Skip to main content
Loading video...

Bits, Please! Ep 8: A Better Big Box Insert

Transcript 28:55

What do you do when the expensive board game insert you paid for stinks? Well, you print another insert. That's coming right up on Bits Please. Bits.

Welcome. Hope you like my new hat. This is Bits Please, the series where we color, construct, 3D print, make, model, and otherwise generate cool stuff to make our board games better. The board game in question today is Teot Walkin City of Gods the Deluxe Master Set. Now, don't worry if you don't own this particular board game, cuz we're going to be taking a look at a really cool 3D printed insert for it. And I think just by coming along for the ride, even if you don't have the game, there's something to learn about the uh science, the art, the science of making a 3D printed board game insert. And by the power of editing, this is the insert that we're talking about. This comes to us by a creator named JS500 who's created a number of different 3D printable board game inserts and offers them for free on sites like Printables.

And we we love that, don't we? Thank you so much, JS500. I'm uh forever indebted to you for creating this uh amazing insert. I think this is really spectacular. We're going to go over the features and you know [clears throat] ins and outs of it in just a second, but first we should talk about what's so terrible about the Tiotakan Deluxe Master Set. Well, pow. There it is again. Now, Ryan, you might be asking, didn't you pay like $50,000 for this game? Well, yes, in fact, I did. Thank you for rubbing it in. And if you watch my unboxing of it a little while back, you can see my as I'm going through and I'm putting different components in the in the containers, the the vacuumformed, you know, those cheap plastic containers. You can see my enthusiasm kind of like draining and and I'm getting more and more bummed out about what's inside the box. and and and but you know, by the time I come to the end of it, I'm assembling this goofy resource holder that doesn't fit in the box and the the instructions were bad for it. I'm just thinking like, what what have I done? Like I was trying to be enthusiastic. I was trying to be upbeat, but they just I mean, I really think I like Board and Dice. I like their games, but I really think that they have a habit now of kind of screwing the pooch on products like these. And you know, it's it's not just them. By the way, have you ever seen the Apocalyptto movie poster? I think this is a uh homage to that. It's it's not just board and dice the the the publisher. I think this happens with a lot of publishing companies who do like a big all-in box for their games that had you know four or five different

expansions. I think that one of the problems I perceive and you know board game publishers can can can pile on and tell me I'm wrong, but I think what happens is they they're designing the insert while they're designing the product. Inevitably, what that ends up with is, you know, a bunch of stuff fits really nicely and then they're just like, uh, create some sort of big well or recess and I don't know, players can just like chuck everything else in there, you know, and or they don't have, you know, they develop they develop some components without knowing the measurements for other components and things end up maligned and awful. I'll open the box and I'll show you what I mean. So, the good thing, I mean, at least there's no box lid, but I'll take all the boards out first, and I'll show you where the trouble sort of begins inside here.

First, apparently, one or two of these are misprinted. There are a couple of misprints inside the box. And, uh, to their credit, Board and Dice offered a free fix pack. So, you could just write them and say, "Hey, send me my fix pack. I've got the first edition of this thing." They corrected it apparently in the second printing. Um, I Unfortunately, at the time of this video, I ordered mine. This is now August. I ordered mine last October and uh they haven't gotten it to me yet. I've been assured that it's coming. So, I don't know. We'll maybe I'll do an update on that later. But here's here's the situation. These are the three big um trays that they've got inside here. One is for holding all the player pieces. So, it has I mean, one thing I do like about these things, if I can catch it in the right light, this has, you know, the figure on the front of the box sort of embossed in the lid. And I do like that there are lids.

That's always handy. So, you can store horizontal or vertical and your pieces won't go flying. Um, but these are just I mean, there's nothing fancy here. These are just like wells. And it's hard to if you're playing just a two-player game or a three-player game, it's hard to dig all of these out. Are they scooped? Yeah. By scooped I mean like is there like a beveled edge to the bottom of the bucket cuz there's nothing worse than trying to get right angled pieces out of a right angled recess. Right. So they are scooped but there's a bunch of like expansion or you know extra module pieces in here that you don't need to play with. So you end up dumping them all out on your table and it's like oh put all the soldiers back cuz we're not playing with soldiers. Put these pieces back. We're not playing with those pieces. So I mean it's I mean I don't know maybe a B for this. It's not the greatest, but it's it's not the worst.

