A Gest of Robin Hood Review
Transcript
hey everybody Welcome to drive-through review 792 today we're going to take a look at a Gest of Robin Hood from GMT Gam has come out a couple of months ago I'm going to pronounce the designer's name frederique sural I hope I have that correct uh what this game is is obviously a game about Robin Hood it's a two-player game it is in The Irregular conflict series from GMT this is actually volume two uh there's another one that's already been published which I cannot pronounce the name of and then there's another one coming out in the future called Cross Bronx Expressway I think so this is the second in that series and what the regular conflict series is is kind of like an offshoot of the coin Series so again uh this is a two-player only game although there is kind of like solo rules but that's more playing uh double fisted so to speak I will talk about those I have tried that uh but it basically is a two-player game with maybe a solo variant that you can use and one player will take on Robin Hood and the marry men and the other time the other team will take on uh the sheriff and their henchmen and that kind of thing and so the objective is to to either restore Justice or maintain order if you're Robin Hood side you're trying to restore Justice if you're uh the sheriff you're trying to maintain order and so um it's sort of loosely based on like the historical is myth of Robin Hood the Fable and they are trying to uh
Robin Hood players trying to you know Rob from the rich to give to the poor to sort of so um uh uh resistance in in the countryside there and then the the sheriff players trying to rob the various different parishes on the map and bring all those uh ill gotten gains back to Nottingham and then also to maintain order uh on the track there so we'll jump down to the table I'll give you kind of a brief overview of the game and I'll come back and I will give you my thoughts okay here I've got the main board setup like it might look at setup uh a couple of things to notice here if we take a look over here you can see I've got the order and Justice track here so the game will start off here on one on the order side the sheriff players trying to pull this marker down as far as they can to the order side and then the Robin Hood player is trying to push it up so it moves into the Justice area there and the winner of the game if you play through the full game and you haven't had kind of an immediate Victory which can happen at different points of the game Whoever has the marker on their side will be the winner of of the game now you can during one of the scoring rounds immediately win if you have the marker on your side in this case if you're the sheriff player in one of these darker shaded uh spots and similarly with the Robin Hood player and you have it up there and you have it there during that scoring round uh then you will immediately win so like I said um you're going to play through a deck
of cards uh just like the coin system and then you're going to have kind of interval what they're called royal inspections which we'll just pan over here and you can see you've got whenever you have a roll inspection come up out of your deck you're going to walk through some very simple steps there and then if at the end of that first step that unrest step somebody has their marker in a shaded area that'll be the immediate Victory there and a couple other things to note about this main map here is you've got a couple of different zones you've got these different parishes here and you can see there are markers that will either be on the Revolt side or on the submissive side this one starts off in Revolt and then you've also got some two forested areas here in the woods and you've got Nottingham there in the center and you've got these different pieces like so so you've got here the merry men you can see these have a little Hidden Side and I forget where I put Robin Hood he's in one of these there we go one of these is actually Robin Hood himself if that will focus you can see on the RH there so the Robin Hood player will know where that is and you've also got these camps here these will also be double-sided these are kind of like bases in other coin games there so this is got a covered side like that and then you also have the henchmen there those little Silver Shield looking things and so you got the different parishes nodding him and you'll be moving these tokens around doing different actions on the card I'm not going to get heavy into it um there is a really nice uh video by watch a play so if you really like want to full rules Deep dive uh that'll work really
well I I watched that myself as well as read the rules and um the video is definitely help ful that's for sure so on your turn what's going to happen is you're going to play through this deck of cards which there are instructions that you will build up you will Shuffle these in a certain order you'll have different scoring cards every basically seven cards and then you have this final scoring card at the bottom here which is the King Richard return card and uh so you're going to flip a card over and then you're going to go based on the initiative here now at the start of the game as well as after every scoring round the Robin Hood player gets initiative and the sheriff player a second and they will choose one of three things they will either do a single plot basically a single action they can do an event on the card or they can do plots and deeds you can do multiple actions and then also a deed which is kind of like a free action but sometimes it cost money to do the other thing you can do is you can also pass if Robin Hood passes they can cover up any of these boxes so maybe I don't have anything really good to do I need some money I can pass cover up the events so now the sheriff player can't take the event and then I get a a single coin so you've got coins that are worth one and three here that come in the game like that those are worth three these worth one and then if the sheriff player decides to pass instead of one coin they get this many coins depicted there so one two or three so let's say Robin Hood does the event and then Sheriff player does a single plot so that card will be resolved these will roll back now the sheriff player
