Skip to main content
Loading video...

What's the best Battle of the Bulge Tabletop Wargame? | Bulge Off '23 | Round 1 | Boardgame

Transcript 16:06

what is the best Battle of the Bulge tabletop war game at this time of the year December it's a question that rages across the halls of Congress our top academic institutions and the local board game aisle at all our Target department stores from Uber drivers to Congress people everybody's got an opinion as to what the best Battle of the Bulge game is this series is going to ask you the viewer to try to answer that question I've assembled 20 of the best and most iconic Battle of the Bulge tabletop War Games put them into a field and we're going to do a March Madness style single elimination tournament to go down from 20 games to 16 to 8 to four and then one the king of all the Bulge games now this journey is going to take us a while the real Battle of the Bulge started just a couple days ago as I'm creating this video on December 16th and it stretches all the way to January 28th we're going to end our tournament and Crown our Champion on January 28th coming up in this video I'm going to introduce our 20 contestants and then we're going to set up the first play-in round which is going to take our field of 20 and narrow it down to 16 games but before I do that I wanted to take a moment and talk about how I built up this collection of 20 games over the past couple of months spent a lot of time researching on Board Game Geek talking to people posting on Blue Sky posting on Twitter connecting with people asking people I was able also to get physical copies of all 20 of these games so I'll be able to show some of

the components as we look at them and explore them a little bit not saying I've played these yet again again this isn't my personal list and playing them feels like a quest for next year's Battle of the Bulge series but I was able to get physical copies in hand regarding that I did want to take a moment now and mention our new channel sponsor Noble KN games from Wisconsin who was a huge help in being able to put together this collection some of these games were a little bit tricky to find but I was able to get about a half dozen of them or so from Noble KN games in Wisconsin they had used games is one of the reasons why I really think their service is great help to war Gamers so I to get some really good copies of some of these games from Noble Knight games and they came ex exactly or better than described so if you're looking for out of print or older war games or used war games they can be a great resource in addition of course they do have new war games they have traditional board games Miniatures role playing games down below in the description I have a link to Noble Knight games and a link to some of the games in this collection um if you do use those links to buy something from the store the channel gets a small percentage of that uh purchase and so thank you in advance to anyone who happens to support the channel by something like that now let's introduce our 20 contestants the games that are going to be battling it out for bulge off 23 to be the king of all the Battle of the Bulge games before I do start this I do want to say all 20 of these games are worthy games so if a game loses in this competition or loses early that's no foul against the game these games are all good games games we're trying to go down from this 20 games

that really represent the iconic and most iconic and best games of the this battle and narrow down the 20 of the best to the one that we're going to name King so please don't take it if you're a designer or a publisher and your game gets knocked out early that's not a knock against your game this is a tough field the competition is real one last thing before we start to announce the games I promise I want to mention the criteria for selection into this pool what types of games did I look for first off the biggest criteria is I wanted games that covered the entire Battle of the Bulge campaign starting in early December and ending in the end of January um I didn't want tactical games so that eliminates a lot of tactical games of course and I didn't want strategic games of which the Battle of the Bulge was a smaller component so games that are specifically focusing on the entire Battle of the Bulge campaign I did somewhat make two exceptions for this and by rule we're going to make those games play in the playin round as well so we'll see those games and talk about them more coming up but for the the most part almost all of these games covered the entire Battle of the Bulge campaign as I introduced these 20 games one last mention these are not in any particular order although I do have a rough seating order to determine the eight games that are going to be in the play on round and some of the rankings for when I'll arrange our tournament of 16 but we'll talk more about that later for now in no particular order let's meet our 20 contestants in bulge off 23 game number one a time from Trumpets from GMT games designed by Bruno C go this game is published in 2020 and has

