Furnace Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at furnace which is a board game released in 2021 a designed by ivan lashian and published by hobby world and arcane wanders this one accommodates two to four players and takes 30 to 60 minutes to play and before i get into the review i just want to give a shout out to kianda dot co dot uk a great website we can buy board games such as furnace i'm at great prices and if you use my discount code key under five then you can get five pounds off at the checkout if your order comes to 40 pounds plus um but enough of that let's get into the review so furnace is a bidding and engine building style game that's going to look a bit like this when you're set up so you've got a deck of cards here you've got this round tracker where you've got four rounds to um to get as many points as you can and the points come in the form of coins so this is a game where you're trying to get as much money as you can by converting resources into points and you've got your four different types of resources here you've got these upgrade tokens you've got these black cubes you've got these kind of metal bars here and you've got these yellow cylinders as well i'm additionally going to have a bunch of cards laid out in the center of the table depending on the player count so in a three player setup i've got here you're going to have seven cards in that middle pool each player is going to give a random um a random setup card like this and a random player power these capitalist cards which will give you a game breaking ability to use throughout the game additionally each player is going to get given a bunch of these bidding discs valued at four three two and one and just a marker to show which color you are so throughout the game you're trying to acquire these cards not only to add to your engine but also to gain
resources so as you can see the anatomy of the card is broken up into two parts or three parts ready and if you want to include the artwork and where you got the resource at the top and you've got this little kind of trading ability at the bottom here and the way you're going to acquire these cards is of course using your bidding desk so in player order you are going to use these disks to try and acquire these cards or again try to acquire the resources on the card so your level four disk is going to be a lot more powerful than your level one disk so it does go up in order and then what you're gonna do is you're gonna use one of your disks to try and claim one of these cards so let's just say i maybe wanted to gain uh i really was set on gaining this car so i put my number four there now my number four's on there i cannot use any other discs on that particular card because only one color per player can be on that card and additionally my opponent cannot place their fours on there um because i've already claimed that four spots so they'd have to go lower than that but not only are you trying to acquire the cards here by placing the biggest number on there because at the moment again i'm going to win that card because nobody can outbid me if the next player along wanted to use one of their discs like so they can do but what it means now because they're not winning they're going to get to use the top part of the card in that many times so at the moment like this player can convert um this metal up to three times into um into this um drum here so that's a really cool thing in this game so not only are you trying to acquire the cards to get the bottom benefit but you're also trying to use your bid tokens cleverly to get the resources at the top because resources are just as
important as the actual cards themselves and then maybe the next player might want to let's just say they were really set on bidding this card here like so and it's going to keep going until players run out of their disks and then they'll be evaluated so once all the bids are complete you're going to resolve these cards from left to right so let's start with this card here where as you can see here the yellow player has got a one token on there so therefore they're going to get one of these metal bars and add them to their resource supply the black player has got a two on there so they are going to get two of those iron bars and add them to their resource supply and as you can see here the white player has won the card because they've got the highest bid token on them and therefore they're going to add that card to their engine that's going to happen for all the cards there so again not winning the card is sometimes great because you get the resources at the top so once all the cards have been evaluated and you've gained the cards you've won you're going to add them to your row of cards or your engine of cards and then simultaneously all the players can choose to run that engine how they see fit now there are two different variants on how you can do this so you can kind of do a free-for-all where you can choose to trigger the cards in any order you want or you can play a variation where when you claim a card you have to put it in a fixed position and therefore you have to be resolved from left to right um every round which i think is actually the best way to play it adds a new kind of layer of depth to the game but we'll get into that a bit a bit a bit later so first off you're going to start with um whatever card you want so this one here
you can see it's going to give me one of these upgrade tokens so i could take this upgrade token here and add it to my supply and then these are going to give me options as well so this one will say i can trade in a black cube and a metal bar to get four points um and i can choose to trade in an upgrade token and a black cube in order to flip a card over because as you can see here some of these cards have a number of different things they can do so this one here you can convert two two bars into one of these um one of these drums um but you can see they've got another symbol here which is kind of um just got a silhouette on it or kind of a the outline of a certain symbol but when you use that upgrade ability you can choose to flip it over and therefore use the new ability when it comes to activating this card which will give me one of these uh yellow drums which are one of the other best resource so again you're going to resolve one card before moving on to the next one so for this one i can maybe get an iron bar and this one i can trade two iron bars into a drum and then get another drum this one here will let me get two black cubes then i can convert an iron an iron bar and a drum like so by discarding them up to twice because it's got times two on there to get seven points so that's a you know really useful way to get points and this one here is gonna get me two black resources and convert two drums uh into or a drum up to twice and to convert it into four points each so i can see here it's all about gaining resources and converting resources into others and then trying to upgrade cars to get better payoffs when you choose to activate those particular cards as i mentioned during setup each player
