Scales of Fate Review: Get The Balance Right
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel.
I'm Mike Delisio.
Today we're taking a look at a game called Who Knows? Because it's just a big black cover. It's actually Scales of Fate. Yes, this is the fancy cover. That's why uh Scales of Fate is a two-player game from uh IV Studios and it's based on a bigger game that they have.
Yeah. It's kind of like the Veiled Fate kind of experience boiled down for a two-player experience
but also No.
Right.
And by that I mean it is Veiled Fates theming and even iconography and it is a completely different game. Yeah,
this is a deduction style game and a bluffing game um with some really nice pieces that Mike is about to show you how to play it. Okay, here we see Scales of Fate all set up. This is a game that plays out over three ages and at the end of the third age, you're going to be doing some endgame scoring and whichever player has the highest points will be the winner of the game. To set the game up, you're going to shuffle a deck of age one, age two, and age three cards and then randomly select one from each deck and then place them so that the age three is on the bottom, age two in the middle, and then age one on the top. That gets flipped over and it's going to show you how to set up the initial board. It's also going to give you some information about what happens at the end of the age and a particular um status that may be uh true or untrue that you would answer at the end of the age. We'll talk about that in a moment, but basically this is telling you that the special quest, which is the red uh token, is going to be here. All of the regular ones will be face down, and then you'll flip them face up. So, this is what it looks like after that. And then it also tells you where to place the action tokens, which you'll see reflected here on the board.
Okay. Um, the other thing that's going to happen is that each player is going to have an identical deck of cards that are going to represent all of the demigods in play. So, there'll be a deck basically of all of the demiggard gods. You shuffle them up and you draw two and you take a look at those secretly, although I'll show you here on uh this overview. So, this player, let's call them player one, would have control uh well, not control exactly, but they're going to be trying to influence the purple and red demigods, which are represented by these tokens here. Agamar and Pantha, they're also represented here. Okay. The other player is going to do the same thing. There is a possibility they could even end up with one or both of the same demigods. In this case, they did not, but that is something that is a possibility. Okay. On a player's turn, they're going to do take one of three actions, and that's laid out on this player aid card here.
It's going to tell you the three actions are to place a demigod, place a servant, or use a god power. It also explains how the endgame scoring works. And on the back, you've got a little bit of a guide for the different icons within the game. Okay, so let's talk about uh the actions. First, it says to place a demigod. When you place a demigod, what you're going to be doing is choosing a demigod that is off the board, and you're going to be placing it onto the board onto one of the action spots. You will then take the associated action that you've placed the demigod on. You can choose to place any of the demigods that are off the board. They can be ones you are trying to influence or not. Sometimes you're going to be uh maybe trying to be a little bit subtle. You don't want to necessarily give away which demigods you have because that's one element of endgame scoring. If players can guess the other players demigods at the end of the game, they're going to get some points for that. All right, so let's talk about placing a demigod. Let's say that this is player one. They've got the first player token. What they're going to do is choose one of these demigods, place it on one of these different gods.
So let's say that they go ahead and just pick this teal demigod and they place it right here. This is the smite action. And when you smite, what you're going to do is you're going to choose a demigod that is off the board, place them into this area, which is known as the abyss. So maybe they're going to be bold and they'll place one of their own demigods right into the abyss. They place that purple demigod right there. All of the demigods that are in this abyss area are going to have one of two things happen to them. And it's going to be dependent upon where this marker ends up. It starts in the center. It's either going to go to the left or to the right based off of an action that will do so. And then the card's going to tell you what will happen. So at the end of this age, if the marker is on the left, every demigod that's in the abyss will lose to renown. And if it's to the right, every demigod in the abyss will gain one renown. Okay, so that is that. So player two would do the same thing. They're also going to place a demigod. The reason that they're not going to do the second action, which is place a servant, which once I can get that into focus for you. Come on now. Play nicely.
It doesn't want to play nice. It says place a servant. Trust me. There we go. That one's playing nice. The reason why is that they don't have a servant in front of them. Maybe they want to get in servant in front of them. So, they'll place a demigod. They'll go ahead and take this one. These three action spots are to claim one of the three different types of servants that are in the game. Maybe they want to get the one that's related to the scorpions. So, they'll go and they'll place there and they'll take the associated servant. Maybe player one sees that and decides, well, I also want to get one of these servants, so I'll go ahead and take this one. And they will take that servant. Comes back to player two. Maybe they immediately want to use this servant. So, they can place a servant. When you place servants, what you're going to be doing is placing them along the edges of the board so that they are affecting either rows or columns. So, if I were to place this or if player two were to place this here, it's going to affect every demigod on this um row. If I were to place it here, it would affect the demigods in this column. So, let's say that player two goes ahead and places it here. Now, what it's going to do is it's going to trigger all of the black tiles and the associated demigods that are adjacent to them. So, in this case, it's saying it's it's affecting this tile and this demigod. The teal demigod will gain one renown. So, they all start at seven.