We We'll get to the worst. Then you have a resources tray. Again, I like that the shapes of all the resources are embossed here so you know where to put the resources back. But this is completely, in my opinion, unsuitable for the table. This is a really deep um deep recessed insert or or tray. And you really, you know, this is you really have to to dig for the pieces that are really deep in there. And inevitably when you play this, you end up dumping these pieces out and putting them in your own trays or little buckets or bowls anyway. So this one, not not such a bop. But the real the real issue, the second worst thing going on in this box, there is something worse, but this thing. So in the game, if you haven't played the game, there are these techiles. And you can see I kind of got them stacked in here willy-nilly, but essentially there's x number of these wooden yellow tiles. And they've got teensy tiny little numbers in red up in the corner. And every game you're supposed to pull out sort of six of these at random. And they all have a corresponding four or five. If you have the five player uh fifth player expansion uh pieces, they all have the corresponding teensy tiny little number.

And it's a like a reprint of the graphic on these cardboard towels. So you got to pull out four of these. So of course like one way to do it is to have like one of these and then 1 2 3 4 5 and then next proper one of those and then 1 2 3 4 5. Right? So they're all interspersed but like you can't see what they are cuz they're stacked vertically. And woo as as I age my failing eyes they're struggling to see board games the best at size. I can't I mean I can't see those numbers. It's just really hard to pick them out. It's really hard to put them back together at the end of the at the end of the game night. It's uh it's lousy. Over here, we have a bunch of different cards and they are for different purposes, but the box just wants to like chuck them just in here. So, here's like three different types of cards and they just go all just go blam, you know what I mean? With no rhyme or reason. They're just chucked in there.

So, that's uh not awesome. And as we get further, we get into the real egregious sin of this insert. On the very bottom is this gigantic tray. And this is what I was talking about before. Now, I haven't put any like you're like, "Well, Ryan, you're not putting you're not putting this back together properly." And it's because the last time I played this game, I knew I was going to print uh JS500's insert. So, I thought as I was putting away, I was just like, I piss on it. It can't be ours to fuss with these stupid trays anymore. One of them, by the way, I should mention, you know, I said these are cheap vacuum formed trays. Is it this one or the other one? Um, when you grab them, you kind of like you kind of have to pinch them with your little robot claws here. And one of them like split on me on at the side, which uh super not not awesome. Not what I would call premium. Uh, but when you get into the very bottom, you got this tray that doesn't have to come out of the box.

Thank god. It's got Tiawalkan uh like word mark embossed on the lid, which is nice. And it has a lid. That's nice. But oh my gosh, guys. Look. First of all, there are no partitions here. All these these are all like these are all like uh pouches. So, there's a big area for pouches. It's good that we have have that. That's fine. So, all your towels can go in there. Fine. I'll tell you what's not fine about these ones in just a second. Over here, though, is this is what I call like a well. You just like throw it all down the deep dark hole and forget about it in your own little like ooiet, right? So, I kept these in a bag because I wasn't going to, you know, mix them all all the pieces. These are just so supposed to like stack just just like loose like this and this just roams around and no, you know, I put these in a bag, but these are just kind of like floating around and oh god, like oh my gosh, this I I wake up in the middle of the night regularly thinking about this part of the not really that's insane, but it's it just bothers me so much. And then when we went to play last time, these are all this is a module that you can have where you get to pick um like a different character to play. So, okay, cool. You know, we shuffled them up. I think you get a choice of two and you you've probably experienced this with board games before. We grabbed two and we looked and like what is what is this talking about? Solo what? I'm like, oh, you got a solo one here. Flip that out.

Grab another one from the stack. It's because they're all like in the same stack. Some of these are solo characters. Some of these like you can only play, you know, use them when you're playing solo. And some of these are multiplayer characters. Who's to know? What's the rhyme or reason? I don't know. They're all just kind of stuffed in there. It stinks. It stinks. It stinks. And thanks to JS500's insert. We're going to fix it. And I I've thought about nothing else for days. I actually printed this insert and then I had to, you know, I had to go on vacation. Oh, so hard. I went on vacation and the entire time I was on vacation, I was like, I can't wait to get home and put the right pieces in the right boxes. I don't have the condition, you know? I don't have the the disorder, but I have a disorder. I don't know. It's it's going to scratch a nice itch is all I can say. So, let's get rid of this stuff. And the very first thing I want to tackle are those techiles. And I'll show you the really neat solution that JS500 came up with. But first, one last little beef. I told you I was going to mention something about these blue tiles.

