Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 25:59

welcome to John gits games today I'll be reviewing dynasties this is a three to five player game that has you trying to take over Europe through marriage essentially The Quirk here is that when you actually get married with your family members you are marrying a member from an opponent's family and it is beneficial for both of you there are I spit you choose mechanics shwn throughout this Euro game that ultimately relies on quite a bit of area uh control so first I'll show you how to play the game and then I'll jump into my review here's a starting setup for a four-player game of dynasties each player takes all the people of their color as well as a starting hand and two green scoring cards what players will be trying to do is to grab these color bricks mostly from the trading area and spend them to do various things like uh send family members to the cities on the map and start marriages as well as uh seek the favor of some of these uh personality cards over here and also activating some special bonus actions on their cards the structure of return is quite simple on a player's turn they simply play one of the cards from their hand or they pass now each of these cards has symbols in the top left and top right which can show you some of the four basic actions in fact this Joker right here has all four of the basic actions there so let's go a and take a look at those first now if we look here we see a little ship action and this is the first one I want to talk about if the red player had discarded this card and said they were taking a trade action they would then take one of their people and put it down on one of these boats now whenever you put a person into a boat and they're the first one there they have to go on this larger spot it's kind of a dominant position and the other one is a secondary position and usually I put the figures face down when they're in those spots now what this means is this person is staking a claim

on some of the goods on this boat but they won't get to take any of them until somebody else comes along and goes into that secondary spot so that would finish the red player's turn and now let's say that the yellow player decides they want to do the same they discard this card because it has this trading symbol on it and instead of going into an empty ship they decide to go into the ship that the red player is already in now what happens is These Bricks need to get split up the person who played the uh secondary character the one lying down will then split this pile of bricks into two different piles and then the person who played the primary character will get to pick one of those piles and take all those bricks and the secondary person will get the remainder in this case the yellow player might make the two piles like this the red player could choose to take this pile of three they could also take the two but this is probably better for them it's more bricks and then the yellow player would take these these people will get cleared off and five more cubes will be randomly taken out of the bag and put down on the board the next action type is this personality blue icon here so a player could discard this card right here in order to activate any of these personalities this one right here is free but the of them cost a certain number of these blue bricks in order to activate them and they do a variety of things for instance this rooll right here will let the player take one brick from each of the uh trading ships down there this one right here lets you the player roll the three marage Dice and pick two of them and those that'll make sense in a little bit and this one over here lets a player make a marriage not going to go into the specifics of them but for the most part they're really good actions and once the player has activated that specific personality you flip it over so that nobody else can use it for the rest of this round the third basic action option is this white rose SYM Sy and when you spend this it allows you to put a duchess down on the board

now in order to do this you need to spend the appropriate number of white bricks in order to put them into the right spot so if we want to put in a Paris that would cost three of these white bricks and you'll notice that there is a large box and a small box so this is a small box we put it laying down but instead if we had spent just two white bricks we could put it in carcassone now this Duchess is in the primary situation and they're standing up and if a prince was to go in here well they'd be laying down and this leads us to our fourth and final basic action option which is this black sword which as you probably guessed is just putting a prince down on the board so if the green player wanted to go into Carone it would only cost them one of these black bricks and they would go laying down like that to show they are a secondary figure it's important to note that you're never allowed to put two of your own figure in a city that would be marrying your sister or brother and that's just frowned upon in this situation as soon as the city has a prince and a duchess a marriage occurs when that happens the player who is in the secondary rooll Will Roll these three marriage Dice and then much like the trading ships they're going to split these three dice into two different piles and the player who is control of the primary spot will get to pick one pile and then the secondary spot will get to take the remainer in this case the green player might split it like this and the red player they might decide they want to take this pile and what this means is the red player would just get one Victory point and you notice that this is just a D6 so it can go from one to six victory points depending on how it rolled this right here lets the player grab two random bricks out of the bag so just getting bricks is definitely a good thing and this symbol uh will match this spot on the board you might notice this is having a baby when a player has a baby they're able to take one of their tokens and put it in the baby slot on any City