is going to have an individual player power with these capitalist cards which let you do some pretty cool things if it has to be said so you can see this character here means that when upgrading cards which you'd only have to spend one of these upgrade tokens for you can actually choose to spend metal instead but you have to use all your upgrade tokens before but this one's also a very efficient card to get these more powerful cards out and to get them flipped over to get the bigger benefits and this one here lets you have an additional one of these two tokens so essentially you've got five discs go into the round so again a very useful tool to have just getting resources or even winning cards with it this one here lets you um it says during the auction phase you may place your disks without following the two placement rules so the values are not summed up if there's a tie you get compensated so that means that if a say a person bids three and let's say the the white player had that token they can also place their three on there which is of course normally would be an illegal move but this one actually is counted as lower as this three so it's a very useful tool to get resources and to get these bigger bunches of resources because this would give me three metal bars which is very useful uh this character here says whenever you can get complicated consider your disk being one higher and this one here says once per production phase you may pay two black cubes to resolve one of your cards again so if you have a particularly strong conversion card and the resources to exploit that then you can choose to spend any surplus black cubes to use that card for a second time to go and be more and more efficient and that is essentially all there is to the game you're going to do the same
thing four times and then calculate the scores at the end by of course calculating the coins and the person with the most coins at the end of the game is going to be the winner so let's talk about my thoughts about furnace so first off uh let's go straight to the key mechanism here the key mechanism of this bidding system is utterly brilliant i love it i find it fascinating at the fact that you have to put these bit um tokens down there and weigh up all the different things you have to do because again you might think oh one i just collect all the cards try and claim all the empty cards um and get you know get more cards into my engine because sometimes you're gonna not have the resources to get those engines going in the first place so therefore you've just got a dud card in your supply not doing anything at all so i'm going to love that tinkering and that waiting of your bids just to sneak in there and get the maximum output of the resources at the top and not only i know these aren't always resources sometimes they're conversions so as i said these are these yellow drums here are really um quite a rare resource and hard to come by but if you end up you know sneaking in there with a with a three bid like so and doing that three times um on other you know either these cards is a really powerful thing to have which will again contribute to your engine when it comes to this part of the game and you get these big outputs in terms of getting money and bang for your buck so yeah that bidding system is so elegant so simple and i love the fact it's not just smash your biggest ones down and hope you win the cards because that's not what this game is about it's all about um striking that balance of your engine and resources so the engine
building itself i think is a nice little puzzle as well i will say um kind of going back to that variant system i think that the freedom you have in the standard game in terms of just triggering the um the cards in any order you want and changing it from round to round and not having a fixed spot for these cards it does actually diminish and take away from the gameplay um a fair bit i think more experienced gamers what kind of economical gamers and people who like engine building games are gonna find a lot of satisfaction of actually mapping these cards out a bit more carefully and using their kind of brain in order to carefully tinker these engines to make sure that this car triggers before this card so that i have the resources here to get when it comes to here i can convert it into points i think that adds a whole new dimension to the game and i'd always consider playing it that way um rather than the standard again free-for-all but yeah i love i love kind of linear engines and this game does a great job of doing that should you choose to play with that variant which of course again i would always choose to do so so from a mechanical standpoint i really can't take anything away from this game it is really stripped down to the bare bones just a two kind of phase game acquire the cards run your engine and i love the fact that even the run your engine park can be done simultaneously with all the other players to negate that downtime and that boredom of when it's another player's turn um so you can actually completely do this at your own time at your own pace and not worry about what other people are doing just to keep that engagement and to keep the game ticking along so yeah in terms of the the speed and the tempo of the game it
does a really great job um again because it is so simultaneous at least for half of the game a really nice touch there and i also think the game is remarkably well balanced considering how asymmetric these player powers are um i've you know i've played this game i've been playing a three player account so far um but all the character cards are wildly different yet it doesn't seem to have a drastically um big impact on the end of the game but you can use these to your advantage of course you know this character is going to be great at upgrading um this character is going to be good at just exploiting particular cars and using them again and again uh this one lets you break those ties or kind of i'm sorry put the second token down but still get the resources for doing so um yeah so these are all really powerful all worth having and i like the fact they're all so interesting but again do strike that balance really well and it doesn't feel like it's frustrating when a particular player has a particular character and therefore are most likely going to win so yeah a really nice job of keeping the player powers balanced the time investment of the game is spot on for me you know this game does take less than an hour to play which i think is fantastic considering the depth here um yeah it's only four rounds and those rounds are pretty rapid but as those get around to develop you are building a stronger and stronger engine so not only is the is the actual time stamp of the game good the actual arc of the game is good as well it does feel like you're moving forward constantly and i also like the fact that these four rounds are quite a strong constraint particularly when it relates to your engine because sometimes you'll have surplus resources at the end of your round which you wish you'd had at the start around to run through your engine and convert them into points
