Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tiny Towns: Review by AYCB

Transcript 7:58

hey everyone Carlo here with a ycb and today i'm reviewing tiny towns which was designed by Peter Macpherson it's actually his debut game and published by AEG this is a game for one to six players that takes only about 45 minutes to play it's a city building game where you have a four by four grid that represents your little town and you're filling that with resources and converting those resources into buildings and trying to squeeze as much as you can into this tiny space if you don't know how to play yet check out our how to play video and if you do then stick around let me tell you what I think about tiny towns tiny towns was actually one of my favorite games of 2019 I think it was overlooked quite a bit in a lot of the recent awards talk and nominations for other games especially when you consider the fact that this was Peter Macpherson's debut game I have to mention it was also developed by Josh Wood who designed catlady which we really really liked I mean first off when you look at it the presentation is beautiful the illustrations on the cards are really really nice there's all these you know cute little animal critters all kinds of different locations like just just staring across the cards as this brings you quite a bit of joy the building components here all the wooden components sort of excellent quality you know they're all kind of uniquely shaped minor issues with them here and there which I'll get to later but overall it's just a beautiful package I really like this whole spatial puzzle that you're

working with this restriction of this four by four grid you know first second turn it might seem like you you think you're in a good spot you have a lot of room and within a few turns you quickly see how restrictive it is and how boxed in you feel and the decisions are approaching agonizing almost every single turn especially when someone else is calling a resource that you don't want to take and you're figuring out where to put it just trying to think of some way to use it later on I really like the way player interaction is done you know some games have sometimes it's just like you draw a card that says like your opponent loses points or destroy your opponent's building or something like that and I often don't like those because it just feels like an arbitrary kind of lazy way to throw and uh hey you know bring the leader down a few points so that it's a closer game in tiny towns what you're doing that hurts your opponent's is also gaining you a resource so I found that even players that I play with who don't normally like mean player interaction in games quickly start to pick up on what is the right move in terms of picking something but yeah sure maybe I can use this stone it's not great for me but if all my other opponents really don't want it I'm gonna pick stone and make them take it and I really like that because it forces you to be aware of what people are doing but you don't feel mean or malicious so that you're targeting a specific person so I have to say a big credit for how the player interactions done here I also like how even when you don't win you it's satisfying to build your town to see it come together even when you fail and you place something in the wrong spot a lot of the time you gotta

look back on and laugh and you also can often pinpoint where you went wrong and exactly on what turn or with what resource in some ways it can be a little unforgiving I've had games where you know I realize I made a mistake on turn three I didn't realize till you know halfway into the game and then I kind of realized oh well the game's kind of out of my control now I'm not gonna win but so sometimes you do have to play through and it's a little unforgiving I don't really consider that a negative I think it accurately rewards you for excellent planning but it also punishes you when you make a mistake and I kind of like that it's it's fair the other thing I really like is the kind of balance between strategy and tactics so think of a game like Dominion where you have a kind of menu of cards and you know when the game starts you're kind of looking at all the cards available and trying to plan out your strategy similar thing going on here every game is gonna have a different collection of buildings available so the beginning of the game you can kind of look around form a game plan and think okay those two buildings go really well together I'm gonna focus on a strategy that's really heavy on this one type of building and maybe these ones I'm gonna try and put in the corners and you're trying to plan that out but as the game goes on your strategy just gets messed up by the other players so much and you're forced to constantly pivot and make use of the resources that you're giving you so there's always these tactical adjustments you have to make along the weight but you're always trying to stay on that path that you set out from your initial strategy as much as possible there are some things I don't like about it it's not a perfect game but honestly my my criticisms are pretty minimal the first one is that the monument cards I

mean it may be it's tough to say I've played about 10 or 12 times some of them maybe seem like they're a little stronger or weaker than others and the other thing is that some of them sort of encourage you to play the game in a different way that either doesn't seem fun or just seems a little counterintuitive to the rules for example the obelisk of the Crescent says you may place all future buildings on any empty square on your town so this means once you construct that monument for the rest of the game any building that you place ignores the regular rules of having to go where one of those resources was now even though it might be balanced out by the fact that this monument doesn't give you any points whereas a lot of them do it still reminds me of kind of an important lesson I learned from reading from the designer of guillotine so in guillotine long story short those are role cards and throughout the game there's all sorts of abilities that you're able to do to manipulate the order of these cards but one of the cards in the game says once you play this no one can change the order of the cards in the line and I remember the designer saying years after the game came out that he realized that he didn't like the design of that card because it basically was telling players to play the game in a way that fundamentally went against the basic rules of the game it's all about changing the role of the order of the cards and this card says you can't do that and that's kind of what this feels like in tiny towns you know you have this really compelling restriction that makes your turns interesting that makes the game interesting and challenging and you're basically saying we're not gonna give any points for this but for the rest of

the game you can place your stuff wherever you want the other thing in terms of the wooden components some of them are a little bit you know have little shapes that are maybe get broken easily or get chipped off or whatever so a pretty minor complaint there the other thing is that because this game does go up to six players some of these buildings you might run out of it playing at higher player counts and it says in the rules you know that there's supposed to be an infinite supply of these so just use an adequate replacement but if you're gonna lose this many pieces and there's they're so nice and colorful you're not gonna really enjoy putting some random like coin or token to represent this big red wooden building or something so I do wish there were a bit more of the building so that you wouldn't run into that issue back to the player account for a second it says one to six on the box but because of the master builder mechanic the solo version while it can be fun to build your own puzzle it kind of takes away from the that interesting player interaction and then I find that playing with five or six is a bit much to keep track of and also if you're only the master builder once every five or six turns nobody's really gonna be able to do what they want with their towns so it'll be pretty tough I found the sweet spot tends to be three or four players even - it works super well so I think of it more as a two to four player game that you know you can play solo or include more players if you really want but I'd stick to two to four either way fantastic game highly recommend tiny towns if you haven't given it a shot yet definitely go for it and be aware that a eg actually sometimes has these townhall variant games online where you can join

in sometimes with hundreds of players so yeah keep an eye out for those you can also check out my full written review on our website at all you can board comm and as I said keep an eye out for our content on the tiny towns expansion fortune coming up thanks again for watching and see you next time

Progress saved