where they are a participant in a marriage and there is not already a baby so it does not necessarily have to go into this city it could go somewhere else on the map where green is already in a marriage but there is no child and this baby will count as plus one when it comes to area majority for the France region and it's also worth noting another possible outcome is getting a free trade action as well as taking a crest of these different colors these all count as plus one uh area control in the given regions as well I might have gotten a little ahead of myself it's also worth noting that whenever you put a character into a city you are usually going to get a benefit right here we see that carcassone would give a player two victory points so in this case red would have gotten two points and Green would have gotten two points when they place the uh Duchess and Prince into the city this uh City here of Dijon has these two book symbols uh when a player places a figurine into this city they take the top book symbol flip it over and get a random benefit this happens to be uh plus three victory points but this could also be extra cubes or more of uh well they could show a sigzil like this but they would keep that hidden from the rest of the game so they'd have a little bit of hidden majority in a given region this spot with the anchor is associated with some scoring cards and finally this plus one for the bag gets the player one random cube out of the bag the last symbol is this crown and that's more of an endgame Victory Point thing and I'll cover that later so now let's look at the special golden actions every card except for the Jokers has one down here and we see right here it shows the symbol of York and a single gold brick that means the player can spend this card here as well as one brick back to the bag in order to put a uh supporter figure into the city of York and they

could put it either in the print slot or The Duchess spot this point they for sure do The Duchess spot they essentially got three white bricks worth of value out of that single Cube and of course like normal they would take the uh top book action here and well looks like they have a hidden blue uh support for the rest of the game for that blue player there are two other special actions I want to cover although this is not all of them this one right here allows the player to spend a single gold brick in order to get two trade ship actions so they could just pop both of these down for the cost of the single gold brick which is pretty great and this one right here allows the player to spend a single gold brick in order to use the Ability that is on these two personalities you may have noticed they're kind of off on their own in this little segregated spot you can only access these abilities on a turn where you able to play this special card that has that unlock ability this seems like a good opportunity to talk about scoring cards if they were to have evaluated this card card they would draw three yellow scoring cards and keep a single one of them these golden scoring cards will allow the player to get victory points for doing a variety of different things for instance uh you can play these at the end of every round this one would give the player seven points if they have the uh most or equal to the most black bricks at that time and then these will give a variety of points depending on the round number and the various board situation they have with their different um supporters out on the map so in this case they might discard both of these and then keep this hidden in a face down Pile in their area each player also started the game with two of these green scoring cards and these are all alike they all show two different cities on them and when you evaluate the scoring card you will get four points if

you have presence in one of these cities and 12 points in this instance if you're in both of these cities but as you can see it's different depending on the strength of the Cities so on this card it's only three and 10 points instead of playing a card on a player's turn they could instead choose to pass they will stay pass for the rest of the round and when they pass they go to the front of this line here however if they choose to they can spend one two or three of these pink bricks back to the bag in order to go on these specific spots which allows them to have essentially jump in line there could have already been a player right here and if they' spent two bricks they jump in line and get first dibs at the player order as well as some bonuses at the end of the round once all players have passed the round ends and several stages of upkeep happen one of the things is that in this order the players will evaluate one of these bonuses this top one can be evaluated by as many people as they want at three points each this spot right here would be three random bricks out of the bag and once the goes on there nobody else can this spot gives more cards well a single another card from the draw for the following turn and there's a variety of other options that these give for the players and they're going to go ahead and take these and once they're all done you move on before players start the next round they need to do some scoring as you can see this tow right here has a one this is for the end of the first turn and this says that every player who has a single family member out on the board that is in a dominant Position will get four victory points um each and then for each one that is in the secondary Position will get two points so essentially you get victory points for your unmarried people in this situation the red player right here is in the secondary position so this Pawn right here would be worth two victory points to the red player once you've evaluated this for everybody this will

be flipped over and there will be a different set of scoring at the end of the second round once we get to that second round it'll be six points and three points for each of these single um Lords and Ladies that are out on the board but then importantly you only need to spend one pink brick back to the bag for each one of your single princes and duchesses and if you don't then they actually leave the board and go off to the nunery so you definitely need pink bricks in at the end of that second round the last thing players do before they move into the next round is they can actually spend their scoring cards now you're allowed to keep two scoring cards between rounds so in this situation this player would want to spend at least one of these let's say they have um the same amount of bricks as the person who has the most so they could go ahead and discard this in order to get seven victory points right away but they might not have a pair in both of these situations yet so they might hold on to each of these cards you can spend as many of these scoring cards in round as you want but you can also sort to so they might keep these and speaking of hand limits players are only allowed to keep one of these blue Ashen cards between rounds so odds are good they won't actually have more than one available to them after the scoring round but on the off chance they do they'll have to discard down until they only have one and someone importantly that happens before the player would potentially draw another card for the next round once players have evaluated the second round we move to the third round and final round of the game and once we go into scoring we're actually going to do area majority for each of the countries which you can see with this symbol on the board at this point we look at each individual country and the player who has the most strength in that given country will get the number one slot so in this case blue has two yellow has one green has two and red has one but blue had this symbol from