will get first choice on the next card so they can do a single plot or action event plots and deeds in the events when you choose the event you just do what it says there are events here that are either more favorable to either side although you can choose if you want to pick the opposite event sometimes that can work out it's rare I've played this four times Well five times if you include solo um and there has been I think one occasion in all those games where um somebody wanted to choose the opposite event and so most of the stuff's going to come from these plots or plots and deeds so if we scan over here we can see for the Robin Hood and Mary men we've got this nice player eight now on the back of these it tells you how to set up your player and you have these three different plots that you can do and then the different Deeds now you can only do Deeds when you do the plots and deeds you can't do a deed when you just do a single plot or a single action but by doing that you're definitely seeding the initiative for the following round but you get to do a lot more hopefully catastrophic stuff for your opponent and then the other thing to note here is I have they set down but you have these shields here because you're going to cover all of the available things if I don't mess everything up here trying to do that so you have that there like that okay now you will not have the money behind your Shield that will be in front cuz money is open information but this way like if you have the Robin Hood character back there and all that kind of stuff or in the case of the sheriff we've got their board here which shows all their actions and things they will have these Carriage tokens here these will be hidden when
they come out on the board but behind their Shield here the sheriff player will be able to look out and put those different carriages so I'm going to talk generally about this cuz the rules are pretty straightforward in my opinion especially if you played a coin game this is going to be very simple um but you've got your different kind of actions so you get recruit so for Robin Hood player you can recruit new um uh marry men to come out which may be Robin Hood if you've got a base there you can recruit two instead of one you can also delete two and then put a base out there when you put a base out there you're going to gain um gain Justice and so that's just the recruit action and it costs you one shilling per space that you do that so if you do a single action you just pick one single spot and then you do the recruit action one of those three things I talked about if you do a multi-action the plots and deeds you can pick up the three spaces when you do that and you pay one shilling per space to do that that's how all the actions work so either do a single action in one space or up to three actions in three spaces and then paying for each of those now the sheriff player the same they have the same thing it's called hire instead of recruit but they have a little bit of a thing here so they have to put up to two of their henchmen into a submissive Parish they can't ever put anything directly into a forest of course cuz that's where Robin Hood hangs out or they can put up the four into Nottingham and then the sheriff can also do what's
called a patrol so they're going to move into here maybe however many they want they pick three destination spaces so three spaces that are going to arrive and then you reveal one henchmen or excuse me one merryman one green piece for each henchmen or if in this case you're in a forest it's got to be for every two so in this case I only moov three and so two henchmen revealed them oh I revealed Robin Hood and then I would have needed to move a fourth one in there to reveal that cuz it's for every two now on the um merryman side they have something called sneak which is how they move around so they'll move to an adjacent spot and in this case you pick the origin space not the destination space so up to three origin spaces and when they move in you'll take a look and see if the number of total pieces there is greater than three if they are then you'll reveal um the henchmen otherwise if there was only let's say one one henchman in there and I remove that brayman in that he would stay hidden cuz there wasn't so many to catch them moving in so that's the sneak action now the capture action from the sheriff player is if you have any of these revealed ones then you can capture revealed ones they will go up here to the prison spot up there these will come out half of them rounded down every scoring round um and that's how you get some of them off the board and there's some other cards and things that will pull them out now the merryman player doesn't capture the henchmen although there is a special action which I'll talk about
which is a turn coat action that can actually turn one of these into a merryman but they can do a Rob action so if we look just look down here so the two things you can rob you can either Rob The Traveler deck which is kind of this random deck here so you just you pick the Rob action you pick however many uh henchmen are in there that you want to reveal that will add to your uh sort of your attack score if you will and depending where you're at if you're in the forest or the parach here you're going to roll uh this dice to add to that and then try to beat um this value here in this case and then you'll also add to this Shield value here uh the number of maybe henchmen that were in there so you're trying to beat that and then before you do your roll though you actually have to choose like you get a sort of a kind of a lowrisk one you just get some Shillings then you get a highrisk one which you get might get more Shillings it might even like you know adjust the score track over here either way um and then or but the the the drawback to doing those other ones these may go to jail when you do that so you have a choice here you can either rck just a random traveler out of this deck and then sometimes you'll create a victim pile out of these as they go in there which other cards might interact with it it tell you depending on the card and in addition to that you can also try to Rob one of these carriages here and so what happens now is the um Sheriff player can do a confiscate deed so remember here so we talked about here higher action Patrol action capture action these are the plots the main actions then they have