Now, this one goes up to eight. The orange demigod is adjacent to this tile, which means that it loses one renown. So, the orange demigod would go down to six. So, that's essentially how these work. If they're placed um with the white, it's going to affect the white tiles and the demigods that are associated with them. If it is the red, which is known as the Hadria's servant, then it's only going to affect the um demigod that is directly adjacent to it. And the tile can either be a scorpion or a feather. So if um let's say that they wanted to go ahead and and give more of the renown to this one. This is affecting this tile which is affecting this and they would gain another renown.
The third action a player can take is to use a god power. There are three god powers that are in the game. They are all one time use per game. And so on your turn, a player can gather one of these three and use its power. This is a smite power. And so if a player takes this, they can smite uh a demigod like um you saw with the smite action. However, when you take the smite action, you can only choose a player that is off the board and put them in the abyss. If you use this god power, you can choose a player uh a demigod that is on the board and place them in there. Anytime you use a god power, you flip it over because at the end of the game, these are very powerful. And as a kind of a a consequence of that, you're going to lose one point for every one of these.
One player could have all three of them at the end of the game. You could have a situation where none of the god powers are used, but that's generally uh how they work. One last thing about this smite uh god power. When you do this, you would flip over the action tile of the one that removed that was removed. Uh I believe this came from here. Let's just assume it was. This would get flipped over. A god will still be placed there, but they won't take the associated action. There are two other god tiles to talk about briefly. One is a swap tile. If you choose this one, what you're going to do is you're going to swap any two of the demigods, whether they're off the board, on the board, or in the abyss. That is uh the what the swap action will do. And the last one is to steal. This is going to allow you to steal a servant token that another player has. It has not been used yet. So if player one took this, they could take this from them and then use it later that age. The age is going to play out where every one of the uh spots have been used and all of the servants that have been chosen have been used as well.
doing the associated adjustment of the renown back and right back and forth. And then at the end of the age, oh uh this is important. I didn't mention one of these. This is the action that will allow you to move this to the left or to the right. So let's say that a player had taken that action and they had moved it to the left side. At the end of the age, what's going to happen is that you are going to each player is going to answer this question. So what this one happens to say is demi out of play. What what the question is is basically saying are one or both of your demiggods out of play? In the in the case of player one, they would say no because both of their demigods are in play. Player two would say the same thing. This is to gain potentially some information from uh for each of the players because you're trying to guess the demigod. So in this case, you can eliminate both of those demigods. each player could eliminate those because clearly uh these two are out of play. No one said yes. So you can do that. So that's just a way to gather some information. Then you're going to evaluate what happens at the end and the gods that the demigods that are in the abyss will be affected. In this case, purple would lose two and orange would lose two. You would reset the uh these would all be removed from the board. All of these would be removed from the board. you'd reset according to the second age, which is going to have a different setup. It's going to have a different question that's asked and a
different result depending upon where this token ends. You'll do that through three ages. And then at the end of the third age, what you're going to do is you are going to guess on your little player sheet your the other two or the other players two demigods. Okay? And so it also will give you this reminder here. And so at the end of the game, you're going to score for a couple of different places. You're going to score for the difference in renowned of your two demigod gods or if they share the same spot, they'll get that. So let's say, let's give an example. If this player one had happened to get both of their demiggods markers, let's say there was even another one on there, but if they were to get both of their demigod markers on 10, they would score 10 points. If instead, however, they had tried for that but had failed by one and they have their one on 10 and one on nine, they were only going to score one point for that. So, you either want to be on the same or have a large gap. In this case, they would get nine points because 10 minus one is nine. So, you'll score for that. Then you'll also score for the number of the demigods of the alternate player that you have guessed correctly. If you guess them both correctly, you get three points. If you get one of them right, you get no points. But if you get neither of them right, you lose a point. And then any god powers that you might have used will subtract one point from the score. At the end of the third age, after you've
handled all that scoring, whoever has the most points wins the game. Let's head back up and we'll let you know what we think. Now, again, we mentioned Veil Fate at the beginning that this is based on. Veil Fate to me has a party game feel. Not quite, but it's in the same category as cosmic encounter and games are big going on and we're there's a little bit of deduction in that game. Although frankly at the end of the game you're like I know who you are. You usually have a pretty good idea because usually in that game you have to make a final push and at that point you're kind of the subtrafuge is off and you're just like hey look everyone knows I'm red. I'm red and I'm pushing. Uh this one has more explicit deduction whereas it counts towards the points at the end of the game.
Right. Before we get into the the the game play, uh I do want to talk about the components. As it's an IV studio components are gorgeous. They're fantastic and they always have a several levels, but even if you buy the lowest level of the game, the the basic game, it still is a very nicel looking game.
