Bulge Off '23 | The Championship! | Battle of the Bulge Wargame Boardgame (Round 7)
Transcript
hi everybody I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome to the final episode in our bulge off 23/24 where we've taken the top 20 tabletop Battle of the Bulge war games and narrowed them down single elimination March Madness style to One champion and today is the day we've been waiting for we are crowning our champion we'll also give the results of our bronze star matchup which was the matchup between the the runners up in the semifinals so we've got two games to take a look at interesting results although I will say a little bit anticlimactic over our semifinal round before we however go into that I do want to mention that this video is sponsored by our Channel sponsor Noble KN games as I was putting together a lot of the games for this competition a lot of them are out of print and somewhat hard to find while I could find some of them on eBay sometimes it's really hard to tell what you're going to get on eBay with a used game when someone says the counters are all complete and things like that and one of the things I've liked about getting games from used games in particular from Noble Knight games is that every time I've gotten one it's at been at that stated level or better and you know if there's ever any issue with it they're going to make it right so I've been really happy with the service I've re re received from Noble KN games and they were particularly pivotal in putting together four of the games for this collection so uh thanks to Noble KN for sponsoring our Channel and all of the games are linked down below so if you are looking for any of the games in this competition uh those links might be a good place to start but now it is time let's dig into our final results we're going to of course start with the Bron
star matchup which is Arden's 2 from multi-man publishing against enemy actions ardens from Compass games this one was somewhat actually it was kind of a route there's really no other way to put this as enemy action Ard Den racked up 69% of the 370 votes and Arden's 2 picks up 31% of the votes the Bronze Star third place medal goes to enemy action ardens now I have another story to tell about enemy action ardens because if you watch the episode before this you know that with something like close to 400 votes enemy action ardens and ardens 44 in their semi-final matchup were just the slimmest margins apart and as I looked at them over the course of the week they kind of were going back and forth in the end when I had to tally the votes it was clear that ardens 44 had edged out enemy action ardens by anywhere from one to five votes because you can't really tell the exact number on a YouTube poll well I can't close YouTube polls I could delete it but I don't want to delete it so I had to leave them open and what I've noticed is I've gone back a number of times now and I've looked at that matchup because now it's up over 400 votes and I think two of the three times I've gone back and looked at the results of that semi-final match enemy action ardens has actually been leading over Arden's 44 and that happens to be the case right now if we look at the results from 402 votes we can see that 50% 50% but the line that bar graph for enemy action ardens is
slightly longer than that of enemy enemy of ardens 44 which means that enemy action ardens now if we if we ended the results today it would have gone on to the final so uh Point made is that I think all of these games are fine games but in particular enemy action Arden's as a bron star winner could have easily had history and the fates been just a little bit different could have been the champion of the entire tournament but now this is it the final moment we've all been waiting for we now by the way I had hoped to get this out on January 28th but uh Patton's tanks kind of ran out of gas a little bit so we're delayed by about a week getting here in the early part of February I wanted to end it on January 28th because that's the historical end of the battle of the Bulls but we're just a little bit late for this Sor sorry for the delay and thanks for your patience with this but we did finally make it we started with 20 games and now we're down to one our denz 44 from GMT games goes up against the last Blitz GG from multi-man publishing both of these games have solid ratings of over eight on Board Game Geek and they come slamming each into each other in the final round how did it go oh Arden 44 got the most votes in every single round it participated in up to the final round and that didn't stop here for the final round as it garnered 64% of the 444 people who voted for this uh in this competition and convincingly picks up the victory over the last grig which had 36% of the vote
so congratulations to Arden 44 for winning the medal of honor award and becoming the king of all the Bulge games in this competition congratulations as well to the last Blitz grig who will earn the Silver Silver Star Award for second place in the competition one does Wonder however had I checked those poll results just a couple days later could it be enemy action Ard Den's sitting in this Championship because again it was such a razortip match between those two games history will never tell us this is the historical result we'll only be able to look back and and speculate on what might have been had just a little bit of a couple of days later a couple of days earlier who knows what the final results could be here but I think that's kind of one of the things that makes these fun again and the idea what I stated back in the beginning just to reiterate at the end here to be perfectly clear this really is a competition for fun uh it's not to really make definitive statements about any and all of these games there's a lot of factors of course which people have talked about in the comments as to why people might pick one game over another game and it's really hard to tell what people are thinking there I think we can say however that the games that made it here to the last four and I would also like to say I would say the games that are in the competition in and of itself I mean I really tried to whittle down the field to what I thought were kind of the 20 most representative and definitive games about the Battle of the Bulge that have been made for the tabletop I think you can go no I think you can't go wrong with any of the games that were in this competition and it's a it's a shame we have to end up with one of course but you know I think we really