earlier in the game which he'll now reveal to show they have the most so they will get 10 victory points and then the second place player will be green who would get six finally we have this Crown bonus here now for every player who has at least one um person in every Crown within a given country will get this amount of points in France there is only one Crown so both blue and yellow in this case would get six victory points but as you can see up here in Britannia where there are two Crown cities only the red player will get this bonus of Four Points because they're in both of them whereas the green and yellow player are only present in one once this area scoring is done and players have spent all of their scoring cards you see who has the most victory points and that person's the winner let's now begin the review for dynasties and I'm going to start with a few positive points the first of these relates to really the jewel of this game and that is the I split you choose mechanisms that are in two main parts the first of these is the dice which is when you marry off one of your family members to an opponent and then the person with kind of the secondary figure rolls these three Dice and then has to split them into two uh piles one's obviously gonna have one die and one's gonna have two and this is a wonderful decision because uh one of these dice is just going to give you a bunch of victory points um depending it could be actually a very small amount or a large amount depending on the die roll and then you could also get crests which will help you out with area majority and then you might also just get bonus actions like a trade action or put a baby down on the board which is going to help you out with area majority so there are a bunch of different different things these dice can do and that that splitting choice is really difficult often times sometimes it's you know oh wow you know you roll a one Victory Point these two things we you just split that way and it's over with but usually when those dice are rolled the the

player who's deciding is thinking about it for at least 20 to 30 seconds before they do it so that um when their opponent picks one of these two that they're still going to get a good pick and I love the variety of actions that you can get from this it's it's a die roll you throw these dice I mean obviously by definition and I enjoy that now I will admit sometimes you'll roll the dice and it's a very lackluster set but in general it provides good decisions the other spot where you have ice blit you choose is in the trading uh part of the game where you have these boats with four to five resources in them and then you have to split those up and so usually it's five and that means you're usually doing a pile of two bricks and a pile of three bricks I don't think I've ever seen anyone go one and four I don't think that one would have been that good for anybody at this point in the game usually it's two and three and that's also just wonderful because you're trying to figure out what you want to do and what your opponent is looking to do sometimes you can actually put it in your favor by putting the two that your opponent probably really wants then you get three breaks out of it so it's just a wonderful way to balance out the random uh draw from the bag with the bricks and the random die roll from those marriage dice you really have the players balancing things out so that things aren't too swingy and I just really love their integration into the game positive number two relates to the five different resources and the cool way that the game decides to tackle them like your average Euro if you see oh yeah of course there's a variety of resources I'm probably going to be spending a a blue and a pink and a white to do this and then like maybe two blacks and one blue to do that but not in this game you actually kind of segregate them out to each do their own thing if you have black bricks you're only going to use them to put princes

out on the board if you have blue bricks you're only going to use them to hire those personalities and I think that's pretty neat because you look at the resources that are down in front of you and you get kind of a snapshot of what some of your options are because you are not mixing and matching it's not like there's a card row where things cost different amounts no you just look down and these are directly analogous to actions now the more you have of a specific color will get you a better action maybe a better placement out on the board if you spend a bunch of the white bricks or you could grab one of the personalities that's just a little bit expensive in this particular round and I really enjoy that the pink bricks are definitely the weakest because they let you manipulate the turn order at the end of the round which is important and it's also quite important to spend those so you don't lose your people to the nunery at the end of that second round so that you can continue to score them for victory points in the area majority but the game kind of acknowledges that pink is the least interesting one so it says well you can use two pinks to be a wild of the other ones and I think it just all comes together really neat I I enjoy seeing that in this game it's definitely a new take on just having a variety of different colored cubes or bricks in your game positive number three also relates to those bricks but in a broader scope to the entire game as a package and it's just I love the look of this game I feel like this is how Euro game should look it's got vibrant popping colors it's got beautiful art all over the place and sure it's still just a map of Europe and you've seen that so many times in Euro games but they made it so colorful you know France is nice and blue and England is nice and red you got these bricks which are great colors they're also bricks which is kind of odd they're not cubes and how much I more I like them as being bricks like that little novelty value it just looks

