Skip to main content
Loading video...

3 Reviews - Chamber of Wonders, Ur, Codex Naturalis - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 10:09

hey everybody today I'm doing a quick review of these three games here we have uh codex naturalis and the Chamber of Wonders but before I get into my thoughts on these three games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so I'm going to start with my least favorite and work my way up to my most favorite which to be honest is not saying much because I'm not a big fan of either of these games um but we're gonna start here with ER now ER is a game by Paulo Mori so palomori um a very popular designer has made some very popular games such as libertalia ethnos um Blitzkrieg and Caesar you know a really versatile and interesting designer now this one um is an abstract area control Style game um as you have this huge grid here a six by six grid of these nice tiles you know very nicely produced and what you're trying to do is you're trying to spread your influence on these tiles and if you have any influence on these Tiles at the end of the game which is when all the tiles have been kind of used I suppose you're going to put them into sets and then sets will score your points based on a sliding scale now it's quite interesting how the board is not only the actual board state but also the actions you can use because whenever you play a tile you replace it with one on the board pick the tile back up and then those are the actions you can take and

they are double-sided and you have this kind of multi-use system where you can either use both of the abilities on the tile you can use one of the abilities or you can use none of them now the fewer abilities you use it means you can put presence on tasks that you already have or even claim a tile that's not been chosen yet but the actions on the tiles are pretty um strange to wrap your head around like for example something might let you attack other tasks which is pretty straightforward but some of them I might say um it'll lose a cube for everything that's not next to an agricultural tile um but then put another Cube on all your agriculture tiles or some of them might say boost all the tiles around you and that are touching a certain type of tile even if it's your opponents and even though there are only a few of these abilities there's only like five or six of them I actually found it really difficult to digest and internalize at the rules because they were quite um esoteric in the way they worked and again but despite being quite a low rules over here there's only like two sheets of rules and both me and my opponent found it very difficult to again learn those rules and understand what all the abilities did and to be honest we we struggled to understand why we were doing what we were doing just all the different parts and moving parts of the game were not clicking together and just weren't they weren't gelling for me and I found it really hard to abstract any fun uh from this one or to extract any fun from this one so I know generally speaking I'm not a fan of abstract games anyway but this one was taking that to a whole new dimension I did not see where the fun was I really did struggle to understand where all the different mechanical parts were coming together and again it was just a big big Miss for

me and I just felt like I played this game without really having a clue what I was doing or you know taking actions with no Rhyme or Reason so um I can't really recommend this one um I suppose for maybe a certain type of gamer who likes pure abstract games then they're probably gonna maybe find something here but I really wasn't willing to do that work and put the you know put the groundwork in and play it again and again and again to internalize what everything did and to understand why we were doing what we were doing so this one's a big Miss for me sadly and I had some promise for it I was quite interested because I do like the way it looks um and you know it's a good designer but I can see why this one has been you know lost to the annals of time um I don't think it's going to hold up for many people nowadays Adam yeah I did not find it fun sadly so that is uh by Paulo Mori next up we have chamber of Wonders this is a wonderful player set collection game that takes around 30 minutes to play on average now I do like the look and style of this game it's got this kind of um you know curious artifacts kind of thing to it you're collecting these different bits and Bobs and scoring points in different ways so all these cards come in different suits and you're collecting them in different ways but they also score in different ways so for example you can score these I've kind of um cars that come in sets where you want to collect the headpiece the middle piece or the Torso and the leg piece as well those ones that score your points if you're the only person to have that certain artifact some will give you money um but the way the game works is that on your turn you use your workers to activate one of these worker placement spots which will kind of let you partake