So, different things fit in your player board. It's a double-sided, not double-sided, it's a double tiered player board. So, it's got recesses in it. Everything fits nicely. This fits nicely. This fits nicely. Start player, last player, token. Right. The masks are they're pretty good, right? So, the tactiles go here. That's nice. The only things you get this sort of like carpet kind of thing that just indicates which player color you are in case you forget because nothing that's in your color sort of stays in your board. And so, what do they do with this? This kind of just kind of sloshes around in here. It doesn't even like this is like kind of landscape and this thing's drawn portrait. I don't know. So that that kind of stinks. Uh but not worth losing sleep over. But what's really terrible is that down here there's a whole channel where you're collecting these blue tiles and uh you can't quite tell from the overhead view, but these don't fit in this track at all. Like this is you would have to take an X-acto knife and carve this out just like a millimeter more for these tiles to fit in here. Everything else fits. These tiles just just don't whatever I've got. Really, if this is all I have to worry about, I got a pretty charmed life. So, like I say, let's get into those techiles and we'll see the solution that JS500 came up with.

This is one cabinet that holds three different trays that each contain your tactiles. Now, I just wanted to talk a little bit about color here because JS500 designed something to go on one of the boards. This is, I guess, the first lesson we can learn about this. This is very smart. So, on this orange board, you've got a bunch of tiles that just kind of like go up here, and you have to like set them up in little stacks and everything. So JS500 made a piece of the insert that holds all of those tiles cuz they don't really have to move around a whole lot and they can go like uh right here whammy schlammy like right on the board. So when I was thinking about the different colors that I would use, I think JS500 just uses white and and it looks it looks nice. It looks fine, but me fancy. So if you can print in color, why not print in color? So this is um something that I did. I I took uh a lesson that I learned from Andre R, who if you'll remember designed that really nice insert for SETI that we put together a little while back and Andre R did this really nice thing where you just set a certain color at a certain layer. So you print with like, you know, one color on the bottom and then you print with another color in the middle and then you just cap it off with like a third color and it just ends up looking like so nice and so sharp. And a little a further note about this color choice.

So, because it was going to a couple of these things sit on the board, I didn't want to go with pure white. I wanted to go with something that matched the board a little bit better. So, this isn't white. This is like an off-white or whatever. I wound up getting a couple of rolls of bone white. And I think I mean, it's not a it's not a perfect match for what's on the board, but I think, you know, it looks it looks pretty darn good. Looks kind of creamy, right? I will have a link below, probably a couple of Amazon affiliate links below the video if you want to check out. Now, I'm purchasing in Canada, so I'm going to link to the American store, and I'll I'll find the closest thing that I uh to what I got in in Canada. But I will tell you that I had some printing issues with this bone white thing with a couple of the larger pieces. And this is one of the larger pieces, and I'll bring the other one up post haste. This is the other one. So, the trays aren't too bad that go inside, but these two big cabinets are pretty beefy boys. And uh I printed them both together on the same plate. It was supposed to take 12 hours.

You know, you you probably set it before you go to bed and you think, "Ah, I'll wake up, you know, sunshiny fresh and my prints will be done." Well, no, cuz this one crapped out like at the 2hour mark and then it kind of like got stuck like every hour for the next, you know, many, many hours. So, it was kind of a kind of a a difficult job to print these big cabinets. But, we will repatriate all of the textiles into this one. And I will show you what I got. First thing I want to point out is that they're made so that they go face up. So, let's just do a time wipe and I'll show them all in there. Okay. And there it is. All of the tiles organized absolutely beautifully. They're all belly up so you can see which ones they are instead of having to dig in, you know, flip through vertically and, you know, with very little room to maneuver. Every single wooden tile is on top and every single cardboard tile is stacked on the bottom.

JS500 warns us that if you do it the other way around, the wooden uh the cardboard tiles will slide around. Speaking of sliding around, one nice feature that he has incorporated is inside the cabinet, if you can kind of see, maybe not, it's a little bit dark, but there are nubbins, sort of runners, two runners, uh, like uh, protrusions that run along the edges here and here. And, you know, this is a common thing in counterry. Wonder if I can turn this out over without spilling everything. That's amazing. So, then you've got impressions, indents in here. So the net effect is that when you slot this in, it'll kind of a little bit catch just a little a little tiny bit so that the drawers don't come like flying out at you when you pick this piece up. So I'm going to put the other ones in here.

He's uh he's left one of the uh there's like one spot for Elijah over here. It's because just the math didn't work out on another number of tiles versus splitting this up nicely 4x4. So, or 4x two, but that's fine if there's ever an expansion or you develop your own extra tech and you got a spot for it. So, we'll slide all that in there and we'll take a look at the solution that he has put together for the player pieces. Next, one thing I should mention is that design-wise, uh, GS500 500 has said in a video that is on YouTube, but it's unlisted, so you have to follow it from a Board Game Geek post that I'll throw in the, uh, the links down below. He said that uh one of his principles in designing this insert is to ensure that all of the stuff you need right away to set the game up is going to be right on top. So you don't have to go digging too deep through the box to get the stuff that you immediately need, which I think is a great philosophy.

