Pond - TCbH Review
Transcript
In the most uncharitable reading, you could describe Pond as My First Root, four-letter game about cute forest critters vying for control and points in the wilderness. And you wouldn't be entirely wrong, but the similarities mostly end there. Instead, let me tell you about a game that so wholeheartedly embraces its poppiness and identity that it becomes one of the most energetic and easy to table combative area control games that I've played in years. The first thing you'll notice when coming across Pond is, of course, the frogs. At first, you might be tempted to think that this is some lower heavy Pond Claw fantasy setting, but I really get the feeling that Brother Ming Games' modus operandi was, if thing plus frog is goofy and or cute, stick it in the game. Players each control a band of frogs, each having a unique starting power and mechanical flavor in their action cards. On your turn, your long fwogs, essentially captain units or even more mechanically related to, say, buildings on account of their immobility, permanence, and restriction of one per player per pond, produce a standard frog each. Then, you use your cards in hand to take actions on the board, generally moving bands of frogs, constructing lily pads, which are point generators, or attacking other players.
More on that in a bit. On the other hand, your cards might generate berries used to purchase new cards from the display and put them in your discard pile, which end of your turn, you discard everything in play and unused in your hand, then draw to five cards and shuffle up if you're out of cards in your draw pile. Oh, yeah. Did I not mention this is a deck-building game, and the cards in your hand, and by proxy the cards in your deck, are what drives all of your action capabilities, the very essence of what you're doing on your turns. But, that's not entirely new, but what I love love is that every time you refresh your deck, every time you have to shuffle because your deck is out of cards to draw, you have to mandatory hibernate [snorts] one card from your play area or your discard pile of your choice, permanently removing it from the game, which is a generally desirable thing in pretty much all deck-building games, but two important notes here.
One, it's great because you're thinning your deck and furthermore, your hibernated cards actually become a currency to buy hero frogs, unique frogs that instead of going into your deck, sit on top of your paid hibernated frogs and give you permanent passive abilities. Very cool, very smart. I have no notes for this other than the fact that for some reason these hero frogs, which fully exist outside of your deck, they never go in shuffling because they're permanent ongoing abilities, for some manning reason have the same backs as the cards that actually go into your deck, and that totally could have been addressed, but outside of that, I I love this system. But two, the other thing that I wanted to mention is that hibernating your frogs quickly goes from cool and great and something you really want to do to exceptionally scary. Every long-time fan of deck-building games knows the feeling of getting your deck down to the thinnest possible margins, just a handful of cards that you're seeing return over and over again, but because you have to hibernate a card mandatory with each shuffle, if you're having to shuffle every turn because you only have five or six cards, you're quickly having to replenish cards, otherwise you're going to run out of your best cards. That can get pretty spicy, but I love teetering on that edge. But okay, okay, okay.
Let's talk about my other favorite thing about this game, which is uh slapping your opponent's big banana for lots of juicy points. Pond is a game of points, lots of points. You set up a pool of points based on player account and end of each turn, you get one point for each pond you have the majority of units in and one bonus point for each lily pad you occupy, whether you control the location that lily pad resides in or not. But just as important, you get points for each damage you do to the enemy's long frog. They're veritable grand negus of the frog world. Whenever you initiate an attack, you choose where you're attacking and roll dice equal to your units there, up to three, then assign damage to other players present based on results. Swords being one damage to them, bombs being one damage to both of you, and X's being misses.
They then decide which basic frog units die, but all remaining damage goes to their undefended long frog, who can't die, but you get a point for each damage you do to it. So, sometimes you make these little death marches of frogs with no long-term plan, no intent on maintaining control of an area other than the fact that it's a somewhat vulnerable big old long frog that you can wail on hopefully to collect on a bunch of points, especially if you have a couple attack actions in your hand that you can spend in succession on a turn. Sometimes you will play defensively or you'll try to take advantage of the board state and seize control of a bunch of lily pads or the ponds themselves for a bunch of end turn points. It's not a huge network of strategies to play around with, but there is a lot of little variety that you can play with given opportunity and customization that makes up the game's overall verve. It invites you to have fun, and the shorter play time, just under an hour for my first learning game with three players and shorter since, the permanence of the long floags, the silliness of the theme, or just the fact that you produce so many darn units from your permanent infrastructure really takes the sting often felt in take that style gaming.
Most of my criticisms of the game are cosmetic. Aside from the card backs I mentioned earlier, the game uses a handful of symbols which are really small and can be mistaken for one another at a glance. It's also a personal thing, but as much as I love the goofiness of the game, I mean, Carrot Frog is my dog, I'm not and have never really been into baby goo goo ga ga speak. Perhaps on account of sometimes having a mush mouth myself, particularly as a kid, but long floag will always be long frog to me. That said, game play wise, this is a game that you have to know what you're getting into. This is more a game of tactics and opportunity than it is of long-term strategy. I also have a slight concern about balance with the wizard frogs being able to lose a unit to draw more cards, particularly potent in a deck building game where chewing through your deck means you become more powerful. Whereas other powers, like being able to re-roll one dice in combat or moving other frogs along, seems more situational. It's not broken, and like any good area control, there should be some self-balancing through banging on the leader at the table, but I wouldn't be surprised to learn the wizards have a long-term higher win rate. On the other hand, again, grinding your deck down too much also comes with the aforementioned risk. So, I'm not entirely too concerned. Also, this is a game that clearly was designed with the intent being accessibility and immediately engaging players in the fun.
It's not trying to focus on grand strategic depth. This is a fairly shallow pond. It's full of great decisions and for what it does, it executes it very well, but it's not something that's ever going to be able to rival some of the strategic darlings that area control combative games tend to be known for. Pond is a game that I truthfully had no knowledge of or expectations going in until it was sent to me for review and I got to tell you, I'm super stoked on it. I think because of how disposable the frogs are and how valuable it is to both have your own and beat up other long frogs, it encourages expansion and getting in the thick of it in ways that combative games often turtle. It feels great to play. It looks so vibrant and fun on the table and it's a game that I'm super happy to bring and play with my hardcore game groups, but at the same time is equally attractive to my less stompy war game oriented family. Pond is an absolute hit and one of my favorite games that I've covered so far this year. And that's our review, but let me know, what is your favorite ultra silly ultra goofy theme that actually has a great game attached. Put it in the comments below and as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help this channel grow. No money ever changes
hands from publishers to us, so we rely on you for
likes, subscribes, comments or sharing our videos out there and of course checking out our Patreon. But above all, let's just
thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.