so always ties back into what's the most efficient way to place these cards because again you don't want to be left with a bunch of resources at the end when you could have used them at the beginning to convert them into points so i love i love that all the way ties together and the pacing the tempo and the arc of the game is pretty much fantastic the replayability of furnace is probably one of my only concerns with it um because this is a kind of a medium lightweight engine building game there's only so much you can do with your engineer there's only three or four resources really to play around with and the way they link together is again they've got a glass ceiling on what you can do with those um but i really love to see an expansion come out for this game to wrap up the complexity so not only is this going to cater to get that medium light market but also to that real heavy euro market by you know ramping up the complexity by another you know by another level or two because if i can use this system and this bidding system and the engine building system on a more involved resource conversion game i think this game could really be um something truly special because not many games do a great job of having the potential to inject a lot of depth in it while still staying true to that core bidding system whereas this one just has pretty much lit uh limitless potential because that that cannot that core ui that cure that pure um gameplay system is just so pure and crisp and clean cut which just again you can just add so much new you know new conversions you could add new resources um new cars or maybe
even like three um three level cars where you can upgrade them three times or something so there's there's so much potential in what you can do and i'd just love to see an expansion come out to just to broaden the horizons here because i do feel somewhat this game does hamstring itself or is somewhat hamstrung by its own its own limitations and it really could go and again another step or two further the interaction this game is pivotal you know you can't do anything without considering what the other people are doing um as you'd expect with all kind of bidding games you know if people are sneaking over the four yeah you're pretty much locked out but are you going to jump in there with a three quickly to get the most resources so yeah everything you're doing is depending on the other people and prioritizing things to get your big tokens down to lock people out taking the cards that you want is equally as important as getting your your resources in the first place so yeah everything you do is meaningful and you can't ignore what other people are doing because that passive interaction is just embedded into the game and from a production standpoint i think the aesthetics of the game is really nice i mean the artwork of all the buildings the cards look fantastic and it's certainly very well polished and professionally done um yeah i think the artwork is pretty spectacular to be honest you know all the characters look pretty good at the actual card quality themselves these are all linen finish so again really high production quality and standard uh the bidding tokens are these big chunky wooden pieces and i like the way that these are all scaled so you know that the bigger tokens or you can just look at glass and see what the bigger tokens are and they fit together quite nicely so you can just see at a glance who's going to win that bid the resource tokens they made somewhat of an effort here to be different shapes and
sizes so yeah i've got no issues with the production at all considering this is actually a relatively affordable game scalability i think i would always play this with three or four players there is a two player variant where you use a dummy player using a dice and then you roll that die and um add add them on to different spots and things just to act as a bit of a blocker and a passive nuisance but i think you do need that player interaction to really make it shine and so therefore i'd probably always play this at three or four players so overall furnace was actually one of the games that i've been most looking forward to for a long long time um i love engine building i love bidding so naturally i i was excited for this one because it has everything i like about it and i will say i am really impressed with that you know expectations were high anderson has certainly lived up to those expectations i've got really nothing just bad or negative to say about the design itself it's so pure it's so clean it's fine it's interactive it's it's quick the engine building is fine particularly if you play with that strict um your locked in location variant and yeah it really is a really well ironed and polished design um again the the one concern with the game is the fact that it has um you know held the reins back a bit too much where i would have liked to have seen it just completely be more ambitious and add more resources more conversions more more cars more card abilities into the game just to really make it complex and and just crunchy um yeah this game is it's fine as it is it still it still works exceedingly well and there is a
lot of replay value in it but just to make it take it up to that next tier that best of the best bracket i would love to see um a module or an expansion just to take it to that level so yeah um regardless of that i still think this is a really fun game it promises on what it delivers um it's um it's pretty versatile and who you can play this with you know relatively you know gateway plus gamers could could enjoy this one because again the rule set themselves are rather simple but still there's enough going on here to satisfy more experienced gamers and these kind of crisp designs without any fiddly or fiddliness or bloat tend to stand the test of time pretty well and this one certainly stays true to that so i think people will still be talking about fairness in in you know three four five years to come because it is a really solid well-polished and well-rounded design so yeah i like this one um has everything i like about board games in a in a very succinct experience and therefore i can't do anything but recommend this one pretty strongly so this one gets my shield of quality i think if you like building games if you like engine builder games this is pretty much a shoe-in and you can really use this one as a gateway tool to get gamers into those more heavy crunchier designs but again i just wish there was a little bit more here just to take it into that elite elite here because this one certainly could do that thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any support from publishers then please
consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time