Let's keep going. This is the player trace cabinet for five players. This goes up to five players. You have to buy an extra thing to have all the, you know, the five player pieces. But just like the other cabinet, it has two little divots in here for runners so that it catches a little bit when you put them in. And each player tray has a little drawer in it. Now, I've gone a little bit extra. You Brian extra? No. Uh, so you can actually I mean, if you're uh if you back me on Patreon, I'll give you access to this. No problem. So, what I've done is I always worry about not being able to remember where stuff goes. So, your dice go here. That's fine. Something goes here and something goes here and something goes here. And generally the shapes fit, but I was kind of worried about the here and here. Especially when I've got not me people putting stuff away in this insert. So, what I did was if all your soldiers go here, then I just went and traced the outline of the soldier and stamped it in there with with the double color print. And again, based on uh Andre's really nice coloring choices for that seti insert, I just put like a nice little terracotta rim on that. So, this is a burnt orange color that I think matches the stuff in the box really nice. It matches the outside of the box for sure, really beautifully.

So, let me patri repatriate all of the um player pieces and we'll show you how that looks. So, there's one done just to show you the progress midway. I was thinking about stamping all the different shapes of these pieces into this tray that comes out, but then I thought I think it's just enough that you stamp in the the soldier and then this is everything else. I think people will get the get the idea. Players who don't know the game so well. And then down here, these are chits that help you track when you loop past 100 200 200 in my dreams. 300 and 400 points on the score track. These are actually in the um in the board and dice solution. These are buried at the very bottom of the box. So, if you want them, you got to go dig it for them, which makes no sense. Take note, board, and dice. So, those are going to fit right here. And again, speaking of things that fit, this fits beautifully, your player color indicator in here. So, all in all, really, really nice. Uh, the other problem, by the way, with stamping all the all the shapes of all the pieces in here is that every player has a different um sort of like hero shape for their color. And I just didn't want to separately trace and then separately have to model five different trays and separately print them. So, that's just how I handled it. I think it's going to be good.

And there it is. Sometimes when I print an insert, I like to print the different player containers in different player colors. So this would be red, this would be black. But what I really like about JS500's design here is quite clearly you can see the different player colors peeking through this finger hole, which I thought was such a smart idea. A little bit hard to grab to be honest. It would be nice to have like a little tiny protrusion, but still so nice. Look how beautiful that is. Love it. Love it. Love it. Love Love it. And now we can finally put this thing where it belongs. [snorts] Let's Let's keep going. Let me show you two of my favorite trays.

So, these are the resource trays or for my American friends, the resource trays. And so, the color choice I think was pretty spot-on. Look, I got a nice burnt orange that matches the color on the box. very beautifully here. And then the uh the teal the teal or the the turquoise at the bottom. You think where that's where's that coming from? Well, the fifth player expansion rule book is in a beautiful turquoisey teal. So, I thought I would springboard off of that. I think it ended up looking really, really cool. So, I wanted to do these ones up nice and multiolors. Notice how I just did this in the in the base bone white all the way. Didn't do anything fancy. These ones are a little bit fancy because like the thing that goes on the orange temple, these are on the table all the time. So, you got to look good, right? And they are scooped. So, hopefully we can get the pieces out. The pieces are kind of chunky and hard to get out no matter what you put them in.

But, uh, let's just chuck all the pieces in there. There it all is looking pretty good. There's Whoops. I think I missed a piece. Anyway, there there's one more insert for the pit. And then just like that internet meme, we're going to draw the rest of the owl. Here we go. Oh, I should point out before I do this one that I stamped the uh image of the of the houses of the dead in this tray. And then when you pull that off, I didn't again like I don't know if I could trust myself to remember what went in here. So, I just did instead of doing the symbols, I just did four discs. So, those ones and the ones for the Eclipse go in there. And again, I'm happy to send that to any and all of my backers.

Look at that. What a welcome solution that is to a really obnoxious problem. I'm really glad that this insert exists. Again, a really nice solution to a really annoying problem. All of the character tiles for the solo mode are split out into their own tray, so you're not going to get them mixed up and forget that there are solo characters in there. So, there are two separate stacks. And not only that, but all of the solo mode stuff goes in its own tray and then gets banished to a corner of the box. So, if you don't care about the solo mode, it's tucked away all in here. So, I'm going to put all that stuff in here right now.