the D you can do one so you can do a ride if you're the sheriff like move a bunch of these guys confiscate which I'll talk about here in a second disperse remove two enemy pieces to available so you can do those they have a cost here but one thing that the sheriff wants to do is they want to put out place an available carriage in each Parish then set it your Parish to where the carriage was placed to revolting so what that is is you're basically robbing these people you're taxing them so if this was submissive put it to revolt you're going to choose one of these carriages these going to have different Awards and benefits for both the merryman player and the sheriff player depending on what happens to it so if it's here Robin Hood player can rob it and in this case they will get two coins and if they fail they're going to go to jail this has a builtin sort of Defense of two so CS is having two uh henchmen there whereas if they put this one out here the Robin Hood player would get five coins and then there's a Third Kind which is they get two coins but then if they also win then this will actually bump it up on the score track for justice now what the um Sheriff player is trying to do they're trying to put those out they don't want these to be revolting they want everything submissive like submissive to uh the sheriff what they're trying to do is move these carriages here into Nottingham and every time you flip over a new event card you're going to look and see here and this is going to tell you the number of characters that
you can move so this says move one of your carriages on the board and what you're simply going to do is choose one of the carriages that's available some of these will have two on them like this one you can have two oops there and you'll choose two different carriages to move you never move one twice and you'll just pick it and move it on the road that's shortest going into Nottingham now one thing you'll notice here is all of your paths into Nottingham go through the forest which you know Robin Hood has some some benefits there they can recruit there they get the dice if it gets all the way to Nottingham without being robbed then the sheriff player will get that reward plus the sheriff player gets a bump on the order track so that will help move that and then on the case of this one here they'll get two bumps one for the token and then one for the extra Crown there so that's what they're trying to do get those out and there are others so there are other things going on so like I said you want to get this up here you want to get money out of the robbing and the pillaging and all that stuff when we hit the scoring round the main thing that we're looking at here is whether or not these are in Revolt or submission now depending on there's a chart here on your on your nice play raate which acts as a shield so we can just look here this is the main thing you're going to be thinking about so when we get to the Royal inspection at the start of the round if there are five to seven submissive parishes plus one order if there's three to four Justice and so the less missive the more justice so if you
have a bunch of revolting ones then you're in bad shape if you're the sheriff so you're going to resolve that and then move counting that up and then moving this wherever it is at that that point if it's in one of the shaded areas on either side that's going to trigger the immediate Victory and then you're going to walk through some of these other steps here get a free Rob action disperse people back to the forest or back to parishes that are submissive that kind of thing just a little clean up to kind of reset the round and then you go into the next card so you're going to play through three of those unless there's an immediate Victory and again if there is no immediate Victory then you're just going to see where wherever that ends up so you're really trying to manage those carriages either robbing them if the Robin Hood player or getting them into Nottingham if they're the sheriff player and then trying to um sort of flip and manipulate these tokens here submissive or or Revolt because you know as the sheriff player you can only Rob the submissive people and then they're like well you're no good actually we don't like you now now and so then these are going to flip back over and then you have to take actions to kind of recover that um by the time the scoring round hits and then the Robin Hood player you're trying to set up traps there to you know to catch those carriages to maybe Rob some of the um The Travelers and that kind of thing there are cards that will mess with the traveler deck and there's of course a little bit of uh not like area control but board control out here in terms of you know getting pieces out cuz if you have a dominance in an area like let's say it's just two men up here they can easily switch that over kind of talk to
people into revolting so there's some management there in terms of you know flipping these back and forth uh but that's kind of Simply uh an overview of the game okay so that is a Gest of Robin Hood let's just go into my three pillars of review uh first of all we'll talk about player count because it is a two-player game uh GMT has published uh an article on their website which I've printed out and I will put a link to it on the video description for like solo rules but it's not like a bot that runs you know one of the sides and then you play against it it's a way to play the game double fisted because there's hidden information with you know where Robin Hood is there's hidden information with where and what uh the carriages are so it gives you a way to kind of randomize that um it it's okay I will say though it just doesn't hold a candle to two-player which I absolutely love playing as two-player uh it's great I do think I will say this about the solo uh rules that are in there I do think those have the beginnings and the inklings of some proper solo rules I could see some very possibly small modifications to the way the Robin Hood thing works and the character thing is probably fine as it is and then playing as aside with some kind of you know coin like flowchart if somebody wanted to come up with that cuz I I could not it would take me too much brain power that I don't have
spare um but I think it's possible I do think it's possible because it there is some there is some uh potential there with those solo rules now two-player fantastic I mean that's what the game's meant for and I love it we'll get more into why I love it in a minute the thing says here 45 to 90 minutes that is absolutely true for subsequent plays i' would say your first game is going to take you longer than 90 minutes uh I just feel like it will um there is you know compared to a coin game which is we'll just get into the whole comparison what is this game like part um it's on the easier simpler side but it is I would say competitive in that sense in terms of complexity uh with a with you know any coin game um not obviously the bigger you know really complex ones like fire in the lake and Pen dragon and all those other ones it's not near that at all Gandhi um but you know there's some stuff going on it's a GMT game it's a war game in effect don't harass me about that but um you know so there is some little idiosyncratic pieces to rules and things like that you know just little not even rules Exceptions there just some detail to the rules but it is not bad and I think it's very very learnable like I said there's a watch played video which will help out tremendously I think the rule book is very well done there's three rule books there's a learn to play there's like a you know official rule book there's a play book which I'll play you through some turns give you lots of details on the events and stuff like that help them
kind of make sense um and I think once you kind of understand the game thematically then it sort of Clicks in uh which is what I kind of felt um yeah this has to be the prettiest coin game that there is I love like the tarot cards with whatever that style of art is that kind of medieval looking art almost like little tap trees or something like that really cool the board looks great gorgeous um you know I can't emphasize enough cuz most coin games the cards is like a photograph like a black and white photograph like of a real historical event or person and then some text and these are these are you this is actual artwork and it looks great it looks gorgeous um you know all of the sort of uh indicators I love the player AIDS play AIDS are great you don't get those in a lot of coin games not like this I mean you get like a big fold out type of thing but it has the setup stuff on the back has some really interesting strategy tips I think for each side it gives you like three basic approaches that you then you can deviate from and I would say yeah for your first game pick one of those approaches and then do it your opponent won't know that you're doing it because you're just like you know maybe just do like the straight up approach and it's like here's the basic first time you play here's the strategy to do I really like that um and then you can sort of you know do that for like two turns or whatever and then go oh maybe I'll deviate here right but keep those principles um in mind and that's a really really cool thing to have right there on the player Aid um and that makes me feel better about like recommending this maybe to somebody
who's never played a coin game um and that's going to be a really cool thing um the other part that this is like in addition to like other coin games is it's kind of like a hidden movement game theory of Dracula type of thing or uh what are some other games like that I can only think of Fury of Dracula but you have kind of you know the Robin Hood character kind of roaming around trying to score points in a way kind of like the Dracula character although thematically the Dracula character is the the sheriff really but um but you've got that sort of thing and then the sheriff player is trying to sort of collect victory points in a way by with those carriages trying to get those on like a cycle and then sort of sniff out and sort of disperse the merry men and that works out really really well and I I think it's um like I said I've played it uh four times now then that solo game which sort of counts um and seen some really different interesting play like some really organic emergent types of things of like different strategies that you can do because you have kind of you have a tug of war there between the order and Justice right so that's that's okay right that's fine but then in the mechanic side you have two tugs of war and there's one Focus around the carriages getting those in or robbing them and stopping them and setting yourself up to kind of trap them and and