cooler on the table it feels cooler in your hand I enjoy the fact that they're not uh cubes and when you also just look at the personalities and everything now sure there are lots of trophy things here you have Laurels for victory points and again you have a big map of Europe we've seen that a 100 times but I just love the variety and color they have in here even though box art is vibrant and colorful and interesting on the front cover where you kind of see a woman looking down on a marriage that's happening and it's like yep there's some power play going on there I just really enjoy the entire package of it and it just looks great on the table it's a pretty big map and yeah just a great package so now let's move into a few neutral points and the first of these relates to the surprisingly tactical nature of this game now I was expecting a reasonable amount of tactics uh because I knew there were multi-use cards that you're going to draw and kind of figure out what you can do based off of those in this one given round and I love that in game games but what I was not expecting was the interplay between that and these um these bricks that I talked about beginning of the game you have zero bricks in front of you so that starting handed cards well you're not thinking about all the interesting cool combos you can do you're thinking I need bricks how do I get bricks oh I probably just do a trading action to throw my person out there put him on a boat I mean if you're the starting player and you have a personality um action in your hand you're probably going to play that because the when you randomly Shuffle those personalities up one of them is always free so you know not spending bricks is great you'll probably do that because most of these personalities are good but everybody else are probably just going to do trade actions and if you're lucky somebody else trades on there and you start to get breaks and you can start to formulate what you're going to do on that given turn but these two layers really make it very tactical like making an overarching strategy for

a given round let alone the three round game is quite difficult you are always dancing around and even when you do that trade action it's not like you know what bricks you're going to get it depends on how your opponent splits them up if you're the first person to go there or how you split it up and how your opponent grabs them odds are good when you do a trade action you're going to get at least one brick that you really wanted but that second or third brick might be a bit of a crapshoot and then you need to once again look at the cards in your hand and figure out what you can do and you could definitely have situations where it feels like you have your bricks and your cards don't match and so then you have this new layer of tactics where you're trying to make the best of the sand that you have that you're given and that's fine but I was expecting it to be a little bit more of a 50-50 strategy to tactics game and it feels like it's more like a 7030 uh split and that may be a little bit more than I wanted and it's definitely going to be more than your average Euro experience that people are going to go into this game expecting neutral number two relates directly to those personality tiles that are shuffled up and put out on the board and on the face of it I really like that kind of mechanic in games you kind of Shuffle these things up and it's got varying levels of worth in a given round but the strictly the fact that one of them is free every round makes it kind of swingy as far as the overall power of the first player now you can dictate who the first first player is going to be based on try arounds usually on you know placing these pink cubes down but you might split it up and put these personalities down so that the free one is really not that interesting or really not that good for the starting player or it could be the one that lets you steal one brick from all three boats and then it's a complete no-brainer as long as the

player has a card in their hand that lets them activate that personality so it can be quite swingy and very random with the way that you parse these out and then two of them are locked out every round which is also kind of neat you need to spend a special card in order to access those two but it's just I thought it was worth noting that because this is fully randomized it it can be a bit swingy I almost wish it was a bit more of a conveyor belt situation where like all the ones that were taken become more uh expensive on the next round the ones that weren't taken Shuffle down uh some sort of situation like that might have made it a little bit more balanced and predictable and I feel like a little more predictability in this game in general would have probably been nice and neutral number three is a simple feeling that you often have when you're playing this game of man I am just not doing enough how do I do more I've constantly had a grasses Greener Vibe when I'm playing the game I look at out the opponents I'm like oh my gosh they're doing stuff and I'm not doing things um in the first round the second round in the third round of the game and I've talked to my opponents and they oftentimes have that same feeling and some people really like that aspect to specific board games where it just feels like they're always playing from behind and everybody's playing from behind and obviously someone's going to end up winning but that's not always my favorite way to play a game like I want to feel like I'm accomplishing things and if I'm constantly feeling like I'm scrabbling to just try and stay even with everybody else even though that might not be the case it's just a Vibe I get no that's a emotional impression that I want you to know that you might have when you go into this game I now want to go into my one negative for the game but it's a bit of a doozy I've alluded to this a little bit already earlier in the review and that is that