It is. It has uh it's cardboard and where you saw wood essentially it was cardboard but it very thick especially the ones that are placed on the board those are like quadruple layer cardboard so they're very very nice now that being said and realize I'm just spoiled I like this game a lot but realize that this game feels and it's not but it feels dense and it is I would opine a high barri barrier entry because it does things in a weird way.
Yeah.
You also don't quite understand the value of things like use a god power. It's minus one point. Well, how much is a point? Is a point a lot? Spoiler. It is.
It is. Yeah.
Right. So, you and there's just a lot of things and I don't think the iconography and the nomature
um of this game helps it much. It's like there's demigods and you're smiting and it's like ah because at the end of the day it is a straightup abstract deduction game.
It is. I will say it helps if you've played Veiled Fate because they keep that stuff consistent as far as like smiting throw somebody into the abyss. But you're right. If you're coming into this game for the first time and you have no knowledge of Veiled Fate at all, there's going to be a learning curve just to kind of understand, okay, what does smite mean exactly? You've got the little player card, but it tells you what the symbol is. is it doesn't really tell you what it does. So, you have to internalize that
and it's just it's kind of a weird game. They are mixing elements of other games. In fact, I part of this game is a game I don't like, but it works better in this game of Mr. Jack.
Yeah,
there's a lot of that like demod's in the right spot or not, but that is not the be all end all. It's this whole I find the game to be a fascinating it's there's a bit of bluffing as to who you are which I'll come back to in a second but there's also a game of chicken as in I would like that piece but I don't really want to go there right now and I think that part's really fun. It's great and and yeah, the fact that you are either taking actions which are going to impact pretty strongly what happens at the end of that age or you're getting uh one of the pieces that go along in the outer side that actually will, you know, change the the uh renowned. Uh they they both are attractive. You want to get both of them. Um there's really this idea of, you know, do I just not get any god powers at all and and just kind of let them do it and they'll take the negative two or three points. There's some interesting decisions in here quite, you know, throughout the game.
Yeah. But the one thing I my favorite part of this game and how it works is I think they've solved a problem that actually is inherent in um Veiled Fate and other games where it's like, "What color am I?" Well, you're obviously not green cuz green's at zero, right?
And I always I'm like, "How do you get around that?" This game does a fantastic job with that because I'm like, "Well, Mike might be green. Green is at zero, but red's at 10, right?
And if he's green and red, he's going to clean house, but also he has there's two at seven,
right?
So, I'm not 100% sure. I I've kind of figured out he's red. So, he might be red and green, but red is at 10 and blue is at nine, and that's one apart. And he might be trying to get those in the same spot cuz that's even better.
Yeah.
Um I I think, man, that's great. That's the best part of this game in my opinion.
I agree 100%. I was going to make that same point to me that makes this game because it really does allow you to to do that kind of bluffing because like you said, you can kind of go and and try to get both on a on a 10, but if you miss it by one, you're scoring one point, right? That's a big that's a a pretty big thing to do. You're probably better off trying to spread them out.
But if you're obvious about it, then people can try to counteract that, too. It it really especially in a two-player game where you've got all of those demigods on the board, it really it makes the game. I don't know how it would work otherwise.
Yeah. Um but but because of that, I like the whole Mr. Jack thing and also the deduction part is not the beall end all of this. It gives you a few points which could swing it your way for sure,
but it's also about fooling your opponent which I think is a lot of fun. I don't think I could recommend this game to everybody. I think it's it's a 30-minute abstract game that's pretty dense and it breaks a lot of rules I have with abstract games, which is usually like have three rules in your game.
That is true.
This doesn't and it's weird. All I Studio games are weird. They try to do things differently and I applaud them for that and I like it.
I just I know the pool of people. This is one of those games where there's a lot of people I'm going to try to teach them this game. I know they won't be fans of it. But if you watch Mike's overview and you think it'll be fun, it is. I like it a lot. I give it an eight out of 10. I think it it feels like a classy game. There's a decent amount of rules compared to most abstract games, but I think the end result pays off for me.
Yeah, you I I echo much of what you said. I do not think it's a game for everybody. I do think that well, shoot, fa Veiled Fate was not a game for everybody for that matter. I mean, there are certain types of games that may not be for you. And there are not a lot of abstract games that tie in this kind of bluffing uh type of a thing and deduction. You don't see that in in a lot of abstract games. More more deduction than bluffing, but uh it does work very very well here. I'm also coming in an eight. Uh you know, I was close to an 8.5, but I do think that it is a little more convoluted than I, you know, it's harder to teach than most abstract games. Also, it's one of those games that would be hard to because I'll go back and go, "Wait, how'd this work again?"
There's a little of that.
There there's a little bit of a It doesn't It's not like riding a bike for this one, per se,
right? But if you can go through the the work, man, the payoff is great. It is a really really unique two-player abstract game.
There you go, folks. That's Scales of Fate. I'm Tom.
I'm Mike.
We'll see y'all on the balance scale. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.