in a little mini game and all those mini games are almost cherry-picked from a bunch of existing games out there on the market like for example one will say pick up a bunch of cards and then do a little pass and draft and take the cards you want some might say I do a little pushy luck game or some might use like the biblios method where you're drawing one at a time and passing them to your opponents or keeping them for yourself and hoping you get the good ones um and things like that so it's very simple things that we've seen time and time again that will Patchwork together in one game here no it's fine but I do find that the game is pretty predictable and the choices are fairly obvious um and it's so quick to the point where all the overproduction here is just it's just far too much now this could easily be condensed down to a pack of cards but you have this huge box here you have a board which is get kind of Superfluous you have these kind of card racks which take up so much space and it's just pure you know the pure definition of being Overkill um in terms of a production now one of the things I did like about this game is that you have a set amount of rounds I think it's um I think it's like nine turns I think and when you get to a certain point of the game you need to actually spend money to unlock to be able to as you partake in the last three turns and you're gonna need to hold back some money in order to do that so I do like that pressure where you have to balance you know how much points am I getting here but I also need some money in order to actually you know play my last three turns or waste them essentially and also when you go to these worker placement spots and you know play the game you get to use one of these adjacent

card abilities which are variable and that's one thing that they did put some effort into this game is that there are a ton of different modules you can plug in to um you know at least make the game feel a little bit different but ultimately I did find the game very predictable um I didn't think you know I think even if you do have a bunch of variability in terms of the mini games you're playing it still does feel like you're doing the same thing and there really isn't much depth and it kind of feels like the game is playing you you know the decision space is certainly uh very shallow and the fact that it is so overproduced is a big negative for me and you know space is at a premium this is a big box takes up so much room it takes up more or takes more time to pack up and set away than it does to actually uh play the game so this should have really been um you know a straight up simple card game where you know they've just gone above and beyond here for no uh reason whatsoever I know it's fine but ultimately I think I'd rather play the games that they've I'm not gonna say stolen but where they've clearly been inspired by um to inject into this one you know I'd rather play those original games such as the bibliosis or the Seven Wonders um this one is just kind of feels like it's piggybacking a bit too much and has failed to find any inspiration to create anything new so therefore I can't really recommend this one especially because of the overproduction of it so that is the Chamber of Wonders another Miss for me sadly and the final game I'm looking at today is codex naturalis now this is a two to four player kind of puzzly card game that takes around 25 minutes to play on average in this game you are building

out a little display of cards that you are drafting initially and they come in two different types you have the kind of resource cards that look like this where on the corners you have these different resources and as long as they're on display you can account as having them and the other ones are the actual scoring cards where you kind of overlap the corners and as long as you have the prerequisites on them then you're going to score those cards in different ways so just giving you straight up points or even giving you points based on different criteria like you can you can see here and for every corner you have covered on this card you'll get two points there's also some public objectives you're working towards like here at every scroll you have on display at the end of the game you'll score two points Etc so from that explanation you probably know how to play the game and that's pretty much how it goes you keep on playing cards back and forth um until you reach a certain threshold of points and then you'll go into the final scoring and tally up everything um one thing I love about this game is the way that it looks it has a very striking visual appeal to it you know if you look at the cards here they have a very nice art style and they even have this kind of gold gilding on them which looks really cool and it has a real kind of deluxe feel to it and despite being a very small and affordable game so they definitely made it look different and it looks quite striking when it's on the table but other than that I thought the gameplay was pretty pedestrian and it was quite predictable in the way it worked again I thought the decision space was quite low and it was almost over before you um before you even begin and I really did find that it was quite easy to reach those resource thresholds

in order to play the cards it almost feels like you always have what you need so you know the struggle wasn't there to actually get anything going so it felt a little bit easy and again maybe even a bit too quick so it was absolutely fine but I do feel like I've played this game in you know 10 different formations and before so it just feels like a tweak on games that are already out there but I suppose um you know if you want a game that looks nice on the table one that's pretty quick and succinct and um comes in a nice little box then this isn't a bad shout But ultimately I think I'd rather play some other puzzly games um over this one so it was fine but ultimately um one that I'm not really itching to go back to because it feels like I've seen it before 10 different times so there we have it that concludes the video unfortunately nothing here that I can recommend but you know sometimes you've got to take the rough with the smooth and hopefully you have enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved