Skip to main content
Loading video...

Zhanguo: The First Empire - Board Game Review & Comparison

Transcript 19:11

hello everyone this is CA and this is Johannes and you are watching board gaming ramblings and today we are taking a look at Sango and Sango the first Empire this is not going to be a review per se it's more going to be like a comparison and and in that we're going to talk about what we like about the game because SP alert we like the game yes we do so we are mostly going to talk about the differences most of you who are watching this probably already own this I want to know if you should get this because if you don't own this and you don't own this what should you do get this because this is impossible to get I think it's possible but it's not possible to find it new anymore sadly uh but we have a new version which is basically this is s we our French who did this new version and as I understand it the designers kind of got a second chance of making the game yeah so basically they said like how could we make this game if we made it today with everything we learn about the other game so it feels like it's a new game it has some new things it has some changes we're going to go through all of that um but yeah you like Sango yes I really do like Sango and it it has one of those like it feels like a classic Euro game but it feels very unique and it has a lot of interaction in it it has a very cool card driven mechanism where you play cards two different places on your player board or uh in the the middle of the board to do actions with them it

kind of reminds me and I read on BGG people thought it was not like official but people like this has had to be an inspiration for L booa because it's kind of much of the same thing like you are playing this card over your board in Lisboa under your board or playing it to do the actions which is has some kind of interaction which is different of course in L booa um I I really like Zango it's not my favorite of the what's your game games so like we think like M and also Z we like a lot I think those are our favit we also have the the one with the um the telephone line I don't remember the name of it oh I don't remember either no but we don't have the expansion for that and that makes the game better but this is not a review of what's your game but I'm just sad that the what's your game is what it is right now and I'm very happy that I did not sell or copy of Madara while I backed the other one but the all this game are fantastic and classic Euros so I was super happy when I saw that they were making a new version we didn't know about the changes before we actually sat down you didn't know them before we sat down to play it I read the rule book and I was like oh I don't remember too much but what we have done is that we have a looked at these two games looked at the differences looked at the changes and we're going to talk to you about them and how we feel about the different changes yes that is kind of what this game this video is going to be if you don't know anything about Sango then this game is probably going to be that this video is probably going to be kind of weird yeah because we're not going to

go like into all the mechanisms and how they work that's true but if you haven't played Zango it is a really good game that we both like we recommend the game yeah so if that's what you want from this video it's a fantastic game I highly recommend it as one of the and this new version is fantastic so basically if that's what you want to know before we go into details this new version fantastic get it if you can um yeah I like the changes let's talk about the changes let's start with the first one that we have written down we might have missed some like we tried our best to find all of them H but probably if you play the game like both of them many times you might have Chang chances that we haven't seen but we're going to go through the ones that we remember in Sango yeah you have some officials yes and the officials you need for many different things and it's a big change I would say from Sango to the first Empire I'm just going to call the new one the first Empire yeah does that sense or TF the new one yes uh the the officials is kind of a resource and in the old game it was depicted by like cubes here it's like tiles what do you call it cardboard tiles and now they have abilities that are specific for that kind of like workers um no sorry that's something um so many names in this game things so now the the different officials can do different things and they they just have to stay in the right

area yeah and in the old one as you probably know if you have played the Sango you had to the it wasn't didn't matter what color they were but you had to move it like up and down in like in the same area to do different things with them yeah basically the old version uh is as as this like when you you needed to have you had two space is up and down you going to see a picture you needed to have the officials in the lower place to be able to get Workers as an action in the new one there is specific of them that can give you workers and it's just going to give you two workers it's not like one or two depending on it then in the old one you could build a palace just if you had two workers and one worker in two different areas you could build a palace here you need to have that and also a specific specific official the last official that you have in this game is for a new mechanism or whole new part the game that we going to talk about a bit later and the thing that they haven't changed is that you need to have like one of each to send out the the governor I think it's called the governor it's so many names in this game and I usually just look at up P say this thing so we're trying our best here but to place the governor out so that hasn't changed but so it's kind of it's a little bit easier to get the workers U because it was that's kind of not true because in Sango you could just you could move them down to the worker bace as much as you wanted to but it was hard to get them then back up again so you tried to like okay I kind of don't need this now I want to get some workers and then I will

move them up and use him so it's kind of some part of it is easier and some part of it is is H is harder which one do you like the most H I like both but I feel like they have streamlined it and made it cleaner with a new version I think that the as you said like I'm going to quote you because you just said like it's not that they taken away the puzzle they just made it a different yes and it's not like completely different I didn't even remember it you remember when we play like w i don't need up and down anymore but yeah it's a good one um briefly some of this as we said in the other one we did like the worms span and wingspan one some of these are going to be short and some are going to be longer like the one we just did there's a change to Palace scoring yes uh the old one uh when you built a palace you were scoring like um dep points depending on how many cards you had tucked under your player board now you score six basic points and then depending on where you build your Palace you uh get a scoring for a specific type of card for example so if you build early then you have more um uh what you call it like incentive yes uh you get more points uh you don't have to like t a lot of cards to get those points and you also it it's more now a little more interesting where you actually put it for for the scoring scoring and also it's more interactive that way because you're going to be like no you took the one that I'm going to

get more scoring I maybe I'm going to try to move my workers around so I can do a better scoring or or try to to to to do find another one before somebody takes it so it's add even though like it was a number of spaces I think like x amount of spaces for them I I enjoy this better it is more of a oh I could do that Palace now it's only going give me four or five points maybe I wait later in the game to get more cards under it so I like this one uh better yeah than than than the other one another thing there's many scoring things that have changed the other thing they scored is the um the the governors the way that when you play the governors out um in the old one there was different bonuses they were the same each time yes now they changed that to variable bonuses yes I like that it actually did decide very much how I wanted to place my what you call it Governors Governors Governors um and because then suddenly an area that that had been taken a lot before wasn't that interesting to me anymore because it suddenly it didn't have any bonus it was like that in yes but but I feel like it's cool with different bonuses yeah I like that they are variable and also as you said like it makes you think more about where yeah because it's a better bonus than just is there somebody else that's taking the bonuses or not that's they also changed the scoring the old version s go there was nine points for the majority and

then there was three points for each uh Governor that you had there and and now it's only a majority so you are going to get if you are first place you're going to get 15 or 20 points depending on the player count and that's it yeah so how do you feel about that I feel like it's good um it doesn't feel like a huge change but but I like that that concept next up is the walles which is a big scoring part in Sango which is kind of like an end of game scoring where you are going to score for different things that you have done throughout the game and they have changed this as well to make it different and maybe better we don't know I don't know what do you think about the wall scoring I like the W wall wall wall I like the wall scoring as a a concept in general that that you want to play early because then you you will get three points for the things that you done instead of for example one or two what I or zero if you don't go there yeah that's true um in the old version it was tree spaces on the walls no matter the player count but here you can also go there if you're playing with four so there's three or four spaces so there are four spaces four four spaces yes and I I don't like that yeah like I enjoyed the tightness of you having to go for it in a four player game if you wanted to m i I personally I I like that racing better but it's not one it's not going to make me choose to play the older one that little thing but I think

I like that one better I don't have an a strong opinion on that I think either way was fine yeah cool so next up another we just going on to the next change which is the tasks as they called in the old one which is boring word but it is a it's a cube pushing base Euro game which we love and now in the tasks you basically had like okay you are going to try to have this amount of things in this or like you're going to have a wall in these areas or a a palace in these areas which it was like the reason to go for Palace earlier on so that you could score those and toask basically before other people because there were going to be more points and in the old version there was also like um two colored areas of of scoring you put out like a tile that told you which area you were scoring in it in or like which area you had to had the specific things in and then if you manage like two in the same area you would get more points per and all three in one area you get like massive Point bonus they have changed that here as well now it's in mosum it's called mosum m m musum I think where you it's a Terracotta Army basically you are getting these statues and you can place them in these scorings and it's the same kind of way they switched it around so instead of like now there is the areas on the board and you place random one around it tells you what you should have in those areas that doesn't change up too much no but now basically you will you want to look at that and you want to score things like you want to get Bingo you want to score

things in rows or columns because you get bonus points I think 10 bonus points for having like a whole row or a column of this of of these goals yeah the newest thing like the new biggest change and other than that is that now you don't have like a scoring token you have these statues and you also need to get the statues to be able to score the points yes I think this is a cool change because it feels like the points doesn't feel as swingy as in the original and I I think it's cool that you add the thing that you actually you need to get the poises that you can actually score with as well L thing which is the biggest thing because it's completely new it's like ins s go there's nothing and here it's a thing and there is called like search for the elexir or something like that it's it's a track with a boat that gives you bonuses and some Alchemist cards you have now some new Alchemist cards you're going to get them in the beginning of the game and there everyone is going to have the same ones and there's five I think of them five or six and those are cards that you can that can be Jokers that you can place everywhere and you can and Trigger them for for different things they're easier uh they kind they doesn't I don't they're they're they're better than the other cards but harder to play and also the last official which I didn't talk about has to be in the area where you want to play one of those blue cards so when you do an action that there is one know a new action which is changed out from the move officials around action

that is now done other ways you can move the both and when you move to specific spaces you'll be able to place an alchemist card and then later on you will get to choose between playing Alchemist cards are getting these statues for the mouse of Liam because you could maybe go for a strategy where you don't really need those you don't need that many cards or you filled up the row you don't really have a good way to use it right now so you rather get the statue and some points as well I feel like this is kind of just a it's a small addition it doesn't it doesn't really change too much but I do enjoy it I feel like it's a very well Incorporated um um segment into the game like an element it feels like it should have been there from the beginning not that the lacks anything but I feel like it doesn't feel like an expansion because you have like in work one of your officials are meant for this uh moving on the the boat track search for The Elixir doesn't only give you the the the cards that can be easily ignored you can just like I don't need the blue cards forget that but you really like if you don't have any final scoring you're going to most likely not win win this game so I feel like this it's it's a part of the game that it's hard to ignore completely so so it feels like a very complete part of the game yeah it feels like there's a little module that is going to be there and I don't think

if you love Sango you're going not like it because of this new thing one thing to talk about which is always the thing with newer games they usually get bigger H and that is kind of the case here but not really the main board is exactly the same is exactly the same as you can see in the pictures yeah there is this this P this piece is now not on the main board yeah because they um they need space for the bat track uh so they've taken away the the the play raid basically from the main board and this is now that yeah this like the the8 for where you play the cards and also they have made the player boards a bit bigger quite a lot bigger but most of that also is information information and the storing of your pieces basically yeah and you have it easily available to you instead of having to look around the board and look at that I think the symbology is better in the new version mhm do you agree yeah yeah and I also think that it looks nicer like I always love the old beige it's not really be but the all like colors it's kind of be because it's like a oh super super be and this new one is is more of a it's less bee yeah and it's kind of like this this is watercolor this is kind of watercolor isn't it I say that the other time you like nope it's not this this is kind of watercolor this is what I think about when I think like watercolor pie that might be watercolor oh so you didn't know the other time as well H best so I think that and the box is the same size I don't think you need that much of aiger a little bit like higher

higher oh narrow was the one so it was what is the other one thicker thicker th narrow thicker I think that's it so but but but all in all as we said in the beginning basically we spoiled you and gave away the final thoughts get this game I recommend it upside down do you recommend it yes which one do you want to keep I don't know which one I want to keep but yeah like nothing in this version is worse than the other version other than like the little thing I didn't I like the more tightness with the w but that is fine you can this you can I don't need that I want to I want to I don't do house rules because I don't like them but I like this new version because it's a fantastic game and I want to play it more yeah if if we weren't like uh doing this video and having a YouTube channel stuff would you if you if you had this would you go out and buy the new version what do you think like I would not do you need it no you don't because you already have a fantastic game but basically you can look at the changes and be like because there are changes that are big enough to make somebody choose to oh I would rather have that version of the game so that is basically completely personal I don't play the game enough to be like oh to Barren to like buy the new one to just like play it one time and maybe one time in four years but it is a fantastic game if you don't have the original go and get the new one and if you have the original basically it's up to you if you look at these changes look at the pictures look at everything

and see if you might want to make the change yes I agree and that's going to be the end if you are new here and you like what you do then you can help us out in a big Way by giving us a victory point and we get victory points when you click that subscribe button you can also click the Bell to get notifications every time we post a new video and this is going to be the end of this video that you've been watching about sang go and sang go the first Empire thank you so much for watching it it means a lot I'm Johannes I'm and you've been watching board gaming ramblings and

byebye e

Progress saved