started out with 20 fantastic games and you can't there's a ton of fun to be had from any one of these games in the competition so there you have it I thought I would wrap up now a little bit with just some kind of Reflections on some of the things that I observed and some of the observed and some of the things that I think this competition kind of brought out and then also just a minute or two about where I think this type of video series might go on the channel um so first up um there's been a lot of comments and lot of conversation in the comments about Board Game Geek ratings and those are the ratings that I kind of use to seed the field that's why I kind of want to have the last Blitz C which had a board game geek rating of over eight uh in in kind of a corner of the bracket Ard Dan's 44 and then enemy action ardens all of these three games when the tournament started had Board Game Geek ratings over eight and I wanted to put them in Corners so they could converge if the ratings turned out to be indicative they could converge on the semi-finals and finals and then we would go from there so I didn't want like enemy action or Dan to go up against the last blitzk in the first round that would have been a little bit odd to put them there so they were roughly seated that way there was in that one game which was really interesting here too is that Arden's 2 which made it to the semifinals didn't have enough ratings on Board Game Geek to get a rating get an official rating when we started the tournament but over the course of the past month and the half it's finally accumulated enough people rating for it that it did actually get a board game geek rating and lo and behold its rating is well over eight it's up in the 8.2 and 8.3
range so for people that might say Board Game Geek ratings don't matter four games in the tournament have Board Game Geek ratings over eight and all four of them made it to the semi-finals and finals so I think we can say that there is a little bit of Truth at least or some truth or a good bit of Truth to board game geek ratings with regards to war games now I think there's the flip side of that right because some of the games that had lower ratings some of the older games in particular that had lower ratings actually did really really well in the early stages of the tournament until they ran up against the juggernauts that were really the semi-finalists and the finalists so I think while it might be say that a high Board Game Geek rating is indicative of a quality game based on this a lower Board Game Geek rating is not indicative of a weaker game it could be a really good game especially if perhaps it's an older game that you're looking at now again we're speculating that we need a lot more data right we need to figure out kind of what what goes into Board Game Geek ratings how people are doing what kind of people there's so much that we're kind of speculating on that we don't really have good data analysis for this but I did think those Trends with Board Game Geek ratings were interesting second observation was all four games that made it to the semi-finals and the finals are games from Big Publishers right and we had some amazing games from smaller Publishers that got knocked out really early and I do think that one of the things that became apparent in this is that to a certain degree a better known game a game that's had more copies printed is going to survive and last longer in a tournament like this simply because more people have played it than
other games that are in the tournament too so there is a certain amount amount of production of marketing of popularity and well-known aspects of games like this that helped make it to the finals and things like that having said that there are a lot of games from the bigger Publishers that did get knocked out earlier than that so there is that kind of blend I think of both quality and popularity that kind of merged as we got to the end of the tournament there the last thing uh the last thing I would like to talk just a little bit about a bunch of people have mentioned in comments down below not necessarily about balof but about how much they've enjoyed it or the fact that they've liked this bulge Off Tournament and could you do a tournament about like gettsburg games or could you do a tournament about D-Day or you know Baba Rosa and things like that or the Eastern Front absolutely this was very much for my idea it was really much a very much a test run I wanted to see if people enjoyed it to see if people liked it I feel this format uh this type of format can really be expanded on and taken in not just the same exact way we did it with like 20 games or 16 games and kind of crunching them down to one game I think we could start even with the field of four and then do playthroughs for all four and then kind of you know so people could see actually the games in action and not have to try to decide about the games just based on whether they played them or not which is really kind of uh it doesn't give you much information to go on if you haven't played the games so we could do one with like four games do playthroughs of all four games and people say which playthrough did you think was the most exciting and created the most dynamic gameplay so I think there's a ton things we could do comparisons across smaller Fields bigger fields we could do World War I we could do Vietnam War we could there soliter
games games that you can play in two hours I think the the potential for doing things like this video series is really large and I would definitely like got definite strong intentions to come back and revisit this format in some way shaped manner or form especially I would like to keep up the idea of audience participation that's what made this really really fun for me so I would like to end on this to say a huge thank you to everybody who commented liked who may have subscribed to the series because of this um and then kind of shared and voted for the games as they were going forward it was really fascinating for me to read all the comments and to kind of see this it was very much more you know usually I make a video and I publish it right and then people give comments and stuff like that but this was really much audience participating you were driving the competition so thank you to everybody who took the energy and time to offer up their thoughts and then vote for all the games this was just as much fun for me as it was for I hope that people that really like the series out there and with that it is time for us to wrap up bals 2023 24 thank you so much for watching Everybody I'd be curious to hear down below what you thought of the tournament what you thought of the results and then ideas for other tournaments like this as well down in the comments down below thanks for watching everybody have a great day