the card play mechanism in this game it just feels a bit clunky and it honestly feels a bit unnecessary when you add in the Tactical level of what cards you draw and what abilities they're going to give you access to with the bricks that are going to allow you to do them there are been several times where players have been incredibly frustrated because they draw those four cards at the beginning of one of the three rounds in the game there's only three rounds when these big draws happen and they have no personality draws for instance and they and they have blue TI bricks in front of them especially if it's the third round those blue bricks are completely pointless and you know sure that was a bit unlucky that they did that but I've seen situations like this happen where you draw zero ability to put duchesses down and you've been saving up these white bricks from the last round to do a big push and now you might put that on the player like oh they they shouldn't have done that they should have been a little bit more tactical in the previous round and tried to play cards around that but maybe they did and they just did not have the U the cards to put those duchesses down in the prior round either that might be why they have all these white bricks because people can see they're not being able to utilize them and I just don't like that I really enjoy the um the gold brick actions that are on these cards and I feel like maybe if every card was a joker so it had all four of the main actions on it and then a bonus action that would have alleviated this issue so I guess it's not that I feel like the card play mechanism should not be in the game at all I just feel like the extra layer of Randomness that it gives you when you are trying the Cards into your hand is just really not good like it almost makes me feel like I should do a hand draft at the beginning of every round like okay we've all drawn our cards okay

now pick one and CH pass it to the left so that you have some control and this game is all about control through Randomness with the ice spit you choose mechanisms you know you roll those dice you pull those out of the bag but then the players figure out how to balance it for everybody else but then you just have drawing these cards from the top of the stack it feels like almost you should I split you choose the cards but that would make the game a little bit too complicated so I am pretty disappointed with the restrictions that that blind card draw can add into the game and it can definitely make people feel like they were knocked out of contention for really no reason of their own I mean if there was I do like the fact that the bricks can only do one thing and then they can't do anything else but when you're hampered by the card draw and that restriction on the bricks that's a very frustrating experience that has hit several people when I've been playing the game including me at one point so it's it's definitely a flaw that I see with the game it's just one too many random things going on and this one in particular players have no control over when it comes to the replayability for dynasties I think it's slightly above average and it's really spoton for what I would have hoped to get out of this box for a Euro of this Sate you randomize the tiles that show how much victory points you get for area majority in the given countries and I know for other games they would have had those printed on the board and when you think about it there's there is something to be said for that because you know France is a little interesting it only has one crown on it so if it has a really high-scoring Crown thing then that's an incentive to go there but I do like that well the the players just need to kind of self-balance that and see that France

right now is much better this game than it was in the last game and that makes going there more incentivized well there's your replayability a little bit I I think that you know the die rolles and the way they split in the decision you're going to go off those is definitely going to make one game play a little bit different from the next like in one game you might have the opportunity to really push out on the board with a bunch of people uh especially early in the game whereas the next you might not be given those opportunities and you're going to try to figure out how to get victory points in a different way and so yeah in general I think it's a little above average Dynasty supports three to five players and I've played the three and four player game and I think that four players is definitely The Sweet Spot in the three-player game and I actually played a couple of those it seemed like it could take a while before people really started to marry each other like I there have situations where you complete the entire first round and everybody is single no marriages happen at all and at the end of the three-player game there are quite a few marriages like marriage is a thing that happens but it feels like it comes a bit late and you also have a pretty real possibility of two players marrying each other more than the third just kind of due to circumstance and those players are really benefiting like even when um you know you split those dice up one person's going to get a slightly better trade than the other but the person who's really missing out is the person who's not in this marriage at all so in a four-player game there's going to be more marriages I think it's more likely that everybody's kind of be evenly married and I've not tried the five-player game but you uh add four extra cities to the board and so I imagine it plays somewhat similar to the four player game just longer and I don't think it really needs to be longer uh one other thing about the three-player game is that since you are not

restricting the cities not only does it make it harder to get married but it makes the area majority a little bit more open and you're a lot more likely to just hit uh ties with the a majority which makes it a little bit less tight and interesting of an aspect of the game in conclusion I really wanted to love this game the um aspects of ice split you choose are just brilliantly implemented in this game where you have this Randomness but then the players control it and really try to balance it out between themselves you have this vibrant beautiful board you've got a little bit of area majority which I'm not usually crazy about but I like it in small doses like this game seems to give you but I really run into a brick wall of the issues I have with the random card draw it's soured the game for a couple of my friends that s the game for me and it I really wish I could fix it like with some sort of house rule I guess I could just house rule that every single card U is a joker but that's a pretty big change to the game and I just really want I don't want that extra layer of force tactic Force tactics and Randomness that the game puts in there I'm not sure if I'm going to be keeping the game I I think it's very likely I'll play it again at some point in the future because I really love some of these ideas that the game is injecting in and I can talk at to a certain extent the issues that crop up with it but they definitely tarnish the beautiful lustrous Sheen that this game had and really could have had if not for that one pretty big issue I'd like to thank all the people supporting this channel on patreon including the producer level pledges if you too would like to directly support the channel you could do it at patreon.com jongetsgames also

if you like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel thanks for watching

Progress saved