more than 2,000 counters a true bulge Monster game number two the deadly woods from Revolution games and designed by Ted racer published in 2021 this takes Racer's popular dark deadly game system and brings it to the Battle of the Bulge game number three the last gamble the Battle of the Bulge by Danny Holt and published by ddh games this 2009 game uses only 120 counters to capture the entire Battle of the Bulge game number four Arden's 2 from multi-man publishing and designed by Dean essig this 20123 game is a re-envision version of the original Arden's game and uses multim man publishing's very popular standard combat series to capture the Battle of the Bulge game number five the Battle of the Bulge from Avalon Hill designed by Bruno caglio and Mick Ule this game is a reenvisioning of the original Avalon Hill Battle of the Bulge game from the early 1960s game number six tigers in the Mist published by GMT games and designed by Ray Freeman this 1999 game is one of five games in the competition that were published before the year 2000 game number seven winter Thunder from Tiny battle publishing and designed by Brian train this game uses a chitole system and a unique combat Matrix to generate a lot of action with a very small footprint entry number eight the last Blitz grig from multim man publishing and designed by Dean essig this game from 2016 takes the Battalion

combat series of multi-man publishing with over 1,600 counters and brings it to the Battle of the Bulge game number nine is iron tide from Pacific Rim publishing and designed by Nathan Gil Kilgore this uh Darkhorse candidate from 2003 has quite a vocal and Ardent following in the wargaming community game number 10 is Cella designed by Roger Miller and published by Revolution games this 2012 game is one of the two games that specifically don't cover the entire campaign I did want to include it as a play-in candidate because it was so highly regarded when I was asking people about Battle of the Bulge games and it does cover a pivotal moment in the campaign game number 11 bitter woods from Compass games designed by Randy heler and Bruno saglio the third time we've mentioned his name as a designer in this competition this 2014 game is an upgraded version of the original game by the same name entry number 12 World War II Commander Battle of the Bulge by Compass games and designed by the esteemed John Butterfield this 2020 game is one of a few only a few entrance into the series that use area movement instead of the traditional hex encounters entry number 13 walked um Ry from decision games and designed by Joe ya this 2380 counter game published in 2012 has the most counters of any game in our 20 game field entry number 14 battle for the ID from simulations Publications and design by Danny Parker this 1978 game at

its heart is four games of the battle for the ardans but it does include a campaign game so I felt Justified to include it it did receive a lot of voices of support it is going to be one of our eight playin games too game number 15 fast action battles from GMT games in designed by Rick young this 2018 game is the only game in the field that uses blocks instead of counters game number six 16 enemy action ardens from Compass games and designed by John Butterfield this 2015 game has three games in one a solo Allied mode a solo German mode and a two-player game game number 17 is the Battle of the Bulge from Avalon Hill designed by Larry Pinsky and Thomas Shaw published in 1965 this is the Battle of the Bulge game the most iconic game that fed them all game number 18 Arden's 44 from GMT games designed by Tony Curtis and Mark Sim this game brings the esteemed zone of control Bond system to the Battle of vge environment game number 19 the Arden's offensive designed by Jim dunigan and published by simulations Publications this 1973 game is our second oldest game in the competition last but not least game number 20 1944 the battle of the buls from Worthington publishing and designed by Dan fornier this 2020 game is fast playing and action-packed so there you have it our 20 contestants in the Battle of the Bulge bulge off do you have a favorite that you think should be

crowned Champion the king of all the Bulge games your voice shall be heard I did want to talk briefly about one game that is not here the last gamble designed by Danny Parker was a game that was published in the 1980s and a lot of people mentioned that one I couldn't find a copy of that one at anywhere close to a reasonable price and there is a new designer signature fancy edition of the last Gamble being produced and it's almost ready for publication now from Compass games designed by Danny Parker as well so I will try to get that game in the course of the next year and play it as I play through all of these games to try to figure out and identify my favorite bulge games in this genre now it's time for Action let's get this tournament started we're going to describe our four play-in games each one of these games will be a separate poll on the Community page of this channel there'll be a link to the Community page down in the description if you're not sure how to find it go there and go vote for which one of these two games in each of these Four competitions you think is the better bulge game and should continue on in the competition let's get started with playing game number one first up is C from Revolution games versus battles for the ardens from SPI cell is the only game that really doesn't cover the entire campaign in the competition but so many people said I needed to include it in the competition that it is here and it does cover December 23rd to the 27th which was kind of the high Watermark of the German advance and the pivotal moment in the campaign now this