And there it is. That's the whole shooting match. And then all your manuals and your donut go on top of that. Your player boards go on top of that. Followed by your temple track boards and map, which go on top of that. Maybe this way. Doesn't really matter because we got everything in the box. Shazam. Shazama Blam. Oh man, how what what a relief. What how amazing is that? JS500 stellar, spectacular job. Thank you so much. I like this is this is awesome. And for publishers who are planning uh big expensive boxes, I don't you know what? I don't know what the solution is.

I've never published anything, let alone anything near this complicated. So, I imagine that it's um it's a real project management challenge because with so many of these, like I say, pieces don't fit. And you can tell that the people making the inserts are planning for things and it's like, "Oh, we changed these components." Like, "What? It's not going to fit." And there's probably a lot of back and forth there if I know how projects go. The only thing that I can maybe suggest or recommend is that publishers I mean I would this would be a major selling point for me if publishers commissioned folks like JS500 folks like Andre R and said hey we've got this big you know big box thing um the insert doesn't have to be necessarily ready for day one but when stuff starts rolling off the the printers down in China and we start getting proof groups and things. We want you to design a 3D printable insert because if I could go to, you know, game found or if I could go to Kickstarter and the then the Kickstarter page, the the the backing page would say this, you will have an insert by so and so, I'll be like, "Oh my gosh, well, that'll be great." So that when they voice this kind of trash. I remember older, wiser board gamers than me, when they'd see these, they'd be like, "Oh, those things are crap. Throw them out." Be like, "Throw them out. Oh my gosh. Soccer blue. I I didn't really say soccer blue, but I'd say like I paid I paid good money for this. Good money for not a

very good product. So yeah, why not chuck them? Chuck them. That's what I say. If you're a board gamer and you don't own a 3D printer, go out and buy one. That is my my big message to you. I've uh since uh the earlier episodes of this series, I have upgraded my 3D printer uh so that I'm no longer torturing myself. It's the most expensive gadget I own. next to maybe my computer, but oh my gosh, it's a it's a Bamboo X1 Carbon. And uh when I was looking around for new printers, people said, "Oh my god, Bamboo X1 Carbon." This is when they were kind of new. They're like, "Ah, you don't want one of those." I'm like, "Why?" They said, "Because you just push a button and it prints whatever you want with no problems." I'm like, and and they said, "Yeah, well, you don't get to tinker. You don't get to I was already on the page clicking by as hard as I could. So, so far it's been a dream. This insert eats up almost two full kilogram of PLA. So, it's a beefy boy. I measured the box before I I put this insert in. And I'm just going to I'm going to nip out right now. I'm going to measure the box right now.

Okay. So, without that, it was 13.1 lb. And with that insert, it's 16.8 lb. And I'll put the metric conversion up there for my non-American friends and non-Canadian friends. We in Canada, we measure in pounds. Don't ask me why. Uh but uh yeah, that ain't that ain't nothing. Oh my gosh. Lift from the knees. I just find with more and more of these big boxes, like I would love to play them more. And I think that oh, once I have it all together and I got this amazing insert, I will play them more, but then then I then I have to lift them off the shelf. I'm like, no, forget it. Let's just play Uno. Not really. I wouldn't do that to myself, but just let's let's let's play something that I have the arm strength to to pull down. Um, but all that said, I this one sits in my living room cuz I want to play it more.

There's so many modules to explore. I haven't tried solo. There's so much to dive into here that I was really bummed out. The insert made it harder to put on the table, harder to put away. Uh, and I just thought, you know, what what have I done to myself? But now, oh my gosh, now once again, thank you JS500. Now, thanks to JS500, I've got a beautiful insert that is designed so that we can get stuff out in the proper order. Solo stuff is shoved to the corner. It's not going to mess up anything. And we are likely going to play this game a whole heck of a lot more. If you are not yet a patron of the Nights Around a Table channel, uh please join me there. Uh with your financial backing, it's a very small amount every single month, uh you will get special colors on the Discord server. And the Discord server is a wonderful community. people are playing games there uh together on board game arena and other places all the time. So if you want to uh to get in on that uh you can that's you can join us for free there. But if you want your name to light up and I know how important that is then back me on Patreon and you get access to uh any modifications. Now I just want to be clear the JS500's insert is completely free. You can go grab that on printables.com. Look at the link below this video and you can grab that no problem. Uh the modifications that I make to these files are very very minor min minor and they're there to benefit my backers. So join me on Patreon if you want to avail yourself of those. That has been another episode of Bits Please.

I have been your host Ryan. And remember, make all your games debilitatingly expensive ones. We'll see you in the next one. Did you just watch that whole thing? Oh, hey. To 100% this video, click the badge to subscribe and then click the bell to get notifications when I've got new stuff.

Progress saved