Enemy Action: Ardennes Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Enemy Action: Ardennes
Enemy Action: Ardennes is the opening title in Compass Games‘ Enemy Action series of card-driven wargames. Designed by John Butterfield and published in 2015, it portrays the German offensive against the Western Allies in December 1944, the Battle of the Bulge. It is built for two players or for one player taking either side. Zilla Blitz placed it in the Bulge Off 23/24 tournament, a single elimination bracket of twenty Battle of the Bulge wargames, and its performance became one of the more talked about storylines of the event.
The game advanced by convincing margins. It defeated the 1944 Battle of the Bulge from Worthington Publishing in the Elite Eight, a result the host had not anticipated in such a lopsided form. In the semifinals it lost to Arden‘s 44 from GMT Games by only a few votes, and when the host returned to the poll, the host found Enemy Action: Ardennes had at times been slightly ahead, which would have sent it to the final. It then took the bronze star match against Arden‘s 2 from Multi-Man Publishing. The host read these results as evidence of a loyal following, particularly among solitaire players, while noting that the bracket blended popularity with quality.
Core Mechanics That Define Enemy Action: Ardennes
A Solo System That Plays the Opposing Side
The mechanic Zilla Blitz returns to most often is the game‘s solo system. In Zilla Blitz‘s 2025 Shelf of Shame video, Zilla Blitz explains that a player can face an AI opponent commanding the Germans, or let the bot system run the Allies. This allows one person to experience either side of the campaign without a second player. In the Elite Eight coverage, Zilla Blitz describes Enemy Action: Ardennes as the only really dedicated solo mode game in the competition, and credits that design with much of the title‘s reputation. Many players count it among their favorite solitaire wargames.
Three Games in One Box
Zilla Blitz presents the title as three games in one: a solo Allied mode, a solo German mode, and a two-player game. The structure serves players who want a head-to-head contest as well as players who want to explore the campaign alone, and the host introduced the title in the tournament with exactly that description.
The Enemy Action: Ardennes Experience
Solo Play as the Centerpiece
For Zilla Blitz, the experience of Enemy Action: Ardennes is defined by its solitaire play. Zilla Blitz describes the solo experience as one of the best in the industry and says it is what drives the game‘s reputation. Because the solo design is so strong, the two-player contest does not generate the same enthusiasm, a difference Zilla Blitz attributes to the exceptional solo mode rather than to any lesser opinion of the head-to-head game. The result is a campaign that a lone player can run against an automated opponent.
A Title Players Keep Coming Back To
The game inspires a devoted fan base that tends to recommend it strongly. Zilla Blitz notes that many people described it as their favorite solitaire game, even though it still sat unplayed on Zilla Blitz‘s own shelf when making the 2025 list. In the tournament, Zilla Blitz observed that voters tended to back the games they had played and genuinely liked, and Enemy Action: Ardennes drew that kind of loyal support.
What Makes Enemy Action: Ardennes Stand Out
The Only Dedicated Solo Mode in the Field
Among the twenty Battle of the Bulge wargames in the tournament, Enemy Action: Ardennes was singled out as the only one with a truly dedicated solo mode. Zilla Blitz notes that this focus is why the title kept the solo gamer vote in the bracket. For players who want a complete campaign experience without finding an opponent, this focus sets the title apart from the rest of the field.
Ratings That Matched Its Tournament Run
At the start of the tournament, Enemy Action: Ardennes was one of only a few entries with Board Game Geek ratings above eight, alongside Arden‘s 44 and The Last Blitz Grig. Zilla Blitz later observed that every game with a rating above eight in the field reached the semifinals or finals, and took this as some evidence that community ratings carry real signal for wargames. Enemy Action: Ardennes therefore performed well both with the community ratings and in the tournament votes.
Potential Drawbacks
The Two-Player Contest Receives Less Attention
The most direct concern raised in the coverage is the gap between the game‘s two modes. Enemy Action: Ardennes is praised most for its solo play, and Zilla Blitz acknowledges that its two-player mode does not generate the same enthusiasm. Zilla Blitz is careful to say this is not a verdict on the head-to-head game but a reflection of how exceptional the solitaire design is. Players who primarily want a competitive two-player wargame may find the strongest praise less directly relevant to their needs.
Popularity and Reach Influence the Verdict
The tournament was a community vote, and Zilla Blitz cautioned that better known games with larger print runs tend to survive longer because more people have played them. Zilla Blitz observed that Multi-Man Publishing, Compass Games, and GMT Games, the three largest wargame publishers in the field, held every finalist spot, attributing that partly to distribution and familiarity. Much of the enthusiasm for the solo system is also secondhand. When making the 2025 list, Zilla Blitz had not yet played the title, so readers should weigh the praise with that in mind.
If You Enjoy Enemy Action: Ardennes
Zilla Blitz‘s recommendations point toward solitaire-focused designs with a strong sense of campaign and command.
- D-Day at Omaha Beach by John Butterfield: Zilla Blitz calls it an iconic solitaire World War II beach game from the same designer, and it shares the solo focus that makes Enemy Action: Ardennes stand out. See the 2025 Shelf of Shame video for Zilla Blitz‘s thoughts.
- RAF Battle of Britain from Decision Games: described as a classic solitaire system in which players can take either the German or British side while recreating the entire campaign, and it also plays two-player.
- Empire of the Sun by Mark Herman: recognized as one of the classic World War II wargames, with both solitaire and two-player play.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Enemy Action: Ardennes again does hold that solo gamer vote. It‘s the only really dedicated solo mode game in the competition, and it does so many, so many unique things with it."
— Zilla Blitz
"This 2015 game has three games in one: a solo Allied mode, a solo German mode, and a two-player game."
— Zilla Blitz
"So many people have told me this is their favorite soliter game, and it still lies unplayed on my shelf. The shelf of shame is so embarrassing."
— Zilla Blitz