Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 5:45

hey now everybody jamie here and i'm back again with another board game oddities now this one since i'm doing this in october is a great game for halloween it's called black stories now this is a game that is a sort of deductive reasoning game there's not much of a game to it it's more of an activity you're trying to get to the solution of a grisly murder or a or a gruesome accident that happened now essentially what happens is you get a card and on the front side of the card there is a piece of a story and a picture and a title on the other side of the card you get the complete solution for what actually happened and you as the riddle master are answering questions of all the players the players are asking you questions that have to be a yes or no answer and of course if you're a lenient uh you know riddle master you can say that has no relevance to the the solution so ask another question and continue to answer there's no points to this game there's no winner there's no loser well i guess loser if you don't get to the solution in a timely manner but essentially there's no points to this game it's a deductive reasoning game more of an activity now the designer of this game is holger bosch and in the rule book he talks about uh these kinds of games are called lateral thinking puzzles now i never heard of that before so i looked it up years ago when i got this game and lateral thinking puzzles were a that term was coined in 1967 by a guy named edward de bono and he wrote a book called the use of

lateral thinking essentially lateral thinking is puzzle solving using reasoning as opposed to procedural logic so essentially you're trying to talk out a problem and reason out the answer and you're trying to rule out all kinds of information so that eventually you drill down to what actually happened or what the solution of the puzzle is it's kind of like when spock says an ancestor of mine maintains that if you eliminate the impossible whatever remains however improbable must be the truth this is kind of what you're doing in this game now i'm going to go through one of these cards now there's 50 in the box and there's a number of different boxes with 50 in each of them so i'm going to spoil one of them i'll let you know exactly when i'm going to spoil the solution but the front of this card says the unseen murderer although everyone was fascinated by the murderer it happened completely unnoticed now that's the only information that the players are going to get now they got to start asking yes or no questions so essentially you look at look at the information you break it down all right there's a group of people they they clearly are aware of a murderer but they don't know that a murder happened so you're okay were this group was this group of people at a party no okay were they at a nightclub or a bar no uh were they outdoors yes we got something there uh all right were they at a park no uh were they in their car yes more information we ruled out a whole bunch of stuff there were they all in the same car no that's

great we got tons of information off of that so you just keep asking those questions until you drill down to an answer now i'm going to give you the answer here so the spoiler alert boom a woman stabbed her husband to death just as another murder was taking place on screen at a drive-in theater now you can see how this kind of works right they were fascinated by the murderer on screen and they didn't notice that the real murder actually happened that's how the correlation goes now of course i think that they're worded a little weird in some cases like this one i think i would have worded it differently on the front it's a little misleading in some cases but really this is such a fun activity i gotta tell you i love doing this i tell you how we play it like the one time we played it i was going to a party at our buddy chris's house and my wife and i were there and we were in the kitchen and we got there a little early so i pulled one of these out and read it and they just started talking and they started asking questions about an hour went by and they finally came to a solution that was really close to the one on the back of the box it was a really fun little activity for that hour could also see this being perfect for a couple living together these cards could go on for days or even weeks you know asking questions every day you come up with a couple of questions and you ask them you know just in passing and you think about it you think about and you go on about your business for the day and the next day you're like hmm got some more questions and eventually you come to the solution that could be a really rewarding sort of activity going on for a pretty

good amount of time in a household i think this is a really neat kind of concept for a game but it definitely isn't for everybody this could get very boring and very frustrating really quickly if you're not into this style of gameplay this lateral thinking and this puzzle solving there's no points there's no winner really there's no it's all cooperative and the the riddle master is trying to get you to the to the right answer no matter what so you're not trying to beat him either so a lot of people might not like that but i really enjoy this activity i think it's a really neat concept and go out there check out black stories if this sounds interesting to you could be a really fun halloween activity thanks so much everybody if you've enjoyed this video please do us a giant favor by subscribing to the channel and clicking that wacky bell icon if you're into board games miniatures games role playing games we have a bunch of audio podcasts you might enjoy you can find those at the secretcobalt.com or on itunes and stitcher

Progress saved