is a 17x 22 in map a very small footprint only 88 counters but so many people have praised the gameplay to High Heavens so if you want cell to continue on in the competition go vote for it going up against cell is battles for the ardens from SBI Publications now this is one of the older games in our competition and it has a transparent box look what I can do that's pretty wild a lot of people praise the gameplay for this one by edit heart really though it is four battles however you can assemble a campaign game out of this to cover the entire Battle of the Bulge a lot of people praised its gameplay if you want battles for the ardens to continue go vote for this game matchup number two features two of our oldies that go by the same name play in game number two the battle of the balls from Avalon Hill games 1965 version and the battle of the balls Avalon Hill games 1981 version now the Battle of the Bulge 1965 version here is the oldest game that we have in the competition tons of nostalgia value here but how does it hold up in the competition I'm interesting to see how Nostalgia and kind of the iconic history of this game might hold up will it carry it far into the competition or will they get knocked out in the very first round this one is the 1965 version it's going up against the vastly updated and revised Battle of the Bulge 1981 version a lot of people in addition to praising kind of its nostalgic value praise the

gameplay of this version have you played the 1965 version do you have fond memories of either of these two games which one do you think is better go vote for that game and its playin game playin game number two to decide which one of these two games will continue to the round of 16 playing game number three features two smaller footprint games winter Thunder from Tiny battle publishing versus the last Gamble from ddh games now both of these games I consider kind of be Darkhorse candidates they're not as widely known as some of the bigger games from larger Publishers but in canvasing the field out there a number of people on social media said both of these games were really fun to play now winter Thunder is a game I did an unboxing of a first look video of a couple of weeks ago on the channel so so if you want to learn more about that one you can look at that one uh this one again uses a small footprint some pretty Innovative mechanics and a number of people said they really like it this is going to be one of the first games of my exploration of Battle of the Bulge games but if you like this game go vote for it having said that it's up against the last gamble now I confess I don't know much about this one other than people are saying good things about it it's still got its Noble Knight sticker on it hint hint nudge nudge wink wink it's got some cards in here another small footprint but people have said the game play is really really solid so which of these two winter Thunder or last gamble do you think should go on go vote for

one of them and play in game number three the winner will go on to the Sweet 16 and lastly our last playin game playin game number four fast action battles from GMT games versus the Arden's offensive from simulation public simulations Publications now fast action battles the the Bulge is the only block-based game in our competition I wanted to include it for that reason because there really aren't many block-based Battle of the Bulge games here and also a lot of people really said they like the gameplay for this one now this this series is continued this is a hard game to find I was really lucky to grab a copy but it does look like it have very Innovative gameplay and again a number of people really like this one so fast action battles the Bulge is in the competition if you know this one you like this one you want to vote for it to go on to the Sweet 16 however it's up against another Nostalgia game the Arden's offensive from 1973 is our second oldest game in the competition it goes back to these simulation publication games back from the 1970s and such that had the game trays right built into the lower box and the plastic sheets that go on the top and things like that a lot of nostalgia for many of you out there I'm sure as you think back on your memories from playing the Arden's offensive with that in mind do you think the Arden's offensive should go on or do you think fast action battles the Bulls should go on these two games going head tohe head the winner goes on to the round of 16 go vote for the one that you think is the

better game based on your own personal opinion and with that we've come to the end of episode one of Bulge off 23 we have four votes again on the Community page on the channel go vote in those four different head-to-head competitions I'll be back on Christmas Eve the 24th to announce the four winners and then to set up the next round in the competition where we're going to play one half of our 16 game bracket so we're going to take 16 16 games down to 12 games I'll introduce those games and introduce introduce those matchups in our next episode but look on the channel on December 24th for the results from these four games go vote and then we'll be back for round two continuing on roughly every six seven days or so until we get to the end of the competition January 28th the end of the Battle of the Bulge thanks so much for watching everybody

Progress saved