels like it's more going on you hear this like hearing that yeah Market versus you just kind of hear your screen and fire yeah yeah something roaring in the background yep so like without making this video any longer than it already is um skill 110 what did you get from frost Haven ten yeah it's like it's if you haven't figured that out I'm sorry I know we were really pissed for this job then yeah we're over here raving about it it's kind of it's kind of five it's pretty good yeah it's pretty average yeah let's let's pull a no puns intended and just start [ __ ] on it uh because that's just what what I do um yeah and I think gloomhaven it's like again like I mentioned if I was being objective about it it would probably be a nine at this point just because Frost Haven now exists like
this would be a 10 right savings improved so they can't both be tens if I think this one's better right uh just object it's a 9.9 then yeah it's like subjectively though this came first right and this doesn't exist without this right and this still does everything great and you don't know the mistakes or the improvements to make without Gloom Haven exactly better it's the same way Jaws the line was still a 10 out of 10. in fact it's 11 out of 10 because that tutorial system is so damn good great so and I agree I think if someone were to be like if they want to jump in you do Jaws the lion yep so if you like it it's a low price point to enter into it then after that the friend I did the top 100 with uh he hated glue Maven like he hated the hand manager it just didn't he didn't make sense to him and then I got you all the line and I'm like you know just for shits do you just want to go test out this tutorial system with me he's like yeah I'll play it and now it's his number five right game like he flipped on it so hard uh it has Frost Haven and everything he he loves it just because that tutorial system was so well done yes it just it hand holds you like okay especially play these two cards right especially for a game that is fairly complex fairly big um you have a DM the monsters a little bit but they have a mechanic use I have to understand how those Mechanics Work yeah but if you have any questions it's just like oh well let me go to the tutorial section where it taught me because there are times where I'm like what the [ __ ] an obstacle again like I just get like those simple things you just forget and I'm like that's right
that's what an obstacle does how do how they decide movement um because there were even things when you were playing when we started Frost Haven and you're and you were like no this is the initship you have to stick with that's the card you have to play I'm like no right no unless I've been playing it wrong nope because I think I pulled out the yeah I pulled up the jaws of the line I wanted to find the rule and that's just what how great it is so I'd say own all three yep and go through it like Jessica's Frost Haven is great glue Maven is still just as good and then you probably appreciate Frost even more you will appreciate that I think and you won't be overwhelmed because there was a lot of stuff in there so much and all in all three so you have what is that 50 characters uh something like there's four in jaws of the lion there are many are in you said it's close it has to be it's between 40 and 50. yeah because you have you have 12 starting totals that'd be 16. right I think there's like 18 or 19 in Frost Haven I think there's around the same right maybe not for you fifty maybe around 30 40 characters you can just play yeah and they're all good they're all unique they're all different yeah they all have depth to them so it's like if you really love the Mind thief because I will play the Mind thief in Frost Haven if you really love the hatchet in Jaws a line which I still haven't played uh so fun I've heard I've heard I loved my Red Guard my bread guard was about that's what a lot of people all say the radar yeah I I was like man this guy is knee is like a chainsickle like right that's dope so yeah just grab him and move him in one thing I I don't know
because obviously we haven't played all the characters but Jaws the lion like one of my favorite things about that was the characters have like that middle point where they got like a really special like buff and as far as I know blueberry does have doesn't have any of that and um I'm curious if Frost Haven does there's no extra boxes okay um that was just something really cool that was really cool in in Jaws a lion so I think that was kind of his special because there was no retiring so here's something that you can look forward to that's true in the mid game okay um but I agree it was so good it was so neat so yeah Frost haven 10 out of 10 still keeping gloomhaven really out of 10 out of 10 jobs a lion 10 out of 10. these games are fantastic yep uh keep an eye out for the uh series that I'll eventually do I don't know yet if I'm gonna do it solo um or with someone else uh at some point I will start it I just wanted to get a review on the channel right um but let us know what you think of the games in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and Bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you