catch them but then also as the sheriff player positioning yourself so that you have some like uh muscle you know around that to sort of you know uh mitigate the dice rolling that's going to happen from the Robin Hood player and setting that up but then you sort of have that sort of playing tug ofwar on each player side with flipping Revolt or submit so you're focused on the carriage sort of Caravan that's going on but then also maintaining or as you will or deviating from the status quo in each of the different parishes so you that will force you to spread your forces out whether no matter which player you are cuz if there's a bunch of submissive ones you don't want that because then you know whatever order Justice is coming right back down the pike there and there are other events and stuff like that that will you know tug at that order Justice thing so it's a real tension there between being spread out and then kind of funneling things into that sort of corridor um where uh the Caravans come through and the wagons uh I will say the one thing I didn't really mention in the sort of rules overview is you have those different event cards which you take actions on but there are also these Fortune events and you're going to have one kind of in each set so you're going to have seven cards six of which are the normal sort of action event cards then there's one it's just like a pure event and just do what it says and I like that um because one thing that I was not sure I liked at the beginning was those
Fortune event cards and then also how the scoring cards are exactly seven cards deep so one of the things with the coin series is you Shuffle it in like a bottom section of a section right so you know oh it might come up the scoring card might come up now but you can't actually count it out with this you can count it out we got 1 2 3 4 5 6 7even okay the next card is scoring so you know exactly where it is which could be a problem but I think they did a smart thing here by adding in a fortune event inside of each of those sections because that will sort of shift things up usually it will end up bumping order or Justice up or down now I have lost a game because of the last minute Fortune event it was the second to last card before the scoring card and it moved it uh trying to remember who I was playing yeah it moved it one step towards Justice it was still on the order side I was playing and then it was like oh now I've lost because I know they're going to be able to just get it so if that hadn't that happened it was a different event or didn't mess with the order and then I would have won the game no sour grapes maybe a little no but um so that you have to keep that kind of stuff stuff in mind um but also also also also also there are other things I could have done and it wasn't a guaranteed lot loss but because of where Robin Hood I don't want to get into it but where Robin Hood was if it wasn't in this one spot then I still would have won but the thing moved Robin was also in the wrong Parish to be for me and then I was also out of money
so I couldn't do multiple plots and deeds I could only do one which wasn't enough to like you know hold those reins on but I had I was basically in a guaranteed win cuz there was nothing like action wise that they could have done you know it's it's too much to talk about mechanically but it's like okay well that event sort of opened the valve and I lost because of the event but I also lost because I did really well and I was like I almost kind of felt like I was breaking the game but then I'm like hey you know what I spend too much money doing that I like locked it down but then so they needed something like that cuz it was like huh so anyway my point with that is is that I liked having those events in there because you know honestly at the end of the day if you lose at the very end of a game cuz there was another game that we played maybe two before that where it was won by a dice roll right at the end and it was like if this Rob succeeds the uh maryman win if the Rob fails then it's going to go through on the next card and cuz we knew the order of the cards and we knew it was either a one or a two so it was going in and then if it fails then it's going to go in and then the other side is going to win but in my opinion that's that's okay because it's like we played so evenly that if it's going to come down to either the last event Flip or dice roll to end that's okay and like I said this is a$ 459 in a game so it's not too bad that way but just you know know that going in that it can be decided sometimes if the game is tight um there's been other games like I've seen where somebody does
win an instant win and these were kind of our first couple of games I think both the first two games I played were not all the way to the end no it was the first and third game anyway um but where somebody just got out and and won so that's why you get the 45 minute cuz somebody come out I don't nobody's won on the first scoring card so far but it's possible probably but we've seen some second card scorings wins and then the rest of them have been playing to time uh but anyway so that's kind of some really nuts and bolts comparisons there but I really love this game I think it's fantastic it's a lot of fun there's a lot of tension um there's like I said there's a lot of cool like little emergent things that happen with like you know funneling people around but the game has that like I said that tug of war of squeezing stuff in and spreading it out out and juggling the order Justice track um and there's a lot of space there to you know like I said feel like you've clamped it down but if you've clamped down too hard in one sort of aspect of the game you're giving your opponent whoever they are that other sort of areas to come and flank you like conceptually around and I think the game does an excellent job of kind of maintaining that and being fairly light and forward straightforward to play so I cannot recommend this enough I feel like I should recommend it to basically everybody that is kind of a hobby gamer obviously not everybody's going to love it um cuz there is you know if you're kind of a yearo person or something then
there's going to be a little bit of granularity I guess with the rules and details but I don't think it's too much and I think you get through that sort of initial hump of it uh I think the reward is there at the other side of it and uh it's it's great it's fantastic fantastic so definitely recommend picking this up thanks